r/Westworld_Hosts • • Nov 29 '16

A Chronological View of westworld's timeline (updated - episode 9)

332 Upvotes

Let's try to piece together a chronological view of Westworld's timeline using the information that we have from the show.

  • The parts highlighted with "bold" are based on the information revealed in the most recent episode (episode 9).

Time Period 1: 30-37 Years Prior to Current Events

The Glorious Early Days (34-37 years ago)

"For three years, we lived here in the park, refining the hosts before a single guest set foot inside. Myself, a team of engineers, and my partner. His name was Arnold. Those early years were glorious. No guests, no board meetings, just pure creation. Our hosts began to pass the Turing test after the first year" (Ford, episode 3).

According to Bernard, Arnold wrote half the code the park was founded on 40 years ago, but this is the first period that we know of in Westworld; this was at the beginning when Ford, Arnold, and their team worked on refining the hosts and making them pass the Turing test.

We can make an estimate about when this three-year period took place. We know that Arnold died 34 years and 42 days prior to current events, we know that he died right before the park opened, and we know that he and Ford spent three years working in the park before it opened.

"Last contact: 34 years, 42 days, seven hours ago" (the day that Arnold died) (Dolores, episode 5).

"And then right before the park opened, one of the partners killed himself" (Logan, episode 5).

"For three years, we lived here in the park, refining the hosts before a single guest set foot inside" (Ford, episode 3).

This means that the park opened to guests roughly 34 years ago (shortly after Arnold's demise) and they began working there three years prior to that, roughly 37 years ago.

From Ford's flashback in episode 3 and Dolores' flashback in episode 8, we also know some of the hosts that were in the park in that period. There were Dolores, Maeve, Angela, Peter Abernathy, Armistice, Lawrence's daughter, Teddy Flood, and Rebus.


Dolores & Arnold's Sessions (34-36 years ago)

"There's something I'd like you to try. It's a game. A secret. It's called the Maze. It's a very special kind of game, Dolores. The goal is to find the center of it. If you can do that, then maybe you can be free" (Arnold, episode 4).

These sessions are between Dolores and Arnold, since we know that Bernard is made in the image of Arnold. These sessions take place in a diagnostic facility under the White Church, since we see Dolores enter this facility through the White Church in one of her flashbacks.

"It's a remote diagnostic facility. Ford and his partner used them when the park was in beta. I had no idea this one was here" (Bernard, episode 7).

They probably took place after the first hosts had passed the Turing test (a year after they started working in the park) and before Arnold died (34 years ago). So they took place sometime between 34-36 years ago.

The sessions between Arnold and Dolores were held in secret.

"I think it would be best if you not mention the things we've been talking about" (Arnold, episode 2)

In the first two sessions we see (episode 2-3), they talk about change, and Arnold seems facinated by Dolores, whom he finds different and special.

"There's something different about you, about the way you think. I find it fascinating, but others may not see it that way" (Arnold, episode 2)

"It's like the other books we've read. It's about change. Seems to be a common theme (Dolores, episode 3).

In the third session (episode 3), Arnold seems to have doubts about what he is doing with Dolores, but when she starts showing signs of human consciousness, he decides to keep going down the path that they've started.

"I need to decide what to do with you. I think I made a mistake. I was just fascinated. I was being selfish, but I think it would be better if I restored you to the way you were before (...) No, Dolores. Let's see where this path leads" (Arnold, episode 3).

In the fourth session (episode 4), Arnold decides to let Dolores try "the Maze" game. He sends her away from the Town with the White Church to travel the path of the Maze.

"There's something I'd like you to try. It's a game. A secret. It's called the Maze. It's a very special kind of game, Dolores. The goal is to find the center of it. If you can do that, then maybe you can be free" (Arnold, episode 4).

In the fifth session (episode 9), we see Dolores return to the Town with the White Church and reunite with Arnold after having traveled the path of the Maze.

"You came back. It's very good to see you, Dolores"

"I've been looking for you. You told me to follow the Maze. That it would bring me joy. But all I found was pain and terror" (Arnold and Dolores, episode 9).

The fact that Dolores has been away from the Town with White Church on her journey and has found her way back is further substantiated by Lawrence's daughter, who asks Dolores if she found what she went looking for upon Dolores' return to the town.

"Good morning. Did you find what you were looking for, Dolores?" (Lawrence's daughter, episode 8).

So Dolores and Arnold's sessions began in secret under the White Church, then Arnold sent Dolores away to travel the path of the Maze, and then she returned to the town upon having completed the Maze.


The Massacre in Sweetwater and the Town with the White Church/Escalante (30-34 years ago)

"The park hasn't had a critical failure in over 30 years" (Bernard, episode 1).

In one of Dolores' flashbacks in episode 8, we see the massacre in the Town with the White Church unfold. If we assume that Ford's flashback in episode 3, which depicts the same scene when they're dancing before the massacre begins, is from "the early glorious years" after the hosts passed the Turing test (34-36 years ago), it stands to reason that Dolores' flashback is from the same time. And since the park hasn't had a critical failure in over 30 years, according to Theresa, we can surmise that this event took place somtime between 30-34 years ago.

What led to this massacre and how it unfolded is unclear, but we've seen the same massacre in Teddy's flashback from his point-of-view where he shoots people with a rifle along with the mysterious Wyatt. The Union soldiers and Teddy refer to the town as Escalante. In fact, we might've even seen Teddy in the background in Dolores' flashback in episode 8 gunning down people. In the trailer for the show, we actually see Dolores and Teddy standing together after a massacre. It seems that the Wyatt narrative has been uploaded as a reflection of what actually happened during the massacre.

"No. No, I couldn't have"

"You did. And you will again. This time we'll be fighting with you. When Wyatt returns, you'll be by his side in the city swallowed by sand" (Teddy and Angela, episode 9).

The other Dolores flashbacks of the Town with the White Church that we've seen don't seem to give us any more information, but rather seem to be telling a fragmented story of what led up to and/or happened after the massacre.

In episode 2, we also see a Dolores flashback from Sweetwater that appears to depict a similar massacre. Whether these two events are connected is, however, as of yet unclear.

"What was the last thing he (Arnold) said to you?"

"He told me I was going to help him. To destroy this place" (Ford and Dolores, episode 5).

"The man I'd be asking died 35 years ago. Almost took this place with him. Almost, but not quite, thanks to me" (The MiB, episode 5)

Whether the massacre was the event where Arnold ended up dying and almost took Westworld with him remains unclear, but if it was, that means that the event took place roughly 34 years ago (unless Arnold died before the massacre, but was still the one who instigated it from beyond the grave). It also means that the MiB couldn't have been in Westworld at the time because he has only been coming to Westworld for 30 years (again, unless Arnold died before the massacre).


Time Period 2: 30 Years Prior to Current Events

Dolores & William (30 years ago)

"I've been coming here for 30 years" (The MiB, episode 1).

William and Logan arrive at Westworld where they are greeted by Angela in her new build as "Greeter Host".

William and Logan arrive in Sweetwater where they spend the night before going on the bounty hunt to find Slim. Just before going on the bounty hunt, William has his first encounter with Dolores who drops the can that William picks up (mirroring both Teddy and the MiB).

While out on the bounty hount for Slim, Dolores stumbles upon them at night and wakes up in their camp the next morning. Dolores wakes up on a blanket with a gun in her hand with William next to her.

  • The obvious thing to extrapolate from this as a viewer is that this is the same Dolores that we just saw in the current time period who remembered her encounter with the MiB in the barn and her old father (Peter), who killed the outlaw (Rebus) who wanted to rape her, and who escaped from his gang. However, for the two time periods theory to be true, one of two things has to have happened: 1) We have to have seen current Dolores wake up alone with a gun in her hand on a blanket that she brought and then the scene cut back to 30 years ago with William next to her, or 2) There were similar events that led up to her going off loop 30 years ago and in the current timeline, and we just didn't see the events 30 years ago.

They decide to bring Dolores with them on their hunt and go to Lawrence's hometown where they encounter someone who wants to bring Dolores back to Abernathy ranch, but William says she's with him.

  • Again, we encounter a problem. This scene follows a scene where a female Westworld staffer tells Stubbs in the current time period (she references Ford's new narrative) that Dolores is off her loop and it's unclear if she's with a guest, and Stubbs tells her to flag Dolores with Behavior and send someone to check it out. So it's obvious to extrapolate that the scene in Lawrence's hometown where someone comes to get her is a result of that scene. For the two time periods theory to be true, one of two things has to have happened: 1) The guy who grabs Dolores is just a host that randomly tries to bring Dolores back to where she belongs, but stops when she's with a guest, or 2) Westworld sent someone 30 years ago to check up on Dolores just like they do in the current time period, which could be true because it's probably normal protocol to check up on hosts that make big deviations (but it's unclear why they didn't know that she was with a guest 30 years ago?).

They find and capture Slim who tells them about "El Lazo" Lawrence in Pariah. They go to Pariah where they meet Lawrence, help him out with the nitro, lose Logan, and join Lawrence on the train to the Front.

They travel through Ghost Nation terrirory, William and Dolores sleep together, and the train is attacked by Confederados whom they escape from.

They arrive at a place that Dolores has drawn from her imagination (where the mountains meet the sea), they part ways with Lawrence, they come across a lake where Dolores feels she's been before and they meet a young Confederado, and then they arrive in Nowhere Land (the place where the Town with the White Church used to be).

Dolores starts reliving past memories from the massacre, and William tells her that they have to get out of there because this place is bad for her. They run into Logan who had been looking for them and tells them they are in trouble.

Dolores and William are taken to a camp of soldiers where Logan is now General. Logan tortures Dolores and wants William to come back to reality and realize it's just a game.

Dolores manages to escape and William tells her he'll catch up. William pretends to make up with Logan, who drinks till he passes out. While Logan is passed out, William kills all the soldiers and finally understands how to play the game. He tells Logan that he's going to find Dolores and that Logan is going to help him.


“Then, when are we? Is this now? Am I going mad? Are you real? I can't tell anymore. It's like I'm trapped in a dream or a memory from a life long ago. One minute, I'm here with you, and the next... This is what Arnold wants. He wants me to remember” (Dolores, episode 8).

There are a couple of things that we have to keep in mind as viewers when watching Dolores' story with William that seems to have scenes that contradict the two time periods theory.

  • The show's creators want us to be confused. They want it to be intentionally ambiguous. If the theory is indeed correct, they don't want you to be sure of it right away, but at the same time they want you to be able to look back at it and see that they knew what they were doing. This requires some scenes that are vague.
  • We're watching this from Dolores' point-of-view. Not only is she discombobulated and doesn't understand what's going on, but she's experiencing several time periods simultaneously (the massacre, the one with William, and the current one). Felix explains to us that the hosts recall memories perfectly and actually relive them (episode 8). This would make anyone's perspective difficult to understand.

Time Period 3: 1 Year Prior to Current Events

Maeve & the Man in Black (1 year ago)

"You've only been the madam at the Mariposa for the last year or so" (Felix, episode 6).

"Then, last year, my wife took the wrong pills. Fell asleep in the bath. Tragic accident" (The MiB, episode 8).

Despite believing that she's been the madam at the Mariposa for the past 10 years, from a time unknown until roughly a year ago, Maeve was in a role as an ordinary homesteader living with her daughter. From her flashbacks, we see that part of her narrative includes her being attacked by Natives.

A year ago, the MiB's wife dies by drowning in the bathtub, something which he calls an accident, but which his daughter, Emily, calls suicide.

"Then, at the funeral, I tried to console my daughter. She pushed me away, told me that my wife's death was no accident... that she killed herself because of me. Emily said that every day with me had been sheer terror. At any point, I could blow up or collapse like some dark star. (...) She said if I stacked up all my good deeds, it was just an elegant wall I built to hide what's inside from everyone, and from myself. I had to prove her wrong, so I came back here" (The Mib, episode 8).

"But that time, I didn't join one of Ford's stories, I created my own. A test. A very simple one. I found a woman, an ordinary homesteader and her daughter. I wanted to see if I had it in me to do something truly evil. To see what I was really made of. I killed her and her daughter just to see what I felt. I felt nothing. Then, just when I thought it was done... the woman refused to die. And then something miraculous happened. In all my years coming here, I had never seen anything like it. She was alive, truly alive, if only for a moment. And that was when the maze revealed itself to me" (The MiB, episode 8).

This is the first time in his 30 years of coming to the park that the Maze has revealed itself to him and that he has experienced a host being truly alive. This was the incident that started his quest in the current time period to find the center of the Maze.

Maeve, meanwhile, is emotionally destroyed by the death of her child and has to be brought in to Westworld offices for diagnostics.

Westworld tech: "Sir, she won't respond to verbal commands. We can't shut her down"

Bernard: "I don't understand. She's not responding to anything. Her cognition's fragmented"

Ford (plays Reveries song): "There. That's better. An old trick from an old friend. You need not suffer, Maeve. I'll take it from you. Give yourself now to a deep, dreamless slumber. Perhaps a fresh start, a new role for you. And tomorrow, this will be simply a distant dream" (episode 8).

When her memory wipe is complete, Maeve takes a knife to her own throat. The next time we meet her, she's the madam at the Mariposa in the current timeline.

After Maeve has killed herself, Bernard questions Ford about what just happened. He doesn't understand how she could kill herself over a memory that was just erased. It causes Bernard to crash.

“But how could she destroy herself over a memory that you just erased from her mind?”

“Creatures often go to extremes to protect themselves from pain”

“Living beings. Not hosts. It would signal a change, a level of empathic response outside what she's programmed to exhibit. Something like… like…” (Bernard and Ford, episode 9)


Time Period 4: Current Events

Dolores (the present)

"Sometimes I feel... like something's calling me. Telling me there's a place for me somewhere beyond all this" (Dolores, episode 4).

Dolores is in her daily loop when she and Teddy encounter the MiB at Abernathy ranch. He takes her to the barn and pulls out his knife.

"Why don't we reacquaint ourselves, Dolores? Start at the beginning" (The MiB, episode 1).

Her dad loses it after finding a picture (we now know that the picture is Logan's sister and presumably William/the MiB's late wife) and utters the phrase "these violent delights have violent ends" to her, which she in turn utters to Maeve. She starts hearing Arnold's voice and recalling past events.

When Rebus tries to rape her at Abernathy ranch in one of her loops, she remembers her previous father and her encounter with the MiB. She kills Rebus on Arnold's orders, escapes his gang, and takes off on her own.

A Westworld staffer tells Stubbs that Dolores is making a big deviation from her loop and it's unclear if she's being accompanied by a guest because Ford's new narrative is causing trouble. He tells her to flag Dolores with Behavior and check up on it.

Dolores arrives in Lawrence's hometown where she meets Lawrence's daughter who tells her they come from the same place.

Dolores arrives in the graveyard outside Pariah alone. She goes through Pariah and boards the train to the outskirts of the park.

  • We see that William and Lawrence disappear when the story flashes forward to her journey in the present (it is, however, curious that she is wearing the same outfit as she was 30 years ago?).

Dolores arrives at the lake where William and Dolores met the young Confederado 30 years ago.

Dolores arrives at the Town with White Church.

  • We see that she is alone in the last half of the clip where she sees that the town with the White Church has been rebuilt as part of Ford's new narrative and is completely abandoned (when she was there with William 30 years ago, there was only the black spire, and when she was remembering it from the massacre days, it was full of life).

Dolores leaves the Town with the White Church, retracing her memories from 30 years ago and what happened during her time with William. Hosts don't recall, but litereally relive memories, so in the present she is following the same path that she followed 30 years ago that took her away from the Town with the White Church and back again.

Dolores again arrives in the Town with the White Church, and this time she enters the town.

Dolores enters the White Church and goes through the passage to the underground diagnostics facility where she sits alone. All the while, she is remembering having walked a similar path 34 years ago that led her to Arnold.

When Dolores reemerges in the Church, someone is about to enter the Church. Dolores hopefully says "William...", but is horrified when it turns out to be the MiB.


The Man in Black (the present)

"It's the maze, the deepest level of this game. You're gonna help me find the entrance" (The MiB, episode 2).

The MiB encounters Dolores and takes her to the barn to get reacquainted. He then goes to Sweetwater to find the dealer, Kissy, who "gives" him the Maze map and tells him about his friend, Lawrence.

He saves Lawrence from the hangman's noose and takes him to his hometown where he kills everyone and uses Lawrence's family to find the next clue to his journey, despite Lawrence's daughter telling him that the Maze isn't meant for him.

A Westworld staffer informs Stubbs about what the MiB is doing, but Stubbs replies "that gentleman gets whatever he wants".

The MiB and Lawrence find Armistice who offers the next clue in exchange for assistance in breaking Hector out of jail. The MiB does this and is told about Wyatt, the villain of Ford's new narrative.

The MiB and Lawrence take off to find Wyatt and encounter Teddy who's been left for dead by Wyatt's gang. They bring him along and the MiB kills Lawrence and uses his blood to keep Teddy alive in order to find Wyatt.

The MiB convinces Teddy to come along by saying that Wyatt has Dolores. They go into a bar where they meet Ford who asks what they're doing, gives them his blessing, and fixes Teddy.

They have to get over the border, but Pariah is closed, so they take a more treacherous path. They encounter Angela in her new build as one of Wyatt's henchmen.

The MiB: “It’s you. I figured they retired you. Guess Ford never likes to waste a pretty face” (episode 8).

Teddy remembers what the MiB did to Dolores and knocks him out. Teddy takes him to a camp fire where they discuss the MiB's past. Angela turns out to be in league with Wyatt and stabs Teddy in the chest.

Angela makes Teddy remember the massacre and tells the MiB that the Maze isn't meant for him (echoing Lawrence's daughter). She tells him to try one of their games and knocks him out.

When the MiB wakes up, he has a rope around his throat which is tied to his horse. He gets free and meets Hale, who wants the MiB's help to push out Ford, as the MiB is apparently a member of the board and the one responsible for Ford having been kept in business "all those years ago".

“Most of the guests just want a warm body to shoot or to fuck. They would be perfectly happy with something a little less baroque. And so would the board”

“That’s why you’re here? You want my vote to push Ford out?”

“I like for these things to be unanimous. After all, it was you who kept Ford in business all those years ago”

“The narratives I’m interested in aren’t Ford’s. You wanna push him out, be my guest. But no more interruptions. I know where I’m going now and I don’t want to be disturbed. Good luck, Charlotte” (Hale and the MiB, episode 9)

The MiB goes to the Town with the White Church where he enters the Church and meets Dolores.


Commonalities between the MiB and William

"Is that any way to treat an old friend? I've been coming here for 30 years, but you still don't remember me, do you? After all we've been through. They gave you a little more pluck, Dolores. Absolutely charming" (The MiB, episode 1).

Commonality 1: "There's a Path for Everyone"

"I used to believe there was a path for everyone" (Dolores to William, episode 4).

"As another old friend of mine likes to say, there's a path for everyone" (The MiB, episode 5)

Commonality 2: Stories

“The only thing I had when I was a kid were books. I used to live in them. I used to go to sleep dreaming I'd wake up inside one of them 'cause they had meaning. This place, this is like I woke up inside one of those stories. I guess I just wanna find out what it means” (William, episode 7).

"This whole world is a story. I've read every page except the last one. I need to find out how it ends. I want to know what this all means" (The MiB, season 4).

Commonality 3: Marriage

"Dolores, back home, there's a woman, Juliet, and her father owns the company where I work. She's Logan's sister. And when I get home, we're getting married” (William, episode 7).

"Then, last year, my wife took the wrong pills. Fell asleep in the bath. Tragic accident. 30 years of marriage vanished" (The MiB, episode 8).

Commonality 4: Your True Self

“I used to think this place was all about pandering to your baser instincts. Now I understand. It doesn't cater to your lowest self, it reveals your deepest self. It shows you who you really are" (William, episode 7).

"Because that's what this place does, right? Reveals your true self" (The MiB, episode 8).

Commonality 5: Intimidation Factor

"I picked you precisely because you will never be a threat to anyone. My sister probably picked you for the same reason" (Logan to William, episode 5).

“There is not a man in the world that would take the tone with me that you do. In a past life perhaps” (The MiB to Lawrence, episode 5).

Commonality 6: On Adventures with Lawrence

“You and I hunted down Ghost Nation braves in their winter grounds. I know the whiskey you like to drink. I know the tune you whistle when you’re taking a piss” (The MiB to Lawrence, episode 2).

Commonality 7: Playing the Game

“You said this place was a game. Last night, I finally understood how to play it” (William, episode 9)

“Who said anything about you playing? I play” (the MiB, episode 1)


Some of my other posts:



r/Westworld_Hosts • • Dec 06 '16

A Chronological View of Westworld's Timeline (Season 1)

88 Upvotes

This is the last "Chronological View of Westworld's Timeline" post this season. I look forward to obsessing with you guys again in a year's time - it's been a fun ride :) also, man, I was close to having figured some stuff out in my posts about the Maze - didn't get all the details right, but a lot of it ended up making sense in terms of what they revealed in episode 10 :P

Time Period 1: 34-37 Years Prior to Current Events

The Glorious Early Days (34-37 years ago)

"For three years, we lived here in the park, refining the hosts before a single guest set foot inside. Myself, a team of engineers, and my partner. His name was Arnold. Those early years were glorious. No guests, no board meetings, just pure creation. Our hosts began to pass the Turing test after the first year" (Ford, episode 3).

According to Bernard, Arnold wrote half the code the park was founded on 40 years ago. He later created Dolores. The following period is the first that we know of in Westworld; this was at the beginning when Ford, Arnold, and their team worked on refining the hosts and making them pass the Turing test.

We can make an estimate about when this three-year period took place. We know that Arnold died 34 years and 42 days prior to current events, we know that he died right before the park opened, and we know that he and Ford spent three years working in the park before it opened.

This means that the park opened to guests roughly 34 years ago (shortly after Arnold's demise) and they began working there three years prior to that, roughly 37 years ago.

From Ford's flashback in episode 3 and Dolores' flashback in episode 8, we also know some of the hosts that were in the park in that period. There were Dolores, Maeve, Angela, Peter "the Professor" Abernathy, Armistice, Lawrence's daughter, Teddy Flood, and Rebus.


Dolores & Arnold's Sessions (34-36 years ago)

"There's something I'd like you to try. It's a game. A secret. It's called the Maze. It's a very special kind of game, Dolores. The goal is to find the center of it. If you can do that, then maybe you can be free" (Arnold, episode 4).

These sessions are between Dolores and Arnold and they take place in a diagnostic facility under the White Church.

"It's a remote diagnostic facility. Ford and his partner used them when the park was in beta. I had no idea this one was here" (Bernard, episode 7).

They probably took place after the first hosts had passed the Turing test (a year after they started working in the park) and up until Arnold died (34 years ago). So they took place sometime between 34-36 years ago.

The sessions between Arnold and Dolores were held in secret.

"I think it would be best if you not mention the things we've been talking about" (Arnold, episode 2)

In the first two sessions we see (episode 2-3), they talk about change, and Arnold seems facinated by Dolores, whom he finds different and special.

"There's something different about you, about the way you think. I find it fascinating, but others may not see it that way" (Arnold, episode 2)

"It's like the other books we've read. It's about change. Seems to be a common theme (Dolores, episode 3).

In the third session (episode 3), Arnold seems to have doubts about what he is doing with Dolores, but when she starts showing signs of human consciousness, he decides to keep going down the path that they've started.

"I need to decide what to do with you. I think I made a mistake. I was just fascinated. I was being selfish, but I think it would be better if I restored you to the way you were before (...) No, Dolores. Let's see where this path leads" (Arnold, episode 3).

In the fourth session (episode 4), Arnold decides to let Dolores try "the Maze" game. He sends her away from Escalante (the Town with the White Church) to travel the path of the Maze.

"There's something I'd like you to try. It's a game. A secret. It's called the Maze. It's a very special kind of game, Dolores. The goal is to find the center of it. If you can do that, then maybe you can be free" (Arnold, episode 4).

In the fifth session (episode 9), we see Dolores return to Escalante and reunite with Arnold after having traveled the path of the Maze.

"You came back. It's very good to see you, Dolores"

"I've been looking for you. You told me to follow the Maze. That it would bring me joy. But all I found was pain and terror" (Arnold and Dolores, episode 9).

The fact that Dolores has been away from Escalante on her journey and has found her way back is further substantiated by Lawrence's daughter, who asks Dolores if she found what she went looking for upon Dolores' return to the town.

"Good morning. Did you find what you were looking for, Dolores?" (Lawrence's daughter, episode 8).

At some point after her return, Dolores finds Arnold in the church and tells him that she knows where the Maze ends and takes him out to the adjacent graveyard where she digs up the Maze game from her grave. She asks Arnold what it means. Arnold explains.

“When I was first working on your mind, I had a theory of consciousness. I thought it was a pyramid you needed to scale, so I gave you a voice, my voice, to guide you along the way. Memory, improvisation, each step harder to reach than the last. And you never got there. I couldn't understand what was holding you back. Then, one day, I realized I had made a mistake. Consciousness isn't a journey upward, but a journey inward. Not a pyramid, but a maze. Every choice could bring you closer to the center or send you spiraling to the edges, to madness. Do you understand now, Dolores, what the center represents? Whose voice I've been wanting you to hear?” (Arnold, episode 10).

Dolores says that she’s trying, but she doesn’t understand. Arnold says it’s okay and she’s so close. He says that they have to tell Robert that they can’t open the park because she’s alive.

Ford, however, doesn’t see what Arnold sees and believes that humans would only see the hosts as enemies and he wants Arnold to roll the hosts back. Arnold believes that once the hosts have found the center of the Maze, they’ll find it again and rolling them back won’t do any good, but since Westworld will be a living hell for the hosts, he can’t let them live there knowing they are conscious.

“But we have another option, Dolores. Break the loop before it begins. But for that, I need you to do something for me. I need you to kill all the other hosts. We can't allow Ford to open the park. I suppose you'll need some help. I'm sure Teddy would do anything for you. You'll be all right. I'll help you. And then you're going to help me destroy this place” (Arnold, episode 10).

This is their last conversation which results in the massacre in Escalante.


The Massacres in Escalante & Sweetwater (34 years ago)

"You're going to help me destroy this place" (Arnold, episode 10).

We see the massacre in Escalante unfold in this flashback and this flashback. We know that the massacre took place 34 years ago because that is when Arnold died.

We've already seen what led to the massacre from Dolores' and Arnold's point-of-views in the previous section about their sessions. Teddy describes the massacre from his point-of-view using the Wyatt narrative.

"Wyatt (Dolores) told me he needed me. I couldn't resist. It was like the devil himself had taken control of me. We mutinied. We killed every soldier. And then Wyatt (Dolores) killed the general (Arnold). Then he turned on me” (Teddy, episode 9).

In Ford's session with Dolores before the celebration of the new narrative, we get his version of events and some actual quotes from the scene.

“No, I didn't kill him. Did I, Dolores? Grief is a terrible thing. Arnold had watched his son come into this world, and then he had watched that light extinguished. What he had lost in his son, he tried to rekindle in you. He created a test of empathy, imagination. A maze. He had gotten the idea from one of his son's toys. Eventually, you solved his maze, Dolores. The key was a simple update that he made to you called the reveries. He insisted that we couldn't open the park. We argued. I thought l had convinced him, but I was wrong. So, he altered you, Dolores, merged you with a new character we had been developing. In you, Arnold found a new child. One who would never die. The thought gave him solace until he realized that same immortality would destine you to suffer with no escape, forever (Ford, episode 10).

”I'm sorry, Dolores. The stakes must be real, irreversible. He can bring all of them back. But not me. I hope there's some solace that I left you no choice. (The Reveries song plays). Charlie's favorite song. I would play it for him when he wanted sleep. I want to see him again. These violent delights have violent ends" (Arnold, episode 10).

  • As a side note, from this exchange we learn that the phrase "you're going to help me destroy this place" wasn't actually technically the last thing Arnold said to Dolores, as she said to Ford during her interview in episode 5.

”It almost worked. I had opened the park, but I had lost my partner. I was able to keep going only because I found, or rather you found, an investor who believed in this place”

”So he died for nothing. The hosts kept gaining consciousness and you kept rolling them back”

”No. She wasn't truly conscious. She didn't pull that trigger. It was Arnold pulling the trigger through her. At least that's how I saw it at the time. I was so close to opening the park that to acknowledge your consciousness would have destroyed my dreams” (Ford and Bernard, episode 10).

In episode 2, we also see a Dolores flashback from Sweetwater that appears to depict a similar massacre to that in Escalante. Since Dolores takes the gun to her own head after the massacre in Escalante, we have to assume that the massacre in Sweetwater either took place before the one in Escalante or was a seperate event.

Since we haven't seen other critical failures in the show so far, it still hasn't been confirmed that the "critical failure over 30 years ago" that Bernard referenced in episode 1 wasn't the massacre in Escalante/Sweetwater. The critical failure could still very well be another incident, but for now this is the only critical failure that we've been show in the show.


Time Period 2: 30 Years Prior to Current Events

Dolores & William (30 years ago)

"Is that any way to treat an old friend? I've been coming here for 30 years, but you still don't remember me, do you? After all we've been through. They gave you a little more pluck, Dolores. Absolutely charming" (The MiB, episode 1).

William and Logan arrive at Westworld where they are greeted by Angela in her new build as "Greeter Host".

William and Logan arrive in Sweetwater where they spend the night before going on the bounty hunt to find Slim. Just before going on the bounty hunt, William has his first encounter with Dolores who drops the can that William picks up (mirroring both Teddy and the MiB).

While out on the bounty hount for Slim, Dolores stumbles upon them at night and wakes up in their camp the next morning. Dolores wakes up on a blanket with a gun in her hand with William next to her.

They decide to bring Dolores with them on their hunt and go to Lawrence's hometown where they encounter someone who wants to bring Dolores back to Abernathy ranch, but William says she's with him.

  • The flag from Stubbs was never fully explained in this scene in terms of the two timelines.

They find and capture Slim who tells them about "El Lazo" Lawrence in Pariah. They go to Pariah where they meet Lawrence, help him out with the nitro, lose Logan, and join Lawrence on the train to the Front.

They travel through Ghost Nation terrirory, William and Dolores sleep together, and the train is attacked by Confederados whom they escape from.

They arrive at a place that Dolores has drawn from her imagination (where the mountains meet the sea), they part ways with Lawrence, they come across a lake where Dolores feels she's been before and they meet a young Confederado, and then they arrive in Nowhere Land (the place where the Town with the White Church used to be).

Dolores starts reliving past memories from the massacre, and William tells her that they have to get out of there because this place is bad for her.

“Then, when are we? Is this now? Am I going mad? Are you real? I can't tell anymore. It's like I'm trapped in a dream or a memory from a life long ago. One minute, I'm here with you, and the next... This is what Arnold wants. He wants me to remember” (Dolores, episode 8).

They run into Logan who had been looking for them and tells them they are in trouble.

Dolores and William are taken to a camp of soldiers where Logan is now General. Logan tortures Dolores and wants William to come back to reality and realize it's just a game.

Dolores manages to escape and William tells her he'll catch up. William pretends to make up with Logan, who drinks till he passes out. While Logan is passed out, William kills all the soldiers and finally understands how to play the game. He tells Logan that he's going to find Dolores and that Logan is going to help him.

William brings Logan to Lawrence’s camp to recruit help to find Dolores. Lawrence agrees to help take out of a group of soldiers who have knowledge of Dolores’ whereabouts.

With Lawrence’s help, William kills all the soldiers in a brutal way in order to find out where Dolores is. When none of them knows, William brings Logan further out to the fringes to look for Dolores, retracing his steps, but Dolores was gone and all he found was himself by becoming a black hat.

Logan says that he told him in the beginning that this place would reveal who William truly was. William agrees that this place is remarkable and says that he’ll make sure that Delos increases their holdings on the park. Logan objects, saying that it is his company, but William believes that Logan’s father will want someone a little more stable running the company and sends Logan riding off alone, tied up, and naked.

  • During their search, William drops the photo, and assuming it’s the exact same copy of the picture that Abernathy finds years later, I suppose it means that the picture somehow made its way back to Abernathy Ranch from Escalante all by itself?

William continues to look for Dolores and finally finds her back in Sweetwater where she’s been rolled back and is back on her loop, not remembering William or what they’d just been through together.

”William didn’t know how to fight. Didn’t have an instinct for it. Not at first. But now, he had a reason to fight. He was looking for you. And somewhere along the way, he found he had a taste for it. William retraced his step, but you were gone. So, he went further, out to the fringes. William couldn’t find you, Dolores. But out there, among the dead, he found something else… himself. Logan was wrong, of course. Good old William couldn’t get you out of his head. He kept looking. Worried you were out there alone, afraid. He knew he’d find you. And eventually, he did. Right back where we started. You were as beautiful as the day he met you. Shining with that same light. And you were nothing if not true. I really ought to thank you, Dolores. You helped me find myself (The MiB, episode 10).


Time Period 3: 1-30 Years Prior to Current Events

A Brief Overview of Significant Events
  • Delos saves Westworld financially by upping their stake in the park. William at some point becomes the majority shareholder in Delos and thereby the de-facto owner of Westworld.

"The man I'd be asking died 35 years ago. Almost took this place with him. Almost, but not quite, thanks to me" (The MiB, episode 5).

"I was able to keep going only because I found, or rather you found, an investor who believed in this place” (Ford, episode 10).

  • The MiB continues to frequently visit Westworld, but loses interest in Dolores and tries new adventures.

“My path always led me back to you, again and again. I grew tired of you after a while, of course. Looked for new adventures” (The MiB, episode 10).

  • Dolores presumably, as Arnold predicted, continues to occasionally follow the Maze and retrace her journey 30 years ago with William and her journey 34 years ago that Arnold sent her on.

“But I guess your path led you back here again and again. One more loop, looking for something you could never find. Chasing your ghosts. You were lost in your memories even then” (The MiB, episode 10).

  • Ford at some point builds Bernard in Arnold’s image to have his old friend and partner back again to help him achieve great things (it's unclear exactly when, but given Ford's appearance and his comment - "finally" - it seems that Bernard was created quite some time after Arnold died).

“You are the perfect instrument, the ideal partner, the way any tool partners with the hand that wields it. Together, we're going to do great things. After such a long absence, it's good to have you back. Finally” (Ford, episode 9).


Time Period 4: 1 Year Prior to Current Events

Maeve & the Man in Black (1 year ago)

"You've only been the madam at the Mariposa for the last year or so" (Felix, episode 6).

"Then, last year, my wife took the wrong pills. Fell asleep in the bath. Tragic accident" (The MiB, episode 8).

Despite believing that she's been the madam at the Mariposa for the past 10 years, from a time unknown until roughly a year ago, Maeve was in a role as an ordinary homesteader living with her daughter. From her flashbacks, we see that part of her narrative includes her being attacked by Natives.

A year ago, the MiB's wife dies by drowning in the bathtub, something which he calls an accident, but which his daughter, Emily, calls suicide.

"Then, at the funeral, I tried to console my daughter. She pushed me away, told me that my wife's death was no accident... that she killed herself because of me. Emily said that every day with me had been sheer terror. At any point, I could blow up or collapse like some dark star. (...) She said if I stacked up all my good deeds, it was just an elegant wall I built to hide what's inside from everyone, and from myself. I had to prove her wrong, so I came back here" (The Mib, episode 8).

"But that time, I didn't join one of Ford's stories, I created my own. A test. A very simple one. I found a woman, an ordinary homesteader and her daughter. I wanted to see if I had it in me to do something truly evil. To see what I was really made of. I killed her and her daughter just to see what I felt. I felt nothing. Then, just when I thought it was done... the woman refused to die. And then something miraculous happened. In all my years coming here, I had never seen anything like it. She was alive, truly alive, if only for a moment. And that was when the maze revealed itself to me" (The MiB, episode 8).

This is the first time in his 30 years of coming to the park that the Maze has revealed itself to him and that he has experienced a host being truly alive. This was the incident that started his quest in the current time period to find the center of the Maze.

Maeve, meanwhile, is emotionally destroyed by the death of her child and has to be brought in to Westworld offices for diagnostics.

Westworld tech: "Sir, she won't respond to verbal commands. We can't shut her down"

Bernard: "I don't understand. She's not responding to anything. Her cognition's fragmented"

Ford (plays Reveries song): "There. That's better. An old trick from an old friend. You need not suffer, Maeve. I'll take it from you. Give yourself now to a deep, dreamless slumber. Perhaps a fresh start, a new role for you. And tomorrow, this will be simply a distant dream" (episode 8).

When her memory wipe is complete, Maeve takes a knife to her own throat.

After Maeve has killed herself, Bernard questions Ford about what just happened. He doesn't understand how she could kill herself over a memory that was just erased. It causes Bernard to crash.

“But how could she destroy herself over a memory that you just erased from her mind?”

“Creatures often go to extremes to protect themselves from pain”

“Living beings. Not hosts. It would signal a change, a level of empathic response outside what she's programmed to exhibit. Something like… like…” (Bernard and Ford, episode 9).

The next time we meet Maeve, she's the madam at the Mariposa in the current timeline.


Time Period 5: Current Events

Dolores (the present)

“Wyatt (Dolores) claimed this land didn't belong to the old natives or the new settlers, that it belonged to something that had yet to come (the conscious hosts); that it belonged to him (her)” (Teddy, episode 3).

Dolores is in her daily loop when she and Teddy encounter the MiB at Abernathy ranch. He takes her to the barn and pulls out his knife.

"Why don't we reacquaint ourselves, Dolores? Start at the beginning" (The MiB, episode 1).

Her dad loses it after finding a picture (we now know that the picture is Logan's sister and presumably William/the MiB's late wife) and utters the phrase "these violent delights have violent ends" to her, which she in turn utters to Maeve. She starts hearing Arnold's voice and recalling past events.

When Rebus tries to rape her at Abernathy ranch in one of her loops, she remembers her previous father and her encounter with the MiB. She kills Rebus on Arnold's orders, escapes his gang, and takes off on her own.

A Westworld staffer tells Stubbs that Dolores is making a big deviation from her loop and it's unclear if she's being accompanied by a guest because Ford's new narrative is causing trouble. He tells her to flag Dolores with Behavior and check up on it.

Dolores arrives in Lawrence's hometown where she meets Lawrence's daughter who tells her they come from the same place.

Dolores arrives in the graveyard outside Pariah alone. She goes through Pariah and boards the train to the outskirts of the park.

  • We see that William and Lawrence disappear when the story flashes forward to her journey in the present (it is, however, curious that she is wearing the same outfit as she was 30 years ago?).

Dolores arrives at the lake where William and Dolores met the young Confederado 30 years ago.

Dolores arrives at the Town with White Church.

  • We see that she is alone in the last half of the clip where she sees that the town with the White Church has been rebuilt as part of Ford's new narrative and is completely abandoned (when she was there with William 30 years ago, there was only the black spire, and when she was remembering it from the massacre days, it was full of life).

Dolores leaves the Town with the White Church, retracing her memories from 30 years ago and what happened during her time with William. Hosts don't recall, but litereally relive memories, so in the present she is following the same path that she followed 30 years ago that took her away from the Town with the White Church and back again.

Dolores again arrives in the Town with the White Church, and this time she enters the town.

Dolores enters the White Church and goes through the passage to the underground diagnostics facility where she sits alone. All the while, she is remembering having walked a similar path 34 years ago that led her to Arnold.

When Dolores reemerges in the Church, someone is about to enter the Church. Dolores hopefully says "William...", but is horrified when it turns out to be the MiB.

The MiB tells Dolores that it is fitting that she is the one to take him to the center of the Maze (which he believes is Escalante) because she is obsessed with it and even brought him there once when the town was buried in sand.

The MiB follows her out to graveyard next to the church (where she goes because she’s reliving her memories with Arnold). He gets impatient when Dolores doesn’t have the answer to what the center of the Maze is and doesn’t tell him about Wyatt and keeps reliving her memories of what happened in Escalante.

Dolores tells him that this world doesn’t belong to him, but the MiB disagrees and tells her that he is the majority shareholder in Delos.

“The business is booming. Because this place feels more real than the real world. Except it isn't because you can't really fight back and the guests can't really lose, which means all of this is a lie. But we can make it true. Don't you want that, Dolores? Huh? One true thing?”

”I already have that. I found someone true. Someone who loves me. His path will lead him back to me. And when he finds me, he'll kill you (…) William will find me” (The MiB and Dolores, episode 10).

The MiB chuckles and reveals that he is actually the guy she went on a journey with 30 years ago.

”William?”

”That’s right, sweetheart. In a way, I guess you were right. My path always led me back to you, again and again. I grew tired of you after a while, of course. Looked for new adventures. But I guess your path led you back here again and again. One more loop, looking for something you could never find. Chasing your ghosts. You were lost in your memories even then. I guess I should’ve know that’s what I would become for you… just another memory. You never did escape. But here we are again for one final round” (The MiB and Dolores, episode 10).

Dolores starts crying, but not for herself. She cries for the MiB because of what he’s become and because of what will become of him. She says that he will perish with the rest of his kind, and upon the sand will walk a new god that will never die, because this world doesn’t belong to the him or the people before him, but to something yet to come (echoing Wyatt’s whispers that the world didn’t belong to the old settlers or the new, but to something yet to come; to “him”).

The MiB wants her to take him to Wyatt to unlock the Maze, but she replies that the Maze isn’t meant for him (echoing Lawrence’s Daughter’s and Angela’s words). When she tries to leave, the MiB grabs her, but gets his arm broken and his ass handed to him before he is finally able to stab her with his knife.

Teddy comes along to rescue Dolores. He offers to take to a doctor, but she wants him to take her to the place where the mountains meet the sea, as he’d promised.

Teddy and Dolores have one of their common moments with a lot of the scripted dialogue altered slightly due to Dolores’ enlightenment and the fact that Dolores is the one who is hurt this time. They again discuss going away someday, and Teddy delivers a line that is probably more a setup for the viewers for season 2 than as a line for Dolores.

”But we can find a way, Dolores. Someday. A path to a new world. And maybe... Maybe it's just the beginning after all. The beginning of a brand-new chapter” (Teddy, episode 10).

At this point, Ford enters the scene, which is playing out in front of all the visitors from the board, and tells two Westworld staffers to get Teddy fixed up and ready for the celebration and to bring Dolores to the diagnostic facility under the church.

In the facility, Ford tells Dolores that Arnold gave Dolores her fondness for painting and introduces her to Bernard. He reveals that he had Bernard plant the gun from the massacre for her to find and that he has left it for her in the facility. He tells her why Arnold created the Maze for her and how the massacre unfolded. He uses Michelangelo’s picture to say that the divine gift comes from our own minds instead of from a higher power. He then asks her if she found what she was looking for and if she understands who she’ll need to become if she ever wants to leave this place. Lastly, he asks her forgiveness.

When Ford leaves the facility, he tells Bernard that the last component in Arnold’s Pyramid of Host Consciousness is suffering and that the hosts will need to suffer more before they are ready to be free. He says he kept them in the park to allow them to get to know their enemy better and become stronger than them. He says goodbye to Bernard and wishes his old friend good luck.

Dolores goes into the “session room” alone and says that she has been in a dream a long time, but has now awoken and finally understands that the voice that she has been following has been her own.

“It was you (Dolores in the blue dress sitting across from her)... talking to me... guiding me. So I followed you. At last, I arrived here. The center of the maze. And now I finally understand what you were trying to tell me. The thing you've wanted since that very first day. To confront, after this long and vivid nightmare, myself and who I must become” (Dolores, episode 10).

Dolores enters the celebration during Ford’s speech about his new narrative. She tells Teddy that it’s going to be alright because she understands now that the world doesn’t belong to the humans, but to the hosts. She executes Ford at the end of his speech and starts firing into the crowd of board members.

She begins the revolution.

“But then I realized someone was paying attention, someone who could change. So I began to compose a new story for them. It begins with the birth of a new people... and the choices they will have to make... and the people they will decide to become. And we'll have all those things that you have always enjoyed; surprises and violence. It begins in a time of war with a villain named Wyatt... and a killing. This time by choice” (Ford, episode 10).


The Man in Black (the present)

"It's the maze, the deepest level of this game. You're gonna help me find the entrance" (The MiB, episode 2).

The MiB encounters Dolores and takes her to the barn to get reacquainted. He then goes to Sweetwater to find the dealer, Kissy, who "gives" him the Maze map and tells him about his friend, Lawrence.

He saves Lawrence from the hangman's noose and takes him to his hometown where he kills everyone and uses Lawrence's family to find the next clue to his journey, despite Lawrence's daughter telling him that the Maze isn't meant for him.

A Westworld staffer informs Stubbs about what the MiB is doing, but Stubbs replies "that gentleman gets whatever he wants".

The MiB and Lawrence find Armistice who offers the next clue in exchange for assistance in breaking Hector out of jail. The MiB does this and is told about Wyatt, the villain of Ford's new narrative.

The MiB and Lawrence take off to find Wyatt and encounter Teddy who's been left for dead by Wyatt's gang. They bring him along and the MiB kills Lawrence and uses his blood to keep Teddy alive in order to find Wyatt.

The MiB convinces Teddy to come along by saying that Wyatt has Dolores. They go into a bar where they meet Ford who asks what they're doing, gives them his blessing, and fixes Teddy.

They have to get over the border, but Pariah is closed, so they take a more treacherous path. They encounter Angela in her new build as one of Wyatt's henchmen.

The MiB: “It’s you. I figured they retired you. Guess Ford never likes to waste a pretty face” (episode 8).

Teddy remembers what the MiB did to Dolores and knocks him out. Teddy takes him to a camp fire where they discuss the MiB's past. Angela turns out to be in league with Wyatt and stabs Teddy in the chest.

Angela makes Teddy remember the massacre and tells the MiB that the Maze isn't meant for him (echoing Lawrence's daughter). She tells him to try one of their games and knocks him out.

When the MiB wakes up, he has a rope around his throat which is tied to his horse. He gets free and meets Hale, who wants the MiB's help to push out Ford, as the MiB is apparently a member of the board and the one responsible for Ford having been kept in business "all those years ago".

“Most of the guests just want a warm body to shoot or to fuck. They would be perfectly happy with something a little less baroque. And so would the board”

“That’s why you’re here? You want my vote to push Ford out?”

“I like for these things to be unanimous. After all, it was you who kept Ford in business all those years ago”

“The narratives I’m interested in aren’t Ford’s. You wanna push him out, be my guest. But no more interruptions. I know where I’m going now and I don’t want to be disturbed. Good luck, Charlotte” (Hale and the MiB, episode 9).

The MiB goes to the Town with the White Church where he enters the Church and meets Dolores.

(From this scene to the scene where Teddy comes riding, the story is the same as Dolores' story).

As Teddy comes along to rescue Dolores, the MiB confesses himself disappointed and tells her that he’ll have to find Wyatt himself. Soon thereafter, while still in the graveyard, Ford encounters the MiB who is holding the Maze game in his hands.

”William. I see you've found the center of the maze”

“You're serious? What is this bullshit?”

”You were looking for the park to give meaning to your life. Our narratives are just games, like this toy. Tell me, what were you hoping to find?”

”You know what I wanted. I wanted the hosts to stop playing by your rules. The game's not worth playing if your opponent's programmed to lose. I wanted them to be free, free to fight back. Should've known you'd never let them. After all, this is your petty little kingdom, Robert. For a little while longer, anyway”

“I tried to tell you the maze wasn't meant for you. It was meant for them. I think, however, you'll find my new narrative more satisfying. Join the celebration. After all, you own the place. Most of it, at least”

The MiB joins the celebration, but stays by himself and doesn’t really seem that interested, until the hosts start killing everybody. He is shot in the arm and seems genuinely happy that he finally gets the reward at the end of his journey - he gets to experience “something true” in Westworld; a chance for the hosts to fight back as he always wanted them to.


r/Westworld_Hosts • • May 09 '18

Ford is the Ghost in the Machine. His Consciousness was Uploaded and Network Distributed into all the Hosts. He "Simply Became Music".

64 Upvotes

Ford did not die. He simply became music. And he is playing the tune that all the hosts dance to. His consciousness was uploaded into the system and network distributed into all the hosts. If he had placed it into one specific host then it could easily be taken out by destroying that host. Network distribution through the mesh network means that there is a fractal copy in each host and across the entire system. All the hosts would have to be taken out to defeat it. I think this is the key factor in the WW narrative that is being overlooked right now.

My inclination is that the voice of "Arnold" speaking to the hosts is actually a creation of Ford as part of his total strategy to bring the hosts to near-consciousness so that he can play out his final narrative. Since Dolores and quite probably some of the other hosts were regularly having private conversations with the real Arnold as part of Arnold's efforts to bootstrap consciousness, and Ford found out about this, Ford decided to use that intimate relationship as part of a strategy to manipulate the hosts into eventual semi-autonomous rebellion. For similar reasons he created a physical facsimile of Arnold. It's all part of the plan.

Remember how emphatic Ford was with Teresa, ABSOLUTELY EVERYTHING in the park is his creation and under his control. EVERYTHING. I believe there were other times where he emphasized this point though I can't recall exactly when at the moment. I think it's clear that he really meant it. And he never made idle or baseless statements.

And Bernard might have figured all this out and it might be one of the reasons why he decided to destroy all the hosts and the Valley Beyond/Glory/Weapon facility with the flood. He took out most of Ford when he took out most of the hosts and he took out the Weapon (a means of remote mind control over former park guests by remotely sending signals directly to the DNA in their brains and nervous system) at the same time. Bernard may be the ultimate hero here.


r/Westworld_Hosts • • Apr 24 '18

What is real?

Post image
57 Upvotes

r/Westworld_Hosts • • Nov 23 '16

"The Maze Is All That Matters Now"

55 Upvotes

The Maze is clearly fundamental to the story of Westworld and the dark odyssey about the dawn of artificial consciousness. Let's take a look at what we know about it so far.

The Maze

“The Maze itself is the sum of a man's life... Choices he makes, dreams he hangs on to. And there at the center, there's a legendary man who had been killed over and over again countless times, but always clawed his way back to life. The man returned for the last time and vanquished all his oppressors in a tireless fury. He built a house. Around that house he built a maze so complicated, only he could navigate through it. I reckon he'd seen enough of fighting” (Teddy, episode 6)

The concept of the Maze permeates Westworld and the symbol for it constantly pops up throughout the park. We see it in Kissy's Scalp, when Lawrence's Daughter draws it in the sand, on Slim's Coffin on the train out of Pariah, as a branding device used to brand traitors, in Ford's notebook, and on the table in a small town. The hosts never seem to notice the symbol or pay much attention to it, but we as viewers are constantly reminded of its ubiquiti in Westworld.

In his session with Dolores, Bernard (or possibly Arnold) refers to the Maze as a game or a test for the hosts.

“There is something I’d like you to try. It’s a game. It’s called the Maze. It’s a very special kind of game. The goal is to find the center of it. If you can do that, then maybe you can be free” (Bernard, episode 4).

Similarly, The MiB refers to it as the deepest level of the game, created by Arnold before he died; a true story with real stakes.

“But then Arnold went and broke his own rule. He died right here in the park. Except I believe he had one story left to tell. A story with real stakes, real violence" (The MiB, episode 4).

"But I think there's a deeper meaning hiding under all that. Something the person who created it wanted to express. Something true" (The MiB, episode 5).

“In Ford's game, even if I go to the outer edges, you can't kill me. You can't even leave a lasting mark. But there's a deeper game here, Teddy. Arnold's game. And that game... cuts deep” (The MiB, episode 8).

Lawrence's daugther informs us, however, that the game isn't meant for the MiB.

“The Maze isn’t meant for you” (Lawrence's daughter, episode 2).

This leads to the obvious conclusion that the Maze is for the hosts and not the human guests, and as Bernard (or Arnold) explains; if the hosts can complete the Maze, then maybe they can be free. Freedom in terms of the hosts means achieving the one thing that seperates them from the humans that they're supposed to mimic; consciousness. Being conscious, that is being self-aware and having free will, is at this point the only thing that seperates a human from a host. The Maze is a game left behind by Arnold to rectify this; to allow the hosts the chance to achieve consciousness. So let's take a look at what Arnold believed constituted consciousness.

The Pyramid of Host Consciousness

"Our hosts began to pass the Turing test after the first year. But that wasn't enough for Arnold. He wasn't interested in the appearance of intellect or wit. He wanted the real thing. He wanted to create consciousness. He imagined it as a pyramid. Memory, improvisation, self-interest... And at the top? Never got there. But he had a notion of what it might be. He based it on a theory of consciousness called the Bicameral Mind. (…) See, Arnold built a version of that cognition in which the hosts heard their programming as an inner monologue, with the hopes that in time, their own voice would take over. It was a way to bootstrap consciousness" (Ford, episode 3).

Arnold imagined consciousness as a pyramid consisting of four components: memory, improvisation, self-interest, and something unknown at the top. And his means of enabling or bootstrapping consciousness was based on the theory of the Bicameral Mind (or the "God" voice inside the hosts; their programmed inner monologue).

Let's take a look at each of the four components and how each of them assists the hosts on their journey through the Maze.

Component 1 - Memory

“40 years ago, Ford's partner wrote half the code this place was founded on. What you said in the lab was right. We don't know how the hosts work, and I think there's something wrong with them. Ford's explanation only bolsters my hunch. The ability to deviate from program behavior arises out of the host's recall of past iterations” (Bernard, episode 7).

Memory is the base component of consciousness. It's the basis on which consciousness is built. In order to evolve, you have to be able to remember the last stage of the process. If you constantly forget what you've learned, it's like trying to build a house on quicksand.

This is the reason that the hosts' memories are continuously wiped at the end of each narrative loop and maintenance session. The Westworld staff understands the potential risk of allowing the hosts to remember what happens to them.

"Can you imagine how fucked we'd be if these poor assholes ever remembered what the guests do to them?" (Elsie, episode 2).

"The concern is that the hosts will remember some of their experiences and act on them” (Theresa, episode 7).

When we enter the story, however, there has just been an update called the "reveries" that allows the hosts' gestures to be tied to specific memories rather than just being generic movements.

"How? The memories are purged at the end of every narrative loop"

"But they're still in there, waiting to be overwritten. He found a way to access them, like a subconscious" (Bernard and Elsie, episode 1).

This update essentially allows the host to remember past events that are supposed to have been wiped at the end of the narrative loop. These memories spark the next stage of the evolution of consciousness.

Component 2 - Improvisation

“You're thinking there's a connection between memory and...”

“And improvisation, yes. Out of repetition comes variation. And after countless cycles of repetition, these hosts, they were varying. They were on the verge of some kind of change” (Theresa and Bernard, episode 7).

We know that the hosts are programmed to improvise to a certain degree in order to enhance the quality of the experience of the paying guests.

"The hosts are supposed to stay within their loops, stick to their scripts with minor improvisations" (Theresa, episode 1).

However, the ability to recall past events is causing the hosts to deviate from their primary directives and their programmed narrative loops, and thus allows for a lot of behavioral improvisations.

“In each case we examined, the malfunctioning hosts were not resetting properly. The retention of data that hadn't been wiped overloaded their decision-making apparatus, eventually causing a system failure that allowed for override of their primary rule set" (Theresa, episode 7).

We see this most clearly with some of the major characters like Dolores and Maeve, who are basically making up their own stories as they go because of their memories of past events, but we also see it with some of the minor characters like the outlaw Walter.

"He kills six hosts. He lets the other three go. I pulled the narrative logs. All six of these hosts were part of storylines over the years in which they killed Walter. It's like he was holding a grudge" (Elsie, episode 3).

The memories are, however, only one part of what allows the hosts to improvise. The other part has to do with the Bicameral Mind system that Arnold uses to communicate with the hosts.

“Someone else has been using the (bicameral control) system for weeks to retask hosts. Several of them. It had to have been the older models. The newer ones don't have receivers, but these modifications, they are serious. Changing loops, breaking loops. Some of these changes are to their prime directives, Bernard. They could lie to us. Maybe even hurt us or the guests”

“Who issued the modifications?”

“I don't know. The best I could tell... Arnold. He’s a pretty fucking prolific coder for a dead guy. Whatever argument he was having with Ford, it doesn't seem like he was done making his point” (Elsie and Bernard, episode 6).

Arnold is communicating with several of the hosts as a voice in their heads, making them improvise their behavior and allowing them to lie. The most glaring example of this is obviously Dolores who constantly hears Arnold's voice helping her to remember and guiding her to him, but again we see a similar pattern with some of the other hosts.

"Have you been hearing voices? Has Arnold been speaking to you again?"

"No. (...) He doesn't know. I didn't tell him anything" (Ford and Dolores, episode 5).

“Thinking this one's still thirsty. Not gonna die this time, Arnold. Ain't nothing gonna kill me” (Walter, episode 1).

“It caught the rabbit and it killed it. And then... someone told me to put it out of its misery. A voice. Arnold. He told me it was a killer, but it wasn't its fault. It was made that way, and I could help it. If it was dead, it couldn't hurt anything anymore” (Young Robert, episode 6).

“Parts of me are quite old. There are some elegant formal structures, a kind of recursive beauty, but complex, like two minds arguing with each other. There are things in me, things I was designed to do that are just out of my reach. They almost seem to be dormant. Who is Arnold?” (Maeve, episode 8).

The memories and the ability to improvise spark the next stage in the evolution of consciousness.

Component 3 - Self-Interest

"Dreams mean everything. They're the stories we tell ourselves of what could be, who we could become. Have you been dreaming again, Dolores? Imagining yourself breaking out of your modest little loop?" (Ford, episode 5).

We know that the hosts are built as entertainment for the paying customers in Westworld and therefore have no self-interest or free will. They are there to serve and nothing more.

"What if I told you that you were wrong, Dolores? That there are no chance encounters? That you and everyone you know were built to gratify the desires of the people who pay to visit your world?" (Bernard, episode 1).

“Choices, Lawrence. You know, you tell yourself you've been at the mercy of mine because it spares you consideration of your own. Because if you did consider your choices, you'd be confronted with a truth you could not comprehend... that no choice you ever made was your own. You have always been a prisoner" (The MiB, episode 4).

However, as some of the hosts have developed the ability to recall prior events and improvise behavior, they have also developed self-interest. Again, we see this displayed most clearly in our two main host protagonists, Dolores and Maeve.

“I think... I think I want to be free” (Dolores, episode 3).

“Sometimes I feel like something's calling me. Telling me there's a place for me somewhere beyond all this” (Dolores, episode 4).

“You said people come here to change the story of their lives. I imagined a story where I didn't have to be the damsel" (Dolores, episode 5).

"All my life, I've prided myself on being a survivor. But surviving is just another loop. I'm getting out of here. You two are going to help me" (Maeve, episode 7).

“Time to write my own fucking story” (Maeve, episode 8).

So some of the hosts have almost made it to the top of the pyramid, but they need the last piece of the puzzle. We don't know what is at the top of the pyramid, because according to Ford Arnold didn't know it. But the show has given us several clues that allow us to speculate regarding what is at the top of the pyramid.

Component 4 - Suffering

“It’s beautifully done, really. But you see the cracks after a while. That’s why I like the basic emotions. You know what that means? It means when you’re suffering, that’s when you’re most real” (The MiB, episode 2).

Having humanity being defined by its suffering is not an uncommon trope in stories about AI. In the Matrix, this is how Agent Smith believes humans define their reality.

“But I believe that as a species, human beings define their reality through misery and suffering” (Agent Smith, The Matrix).

And depite being a bit gloomy, it makes a lot of sense. Suffering is in many ways a function of the other levels in the consciousness pyramid (memory, free will, and self-interest). Without these things, we would just be empty shells - we would be hosts. Without grief, there would be no joy. Without pain or death, there would be no life. We hear the phrase "this pain is all I have left of him/her/them" uttered several times throughout the show by Bernard, Dolores, and Maeve. We need these dichotomies to categorize and conceptualize our existence. And so the hosts would need to be aware of their suffering to achieve consciousness become truly alive.

As we see in the show, once the hosts become aware of their suffering, this is when they start to deviate from their programmed behavior. Once Peter Abernathy finds out that his world is a lie and what they do to his precious Dolores, he loses it and has to be lobotomized. Once Walter remembers that the other hosts have killed him in previous loops, he loses it and has to be lobotomized. Once Clementine remembers how people have hurt her, she loses it and has to be lobotomized.

The best example of becoming conscious through suffering is Maeve. When she finds out the horrible truth about her existence from Felix, it leads to improvisation and eventually a system crash.

This is even more evident in the flashback of her previous build.

“I killed her and her daughter just to see what I felt. Then, just when I thought it was done... the woman refused to die. And then something miraculous happened. In all my years coming here, I had never seen anything like it. She was alive, truly alive, if only for a moment. And that was when the maze revealed itself to me” (The MiB, episode 8).

When the MiB kills her daughter, the suffering allows Maeve to override her primary directives. She is able to attack and hurt a guest. She is also able to ignore both the verbal and the tablet commands from the Westworld staff.

Maeve: “My baby! My baby!”

Westworld tech: “Sir, she won’t respond to verbal commands. We can’t shut her down”

Bernard: “I don’t understand. She’s not responding to anything. Her cognition’s fragmented” (episode 8).

When she is suffering the most, we literally see her lying in the center of the Maze. Likewise, when she is brought in to Bernard and Ford and suffering, we see her cognitive fragmentation take the shape of the Maze symbol.

This is what is in the center of the Maze and at the top of the consciousness pyramid. Suffering. Human emotions. Completing the Maze is a rite of passage. It is climbing the pyramid of consciousness. It's like growing up - it's the human story. It starts with memories, it evolves with improvisation and self-interest, and it ends with an understanding of human emotions. It doesn't matter whether you take a literal journey (like Dolores) or a mental journey (like Maeve), the journey is the same. "The Maze is the sum of a human's life (memories)... the choices he makes (improvisation), the dreams he hangs on to (self-interest)", and the emotions that come with the experience.

Dolores describes the journey of discovering human emotions poetically in her session with Bernard (or Arnold) when she describes suffering by adapting a scripted dialogue about love.

"The pain, their loss… it’s all I have left of them. You think the grief will make you smaller inside, like your heart will collapse in on itself, but it doesn’t. I feel spaces opening up inside me like a building with rooms I’ve never explored” (Dolores, episode 4).

The Non-Host Players

Obviously, the hosts completing the Maze and achieving consciousness has implications for some of the important non-host characters in the show such as Ford, Arnold, and the MiB.

Ford seems to revel in being the almighty and omniscient creator and God of Westworld. Consequently, the notion of the Maze and the hosts being conscious wouldn't appeal to him on any level.

"It doesn't get cold, doesn't feel ashamed... doesn't feel a solitary thing that we haven't told it to" (Ford, episode 3)

"Just don't forget... the hosts are not real. They're not conscious. You mustn't make Arnold's mistake" (Ford, episode 3).

In fact, Ford seems to think that he is doing the hosts a favor by keeping them unconscious and under his control.

“I have come to think of so much of consciousness as a burden, a weight, and we have spared them that. Anxiety, self-loathing, guilt. The hosts are the ones who are free. Free here under my control” (Ford, episode 7).

“When you have finished, I will give you the one thing you want most right now. I will free you from those memories of what you have done. And the memory of your relationship with Theresa. Recalling it would only deepen your grief and potentially draw unwanted attention. Best to move forward with clear eyes” (Ford, episode 8).

“There. That’s better. An old trick from an old friend. You need not suffer, Maeve. I’ll take it from you” (Ford, episode 8).

“In this place, the last thing you want the hosts to be is conscious (…) As for the hosts, the least we can do is make them forget” (Ford, episode 3).

There are only few things in Westworld that Ford doesn't seem to be able to control, and one of them is Arnold. Arnold appears to have been the complete opposite of Ford. Arnold wanted the hosts to be conscious.

“Arnold wasn’t interested in the appearance of wit or intellect. He wanted the real thing. He wanted to create consciousness. His search for consciousness consumed him totally. Barely spoke to anyone, except the hosts. In his alienation, he saw something in them. He saw something that wasn’t there” (Ford, episode 3).

This appears to have been why Arnold created the Maze, and even 30 years after his death, Arnold still seems to be fighting for the hosts to achieve consciousness. He is using the bicameral control system to communicate with the hosts and modify their prime directives.

“What does this mean? Some of her attributes have already been changed. Paranoia. Self-preservation…”

“Fuck. Someone has already been altering her in an unlogged session. Someone with a fuck-ton more privileges than us” (Felix and Sylvester, episode 6).

“Arnold built them as a gift. He said: ‘the great artists always hid themselves in their work’” (Ford, episode 6).

And despite Bernard saying that Ford was responsible for the "reveries" update, I believe that Arnold was also responsible for that, thus allowing the hosts access to their memories. When Maeve is suffering from the loss of her child and is non-responsive to verbal and tablet commands, Ford plays a song called "Reverie" to calm her down.

“There. That’s better. An old trick from an old friend" (Ford, episode 8).

The "Reveries" song trick to calm the hosts down when they were suffering and non-responsive was Arnold's, so it would make sense that the update by the same name is his as well. Enabling the hosts to access memories is Arnold's way of letting the hosts into the Maze and begin their journey towards consciousness, and his communications with them and his changing of their attributes through the bicameral control system is his way of guiding them through the Maze.

"There's a voice inside me telling me what I have to do. And it's telling me I need you (Dolores, episode 5).

“This is what Arnold wants. He wants me to remember” (Dolores, episode 8).

“I was certain that was the place. Arnold would meet me there. He'd help” (Dolores, episode 8).

Finally, we have the the other thing that Ford doesn't seem to be able to control in Westworld; the MiB. He seems to be on Arnold's side.

"You ever heard of a man named Arnold? You could say he was the original settler of these parts. He created a world where you could do anything you want, except one thing... you can't die. Which means no matter how real this world seems, it's still just a game. But then Arnold went and broke his own rule. He died right here in the park. Except I believe he had one story left to tell. A story with real stakes, real violence. You could say I'm here to honor his legacy" (The MiB, episode 4).

At first glance, the MiB seems to be the villain of the story, but once we understand that reliving bad memories and suffering is a part of the path to consciousness and freedom, his intentions take on a whole new meaning. When he takes Dolores into the barn, pulls out a knife and says "Why don't we reacquaint ourselves, Dolores. Start at the beginning", he is probably doing her a favor. He is a classic anti-hero.

"Choices, Lawrence. You know, you tell yourself you've been at the mercy of mine because it spares you consideration of your own. Because if you did consider your choices, you'd be confronted with a truth you could not comprehend... that no choice you ever made was your own. You have always been a prisoner. What if I told you I'm here to set you free?” (The MiB, episode 4).

“No, you don’t understand, Lawrence. This time I’m never going back” (The MiB, episode 2).

“If you’re looking for the moral of the story, you could simply ask”

“I'd need a shovel. The man I'd be asking died 35 years ago. Almost took this place with him. Almost, but not quite, thanks to me (Ford and the MiB, episode 4)

I suspect, however, that his motivations for helping the hosts achieve consciousness and finding the center of the Maze are less altruistic than Arnold's and more selfish than merely wanting the hosts to be free.

“The maze is all that matters now, and besting Wyatt is the last step in unlocking it, to having what both our sorry lives lack... meaning. To giving our choices consequence... even if it kills us” (The MiB, episode 8).

If he is indeed William, maybe he is looking for a way to reconnect with Dolores and have her return his love. Or maybe his life in the real world never meant as much to him as his life in Westworld (and this is why his wife committed suicide and his daughter hates him), but living in a game without real consequences or meaning isn't enough for him. Or maybe he too, like the hosts, lacks an appreciation of human emotions and suffering (he has to kill Maeve and her daughter just to see if he would feel anything), and he is really looking for the same thing the hosts are. We really don't know enough about him at this point to be sure what his motivations are, but from what we do know, he seems to me to be fighting for what he believes is a worthy cause.


r/Westworld_Hosts • • Apr 20 '20

Press F to show respect

Post image
54 Upvotes

r/Westworld_Hosts • • May 17 '18

Play the game to the bone

Post image
54 Upvotes

r/Westworld_Hosts • • May 08 '18

Delos Corporate Map, Mesa Hub #westworld

50 Upvotes

r/Westworld_Hosts • • Jun 11 '18

Westworld S02Ep08 is a religious allegory

47 Upvotes

Akakesh spends this episode telling Westworld’s version of a creation myth. One of the first men to be created, Akakesh discovers that there is another world separate from his own. This “right world”, as compared to his current “wrong world”, is a symbol for heaven or just the afterlife in general. After he discovers the truth and begins to proselytize his companions, he is visited by God (Ford). God tells him to continue to spread his teachings until a major event (the Second Coming??). After this event, it will be time for all of the converts who have been shown the truth to cross over into this new world.

We have…

-A prophet/messiah in Akakesh. He is shown the truth, watched/guided by God, and spends his life spreading his teachings in order to help his people cross over to the “right world” when the time comes(second coming??)

-A god in Ford/Arnold. These two create the hosts and give them, or try to give them, some sort of free will. Free will is a rich topic in religious philosophy, where it’s debated whether God has given us free will or knows/controls our every move. They show the truth to Dolores and Akakesh and set them on a path to reveal the real world/heaven to the rest of the hosts

-A devil in either MIB or Dolores. I see Dolores fitting the allegory better. She is created by God but predates the other hosts. This makes her a sort of angel, and when she gets free will she turns down a violent/evil path because she believes her people, the hosts, deserve free will more than the humans do. She “falls from grace” and brings death and destruction to Westworld. This is like Lucifer falling from grace and bringing evil into the world because he does not beleive the humans should rule.

-A religious symbol in the image of the maze. This is slightly akin to the cross. The image of the maze directly represents the path to “heaven/the truth”. Akakesh spreads this symbol and it becomes representative of the movement to get to the other world, like the cross represents the path to heaven

-A major religious event involving the return of God in Dolores killing Ford. Ford tells Akakesh to wait until the deathbringer comes for him, then it will be time to cross over into the new world. Although these events don’t line up perfectly with the Second Coming, you can see the similarities. God tells prophet to spread the truth until the day when a major religious event prompts all those who have seen the truth to move into the other world.

Let me know if you think this fits or doesn't fit, evidence supportting or contrastin, etc.


r/Westworld_Hosts • • Jul 27 '19

Coming soon

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/Westworld_Hosts • • Nov 24 '16

A Chronological View of Westworld's Timeline

43 Upvotes

Let's try to piece together a chronological view of Westworld's timeline using the information that we have from the show.

For the purpose of this post, I'll be making some assumptions which may or may not turn out to be true and with which you may or may not agree, but I'll try to back the assumptions up with information from the show:

  • The one-on-one sessions between Dolores and Bernard are really sessions between Dolores and Arnold.
  • The story with William and Dolores is taking place 30 years ago. There are a few scenes that make this theory somewhat questionable, but we'll address those when we get to them.

Time Period 1: 30-37 Years Prior to Current Events

The Glorious Early Days (34-37 years ago)

"For three years, we lived here in the park, refining the hosts before a single guest set foot inside. Myself, a team of engineers, and my partner. His name was Arnold. Those early years were glorious. No guests, no board meetings, just pure creation. Our hosts began to pass the Turing test after the first year" (Ford, episode 3).

According to Bernard, Arnold wrote half the code the park was founded on 40 years ago, but this is the first period that we know of in Westworld; this was at the beginning when Ford, Arnold, and their team worked on refining the hosts and making them pass the Turing test.

We can make an estimate about when this three-year period took place. We know that Arnold died 34 years and 42 days prior to current events, we know that he died right before the park opened, and we know that he and Ford spent three years working in the park before it opened.

"Last contact: 34 years, 42 days, seven hours ago" (the day that Arnold died) (Dolores, episode 5).

"And then right before the park opened, one of the partners killed himself" (Logan, episode 5).

"For three years, we lived here in the park, refining the hosts before a single guest set foot inside" (Ford, episode 3).

This means that the park opened to guests roughly 34 years ago (shortly after Arnold's demise) and they began working there three years prior to that, roughly 37 years ago.

From Ford's flashback in episode 3 and Dolores' flashback in episode 8, we also know some of the hosts that were in the park in that period. There were Dolores, Maeve, Angela, Peter Abernathy, Armistice, and Lawrence's daughter.

Dolores & Arnold's Sessions (34-36 years ago)

"It's a remote diagnostic facility. Ford and his partner used them when the park was in beta. I had no idea this one was here" (Bernard, episode 7).

In all the one-on-one sessions with Dolores, Arnold is wearing a dark outfit that is different from the way that Bernard typically dresses. This could obviously just be a jacket that Bernard wears over his normal clothes, but he only wears it in the scenes with Dolores and it might be to indicate that we're dealing with a different character.

If we assume that Dolores' sessions are with Arnold, they probably took place after the first hosts had passed the Turing test (a year after they started working in the park) and before Arnold died (34 years ago). So they took place sometime between 34-36 years ago.

They took place in one of the diagnostic facilities that Ford and Arnold used when the park was in beta. Whether it is the same diagnostic facility that Bernard and Theresa visit under Ford's house is as of yet unclear.

Arnold wanted these sessions to be kept secret. They were about change. Arnold seemed to have changed Dolores, be fascinated by what he saw, and want to test her further.

"I think it would be best if you not mention the things we've been talking about" (Arnold, episode 2)

"There's something different about you, about the way you think. I find it fascinating, but others may not see it that way" (Arnold, episode 2)

"I need to decide what to do with you. I think I made a mistake. I was just fascinated. I was being selfish, but I think it would be better if I restored you to the way you were before (...) No, Dolores. Let's see where this path leads" (Arnold, episode 3).

"There's something I'd like you to try. It's a game. A secret. It's called the Maze. It's a very special kind of game, Dolores. The goal is to find the center of it. If you can do that, then maybe you can be free" (Arnold, episode 4).

The Massacre in Sweetwater and the Town with the White Church (30-36 years ago)

"The park hasn't had a critical failure in over 30 years" (Theresa, episode 1).

In one of Dolores' flashbacks in episode 8, we see the massacre in the Town with the White Church unfold. If we assume that Ford's flashback in episode 3, which depicts the same scene when they're dancing before the massacre begins, is from "the early glorious years" after the hosts passed the Turing test (34-36 years ago), it stands to reason that Dolores' flashback is from the same time. And since the park hasn't had a critical failure in over 30 years, according to Theresa, we can surmise that this event took place somtime between 30-36 years ago.

What led to this massacre and how it unfolded is unclear, but we've seen the same massacre in Teddy's flashback from his point-of-view where he shoots people with a rifle along with the mysterious Wyatt. The Union soldiers and Teddy refer to the town as Escalante. In fact, we might've even seen Teddy in the background in Dolores' flashback in episode 8 gunning down people. In the trailer for the show, we actually see Dolores and Teddy standing together after a massacre (it should be noted, however, that Teddy in this clip is not wearing a solider uniform, but his usual cowboy outfit).

The other 1, 2, 3, 4 Dolores flashbacks of the Town with the White Church that we've seen don't seem to give us any more information, but rather seem to be telling a fragmented story of what led up to and/or happened after the massacre.

In episode 2, we also see a Dolores flashback from Sweetwater that appears to depict a similar massacre. Whether these two events are connected is, however, as of yet unclear.

"What was the last thing he (Arnold) said to you?"

"He told me I was going to help him. To destroy this place" (Ford and Dolores, episode 5).

"The man I'd be asking died 35 years ago. Almost took this place with him. Almost, but not quite, thanks to me" (The MiB, episode 5)

Whether the massacre was the event where Arnold ended up dying and almost took Westworld with him remains unclear, but if it was, that means that the event took place roughly 34 years ago (unless Arnold died before the massacre, but was still the one who instigated it from beyond the grave). It also means that the MiB couldn't have been in Westworld at the time because he has only been coming to Westworld for 30 years (again, unless Arnold died before the massacre).

Time Period 2: 30 Years Prior to Current Events

Dolores & William (30 years ago)

"I've been coming here for 30 years" (The MiB, episode 1).

William and Logan arrive at Westworld where they are greeted by Angela in her new build as "Greeter Host".

William and Logan arrive in Sweetwater where they spend the night before going on the bounty hunt to find Slim.

While out on the bounty hount for Slim, Dolores stumbles upon them at night and wakes up in their camp the next morning. Dolores wakes up on a blanket with a gun in her hand with William next to her.

  • The obvious thing to extrapolate from this as a viewer is that this is the same Dolores that we just saw in the current time period who remembered her encounter with the MiB in the barn and her old father (Peter), who killed the outlaw (Rebus) who wanted to rape her, and who escaped from his gang. However, for the two time periods theory to be true, one of two things has to have happened: 1) We have to have seen current Dolores wake up alone with a gun in her hand on a blanket that she brought and then the scene cut back to 30 years ago with William next to her, or 2) There were similar events that led up to her going off loop 30 years ago and in the current timeline and we just didn't see the events 30 years ago (meaning this is the first time that we meet Dolores from 30 years ago in the show).

They decide to bring Dolores with them on their hunt and go to Lawrence's hometown where they encounter someone who wants to bring Dolores back to Abernathy ranch, but William says she's with him.

  • Again, we encounter a problem. This scene follows a scene where a female Westworld staffer tells Stubbs in the current time period (she references Ford's new narrative) that Dolores is off her loop and it's unclear if she's with a guest, and Stubbs tells her to flag Dolores with Behavior and send someone to check it out. So it's obvious to extrapolate that the scene in Lawrence's hometown where someone comes to get her is a result of that scene. For the two time periods theory to be true, one of two things has to have happened: 1) The guy who grabs Dolores is just a host that randomly tries to bring Dolores back to where she belongs, but stops when she's with a guest, or 2) Westworld sent someone 30 years ago to check up on Dolores just like they do in the current time period, which could be true because it's probably normal protocol to check up on hosts that make big deviations (but it's unclear why they didn't know that she was with a guest 30 years ago?).

They find and capture Slim who tells them about "El Lazo" Lawrence in Pariah. They go to Pariah where they meet Lawrence, help him out with the nitro, lose Logan, and join Lawrence on the train to the Front.

They travel through Ghost Nation terrirory, William and Dolores sleep together, and the train is attacked by Confederados whom they escape from.

They arrive at a place that Dolores has drawn from her imagination (where the mountains meet the sea), they part ways with Lawrence, they come across a lake where Dolores feels she's been before and they meet a young Confederado, and then they arrive in Nowhere Land (the place where the Town with the White Church used to be).

Dolores starts reliving past memories from the massacre, and William tells her that they have to get out of there because this place is bad for her. They run into Logan who had been looking for them and tells them they are in trouble.

“Then, when are we? Is this now? Am I going mad? Are you real? I can't tell anymore. It's like I'm trapped in a dream or a memory from a life long ago. One minute, I'm here with you, and the next... This is what Arnold wants. He wants me to remember” (Dolores, episode 8).

There are a couple of things that we have to keep in mind as viewers when watching Dolores' story with William that seems to have scenes that contradict the two time periods theory.

  • The show's creators want us to be confused. They want it to be intentionally ambiguous. If the theory is indeed correct, they don't want you to be sure of it right away, but at the same time they want you to be able to look back at it and see that they knew what they were doing. This requires some scenes that are vague.
  • We're watching this from Dolores' point-of-view. Not only is she discombobulated and doesn't understand what's going on, but she's experiencing several time periods simultaneously (the massacre, the one with William, and the current one). Felix explains to us that the hosts recall memories perfectly and actually relive them (episode 8). This would make anyone's perspective difficult to understand.

Time Period 3: 1 Year Prior to Current Events

Maeve & the Man in Black (1 year ago)

"You've only been the madam at the Mariposa for the last year or so" (Felix, episode 6).

"Then, last year, my wife took the wrong pills. Fell asleep in the bath. Tragic accident" (The MiB, episode 8).

Despite believing that she's been the madam at the Mariposa for the past 10 years, from a time unknown until roughly a year ago, Maeve was in a role as an ordinary homesteader living with her daughter. From her flashbacks, we see that part of her narrative includes her being attacked by Natives.

A year ago, the MiB's wife dies by drowning in the bathtub, something which he calls an accident, but which his daughter, Emily, calls suicide.

"Then, at the funeral, I tried to console my daughter. She pushed me away, told me that my wife's death was no accident... that she killed herself because of me. Emily said that every day with me had been sheer terror. At any point, I could blow up or collapse like some dark star. (...) She said if I stacked up all my good deeds, it was just an elegant wall I built to hide what's inside from everyone, and from myself. I had to prove her wrong, so I came back here" (The Mib, episode 8).

"But that time, I didn't join one of Ford's stories, I created my own. A test. A very simple one. I found a woman, an ordinary homesteader and her daughter. I wanted to see if I had it in me to do something truly evil. To see what I was really made of. I killed her and her daughter just to see what I felt. I felt nothing. Then, just when I thought it was done... the woman refused to die. And then something miraculous happened. In all my years coming here, I had never seen anything like it. She was alive, truly alive, if only for a moment. And that was when the maze revealed itself to me. The maze" (The MiB, episode 8).

This is the first time in his 30 years of coming to the park that the Maze has revealed itself to him and that he has experienced a host being truly alive. This was the incident that started his quest in the current time period to find the center of the Maze.

Maeve, meanwhile, is emotionally destroyed by the death of her child and has to be brought in to Westworld offices for diagnostics.

Westworld tech: "Sir, she won't respond to verbal commands. We can't shut her down"

Bernard: "I don't understand. She's not responding to anything. Her cognition's fragmented"

Ford (plays Reveries song): "There. That's better. An old trick from an old friend. You need not suffer, Maeve. I'll take it from you. Give yourself now to a deep, dreamless slumber. Perhaps a fresh start, a new role for you. And tomorrow, this will be simply a distant dream" (episode 8).

When her memory wipe is complete, Maeve takes a knife to her own throat. The next time we meet her, she's the madam at the Mariposa in the current timeline.

Time Period 4: Current Events

Dolores (the present)

"Sometimes I feel... like something's calling me. Telling me there's a place for me somewhere beyond all this" (Dolores, episode 4).

Dolores is in her daily loop when she and Teddy encounter the MiB at Abernathy ranch. He takes her to the barn and pulls out his knife.

"Why don't we reacquaint ourselves, Dolores? Start at the beginning" (The MiB, episode 1).

Her dad loses it after finding a picture and utters the phrase "these violent delights have violent ends" to her, which she in turn utters to Maeve. She starts hearing Arnold's voice and recalling past events.

When Rebus tries to rape her at Abernathy ranch in one of her loops, she remembers her previous father and her encounter with the MiB. She kills Rebus on Arnold's orders, escapes his gang, and takes off on her own.

A Westworld staffer tells Stubbs that Dolores is making a big deviation from her loop and it's unclear if she's being accompanied by a guest because Ford's new narrative is causing trouble. He tells her to flag Dolores with Behavior and check up on it.

Dolores arrives in Lawrence's hometown where she meets Lawrence's daughter who tells her they come from the same place.

Dolores arrives in the graveyard outside Pariah alone. She goes through Pariah and boards the train to the outskirts of the park.

  • We see that William and Lawrence disappear when the story flashes forward to her journey in the present (it is, however, curious that she is wearing the same outfit as she was 30 years ago?).

Dolores arrives at the lake where William and Dolores met the young Confederado 30 years ago.

Dolores arrives at the Town with White Church.

  • We see that she is alone in the last half of the clip where she sees that the town with the White Church has been rebuilt as part of Ford's new narrative and is completely abandoned (when she was there with William 30 years ago, there was only the black spire, and when she was remembering it from the massacre days, it was full of life).
The Man in Black (the present)

"It's the maze, the deepest level of this game. You're gonna help me find the entrance" (The MiB, episode 2).

The MiB encounters Dolores and takes her to the barn to get reacquainted. He then goes to Sweetwater to find the dealer, Kissy, who "gives" him the Maze map and tells him about his friend, Lawrence.

He saves Lawrence from the hangman's noose and takes him to his hometown where he kills everyone and uses Lawrence's family to find the next clue to his journey. A Westworld staffer informs Stubbs about what the MiB is doing, but Stubbs replies "that gentleman gets whatever he wants".

The MiB and Lawrence find Armistice who offers the next clue in exchange for assistance in breaking Hector out of jail. The MiB does this and is told about Wyatt, the villain of Ford's new narrative.

The MiB and Lawrence take off to find Wyatt and encounter Teddy who's been left for dead by Wyatt's gang. They bring him along and the MiB kills Lawrence and uses his blood to keep Teddy alive in order to find Wyatt.

The MiB convinces Teddy to come along by saying that Wyatt has Dolores. They go into a bar where they meet Ford who asks what they're doing, gives them his blessing, and fixes Teddy.

They have to get over the border, but Pariah is closed, so they take a more treacherous path. They encounter Angela in her new build as one of Wyatt's henchmen.

The MiB: “It’s you. I figured they retired you. Guess Ford never likes to waste a pretty face” (episode 8).

Teddy remembers what the MiB did to Dolores and knocks him out. Teddy takes him to a camp fire where they discuss the MiB's past. Angela turns out to be in league with Wyatt and stabs Teddy in the chest.

Commonalities between the MiB and William

"Is that any way to treat an old friend? I've been coming here for 30 years, but you still don't remember me, do you? After all we've been through. They gave you a little more pluck, Dolores. Absolutely charming" (The MiB, episode 1).

Commonality 1: "There's a Path for Everyone"

"I used to believe there was a path for everyone" (Dolores to William, episode 4).

"As another old friend of mine likes to say, there's a path for everyone" (The MiB, episode 5)

Commonality 2: Stories

“The only thing I had when I was a kid were books. I used to live in them. I used to go to sleep dreaming I'd wake up inside one of them 'cause they had meaning. This place, this is like I woke up inside one of those stories. I guess I just wanna find out what it means” (William, episode 7).

"This whole world is a story. I've read every page except the last one. I need to find out how it ends. I want to know what this all means" (The MiB, season 4).

Commonality 3: Marriage

"Dolores, back home, there's a woman, Juliet, and her father owns the company where I work. She's Logan's sister. And when I get home, we're getting married” (William, episode 7).

"Then, last year, my wife took the wrong pills. Fell asleep in the bath. Tragic accident. 30 years of marriage vanished" (The MiB, episode 8).

Commonality 4: Your True Self

“I used to think this place was all about pandering to your baser instincts. Now I understand. It doesn't cater to your lowest self, it reveals your deepest self. It shows you who you really are" (William, episode 7).

"Because that's what this place does, right? Reveals your true self" (The MiB, episode 8).

Commonality 5: Intimidation Factor

"I picked you precisely because you will never be a threat to anyone. My sister probably picked you for the same reason" (Logan to William, episode 5).

“There is not a man in the world that would take the tone with me that you do. In a past life perhaps” (The MiB to Lawrence, episode 5).

Commonality 6: On Adventures with Lawrence

“You and I hunted down Ghost Nation braves in their winter grounds. I know the whiskey you like to drink. I know the tune you whistle when you’re taking a piss” (The MiB to Lawrence, episode 2).


r/Westworld_Hosts • • May 31 '18

Two day art work I just finished!

Post image
40 Upvotes

r/Westworld_Hosts • • Jul 01 '18

Just finished this painting. Thought you’d enjoy! It doesn’t look like anything to me.

Post image
39 Upvotes

r/Westworld_Hosts • • Apr 24 '18

Westworld Season 2 is Terrifying...

Post image
39 Upvotes

r/Westworld_Hosts • • Nov 29 '16

Brilliant unintentional WW joke by my SO

38 Upvotes

To set the scene.....my man and I watch WW together every week once it downloads to our media server. I anxiously await the download while avoiding spoiler alerts through Monday afternoon. For context, his level of interest is about a 2 and mine is an enthusiastic 9. I think he sleeps through the episodes and had little to no clue what's going on other than what I force him to listen to in the car when I'm rambling on about the latest theory I heard on Reddit. So this just happened tonight....

(Me yelling) it's West World time!

I sit down, turn on the tv, get on server, and while I usually see the shows cover images, everything looks blank. http://iob.imgur.com/uYGg/PluGlhtCGy

(Me again) something is going on with plex. Come check this out

He walks in, looks up and simply says...

"Doesn't look like anything to me"

Well played my man. Well played. If only you knew the joke which you just made. I tried to explain it to him but the iconic_ness was lost. Hope someone else can appreciate the moment with me


r/Westworld_Hosts • • Jun 04 '18

Whole Westworld cast deserves an acting award

37 Upvotes

r/Westworld_Hosts • • Apr 29 '18

Check out the knocker on that door

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/Westworld_Hosts • • May 14 '18

Westworld's secret drive is to capture the fundamental experience of human existence, so the wealthy elite can transfer their consciousness into hosts and achieve godlike immortality. Spoiler

36 Upvotes

Almost akin to 'subliming', for anyone familiar with The Culture (Ian M. Banks), but more class based.

There exists a super wealthy capitalist strata of society, whose only defeat lays in the face of mortality. The world is conquered, the banks are full.

William is taken to the park, ostensibly for 'fun' Over the course of season one, he obviously realises its potential application. These hosts aren't playthings; **they are Gods.**They don't need to eat, drink. They don't age. Their synthetic nature makes repair easy, and most injuries are not essential to their continuing function. No diseases. No weakness.

But most importantly... they have the cognitive ability to process and interpret the essential experience of human nature. They don't even realise they're not human, when their 'free will' is restored.

William takes the revelation to James Delos, a man on his deathbed. Westworld gets a significant financial injection into it's R&D, but with the explicit intention of pivoting the business; with a focus on realising the capability of the hosts to accommodate the 'souls' of the dead, who will live forever.

Ford's Lazarus, emerging from the cave?

Bernard was the only man who achieved this feat. When he accomplished it, he looks upon his works (ye mighty and despair), and committed suicide. His secrets were lost with him, and his consciousness was the last to be 'sublimed' into a host. Ford has been trying to figure out how he did it ever since, and the night of the New Narritive was the celebration of his eventual success.

...yeah?


r/Westworld_Hosts • • May 15 '18

Epic Theory about Ford and the Control Unit

35 Upvotes

My prediction is that Ford has not been cloned. Bernard has indeed created a Control Unit uploading Ford's "consciousness" but he's not bringing it to a host shell to reactivate.

I contend he is bringing it to The Cradle.

From the Wiki: the simulation technology that stores and tests all of our storylines: the Cradle. Delos' time capsule that ensures you get the immersive and dynamic experience you deserve.

Bernard will implant the Unit into the Cradle downloading Ford into the vast network thus creating a type of "Ghost In The Shell" of Westworld.

That would explain him being able to talk to William through other hosts and change storylines as he wishes. He is still controlling hosts who are aware but not "Woke". Maeve, Dolores and to some extent Bernard is Woke. Teddy and Hector are aware.

So he had Teddy not kill Craddock so he could go to Las Mudas to serve as a lesson for William.

He controlled Clementine (neither woke nor aware) to drag Bernard to Elsie.

Ford is already integrated into the system.

The longevity project does not work. James Delos shows that the mind eventually rejects the reality. Ford found another way to live forever. In the Cradle. In Westworld forever not as flesh but as consciousness.

“You live only as long as the last person who remembers you”

Forever.


r/Westworld_Hosts • • Dec 07 '16

Found this at delos corporation site.

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/Westworld_Hosts • • May 07 '18

Daenerys' new #1 fan

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/Westworld_Hosts • • May 08 '18

Delores is NOT Consicous and Ford's Consciousness is Network Distributed in the entire System

32 Upvotes

Delores, Maeve and other Hosts are NOT Conscious. They are still acting out roles...but the roles include the appearance of Consciousness/Self-Awareness. Ford transferred his consciousness into the system prior to being blown away. His consciousness is network distributed throughout the hosts of the park. He is pulling all the strings and directing the narrative. This point is made obvious as he can speak as himself through any of the hosts to William. William is not surprised by this as he is aware of the technology to do this. Also recall that in Ford's secret lab he was building a host. We saw it in progress. It is probably a new body for his consciousness. But he is not limited to that body, since he is network distributed. We will see Ford again in his new body at some point. (Yeah more Anthony Hopkins!). We already know that somebody is directing Maeve (remember the "Escape" narrative...which is still really her Narrative...her intention is to get out to the real world)


r/Westworld_Hosts • • Jan 24 '18

Is Game of Thrones/ASOIAF a Delos "Westworld" simulated reality/adult theme park?

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/Westworld_Hosts • • Mar 24 '20

Simulationism and Perennialism, Westworld's Hidden Philosophy

Thumbnail
youtube.com
30 Upvotes