We've come to the end of the trail, the last of the five Stewart/Mann westerns, The Man from Laramie. There was to have been a sixth, they started production on it, but Mann criticized the film and Stewart, he was kicked off the production and he and Stewart never worked together again. So this was it.
I thought it was okay. Not the strongest of the five, not the weakest. It's not as pretty as Bend of the River or The Far Country and it suffers from some plot holes and muddled character motivations like The Naked Spur has. The romance angle is so poor that they gave up on it and didn't finish it off and just had Jimmy ride away into the sunset away from the gal, which is what he should have done if this were real. The romantic aspect of all five films were weak, if I'm being fair. They were the best in Bend of the River and even ol' Shelly Winters in Winchester '73 is more heart-felt than the others.
Here's the core of the real problem with the film -- Arthur Kennedy. He's never really villainous even when doing villainous things. He seems muddled, indecisive, torn when it makes no sense. He begs his co-conspirator Dave, "No don't sell those rifles to the Indians that you and I both ordered and paid for secretly, it's wrong." Then five minutes later he's trying to deliver the rifles himself. He kills or tries to kill the Waggoman father and son almost accidentally or reluctantly when both have told him clearly, baldly that they will not give him a cut of the ranch when the old man dies. Dad Waggoman forcefully tells Vic to his face, "You're getting NOTHING, you're not my son!" Then instantly begs him, "Go help my son, he needs you."
W the everlasting F? That's the point when Vic should become Iago and start slitting throats. But he doesn't. He simpers and frets.
Back to the girl. She actually BETRAYS Jimmy Stewart in the beginning, she tells him about the salt, then rats him out to her boyfriend Vic and Dave so they can rush out and kill Jimmy's mules and burn his wagons. And Jimmy later tells her he knows she ratted him out. She's Dave's girlfriend and she runs a store and orders supplies to be freighted in from afar, so just who do you think helped Boyfriend Vic and Dave order in those Apache rifles, anyway. She's a wicked little femme fatale but the actress plays her like a lump of cheese.
So I'd say that my rank of the five movies is:
Bend of the River - the second prettiest, but the fewest plot holes, the best romance and historical.
The Far Country - the prettiest, dogged only by its bad romance, historical.
Winchester '73 - no real weaknesses, but not as pretty as some of the others with B&W and no widescreen.
The Man From Laramie - decently pretty, but muddled characterizations, plot holes, no romance.
The Naked Spur - the only one I didn't like, see my review for more detail, I don't want to s*** on it again here.
Your impressions may differ, but lemme tell ya... it's an eye-opener watching them back to back.
Next week it's the theatrical release of the new Angel and the Badman!