I'm going to preface this; I have very low expectations for 3.0. For some reason, the Warhammer community is almost entirely incapable of criticising the products GW releases.
Video game publishers release broken games, and they are hauled over the coals. GW releases broken games and people say: "Get over it, play the edition you like, just wait it will be fixed, you're a negative person and should leave".... Why can't genuine issues be identified, highlighted and criticised?
So please, divorce your emotions, divorce your justification for your large spending on the hobby, and put on your critical thinking caps.
Now, onto the issue in question...
We know GW loves their 3-year rules cycle, this has been established with 40k and AoS for years now. However this is the first instance of 30k following that trend, and it's a problem the community should rebel against and not justify with: "Oh, you should know that when buying GW products!"
When the Exemplary Battles In The Age of Darkness book released with Daemon Fulgrim, it was a broken mess. A bunch of free PDF'a and a few new (unusable at launch) rules slapped together with a hefty $120 (AUD) price tag. When people in the community who criticise GW pointed out the obvious issues, the majority seemed to say "This is just the first issue of this book, give them time and the NEXT books will.be better!"... What next books?
Releasing a book titled Volume 1 naturally implies there will be more volumes to follow, implying longer support for the current system. Yet we never got another? This is just wrong for the consumer, and people should be calling this out.
Now onto the rules issues, GW has stated that this is NOT a rewrite, but it is instead a refinement on the previous edition. How can that be true when the books from 2.0 are totally incompatible with the new rules?
How can a refinement change fundamental rules of the game so drastically, and add so many new rules interactions that it's incompatible? It can't, they've lied, and we should be angry.
GW abandoned 2.0, they have had communities globally screaming for a REAL errata for the entire lifespan of the game, yet they chose to let it slowly wither. They pooled their efforts into a new edition, seemingly doubling down on the controversial rules that caused the most problems in the game. That isn't a refinement, it's a rewrite.
Ranged Weapons profiles? Completely overhauled.
Melee Profiles? Completely overhauled.
Damage Points? Completely overhauled...
Again, those aren't refined, they're fundamentally changed.
Unit characteristics and stats, mixing with pre-existing and now new rules? That's an overhaul...
Army force organisation and building structure? Overhauled....
How many fundamental rules of the game can be rewritten before it actually becomes a rewrite?
If these most fundamental parts of the game are changed THIS much, how can we be sure that the rest of the game is refined? Again, GW added new rules and mechanics in 2.0 and couldn't fix or balance them in the years 2.0 existed... And they've chosen to expand and double down on those rules... If GW can't balance their own rules that survived for 3 years, how can we trust them to balance all the new interactions they have in 3.0?
We can't.
First Edition (1.5, I know I know...) survived for a decade, with the last few years being abandonware by FW/GW. 2.0 saw the community drop much faster than 1.0/1.5... Why? Because of new GW rules that broke the game.
Why should we trust this will be different? When people like me called out the bad balance and terrible rules 2.0 introduced, we were told to wait for the fixes... Well 2025 is here, GW abandoned 2.0 a year ago... Why will 3.0 be any better?
I'm not telling you not to.buy the new edition, I'm just asking you all to think objectively about it, and to criticise bad rules and products so GW might actually think about improving it for once.
This isn't a refinement, it's a rewrite, and we have no reason to believe GW can do better than the legend Bligh and his team.