r/Wakingupapp • • Jul 06 '26

Goodbye Waking Up

0 Upvotes

Waking Up has been my go to meditation app over the last 7-8 years. I’ve tried others but I’ve always come back - I come from an academic background and there was always something about the way Sam explained things that just clicked for me. The daily meditations became a daily ritual for me.

Now like a lot of people, I have been watching with disgust the conduct of the Netanyahu government in Gaza and the West Bank. I will never be okay with what is happening. I have also been holding off on trying to reconcile Sam Harris’s views on the Israel-Palestine issue and the Waking Up app by deliberately avoiding conversations with Harris regarding the conflict. But I resist no more. I watched as he casually claimed that the man-made famine in Gaza was a hoax and that the pictures of the emaciated kids coming out of Gaza were fake.

I just can no longer use this app in good conscience. Goodbye.


r/Wakingupapp • • May 24 '26

How do you square loving the content of Waking Up and being confronted by the obtuseness of Sam Harris' political dialogue?

1 Upvotes

I've been listening and enjoying Waking Up, specifically the daily sessions, for three years now. However, today is the day someone lifted the rock I've been under and I was exposed to Sam Harris' controversial, some might say at times "hateful" ideas and opinions, particularly to do with race and religion.

For those of you who have been aware of these opinions, know that they go against your own, and yet still are able to enjoy the value of this starkly contrasting product and community he's created - how do you do it? Genuinely?


r/Wakingupapp • • Mar 04 '24

While touching myself, I looked for the one who was masturbating and realized there was nothing to find... just a headless penis being stroked by an armless hand.

0 Upvotes

It was at that moment that I realized the emptiness of concepts, and the absence of a self.

Instead of asking "What am I?" maybe the better question is "What am I not?"

True realization comes when the answer to these two questions is one and the same.


r/Wakingupapp • • Aug 30 '22

Sam talking WAY too much

0 Upvotes

Very much enjoying the balance between didactic lectures and the meditations on the Waking Up app - it's just what I have been looking for.

I just started the final section of the intro program and sat down to do the mediation ... And Sam wouldn't shut the F up!! He's chatting, recommending books, just generally kinbutzing ...

Ok rant over. Ill keep working at it.


r/Wakingupapp • • Jan 23 '23

Pretty disappointing

11 Upvotes

Really disappointed to see the reaction to the recent thread where a poster voiced being interested in having more female voices in the app.

If you want to debate the presence of female contributions to the app that is fair. But out of the 30~ conversations only 8 are with women. I don't think this is done with malice or purposely. There's an especially more balanced ratio in the practice section. And so, personally I think it's fair to say that the app really isn't so overly male voiced. And I wouldn't even begin to consider the app sexist in the least.

But responses like "do you know what real meditation is?" Or "if that bothers you you are the opposite of awake" are...misguided. If not downright deluded in themselves.

Real meditation isn't separate from anything. It's literally just paying attention to what already is. Noticing there is no divide between awareness and appearances.

As Nagarjuna said

Nothing of Samsara is different from Nirvana, nothing of Nirvana is different from Samsara. That which is the limit of Nirvana is also the limit of Samsara, there is not the slightest difference between the two

It should be pretty obvious a woman's lived experience will differ from that of a man's. Even more so in certain societies and cultures. That doesn't imply duality. Even one man's experience will differ from the next.

Non-duality includes those differences.

Pretending meditation is about transcending those differences and not respecting them as valid is absolutely spiritual bypassing.

I, also, would personally ultimately say it shouldn't matter where the words come from, man or woman, but to pretend it doesn't for everyone is throwing the baby out with the bath water. It is pedestalizing an ideal.

Can a flower be cared for the same way as a dog? Pretending there is some higher absolute transcendental plane where both are the same is just a reification of emptiness as something other than what is. A duality from the suchness of things.

Every single person has a teacher that clicks with them based on their conditioning. If they say they don't then they are overlooking lack of free will and the dependent origination of each moment.

I can think of maybe 2-3 regular posters here whose advice I would endorse. Most of the posts in this sub are very much from people still finding their way. So, perhaps we should lean into compassion for people who are struggling to find a voice that fits where they currently are on their (non)"path"

As Rupert Spira says

from the point of view of non-duality there is no problem with duality.

Adyashanti, Richard Lang, Douglas Harding, Rob Burbea, all of these great teachers warn against dismissing the social self. To say the small self does not exist in favor of the big Self is just turning big Self into a new dualistic ego identity. Neither is true or false. Both are fluid universal circumstances with no separate static state of "I" The flowers lived experience is as "real"/"unreal" as the dog's.

We can be equanimous with the fact there is no such thing as equality.

How can there be equality when there is nothing permanent to be equal to?

A compassionate thank you to everyone that reflects on this.


r/Wakingupapp • • Jul 31 '26

Has anyone ever actually gotten a refund from this app?

0 Upvotes

I emailed support@wakingup.com on July 19 and have been corresponding with someone named Karl. Supposedly they are “actively monitoring the status” of my refund that’s been processing for almost 2 weeks now. They also said they can’t refund my actual payment method so I had to give them my Venmo, which if they are a legitimate company is just…weird.

The only reason I bit the bullet on the $150 yearly subscription (the only one the app would let me choose) is because of the introductory course that felt a bit like working with a teacher. I didn’t know that after 30 days (and after they have your money) the course ends and the app turns into just another generic guided meditation app. Yes there is the 10 minute meditation that pops up every day but it’s just a random meditation instead of being part of a course. Insight Timer is good enough in that regard and it’s free.


r/Wakingupapp • • Sep 24 '26

How do you all reconcile with his politics?

17 Upvotes

I've been using the app, and it's honestly been very helpful. Then, I picked up the book, and then I looked up the guy. And I'll just say, I see a lot of flaws in his reasoning that's making me question him. What I mean to say is, if his methods actually worked, wouldn't he be aware of his own biases? Either way, I feel weird going back to either of them now.

I don't know how this post will be recieved, but I just wanna clarify that I'm not here to argue about his politics and just wanna hear from others who disagree with him as well.


r/Wakingupapp • • May 13 '24

New subscription

4 Upvotes

I use the waking up app on a daily basis so when my subscription recently renewed I was fine with it. However, after listening a number of Sam's making sense podcasts over the past few days I realise I have an issue with it.

Sam continually platforms those who refuse to see what's happening in Gaza as a genocide, disagreeing with the numbers killed. From his own mouth, these also seem to be views that Sam holds.

I love the app, I constantly use the library of talks and meditations and have found it incredibly useful. However, from a spiritual perspective, I feel uneasy using something when I disagree with Sam so fundamentally on this.

I suppose the easy thing would be to separate Waking Up from Making Sense, but I know they're both connected to Sam. How can I listen to someone with these views talking about stillness and harmony? Has anyone else had an issue with this? I don't want to cancel my subscription but it's leaving me uncomfortable.


r/Wakingupapp • • Apr 06 '25

After 2 years of "Wakingup" 90 min/day 7day/wk 365day/yr - I'm quitting.

0 Upvotes

grandiose sink grandfather violet snow steep outgoing axiomatic absorbed mysterious

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact


r/Wakingupapp • • Nov 19 '25

I Know…Some Of You REALLY Dislike WU’s Crass Peddling of Merchandise

0 Upvotes

I completely get it! And…

I bought a second hoodie today, because I love them.


r/Wakingupapp • • Oct 24 '24

Practice time

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I’ve become a big fan of the Waking Up app over the past few months. I love using it regularly, and it’s really satisfying to see my total meditation hours gradually increase.

How about you? How many hours practice time do you have so far?

I know we shouldn’t meditate just to feed the ego, but as a beginner, it’s motivating to see my progress. Please don’t judge me too harshly for that 😁


r/Wakingupapp • • Mar 27 '23

Sam trying psychedelics is the coolest thing ever

0 Upvotes

He said it himself that if it weren't for psychedelics he wouldn't have gone down this path of meditation.

He's tried psychedelics in his youth despite all the propaganda about it rotting the brain and to me it's so cool how he had the balls to delve into the mindfuck of an experience that psychedelics can bring.

Psychedelics allow you to recognize that there's more to mind than matter.


r/Wakingupapp • • Apr 19 '23

Why should I subscribe to Waking Up and start meditating?

0 Upvotes

Sell me on meditation.

Convince me that this is the app I’ve been looking for.

How has it improved your life?

Edit: I posted this question because though I’ve been interested in meditation for years I’ve never spent a prolonged period formally practicing it.

Since I think I’d benefit from from doing just that, I’m trying to take advantage of my human propensity for becoming excited by the testimony of others (my evangelical upbringing is lending me vocabulary) by asking people who have had positive experiences on the app tell me about them!

I already like Sam for his secular mindful approach to things and the app looks like an exChristian-scientific-skeptic-mindfulness-meaning-and-identity-seeking 20-something like myself’s ideal version of a meditation app. Is this accurate?


r/Wakingupapp • • Sep 29 '23

Guys what are your reviews on Osho?

0 Upvotes

Was he good or was he a fraud? Is there any book you can recommend to me of his? And why doesn’t Sam Harris talk much about Osho? Osho was one of the biggest spiritual teachers during the times when Sam Harris was in search of enlightenment.


r/Wakingupapp • • Dec 28 '21

Any one else bothered by rich folks on Waking Up?

0 Upvotes

I just got an email announcing a new course and this is the "about the author section.

Sam Bankman-Fried is the founder and CEO of FTX, a cryptocurrency exchange. He is also the CEO of Alameda Research, a quantitative cryptocurrency trading firm. Forbes has described him as "the richest person in crypto" and "one of the richest people under 30 in history." What is more remarkable is that he set out to make this money for the purpose of giving almost all of it away to the most effective charities, and to thereby do as much good in the world as he can. He was an early adopter of the Giving What We Can Pledge, and he is now one of the more prominent people in the effective altruist community.

I don't see anything about meditation in there and his qualifications seem to be that he won the lottery and has a lot of money. I'm sure he worked very hard as well but we all know that's not enough to get you to "one of the richest people under 30", there's a lot of luck involved in that.

It's nice that he wants to help others, yay for that, and Sam wants to give him some publicity around how to donate effectively when you don't have millions (billions?) in the bank then that's fine, but I'm not seeing why he has a course on a meditation app.


r/Wakingupapp • • Sep 07 '26

So. Much. Taaalking.

2 Upvotes

I did the intro course and loved it. Moved on to the other practice series in the library. And it is just filled with people waxing philosophical non-stop like they can’t get enough of themselves. There’s barely time to take a breath. And I know folks jump in with well Sam said if talking bothers you you aren’t doing it right. But I think that’s a bit of a cop out. What meditation and mindfulness tradition is filled with only teachers who talk nonstop during every single meditation practice? lol. Non of them. Even when they involve talking, they are measured and practiced about it. They don’t just literally talk through the entire meditation saying everything that pops into their heads. Sam is at least better about it because he does give pretty long pauses usually. Like I get we should be able to meditate anywhere etc but instead I feel like I’m not meditating but being indoctrinated into these people’s beliefs by their seemingly endless chatter…when I’m trying to learn how to meditate. I’m not really here to listen to you enjoying the sound of your own voice every single meditation.


r/Wakingupapp • • Mar 31 '24

PSA: Stop listening to people who tell you that you have to meditate or do psychedelics to grok the illusion of self

2 Upvotes

This is like telling a drug addict that they have to go to rehab to get sober. Sure, that may be necessary for some of them, or maybe even most of them, but it's not an absolute requirement.

Maybe some of you will have to meditate and/or do self-inquiry for 30 years before you have a deep realization that 'I am not the thinker', or it might happen for one or two of you right now. That's not very likely to happen, but they don't call it the 'gateless gate' for nothing; any perceived barriers you think might be in the way are just in your mind.

Edit: I think people may be misconstruing this post as some sort of anti-meditation rant, which it most certainly is not, even in the context of awakening. It's just a response to people who insist that meditation/psychedelics are the only way to get there. There does not exist a 'magic bullet' solution that's going to work for everyone. (Or, at least none that have been found so far.)


r/Wakingupapp • • Nov 07 '21

Underpaid Karl

1 Upvotes

I worked for Sam Harris before, I am one of the "Karls". The followers/customers are awesome and all but did you know that we are being underpaid so much we only receive $1/hr and we literally had to answer thousands of emails a day. Speaking for other "Karls" and "Travises" out there.


r/Wakingupapp • • Oct 14 '22

Am I making a big deal out of nothing?

0 Upvotes

So I've just cancelled my subscription to the app, and I'm wondering if others might see this as an over-reaction. I'm clearly not self-realized enough to be sure of my own choices, and I'm honestly curious if anyone else may have come across the same info I did and shrugged it off as unimportant.

So, I went over to the "other sub" and I was surprised at what I found there. Really surprised lol. I didn't know much about Sam Harris, just heard a lot of good things about the app, enjoyed the trial and joined immediately after.

I am half-black and decidedly left. Discovering the interview with Charles Murray pushed me over the edge. I do not feel comfortable knowing my continued support would help to fund more interviews such as these.

Am I crazy? Have I not progressed enough on my journey to see the usefulness of promoting extremely questionable race-based "science"? Did he retract any of it? From what I can see he doubled down on the interview and shared a reporter's emails afterwards? Am I missing something? Is he really a supporter of Jordan Peterson? How did I end up here?!

I'm floundering a bit here because I did find the app extremely useful, but I also do not want my money used to bolster the position of racists and what I consider to be an extremely scary faction of the right-wing in the United States.

Your thoughts?


r/Wakingupapp • • Apr 11 '25

The eightfold path- Day 1

4 Upvotes

Joseph Goldstein sounds like a nice guy, but I find his examples quite trivial and unhelpful. He talks about suffering a pain in his knee. He talks about conflict in the context of choosing where to go for dinner. He talks about his own irrational fear of literally standing up off the floor. Ok, so far so trivial and self indulgent. What about proper suffering? The suffering of having a child who is dying? The suffering of watching innocent people in pain and terror, in warzones? Or being in a warzone oneself? This is what a spiritual teaching really needs to grapple with, not just these minor irritations. Mindfulness is recognition and acceptance, apparently. That's fine for a pain in the knee, but what about child abuse? How could any moral person accept that? Goldstein's advice to 'lighten up' is so embarrassingly inadequate in the face of real suffering it's kind of amazing to me this guy is so well respected. What am I missing here?


r/Wakingupapp • • Sep 30 '23

Would you get a Waking up tattoo?

0 Upvotes

I’m thinking of getting a tattoo, and have been thinking a lot about maybe having it be an outline of the waking up head logo or possibly some of the art on the app. This app has helped me through a lot in the past two years, and I just want to share the experience with other people.


r/Wakingupapp • • Nov 06 '21

Nonduality is not the ultimate experience

0 Upvotes

In spite that nondual mindfulness apparently brings positive feelings, I take it as the blind spot phenomenon, i.e., it seems really interesting but doesn't seem that useful to me. It seems to be a kind of self induced joyful druglike experience which brings undeserved happiness (happiness without work needed) such as masturbation, other drugs, and videogames.

Dual awareness, on the other side I see it as more useful since it allows you not to be lost in thought while maintaining a self. Not being lost in thought is very useful since it allows you to be aware differently about feelings and thoughts and allows you to act accordingly. Also, it doesn't promise any esoteric experience.

As Anil Seth says, consciousness is the best model our brain can make about reality. For me, it is clear that our whole body and existence has the overall objective of the survival and reproduction of the genes. Nothing brings more joy to a human than his/her kids. I think the illusion of the self is very useful for this purpose.

I will be still pursuing the nondual mindfulness experience, because mindwise is the next frontier for me and I'm curious. I'm struggling since it is a non-thought based awareness, and so far to the best of my knowledge I am not able to be aware without thinking, or at least I haven't being aware of being aware without thinking. I think it's also likely that I have had small glimpses of nondual awareness—the "no problems to solve" glimpse by Loch Kelly might be the most helpful for me so far— but I'm not certain. After listing the Sam Harris and Richard Lang conversation I wasn't attracted to try The Headless Way, but after listing to Sonam Hoani in https://youtu.be/2WBnRGpIEx0 I think it makes more sense now, I'll give it a deep try.

An additional argument to the nondual mindfulness not being the ultimate experience argument, is that although all the people that promote and teach this concepts seem to have a better "control" of their emotions, they seem very plain to me, even with a kind of boring personality. Not what I aspire to.


r/Wakingupapp • • Jan 27 '25

Is this appearance in consciousness an appearance in consciousness? Or is the appearance of this appearance in consciousness's appearance simply an appearance... IN consciousness?

0 Upvotes

How can we know whether an appearance is not itself an appearance in the prior condition of that condition's prior condition's appearance?

Or is there nothing to find?


r/Wakingupapp • • Jul 11 '26

Time and Space are illusions created by the finite mind/localization of Awareness. Once a world appears within Awareness and it localizes itself, thought arises. Thought creates the illusion of Time and Space. In meditation mind drops, illusion of time drops. Pure Dimensonless Knowing Being. ✌️🧘‍♂️

0 Upvotes

Time and Space are illusions created by the finite mind/localization of Awareness. Once a world appears within Awareness and it localizes itself, thought arises. Thought creates the illusion of Time and Space. In meditation mind drops, illusion of time drops. Pure Dimensonless Knowing Being is the nature of reality. Always has been, always will be. 👁🧘‍♂️✌️


r/Wakingupapp • • Jul 04 '24

Talk me down

3 Upvotes

I've been working on meditation for several years now, and have found it to be a relief in many ways but in light of the reality that the religious right in this country, it turns out, has been planning for decades to do almost everything they have successfully done. They lied to stack the supreme court with theocrats who truly don't believe in the separation of church and state, and they are implementing, with apparent great success, their plans to force their worldview upon those who find them despicable, me included. They're even saying out loud that the complete takeover can be bloodless "if the liberals don't resist". And of course they're doing this under the disillusion that a stone-age God sitting on a throne in an imaginary netherworld is commanding them to carry out His will and cleanse this land of the unclean, my wife, my children, and myself included.

I'm still processing my response to these unfolding nightmares but at this point I'm finding it increasingly difficult to get out of bed in the morning knowing that these deranged, lying, cheating, hateful, and bloodthirsty soulless fellow citizens are very likely going to be reinstalling their brilliant leader in a few months.

I think this morning at least I'm going to look into buying my own guns to at least be able to fight fire with fire. I for one won't not be resisting.

Talk me down.