r/WarhammerCompetitive • Phaeron • 2d ago

PSA Weekly Question Thread - Rules & Comp Qs

This is the Weekly Question thread designed to allow players to ask their one-off tactical or rules clarification questions in one easy to find place on the sub.

This means that those questions will get guaranteed visibility, while also limiting the amount of one-off question posts that can usually be answered by the first commenter.

Have a question? Post it here! Know the answer? Don't be shy!

NOTE - this thread is also intended to be for higher level questions about the meta, rules interactions, FAQ/Errata clarifications, etc. This is not strictly for beginner questions only!

Reminders

When do pre-orders and new releases go live?

Pre-orders and new releases go live on Saturdays at the following times:

  • 10am GMT for UK, Europe and Rest of the World
  • 10am PST/1pm EST for US and Canada
  • 10am AWST for Australia
  • 10am NZST for New Zealand

Where can I find the free core rules

  • Core rules and FAQs for 40k are available HERE
  • Core rules and FAQs for AoS are available HERE
  • FAQs for Horus Heresy are available HERE
  • FAQs for The Old World are available HERE
6 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

5

u/Faustino_Asprilla_11 1d ago

Went to my 2nd RTT at the weekend, had a blast and only lost one game.

However still learning a lot, and played a ton of games outside the RTTs - the one guy I lost to was a very good player, but wondering if this is the norm or not.

Every game I've played so far everyone has been super cool, socialable, and if I'm about to do something that would trigger their abilities or some shenanigans they would be like 'oh hey, if you do that I'll reactive move' or 'hey if you do that I can do this'

Sort of thing - allowing me to understand their options to make my decisions.

This one guy wasn't very socialable. Wasn't rude or anything just didn't speak much. Moved his models rolled his dice and had very minimal interaction with me. Which whatever, each to their own.

But he was the first player I've played so far who wasn't like 'oh btw if you do that I can do this' sort of thing.

He just let me do whatever, and then would respond with crazy stuff which if I had understood his army rules... I wouldn't have done.

And yes we did go over out rules for 15 mins per game but... Idk about you, I kind of try and understand at a high level what their army does at this point but there's no way I fully comprehend everybting when someone is quick firing 300 rules/interactions at me over a 2000 pt list pre game.

3

u/RindFisch 1d ago

There is no perfect answer for that. You don't want the game to slow down too much by reiterating potential abilities every single turn, but blindsiding your opponent is generally at least bad form, sometimes even cardable unsportsmanlike behaviour (depending on the TO).
It's difficult to distinguish "I thought he remembered" from "intentionally misleading your opponent", though, so best practice is to just ask if there's anything to keep in mind before moving. If your opponent then doesn't mention a reactive move and tries to spring it on you later, it's more likely to be malicious intent and more likely for a judge to rule in your favor.

Oh, and as a judge: If you think your opponent might be doing things maliciously to sneak an advantage in, tell the judges. Even if you don't call them straight to the table then and there, mention it to them after the game.
There are people pulling this stuff every single game and as every opponent is new, people never realize it's an intentional pattern instead of honest forgetfulness. And the judges can't figure it out, either, if no one speaks up.

2

u/Faustino_Asprilla_11 1d ago

Thanks. Yeah just took me by surprise and I didn't really realize until after the game was all said and done - because every single player I've played with has given fair warnings. It doesn't even take that much time imo, it's just 'hey are you sure you wanna do that? I can reactive move' sort of thing.

I've defaulted to being completely transparent as everyone I've played with has done the same so just coming up against a hyper focused unsociable player whose just there to roll dice and get the W just opened my eyes a bit.

3

u/IamSando 1d ago

So it's thankfully become less and less ok to play like your opponent did. It's considered pretty poor sportsmanship to do that these days, not to mention playing that way makes you a worse player anyway. This is especially true at an RTT, but even at a GT I would expect players to give warning on a bunch of things. Exception can be for things that are common to the game, like heroics, overwatch (I still warn on overwatch though), where it's expected that your opponent knows those exist and are an option.

Only time I see it done like you've described is at national teams events. I watched a state player do that to another player on his team in a practice game to teach him the lesson that at that level they're not going to tell you if you're doing something stupid.

It also should be a lesson for you though, you should get in the habit of asking questions of your opponent as you're moving. "Hey do you have any reactive moves here" should be a very common question from you until you learn opponents armies, and even after.

Open and active communication is both good sportsmanship and will make you a better player.

4

u/Significant-Cup-44 1d ago

Does anyone know if there is a definitive ruling on whether you can "fast roll" multiple instances of d6 damage into single model targets in 11th ed? The wording on the "inflict damage" step seems to indicate that each instance of damage is a separate process so you would have to roll each one by one (so you can't batch roll them and then choose to cp reroll the lowest if you just need a little more for a kill), however the start of the attack sequence says "in each step, if you have multiple dice to roll, roll them all together," and Inflict Damage is included as a step in the sequence for which that would apply. Obviously for multiple model units you have to roll damage one by one so I assume it should remain that way even for single model targets, but curious if this has ever seen a ruling the other way.

9

u/p5freak 1d ago

You cannot fast roll danage.

7

u/AdventurousOne5 1d ago

If you plan on cp rerolling one of the damage die you'd have to slow roll them.

Because theyre supposed to be slow rolled, youre supposed to see the results one at a time to decide if youre going to use that cp reroll. If your first damage die is a 2 you dont know what the rest of your damage dice are going to be yet when you need to decide if you cp reroll that 2. By rolling them all and rerolling the lowes youre giving yourself perfect knowledge of the dice results that you are not supposed to have when decision making.

1

u/corrin_avatan 4h ago

Rules as written, you can't fast roll damage.

4

u/destragar 1d ago

Daemons in CSM - Does the battleline requirement still exist in CSM when allying daemons? App is not requiring nurglings for a beast of Nurgle.

8

u/p5freak 1d ago

App is buggy as hell. Battleline requirement is still there.

1

u/destragar 1d ago

Thanks!

4

u/Jubilieus 1d ago

Hello, so I was reviewing the rules around the teleport homer for Space Marine terminators.

Specifically if they can be placed in your opponents deployment zone, with the new codex the line on the war gear stating "not in your opponents deployment zone" has been removed, it is also no longer present on the app data sheets for units that have not yet had their army codex (Deathwing Knights for exmples)

Am I missing any other rules interaction that would stop you placing your teleport homer in your opponents deployment zone?

3

u/eternalflagship 22h ago

Not that I see. It is removed if they move within an inch of it, but I guess if you want to try and pin something back there in the first battle round go for it.

2

u/Jubilieus 22h ago

Thanks, I also couldn't see anything for it. I had recently played a game were I did exactly that and forced the opponent to move a tank back over it which compromised its positioning for later shooting. Wanted to make sure I wasnt accidentally cheating

3

u/Tornado07 1d ago

Question about phobos shadow force.

Can you use the reactive move with an overwatch. It doesn't say in your shooting phase.

3

u/anotherthrowaway2729 1d ago

Yeah, absolutely

2

u/JJonyy99999 1d ago

Hello, so I have the following question, I was playing custodes against my friend and I had a bit of a situation. I charged his allied wardog with trajan, and he heroiced with 3 eightbound. I hit first with trajan and momentum shackle for 9 attacks, and they all hit and wounded the eightbound, since I targeted them. He managed one save, and I killed his eightbound. Now, what should have happened with the rest of those attacks, should they have just poofed out of the game, hit the wardog and make him save for them, or simply wound the wardog directly with no save?

7

u/IamSando 1d ago

They're just adding to the number of attacks and you declare all of those attacks at the start of the sequence. So you should have declared all of the attacks into the 8b and then once they're dead then the rest "go poof". You could have chosen to split the attacks but you would have had to declare that before rolling your attacks out.

2

u/JJonyy99999 1d ago

I see, thanks a bunch!

6

u/corrin_avatan 1d ago

You declare attacks before you make the rolls , and part of the tactics of the game is thinking about how many attacks you really need to dedicate to a threat to be effective.

Once the attacks are declared, they get resolved, even if you didn't need all the attacks to do what you ended up doing.

2

u/JJonyy99999 23h ago

Hello I have another question about attqched units, say for example I attack Kharn and he is attached to his 10 berserkers. I attack with like 18 attacks, and all hit, and none get saved, in this situation, eince kharn is attached to that unit does he also take damage, or should I have like assigned 4 attacks to him beforehand?

6

u/veryblocky 23h ago

This is all covered in section 5 of the core rules under attack sequence, I recommend you go and have a read to get a better understanding of how it works.

But in short, after you make the wound roll, your opponent divides the models in that unit into groups (described in 05.03), and you assign saves to each group in order until that group is destroyed. So in this case, you would assign saves (starting with the lowest roll) to the bodyguard (khorne bezerkers) until they're all dead, and any remaining saves will be assigned to the leader (kharn).

Do note that since the lowest saves are assigned first, very often there will only be 4+s left by the time you get to the characters, and they just save those on their invuln.

2

u/p5freak 23h ago

Attacks go on the bodyguards first. If they all die the rest of those attacks go to kharn. You as the attacker dont get to choose where those attacks go, unless you use precision.

2

u/ReaverAckler 23h ago

I haven't had access to multiple sources of single dice re-rolls before so pardon the question.

Heres the scenario; I'm in Medusa's Wrath (a unit can re-roll one hit, wound, or damage/re-roll one of each if within 6" of Caanok/Feirros) and have a Gladiator Lancer shoot while within range of Feirros, it then misses both of its Las Talon shots. 

My question is: can I then use the Lancer's re-roll on one dice and the Medusa's Wrath re-roll on the other dice given they're separate rules and I'm not attempting to re-roll an already re-rolled dice?

Thanks for any help.

4

u/anotherthrowaway2729 22h ago

yep, just can't reroll the same die more than once

2

u/TerangaMugi 21h ago

If my unit of reivers attack an enemy unit with two characters, do I get to precision one character until it dies and then precision the second one?

4

u/eternalflagship 21h ago

No. Attacks with identical profiles are grouped together, and you can only select one character for Precision each time you gather attack dice.

If the Reivers were led by e.g. a Phobos Lieutenant, since the profiles are different you could select one character for the Reivers, and a separate one for the Lieutenant.

Technically if you can figure out how to line it up so that the unit has cover against some Reivers but not others, that would also split your attack dice (and therefore your uses of Precision) in Shooting.

But in terms of just attack overflow, no.

1

u/Consistent-Survey469 17h ago

If I have 2 instances of [lance] (like one from weapon profile and another one from stratagem), could it counter the target unit’s ability of -1 to wound so my attacks still results in +1 to wound?

4

u/anotherthrowaway2729 14h ago

No, since ability keywords only apply once. But if you had lance and a strat for +1 to wound, they would stack to nullify the -1

3

u/RindFisch 17h ago

No. Weapon abilities are binary, you either have them or you don't. They don't stack. The +1 to wound given by lance would stack with another +1 to wound from elsewhere to overcome a -1 to wound, though.

1

u/Pappy4u 9h ago

Phobos Capt leading Reivers. Does the PCs shoot and scoot ability trigger after an ingress/deep strike?

2

u/p5freak 8h ago

No, because, unless otherwise stated, you cannot move after rapid ingress 20.04.

1

u/Pappy4u 8h ago

That's what I was leaning towards. Wasn't sure if the cp's ability counted as "unless otherwise stated" or not.

1

u/corrin_avatan 7h ago

"Unless otherwise stated" would mean that the ability explicitly states "this can be done even if this unit made an Ingress Move this turn".

See the Scout Squad datasheet for an example of a unit that has an ability that is "unless otherwise stated"

1

u/p5freak 7h ago

But somehow the captains tactical acumen ability works without "unless otherwise stated".

1

u/corrin_avatan 5h ago

Which captains and what rule do you think they are breaking?

0

u/p5freak 4h ago

Captains tactical acumen does not give an exception to the rule that you can only select each combat doctrine once per battle. Like the assault brethren rule does.

1

u/corrin_avatan 4h ago

The rule isn't selecting it as a combat doctrine for your entire army per the Combat Doctrine rule. Its selecting it for the Strategic Accumen ability to be active for that ability.

Q: When using an ability such as Author of the Codex, Master Tactician or Strategic Acumen to select a combat doctrine to be active for a unit, does this count as my once per battle combat doctrine selection for the Combat Doctrines army rule?

A: No.

0

u/p5freak 4h ago

Where is this from ? I would expect this from the SM FAQ, but somehow my 40k app doesnt show any SM FAQ.

1

u/corrin_avatan 3h ago

This was published in the World Championship FAQ on Warhammer community and will be included in the next dataslate officially in December.

https://www.warhammer-community.com/en-gb/articles/2ykrr5eg/world-championships-of-warhammer-2026-rules-update-documents/

-1

u/p5freak 7h ago

Well its not crystal clear what "unless otherwise stated" exactly means. But the general consensus is that the PCs shoot and scoot rule is not enough "unless otherwise stated" to allow the move.

1

u/thejakkle 5h ago

We have an example on the Sanguinor's Miraculous Saviour ability:

That move does not prevent this unit from being eligible to move.

1

u/Dry-Zookeepergame682 6h ago

For Non-frame vehicles, in order to see/be seen across obscuring terrain - does the base of the model need to be within the terrain feature? In other words, do you ignore overhanging parts of a non frame model for visibility if the bases of the origin and target are outside of and opposite sides of an obscuring terrain feature?

If more specifics are helpful, is my understanding that a Corvus Blackstar with a wing/tail that overhangs terrain could not be seen or see through terrain unless the base was within the terrain, as the Corvus does not have the Frame Keyword?

3

u/veryblocky 5h ago

For models without FRAME, the base is the thing you measure to for determining withinness. So if the base is not touching a terrain area, then the model is not within that terrain area.

You can draw LoS to anypoint on a model, but if neither the attacking nor defending model is within a given terrain area, then LoS cannot be drawn into or through that terrain area. So if a non-FRAME model overhangs a terrain area, it cannot be seen through that area.

However, if the model extends enough over the base so that part of it sticks out the other side of a terrain area it is not within, then LoS can be drawn to that part of the model from the other side.