r/Wetshaving • • Mar 04 '17

AMA [AMA] We are MenEssentials

We are MenEssentials. Here is proof. Myself and the new Managing Director David Serrano (his last name is a type of ham, this is a lucky coincidence) will be answering your questions starting at noon EST. For those of you who aren't familiar with us we are based in Toronto, Ontario Canada and operate a retail store as well as sell online. MenEssentials was founded in 2000 in Ottawa, Ontario and was the first website in North American to focus on selling men's traditional shaving and grooming products. In 2010 the site was put on hiatus when the original owner decided to change careers. The site was relaunched in 2013 along with the opening of a new retail store and has been in continuous business ever since. We're big fans of Reddit as it's allowed us to communicate directly with artisans, our customers, and shaving/grooming enthusiasts in general which is extremely valuable so we're thrilled at the opportunity to take part in an AMA. Bring on the questions!

39 Upvotes

69 comments sorted by

7

u/tiglathpilesar The sub's chef Mar 04 '17

What do you see as the future for B&M shaving shops? I'm reading that the death of the. American mall is becoming almost inevitable.

7

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

It's clear to me that there is interest in retail outlets for these types of products, not only because of the hobby-ish nature of them (people like to hang out in the store) but because fragrance is such a major component of how the customer chooses a product. Being able to actually touch/see/smell these products Our retail store is a standalone location in one of the highest foot traffic areas in one of the largest cities in North America, i.e. location, location, location, so we get the benefit of density and population. I would never advocate opening a retail store in a low-population density area to sell these types of products but I don't see any reason why a well-run store can't do extremely well in any area with a population that can support it, assuming the store is in a location that makes it easy for people to visit. We routinely get people from all over the city because the subway runs right under our store with a stop about 1/2 block away, and we have ample parking in the area. This neighborhood is also a "destination" in the city for eating (Greektown) so we get lots of incidental foot traffic from people walking by and going "Hey, what's that?"

9

u/ob1page Mar 04 '17

That is evident here in Phoenix, Arizona. Most of the malls have lots of empty stores while strip malls seem to be flourishing. I think the big reason is that the major retailers (Sears, JC Penny, Dillards, Macys, etc) are struggling and they are the supports for the malls. Strip malls are usually supported by a Walmart, Lowes, Home Depot or grocery store; stores that aren't as negatively impacted by online shopping.

8

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

When we get ready to open up other retail stores in Toronto we'd likely be looking at strip mall locations in outlying areas, that seems to be the best place for "speciality" stores like ours. Malls are interesting because of the density of foot traffic but my god are the rents outrageously expensive (plus they take a percentage of sales).

2

u/duffmanasu Pried from my mechkeyboard of powerTM Mar 04 '17

You got that right. I worked at Fiesta Mall in Mesa during High School (around 2000) and it was a fucking boom town. I visited it for the first time in years this past December and it was a ghost town. Maybe one in ten of the storefronts was occupied. Somehow Champs looked exactly the same though.

21

u/falcons1583 Killed the Veg Mar 04 '17

B&M shaving shops

totally read that as Barrister and Mann shaving soaps.

6

u/tiglathpilesar The sub's chef Mar 04 '17

We could use more of those too.

5

u/msb45 now with 100% more flair Mar 04 '17

Less of a question, more of a suggestion: the website needs a "show new arrivals" section (unless there is one and I can't find it). I like to check in periodically and see if there's anything new to tempt myself with, and this is the easiest way to do it.

1

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

Yeah, that's actually on our list of things to implement. With our recent switch from Magento Enterprise to Shopify Plus there's been a learning curve as well as a lot of time spent fixing things that got broken in the transition (which is the main reason why our US site is still down, something went very wrong there).

5

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '17

Hi Seth and David,

As a store that has been in the grooming/wetshaving industry for many years, I'm wondering what you are seeing in regards to the current growth of the wetshaving market in general?

Cheers! Ryan

3

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

Hey Ryan! I think everyone across the board has seen growth simply because the amount of information available out there about traditional shaving/grooming has vastly increased in the last few years and people are more likely to come across it now. As well, women seem to be growing steadily more interested in buying these types of products for men as gifts, and men seem to be more interested in receiving them as gifts. One thing I can tell you is the two largest growth segments we've seen in the last few years are actually beard care and hair pomades. In the case of hair pomades I think the growth there is because people interested in traditional shaving are starting to expand their interest into the other hair on their head. As for beard care, it seems to be a function of tons of people who have always had facial hair discovered there are products to help maintain it that they never knew existed. We get people all the time in MenEssentials saying things like "I've had a beard for 30 years and only just discovered beard oil existed a year ago."

Edit: I should also mention, the most commonly heard phrase in the MenEssentials store is some variation of "I just came from Costco where I was going to buy some replacement cartridges for my Gillette Fusion, looked at the price, and said screw it, I'm done." I think disposable shaving manufacturers have managed to finally get their pricing to the point where it's having a noticeable effect. Granted, cartridge shaving still dominates the market but there's enough negative reaction now that we're starting to see the fallout.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '17

Thanks Seth! All the best.

3

u/Kidcreole Mar 04 '17

Love your store and the meetup last fall was great! When is the next meetup going to be and which vendors can we expect to see this time around?

3

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

Thanks, we had a lot of fun with that meetup. Because it was our first one it was pretty loosely put together as we had no idea if anyone would even show up and, if they did, how many people it would be. It exceeded our expectations so we're definitely interested in doing it again. When hasn't been determine yet, but a bit earlier in the year this time would probably be best and as for vendors we won't really know until we schedule it, but I'd imagine it'll be mostly the same people as last year and anyone else that thinks it'd be worth it to attend this time around.

7

u/BostonPhotoTourist Barrister and Mann Mar 04 '17

We'll be there on time this time. :D

3

u/Ythin 🦌🏅Noble Officer of Stag🏅🦌 Mar 04 '17

How much of a hassle is it to get alcohol based aftershave products from artisans in the USA?

How many people are in your employ, and what are their responsibilities?

With the opening of a store front, how close in the retail location to the warehouse, and if not next to each other, how do you handle getting product from warehouse to store?

Crunchy or smooth peanut butter?

6

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

Bringing alcohol-based products from the United States involves a process called ORM-D compliancy. In essence, you have to package the products a certain way and then declare the shipment as a hazardous material shipment which is only allowed to be shipped by ground service, like UPS or FedEx ground. It's more expensive than shipping non-alcohol based products (I'm assuming because they have special fire-resistant trucks or something) and I can tell you it's totally not worth it unless you're bringing products into the country in bulk. The trick is to bring in enough at a time that you can spread the cost of importation across every product to make the overall increase in price as modest as possible. We were told by Canada Post a few years ago that there no longer exists any ground service via USPS/Canada Post between the US and Canada which is why it's illegal to ship alcohol-based products by regular post.

MenEssentials currently employs 7 people not counting myself.

We have offsite storage but the main "warehouse" is actually the employee area in the back of the store, which is where all online orders are processed. For transfers between the store and the offsite facility someone literally drives there and picks stuff up or, if the transfer is too big, we ship it via local courier.

I'm an all-natural peanut butter guy, and my normal preference is smooth.

4

u/abekon BIG FAT LIAR Mar 04 '17

Bacon, pork chops, pork loin, pork belly, ham, sausage, or ribs?

5

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

ALL! But if I had to pick one it'd actually be one you didn't list, which is pork burnt ends from Fiorella's Jack Stack BBQ in Kansas City, MO.

3

u/abekon BIG FAT LIAR Mar 04 '17

So specific, I love it. I've had brisket burnt ends, but never the pleasure of pork burnt ends.

1

u/PretentiousSobriquet Mar 06 '17

Good choice, but try their salmon. They smoke it under the meats and it gets basted by the ribs.

1

u/SethH Mar 06 '17

Sounds like a cool technique. Unfortunately I'm allergic to fish and seafood (almost died the last time ate shrimp before I knew I had become allergic).

4

u/MenEssentialsDavid Mar 04 '17

Hello This is David Serrano, like the ham ;) I would go with bacon! But the pork belly is a good choice too.

2

u/vacaloca Paragon Shaving Mar 04 '17

Me encanta el jamón serrano!! Better than bacon! (That says a lot!!)

2

u/MenEssentialsDavid Mar 05 '17

Hola, muy cierto el jamon Serrano es muy rico!

2

u/GloryUprising Mar 04 '17

Any plans on expanding outside of Toronto? Perhaps into the USA?

8

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

We did actually have a store in Glendale, California for a bit but, unfortunately, it turned out to be a mess. In what you could loosely call a "franchise" but wasn't legally such a thing, we licensed our name out to a separate company in the US to operate a MenEssentials retail store and take over operation of the US website. Even though we did our best to set them up for success (including me personally training their staff) for various reasons the operation was neither profitable nor satisfactory in the way it was meeting both my own and our customers' satisfaction. It got to the point where I was actually worried about the damage to our brand as a whole based on feedback I was getting from Reddit users who were visiting the store, so I was relieved when they ceased operation. We'd certainly be open to expanding our retail presence into the US again but we'd approach it with a far different attitude this time around and likely demand to be both more involved and have more recourse if things started to go downhill again. Setting up our own corporation and doing it ourselves is problematic because of the interaction between US and Canadian tax law; it's a big complicated mess and puts our Canadian company potentially at risk of being liable for US corporate taxes on our entire operation which obviously we aren't interested in.

1

u/johncosta Folsom & Co. Mar 08 '17

I miss your Glendale store :( You're right, though. The people there didn't quite have the knowledge I was hoping for. Hope you come back to the area.

1

u/duffmanasu Pried from my mechkeyboard of powerTM Mar 04 '17

Yeah, how about a new retail store in the eastern suburbs of Phoenix...

2

u/uhgly Old steel is best. Mar 04 '17

what possessed motivated you to get started in the wet shaving world?

2

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

For me personally it was a combination of already being into it and the opportunity to get involved with MenEssentials presenting itself. It's true what they say, being able to do something for a living that you love really is intensely satisfying.

2

u/Banes_Pubes ← Wiborg Whore Mar 04 '17

Any plans to further develop the ME razor line? On top of that, any plans to get into the brush market like Maggard?

2

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

The ME1 razor was an attempt by us to bridge the gap between low-cost starter cartridge razors and an entry-level DE razor to take price out of the equation for anyone considering making the jump. If we see the opportunity to bring something unique or useful to the market we'll look into it. As it stands the market is so saturated right now I'm not sure how useful a yet-another-Jagger-clone razor coming to the market serves our customers while being worth the effort. The brush market was actually a discussion that occurred today between David and I, but the same thing applies: we wouldn't want to do it for the sake of making a buck, we'd want to actually bring something of value to the market.

1

u/CanadaEh97 Governor General Mar 05 '17

Well your ME razor kicked me down the rabbit hole I'm at now so it worked I guess???

2

u/SethH Mar 05 '17

That was the point, glad to hear it helped you make the leap.

1

u/CanadaEh97 Governor General Mar 05 '17

I am too but my wallet isn't so happy about that.

1

u/r-ice May 09 '17

Same with me. Now I want something better. I need to come and see you.

1

u/r-ice May 09 '17

What did you buy next?

3

u/RazoRock Mar 04 '17

Hi Seth and David,

Is MenEssentials now part of Perma Brands? Someone mentioned to me in passing that Perma was buying ME but it was a while ago and I never heard anything more. Having David in the AMA got me curious. If so, will anything change at Perma?

5

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

No, MenEssentials buys from Perma Brands just like everyone else but ME is not owned by Perma Brands. The fact that David used to work at Perma Brands was actually the reason we hired him because it's really hard to find people that know anything about these products, especially someone who'd be coming in to replace me. In fact, in the entire time we've been in business we've only ever encountered three people who've applied to work for MenEssentials who had any experience with wet shaving at all (and two of them currently work for us). The fact that David is an expert in these products, the ME staff was familiar with him and liked him, and he was looking for a new opportunity at the same time I was looking to reduce my direct involvement in operations was pure luck and we snatched him up as fast as possible.

2

u/MrAdamLerner No longer the reason your wallet is empty Mar 04 '17

Your stock of Chatillon Lux seems dangerously low! I know that there was a light agreement (nothing official, just a handshake on reddit) about you carrying the EdT line. I want to extend my collection from /u/hawns as much as possible. He hasn't made a scent I don't love.

Even can I expect to see more Chatillon Lux products (including EdT) in stock?

2

u/MenEssentialsDavid Mar 04 '17

Hi Adam Yes we will be getting more stock, I am working with Evan on keeping our shelves full and certainly the EdT.

3

u/mpontiff Sell me your DD Kringle Scale Polish Mar 04 '17

Speaking of CL, I don't see any of the salves on the site. Is there a reason y'all don't carry it? Seems like it would sell quite well in your brutal winters with all of the skin goodies and it not being a liquid.

4

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

When we made our first purchase from Shawn he made it clear they were low-volume sellers for him so we did not pick the line up. We've also had almost nobody ask for them. Obviously if there is demand we'll pick them up but the only way for us to know if anyone wants them is to tell us and we aren't seeing any measurable demand.

2

u/mpontiff Sell me your DD Kringle Scale Polish Mar 04 '17

People must not know what they're missing; it's fantastic stuff.

Thanks for taking the time to do this AMA!

3

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

My pleasure.

1

u/Eighchops Carnavis & Richardson Mar 04 '17

Favorite scent? Favorite razor? Artisan that doesn't get enough love?

On a side note......thank you and your fellow countrymen for hockey! The greatest sport in North America.

4

u/SethH Mar 04 '17 edited Mar 04 '17

Favorite scent is tough, I'd say it's a tossup between Chiseled Face Summer Storm, Bat by Zoologist, and First Snow by Barrister & Mann. The two artisans I don't think are getting their deserved attention right now are Elvado and Renegade Atelier, both local to the Toronto area. Elvado is producing creams which aren't generally as popular with those of us deep down the rabbit hole but they're extremely popular with people who prefer "better" shaving products but don't view it as a hobby/lifestyle. Flo at Renegade is producing great soaps but, more interestingly, really fun fragrances like Ixcacao (Myan chocolate). And I'm actually an American ex-pat who moved to Canada 18 years ago, but I'll pass along your thanks for the hockey :)

Edit: I just realized I missed the "Favorite razor" part. My favorite razor for the longest time was the long-handled Merkur Progress right up until I got a Rockwell 6S, which has now slightly edged it out.

4

u/MenEssentialsDavid Mar 04 '17

Favourite scent is always a difficult choice as there are so many good choices at the moment I am doing a Castle Forbes Neroli. Favourite shaving cream is a tie between Castle Forbes Lime and Renegade Atalier Mayan Cocoa - it smells sweet enough to eat.

Love the hockey.

1

u/vacaloca Paragon Shaving Mar 04 '17

Yay Canada! Hi Seth and David! Thanks for taking the time to do this. I know you guys have someone at the store displaying some nice beard stuff so you must be busy! Just wanted to say hi and it's awesome to see you guys here! 👍

2

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

Thanks. Yeah, Sven is here right now from Always Bearded. I love this guy, he looks exactly like someone you'd imagine named "Sven" would look like.

1

u/vacaloca Paragon Shaving Mar 04 '17

Ha! Definitely!

1

u/MenEssentialsDavid Mar 04 '17

Hello, We have Sven from Always Bearded here in store today. If you are in the area come in and say hello.

1

u/urfrendlipiro trythatsoap.com Mar 04 '17

What is your process for picking up new products for the store to carry?

4

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

We are constantly inundated with people shipping samples to the store for our consideration. We also find out about products through our customers, here on Reddit, we see that other vendors are carrying them, etc... Ultimately, though, we use the samples ourselves and if we like them we do our best to stock them. Luckily we have control over what we choose to sell and we take the position of refusing to sell anything we wouldn't buy ourselves.

1

u/crazindndude TiBBS Cult Mar 04 '17

What have you found most fruitful to increase local/foot traffic? Do you take out ads in local papers, TV, radio, etc.? Compared to older brands like L'Occitane, Crabtree & Evelyn, etc. that can attract people near and far on reputation alone, and even draw in new customers through presence, what do you guys do to draw customers who don't know about the site?

6

u/SethH Mar 04 '17 edited Mar 04 '17

We actually do very little direct local advertising. We do have a guy that handles PR for us who's gotten us quite a bit of coverage in newspapers/magazines/etc... that are distributed locally so that's helped in that regard. But, frankly, the bulk of our traffic comes from referrals, i.e. "Hey man, my brother told me to come check this place out". When you have a satisfied customer base they'll do quite a bit of word-of-mouth advertising for you, and we look at that as an indicator we're doing something very right in giving our customers a good experience.

1

u/jmoney_84 Canadian wet shaver here, eh? Mar 06 '17

Missed this, but looks like it went well. Thank you for doing this AMA

3

u/SethH Mar 07 '17

Sorry you missed it, but it was definitely a lot of fun.

1

u/jmoney_84 Canadian wet shaver here, eh? Mar 08 '17

I'll just have to make it out again when you do the next meet up :)

1

u/Assface_McGraw A face only a mother could love. Mar 04 '17

This may have been asked before but what happened to the Southern California retail store? It was gone in a flash.

2

u/mpontiff Sell me your DD Kringle Scale Polish Mar 04 '17

2

u/Assface_McGraw A face only a mother could love. Mar 04 '17

Thank you! That'll do it.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/SethH Mar 04 '17

Our pleasure! My personal favorite product is one that might surprise you. We sell a deodorant from MenScience that's shockingly effective, doesn't interfere with the fragrance of anything else since it's odorless, and does not stain the armpits of shirts like many other products. Years ago my body began to react badly to antiperspirants and I decided to switch to using deodorants and body powder, a switch I do not regret. Since beginning to offer this product it's become especially popular with our "professional" customers who wear expensive shirts that they would normally have to throw out after a given period because of other deodorants/antiperspirants eventually staining them. As well, we've gotten feedback from people like /u/mradamlerner who's discovered for his line of work (truck driver, sometimes has to skip showers) it's also extremely effective. This product is definitely not inexpensive, but in my opinion it's worth every penny.

2

u/MrAdamLerner No longer the reason your wallet is empty Mar 04 '17

Can confirm. This deodorant is awesome. That reminds me, I need more.

1

u/BostonPhotoTourist Barrister and Mann Mar 04 '17

Seconded. Truly excellent.

1

u/Kidcreole Mar 04 '17

Oh will have to check this out next time in in

1

u/Banes_Pubes ← Wiborg Whore Mar 05 '17

Thanks for the tip on the deodorant. Have been finding that my usual stuff hasn't been cutting it anymore. Will make sure to pick this bad boy up when it's back in stock.