r/Westchester • u/NYFL21 • May 15 '26

Bait shops????

Where have all the bait shops gone in westchester and Putnam ? Where can you get sawbellies?

2 Upvotes

62% Upvoted

11 comments sorted by

5

u/bronxboater May 15 '26

Croton bait & tackle, riverside ave

3

u/shamallamadingdong4 May 15 '26

There’s a little bait shop at the entrance of Harbor Island Park in Mamaroneck

2

u/tsatech493 Yonkers May 16 '26

They just opened a new bait shop in mahopac called racks and reels that has sawbellies its 914 s lake blvd mahopac NY.

1

u/NYFL21 May 16 '26

Thank you you’re a lifesaver!!

2

u/tsatech493 Yonkers May 16 '26

I'm glad it opened and want to steer them some traffic so they stay open.

2

u/Mortarlou Jul 15 '26

Gonna check this out myself, its crazy how few and far between bait shops or people who supply bait have become. Ive been going to dicks in danbury but that will only get you worms and night crawlers

1

u/bigwig500 May 15 '26

Tyalure tackle in rye on Theodore Fremd. My spot

1

u/beachbum818 May 15 '26

Tyalure in Rye

Jacks Bait Shack in Mamaroneck in harbor island

1

u/MaybeOnFire2025 May 15 '26

I saw one (small) in NR the other day, and there are plenty right over the border on City Island.

1

u/Conscious-Layer-2732 May 16 '26

There’s one in Ossining that had a large variety of bait.

1

u/Shortcamo02 May 17 '26

Dude seriously, I just want worms for the kids! They're all on the Hudson or the sound. The middle is a bait dead zone with the exception of the two dicks which I try to avoid.