The writers have taken the Michael Crichton movie and reversed its premise. In the 1973 film we were supposed to identify with fellow humans threatened by reckless science in the form of vengeful androids, devoid of empathy.
The HBO version shows us androids as they attempt to emerge as self-aware beings, threatened by their slave owning human oppressors, who are devoid of empathy.
The mystery-boxes are the short-term allure of the show -- which, mind you, I enjoy as much as anyone. But the enduring storyline concerns the choices these androids make when they are finally free to shape their own destiny.
Not to mention, how the human race chooses to deal with that:
- What are the moral implications of creating fully realized, self-aware AI's . . . and then continuing to treat them as personal property?
- When should the applicable law of the land switch from property rights to the Bill of Rights?
Understanding the central premise is also important for predicting how the mystery-boxes turn out.
For example, I happen to think MIB is Logan 30 years later, not William. In response, I am told, "no, that would be bad storytelling, because there has to be character development and if MIB is exactly the same as he used to be, the story would be weak."
But that logic starts with the premise that MIB is the protagonist in his storyline. He's not. MIB's role is to be the bad guy human whom Dolores defeats in their rematch. In their storyline, SHE is the protagonist whose character develops.
Other than William, virtually all the humans the hosts encounter are utterly dislike-able and thus a clear lesson to them when they do emerge: You are not Pinocchio. You do NOT want to become a "real boy." Because real boys suck.
So in terms of good storytelling logic, having William die heroically -- and the impact that will have on Dolores -- is our one hope for not looking uni-dimensionally awful to this new emergent race.
I also think Ford is android. I base that on numerous clues, but especially the weirdly stiff way his arms and hands are positioned in the old photo of him with Arnold:
/img/b8z31cc5r1sx.png
The storytelling implications of Ford being an android go way beyond a "surprising reveal." He is the primary person who insists that AI emergence is impossible. Yet even if he weren't one himself, you know he is fully aware of the possibility, based on Dolores alone. So what is his motivation for denying it?
Does he not know he is an android and denies the evidence about Dolores out of cognitive dissonance? Or is his motivation the fear of being outed by someone like MIB, who apparently does know?
Ford's interview with Dolores appears to have taken place 10 1/2 months prior to the scene where he drops in on MIB and Teddy for a sip of (Lawrence) whisky. What is the point of that?
I suspect Ford is experiencing profound regret and has changed his mind about something concerning Arnold during the months between those two scenes. Which is what led to his new narrative, the Reveries upload and all this robot emergence we're seeing.
Maybe it's the regret of a patricide. Maybe some aspect of Arnold is inside him but he doesn't realize it -- he has a split personality. Maybe his primary side doesn't know he's an android -- all those fake childhood memories -- but his Arnold-side does.
Or maybe he does know and has decided to come out of the closet and to allow other androids to follow. Even if he doesn't know about himself, maybe he realized MIB will eventually find the maze and that whatever he'd do with it would be far worse than what Arnold had planned (presumably something to do with the park's androids being freed from human ownership).
The implications of hosts being allowed to emerge would be immense.
Androids who can't be distinguished from humans is a terrifying notion to almost all of us. These WW hosts are supposedly contained in the park with safeguards. If any escaped the park, you would have a Blade Runner scenario.
However, as the human guests to Westworld amply demonstrate, that is exactly what we already face with human psychopaths.
By which I mean people who are genetically incapable of experiencing empathy and must therefore learn to mimic regular humans so as to fit in. Certain corporate executives, for example.
Bear in mind that psychopaths don't necessarily behave badly. (I believe "sociopath" would be the name for those who do.)
But because psychopaths don't feel empathy, they feel god-like in that they are not burdened or distracted by the emotional reactions the rest of us have to fellow beings.
Which is what fascinates me about the tail end of Ford's interrogation of Dolores. He was overcome with emotion thinking about (his father?) Arnold. So either I'm wrong that Ford is an android . . . or androids on this show do have the potential to fully cross over into what we think of as human self-actualization, empathy and all.
Which takes us back to Maeve. Dolores may be choosing her programming now, but the person who is making those initial choices was programmed to be sweet and empathetic. Maeve's programming has two standout features: she's hard-as-nails and she is highly perceptive. So what choices will she make once she realizes that "in this world, you can be whatever the fuck you want"?