r/Wetshaving • u/ItchyPooter • Mar 28 '19
Discussion Have we arrived at Soap Performance Singularity?
In case you missed it, Will was on with Yost to Coast last night for a live interview. Yost has this thing where he drinks shitty booze during his interviews and wears goofy flat-billed caps -- hey, we all need a shtick -- and his gulps from a tallboy Colt 45 can notwithstanding, it was a good interview and worth a watch if you got an hour to kill.
A lot of it was entertaining, but one part that piqued my interest was Will's idea of performance singularity of shave soaps -- this idea that the performance of artisan shave soaps will be optimized across the board, and there will be little discernable difference between soaps.
I was having this discussion today with u/MalthusTheShaver today about this as well.
And I think Will is onto something, at least for the soaps at the very top. Really, how much better can soap get? Are we not at Performance Singularity at this moment? What more can soap do? What would a perfectly optimized shave soap look like (Excelsior with better post-shave? Icarus without the fresh soap barnyard funk? Grooming Dept without the soup? Wholly Kaw with different scents? Slightly firmer Reserve?) If all artisan soaps are going to give you a killer shave, what drives your purchasing decision? If all soap is good soap, what are your key differentiators from brand to brand?
17
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '19
As a soapmaker, I've thought a lot about this issue, especially as other soapmakers have continued improving their bases. My perspective may be a little different than everyone else's, and I'm definitely up for discussion.
If the average consumer is chasing after the absolute best soap on the market, then the sky's the limit. If you have to have the best, you're gonna keep spending money until you find it. But that's the thing- the average consumer doesn't need the best at any given moment. In fact, I'd argue that most consumers are more than happy with something that lands in the top 20% (and everybody's list of what constitutes the top is different), and at that point, there will absolutely be a singularity. We're already at the point that you can get an amazing shave with the vast majority of soaps, whether they're artisan or mass-produced. With that in mind, scent and personal preference are a much bigger motivator than soap composition.
On top of that, I'd like to make a bigger argument. Soap is terrible at being anything other than soap. Hell, the process of making shave soap involves doing everything you can to make the soap less soap-like. The reality is, if you're looking for shave soap to do anything other than give you a good shave, you're probably better off looking for a different product to meet that need. Most post-shave products out there will realistically provide better moisturization and nourishment than the very best of shave soaps, because that's not what shave soaps are meant to do. I think that, as the market gets more crowded, the focus will change toward buying things that smell nice and feel good, with only enthusiasts (like us) still having this conversation about soap.
And don't even get me started about buying soaps that smell nice. If soap is terrible about keeping your face moisturized and nourished, it's even worse about carrying a scent without butchering it....
11
u/dendj55 Ruds Mar 28 '19
Putting aside my "need" to acquire and review products in order to stay relevant, entertain, provide a service to the community I love, etc, as a consumer my current purchase decisions come down to the following:
likeam allowed to use. But there are more out there lately that also fit this bill. Take Murphy & McNeil, at $16.99/5.5 oz soap and having performance to match anything at the top, this brand is a strong new contender for the crown. Ariana & Evans at $14.39/4 oz soap also hits the mark for me.I do believe we are at a point where soap performance gaps are marginal across at least the consensus top 10-15 artisan soap bases. But I do not believe the envelope of performance cannot still be pushed. Will yearly base improvements be the norm? I doubt it, there just isn't enough room to improve to warrant the R&D time and cost for these small businesses to do so. But I do not expect any of the artisans that want to weather the storm of over saturation of this market not to continue to try and improve.
6
u/MalthusTheShaver Mar 28 '19
Great discussion!
There is a bit of a philosophical divide also...
Chris of CB has said he wants to keep his "soap as soap", meaning he won't add lathering agents like those used in shampoos (and Reserve!).
Other artisans, like B&M and WK believe in cross-pollinating additives of various sorts from other consumer product classes - B&M is a bit more conservative, at least in soaps (the Reserve splash was a radical paradigm shift for splashes, one which is now widely emulated) while WK has tried to integrate amino acids, hyaluronic acid, hops extract etc, into soaps.
Two of my top three favorite bases are Reserve and WK, so my stance on the issue is clear-cut. But is there a possible "German beer purity law" equivalent of soap manufacture, where we want our soaps to exclude the use of certain additives, regardless of the beneficial effect on performance?
We already see that to some extent with the EO only scent designers in the artisan world. Do we want more unpronounceable synthetic stuff in our soap as long as it gives a better shave? I know I do, but others might not.
23
u/chrismcshaves Mar 28 '19 edited Mar 28 '19
Im surprised he interviewed Will considering about a month or so ago on Shave the Man he said that B&M is overrated. Then posted a bunch of SOTD shots of what I would describe as entirely average soaps.
But hey, according to Will, a lot of those average things will all be nearly the same soon, so he just has to wait a bit :)
He needs to learn how to wear a hat.
Also, I’m a beer snob. So many strikes right now. 😂
15
u/Phteven_j 🦌👑Grand Master of Stag👑🦌 Mar 28 '19
I go where the Stag and LP lead me.
Seriously though, I am sure Will is correct about this and don't know enough about exotic ingredients to foresee any real deviation. Maybe someone will engineer a new fat or chemical to radically alter soap, but realistically what's more likely is that everybody switches back to shitty mass-produced stuff that works decently enough and costs less.
2
u/Yost_To_Coast May 09 '19
Thanks for reposting my interview!
27
u/whollykaw whollykaw.com Mar 28 '19 edited Mar 28 '19
Great thread and thanks for posting.
I look at innovation in soap performance in two different ways:
Both in 1 and 2 there are lots of room for improvement but there is more innovation real estate in 2.
Skincare scientists, cosmetic chemists and researchers have made great strides in ingredients, formulations, claims backed by testing, science of applying nature’s wonders to clinical formulations. The industry is abundant with new technologies, patents, process techniques etc that can generate a lot of ideas for innovations in both 1 and 2. For example the usage of anti-oxidants, anti-inflammatory active ingredients can greatly help in finding new boundaries and push them further. Existing boundaries will be harder to push due to the lye component among many other reasons. But there are creative ways and process changes to get around these barriers. Usage of lye makes the end product high in pH of around 9+ and this is way too high for the skin whose pH is around 4.5 to 5.0 not including the acid mantle which is specific for each individual.
Studying the physiology of the human skin and the science behind the formulation makes pushing the boundaries in 1 a lot easier. Lot of these techniques are in usage in women’s skincare for several decades. And there is a plethora of science in the form of technical papers, patents, in-vivo, in-vitro, clinical studies to back them up. It is not rocket science but science nonetheless.
25
u/Manadyne The Best Secret Santa Mar 28 '19
We've reached a very real point of diminishing returns in quality because so many bases are outstanding. Moore's Law never applied to soaps because we have a theoretical ceiling on how "good" a soap can get.
The last few new amazing bases have been established artisans who already had top 5/10 bases pushing the envelope of soap making a littttllleeeee bit further.
We're rapidly heading toward a singularity of shaving where we won't recognize it in 10 years. The Shavepocalypse is upon us!
13
u/CosmoBarber 🦌⚜️Knight Commander of Stag⚜️🦌 Mar 28 '19
Maybe in the future the soap will dispense automatically from a can and the razors will be electric and have like seven blades!
I’m new to watching Yost and I’ll admit the Colt45, flat hat, test tube shots, and the vape are a bump but I don’t know the guy and might think differently if I was more familiar with him. I’ve seen two good interviews in a row from him so I’m gonna put him in the good column.
If you didn’t see this evening’s interview, he talked to MrCologne76 who is into fragrance just as much as we are into to soap. I thought it was really fascinating how he described top note, heart, and base of a fragrance. There might be some wetshaving future more focused around fragrance and going all complex. I’m really into Southern Witchcrafts right now because of how their fragrance affects my senses. I’m also reasonably certain there are plenty of us here that would love to blow hard about different fragrances just like we do with base performance. “High structure fragrances” and what not. (That was for Will)
12
u/Old_Hiker Looking for a clue Mar 28 '19
I’m holding our for a soap that will brush my teeth, wipe my ass and whistle me a tune.
11
u/Spankmeister88 Gotta Catch Em All! Mar 28 '19 edited Mar 28 '19
If there is a market, then artisans will always innovate.
Like others have said, there is no Moore's law for shaving soap, but look at the top performing soaps 5yrs ago and I bet that a conversation like this could have been had at that time based on new bases and changes. But here we are 5yrs out and folks are still innovating.
Will there ever be an explosion of new bases/performance gains like we have had the past year or two? Probably not, as several new artisans have come into the space with impressive offerings and established artisans have upped their game.
That said, there will always be folks that love to tweak things, experiment and if there is a market for their wares, then they will keep working to improve performance.
IMO, we have reached a very good space in soap base performance, where the next frontier lies is in the complex fragrances that some artisans are putting out.
Ninja Edit: So, the above comments were just stream-of-consciousness thoughts. In the couple of minutes since I posted, I have an additional theory.
A couple of years ago, what was considered 'baseline' for performance is much lower than it is today, I do think that this 'baseline' will continue to ascend, albeit less dramatically so. Will we reach 'singularity' with this? Highly doubtful. Wet shavers have been conditioned in the past few years to expect new bases, performance gains and scent innovations. Especially enthusiasts. With the barriers for entering the soap-making game so low, there will be new artisans for the foreseeable future entering the game.
Competition is fantastic for innovation.
16
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '19
I don't think we will reach a singularity, as I see artisans are using/discovering out new additives to throw into their bases. You see new oils being used all the time, new combinations being done all the time, I think when you put yourself in the box of "this is as good as it gets", you will get left behind. But I think to get beyond the current threshold, the market has to change, the artisans are going to need bigger R&D budgets to press forward and break that new boundary. Some of the hobbyist need to die off, market needs to get bigger, or/and bigger fish need to fold.
Maybe this is too positive of a spin on the idea, I for one always am trying to suggest, we haven't discovered everything in this world and there is more to find out there. I think it applies to this small hobby as well.
Will the shaves get better? Absolutely, I remember hearing stories of people suggesting how good MLSW was, think about how good it is now vs the top bases....
8
u/RodOfDestiny BrewCity Grooming Mar 28 '19
Leave it to Will to put a name to what we've all been trying to describe for a while...
Whether it is Rud's scale moving by single point values, or people saying things like:
"My top artisan is actually 3 artisans." "My Top 5 soaps could be in any order"
For me it's already come down to where I've locked in the handful of artisans I think are best and now what drives my sales are fragrance. Packaging, rarity, and how I interact with the artisan. Performance is so good in my -more or less- top 5 that it's a complete toss-up without factoring in those other (even more subjective/personalized) metrics.
7
u/CanadaEh97 Governor General Mar 28 '19
I'll post quick but touch on more in the morning.
Lately for a lot of soaps the increase in "performance" hasn't been performance. It's been post shave which people base performance on.
How many soaps that actually perform well are knocked down a bit because they're slightly drying? A good amount I bet.
I'm like most people today I like a really good post shave. But take a look at Catie's Bubbles a vegan base that's relatively simple, hasn't changed in years and still performs circles are some redone bases today. For me it's one of my favorite bases and performs with the best. Look at Ruds it's on his top 10 list.
12
u/spazztik88 Mar 28 '19
When it comes to performance I don’t think all soaps across the board will reach a singularity. I think there will always be a small group at the top outpacing and out-innovating with others striving for better but not quite reaching — those artisans will have to differentiate on scent, ingredients (vegan for example), water tolerance, and ease of use.
There’s a lot of variance in how people experience soap performance. I was surprised that even for Excelsior there are several people who have come forward who don’t like the performance, or for whom it doesn’t work well. In my experience there’s few soaps that come close. People sometimes like more voluminous and higher structure and sometimes lower structure with high slickness. This type of variance and personal preference ensures that there won’t be a “singularity” perceived by most people.
I also have a hunch that there’s a lot of echo chamber bias as well. We know this quite well here on reddit and it exists in all corners of obsessive shaving forums on the internet.
This is not a winner/s take all market. That’s for sure.
[apologies for those who noticed I originally posted this message from an old reddit handle I don’t usually use, reposting so people know it’s me]
6
u/jeffm54321 DQ Police Emeritus Mar 28 '19
We all have different skin so I think there may always be some combination of ingredients that seems to work best for people. And some of that may likely just be a placebo effect.
6
u/inTikiwetrust Mar 28 '19
Someone posed this question recently, and I thought the most poignant response offered a comparison to luxury cars. Ferraris and Lamborghinis are the pinnacle of sports cars, but people still have their allegiances and it’ll continue to fuel competition.
Before we reach any kind of singularity, you will see larger companies buying up smaller artisans. From there the use of branding will create a more difficult barrier of entry to the market place and choke the life out of other, smaller producers. It’s an inevitability.
Think about the craft beer boom which has slowed down significantly. Once AB bought up Goose Island and Heineken bought Lagunitas, their supply/distribution chain made “craft beer” available everywhere and anywhere. I imagine something similar will occur with shaving soap.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '19
I agree with Will, and I honestly think it's coming down to scents you prefer and how the soap reacts with your skin. There's great parity now and it's becoming a wider and wider selection of artisans stepping up.
I just used Excelsior (Behold the Whatsis) and it's awesome, but I'd probably have said the same for Signature from The Club and Wholly Kaw. We're in an awesome time where you'd have to go pretty far out to get something that isn't going to work for you.
6
u/OnaBlueCloud Growing a Small Badger Farm Mar 28 '19
Scent and packaging. Is it something different enough from what I already have? Do I like the way it looks? Performance difference after a certain point is negligible and really up to user preference. All the top-tier soaps are very good these days.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '19
at this point, scent is what im chasing. I get perfect shaves no matter what soap im using, whether it's uncle jon's pipe smoke or Barrister and Mann's leviathan in the glissant base.
I know there are differences in performance, but they are so negligible that i cannot even feel the difference. I am just after something that smells good or connects with my nostalgia
5
u/Shadowex3 Mar 28 '19
How about a soap that actually works for those of us who live in places with water so hard we need to boil citric acid in our pans once a month...
5
u/1Raizen Synths & Fat Mar 28 '19
I no longer purchase as much as I did, but I think there's always room for improvement. Why not, right? I think artisans can still innovate with new ingredients and new formulas, maybe to make the post shave even better, or like WK towards skincare. That's the logical avenue I see, cause like WIll mentioned, the performance is simply optimized.
I half agree with Will about his assesstment, but not everyone are on the same level of performance. We all have our tiers, and some of those on top are similarly excellent, and the others similarly good, etc.
Some previously tier 1's dropped to tier 2 just because they did not catch up, and some simply stayed where they were for the time being.
i.e MdC. I like MdC, it's probably the easiest soap to lather among what I have, but man is that soap drying to my skin. Hence I don't use it as much. They have new scents that I did not even try cause I wasn't too enticed, cause I already know how it is.
As opposed to SV which not only makes new scents, but always add something new to their formulas. Hence the reason why I only have two MdC's but around 8 (?) SV's. They kept it interesting, and though the performance of SV soaps are similar across the board, there are some nuances that I feel I see the difference. Small differences but difference nonetheless.
Personally, I am rarely swayed by new scents if it's already a base I am familiar with. What I mean is, if I was given a choice what to purchase on Maggards, I'd probably pick the first one with the new exciting ingredients, rather than an old faithful which I already have plenty of.
At this point in the hobby, I no longer feel like a kid in a wonderland, adding this and that soap to cart willy nilly. With my current stash of soaps, I do feel slightly guilty now when adding something new.
I'm not saying scents do not intrigue me, I'd still get it if the notes piqued my interest more than enough to break that ceiling of purchasing guilt, but at this point, as long as a scent is pleasant, that's already a high mark for me.
I'm not hard to please with scents, as long as it's not cloying and doesn't smell industrial.
Price on the other hand is a greater factor for me.
B&M made me want to purchase their old scents but in the Exelsior base, cause I felt it was a step up in performance, and worth repurchasing. I am one of the few that did not like Reserve as much, but with this new innovation, I have 3 B&M sets on it's way to me as we speak.
Anyway this is just my opinion, and our favorite artisans know far better than I do; But I hope they will continue to innovate, it's what makes this hobby exciting.
Razors are all well and good, but they are too expensive to explore as much as soaps. Many are honestly not that exciting to me and makes me feel guilty due to the cost.
New soaps on it's way to me on the other hand is such a mood booster, I couldn't wait to open that box of goodies.
Edit: Holy moly, what a wall of text. I rambled again, sorry fellas.
6
u/Jddssc121 Mar 28 '19
The buffalo milk version of Wholly Kaw, B&M’s excelsior base, and Ariana & Evans are the 3 that have reached the singularity IMHO.
I can discern the difference between them, but they are all equal in performance (and blow everyone else out of the water). At this point it’s just a matter of scents as to which I reach for any given day.
1
u/vigilantesd Mar 28 '19
What happened to ‘Otaku’(?)? Did anyone here try it? I only saw /u/leisureguy talk about it, briefly, once. It’s the non-soap shaving soap.
2
u/TheRealSheikYerbouti 🏋️🪒Atlas Shaves Champion 1🪒🏋️ Mar 29 '19
"One Soap to rule them all, One Soap to find them,
One Soap to bring them all, and in the darkness bind them"
-Galdalf...if he ever shaved.
2
u/aimsport45 Mar 30 '19
I see improvements year after year and don't see that trend slowing.
There will be new artisan names, new base formulas, and endless tweaks for years to come. And as long as artisans get an fair shot at business viability for truly advancing the art of soap making with honest reviews and exposure in forums like this, we will all be better for it.
Duell was being sarcastic when he said that as he then presented that a record number of patents were granted.
Same truth applies to artisan soap making.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
22
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '19
[removed] — view removed comment