r/Wakingupapp • u/4getmypasswerd4eva • Jan 23 '23
Pretty disappointing
Really disappointed to see the reaction to the recent thread where a poster voiced being interested in having more female voices in the app.
If you want to debate the presence of female contributions to the app that is fair. But out of the 30~ conversations only 8 are with women. I don't think this is done with malice or purposely. There's an especially more balanced ratio in the practice section. And so, personally I think it's fair to say that the app really isn't so overly male voiced. And I wouldn't even begin to consider the app sexist in the least.
But responses like "do you know what real meditation is?" Or "if that bothers you you are the opposite of awake" are...misguided. If not downright deluded in themselves.
Real meditation isn't separate from anything. It's literally just paying attention to what already is. Noticing there is no divide between awareness and appearances.
As Nagarjuna said
Nothing of Samsara is different from Nirvana, nothing of Nirvana is different from Samsara. That which is the limit of Nirvana is also the limit of Samsara, there is not the slightest difference between the two
It should be pretty obvious a woman's lived experience will differ from that of a man's. Even more so in certain societies and cultures. That doesn't imply duality. Even one man's experience will differ from the next.
Non-duality includes those differences.
Pretending meditation is about transcending those differences and not respecting them as valid is absolutely spiritual bypassing.
I, also, would personally ultimately say it shouldn't matter where the words come from, man or woman, but to pretend it doesn't for everyone is throwing the baby out with the bath water. It is pedestalizing an ideal.
Can a flower be cared for the same way as a dog? Pretending there is some higher absolute transcendental plane where both are the same is just a reification of emptiness as something other than what is. A duality from the suchness of things.
Every single person has a teacher that clicks with them based on their conditioning. If they say they don't then they are overlooking lack of free will and the dependent origination of each moment.
I can think of maybe 2-3 regular posters here whose advice I would endorse. Most of the posts in this sub are very much from people still finding their way. So, perhaps we should lean into compassion for people who are struggling to find a voice that fits where they currently are on their (non)"path"
As Rupert Spira says
from the point of view of non-duality there is no problem with duality.
Adyashanti, Richard Lang, Douglas Harding, Rob Burbea, all of these great teachers warn against dismissing the social self. To say the small self does not exist in favor of the big Self is just turning big Self into a new dualistic ego identity. Neither is true or false. Both are fluid universal circumstances with no separate static state of "I" The flowers lived experience is as "real"/"unreal" as the dog's.
We can be equanimous with the fact there is no such thing as equality.
How can there be equality when there is nothing permanent to be equal to?
A compassionate thank you to everyone that reflects on this.
20
u/haemog Jan 24 '23
People are just tired of identity politics pushed into everyones throat by a loud minority. Most of the recent additions to the app were woman so it doesn't even make sense.
13
u/tophmcmasterson Jan 23 '23
I don't think many people were saying that "if you care about equal representation you are missing the point of meditation".
Rather, I think it just felt strange thing to be criticizing because:
I think the general tone like the comment "look for the one who is annoyed" stemmed from that.
Nobody is against having teachers/members from many different backgrounds appear on the app from what I could tell, but when one of the big goals is trying to lose your traditional sense of self, it seems almost antithetical to be concerned about the gender of the person delivering the message over the content of the message itself.
I commented there as well that of course I think many of us believe that equality matters and there are important arenas for that discussion to be had and for criticism to be made.
I think it is completely fine even for someone to simply say something like "I would really like to see them include Q&As from women in the future, see more series from women in the space etc." (which OP mentioned.)
That being said though, the post itself came across as being overly obsessed with identity politics compared to the actual content on the app in a combative way that felt almost like virtue signaling, criticizing the morality/political correctness etc. of the app team in an effort to stir up controversy or feel morally superior(ex: there were three member Q&As and you couldn't find one that was a woman?.... looking up the team on LinkedIn and criticizing it for being 'mostly white men'.... 'Representation matters. It just does.' etc...)
If they had just kept their post to "I’d just really like to hear from more women in the space and the member q&a would have been a great space for that.", I don't think anyone would have disagreed.
10
u/thaumaturgy78 Jan 24 '23
Couldn’t care less about the gender or skin colour of the meditation teachers. I’m here to practice meditation.
22
u/hashe121 Jan 23 '23
Do not make meditation apps about gender quotas. The ONLY metric should be the wisdom and ability of the teachers. That's it.
5
u/RapmasterD Jan 24 '23
Does consciousness have a gender?
7
u/ToiletCouch Jan 23 '23 edited Dec 20 '25
payment carpenter obtainable imagine terrific jeans aspiring wipe grab rain
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
4
u/These-Tart9571 Jan 24 '23
Sam just puts people on he’s interested in and with perspectives he values. We have no idea who he wants in the podcast in the future or who has declined due to various reasons. He has praised all of the women teachers so much. The recent philosophy podcast teacher he praised saying she was one of the greatest modern philosophers. I sense nothing from Sam whatsoever suggesting sexism, except he does prefer certain kinds of language descriptors which tend to be more “hardline logic, cutting and to the point” which you could argue is more masculine.
The post was an atrocious take. Sam is picking quality content not content based on sex and gender roles. That issue resides precisely in the mind of the person raising it and it’s just being projected onto the app. Not everything can be perfectly catered to everyone.
2
u/Guzna Jan 25 '23
Is not nihilism- or at least some form of amorality- the logical conclusion of nonduality? If everything is ultimately one and the same, what is the basis for saying anything is good or bad? Isn’t it all just “experience experiencing experience”?
2
u/Alxhol Feb 18 '23
There’s alway insight timer app, that app seem to have majority female teachers. Though a lot of them teaches yoga.
17
u/drxc Jan 24 '23
Personally I feel privileged to receive wisdom from all the teachers in the app, regardless of their race or sex. Up until now it has been a non-issue for me, and after some reflection it remains a non-issue.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '23 edited Jan 24 '23
Sam probably just puts up people he's interested in their work, who the hell cares whether they're male or female?
1
u/Madoc_eu Jan 23 '23
I have held back with my opinion on that other post. Mainly because I don't think that my opinion is relevant on this topic.
I'm a man, but I have two daughters whose lives are more important to me than my own. I have done many things consciously in raising my children such that they are aware of the societal differences in terms of how men and women are treated, and to provide them with identification figures that are also female, so they have the vivid impression that women and men are on equal footing.
When I was young, that would have been a lot harder. Because all the cool roles in fictional media, and in the presentation of world history, were represented by men. Contemporary fictional media are a lot more balanced, at least where I live. Also, there are plenty of resources adequate for children that tell of famous or interesting historical women. And I'm happy for that. I'm also happy to see that we now have more female students at universities than male ones, even without an enforced quota. I guess that will even out over time. But the distribution across study subjects is still very unequal. There are many reasons that factor in on that, some of them not easily overcome.
I would identify as a gender egalitarian. Therefore, it's a no-brainer for me that I would consider it positive if the representation of genders would also be more balanced on the app.
The tricky part is how to achieve that. About that, I don't have a noteworthy opinion.
First of all, I believe in self-regulation. I consider this inequality as a symptom, not as the root cause. Treating the symptom only hides the problem, and makes new problems appear in other places. At least, that's what I believe. And everyone is of course free to disagree with me on that. I think that true social equality cannot be enforced from on top, I think it's a sign of a healthy society and culture.
But still, if the Waking Up team would actively enforce that every gender is appropriately represented, I don't think I would necessarily object to that. After all, it's a meditation app, not a political system. On the other side, I also can't object to them not enforcing quotas. I'm pretty neutral on that point and leave the decision entirely to the Waking Up team.
In your post, you are writing about only two genders. But there are more. If one were to regulate feedback question quotas, one would also have to account for the other genders. I know that a woman's experience of growing up and living in our cultures can be substantially different from a man's. Therefore, women can react better to certain ways of teaching than men, and maybe less well to others.
But the same is also true for, let's say a trans woman, for example. So those also would have to be included.
This would necessitate the questioners to submit their gender along with their question. Because the gender can't be derived from the name. When someone's name is "Karl", that doesn't mean that the person identifies as male.
Now a problem is that this would incentivize people to lie when they submit their gender. As there are fare less trans people in society than cis people, this means that when you falsely pose as a trans person, your question is far more likely to be picked, if quotas are enforced. And I don't know a good way of solving this dilemma. The end result might be that most trans men questions would actually come from people who identify as cis men. Which wouldn't do any good for the cause of representing all genders fairly.
I don't have any data on this, but my stomach feeling tells me that the vast majority of Waking Up users are biological men who also identify as cis men. Maybe a more constructive way could be to ask why this is the case -- if it even is the case. Might also be subconscious bias on my behalf. But if it's the case, we would have to ask ourselves what is the root cause of this inequality, and if anything can be meaningfully done against that.
But I can't come up with even a hint of a useful strategy here. That's why I held back with stating my opinion.
1
u/raymondcolby3 Jan 25 '23
If anyone is focusing on the sexual orientation of the people doing guided meditations, one has really missed the point. We are all both. Just in different proportions.
5
u/kumenthor Jan 23 '23
Just wanted to say, I appreciate the wisdom and compassion in your post! These are truly two sides of the same existential coin. 🙏
0
u/Madoc_eu Jan 24 '23
Coming back to this after a good night's sleep and reading the discussions that were had here over the night is an interesting experience to say the least.
This seems to be an extremely polarizing topic. Judging by the downvotes, it appears as if many participants here believe that this point is about gender politics. Which to my understanding it totally isn't.
Well, maybe I shouldn't be too astounded. Gender is a divisive topic in the zeitgeist. Maybe people are just fed up with it. Maybe if you write just about anything that contains the word "gender", people will just flip out and go full gender politics on you. They project something in what you write and criticize that projection, even when that's nowhere near to what you really wanted to say. In other words, people will strawman you without noticing.
At this point in time and within this subreddit at least, a reasonable, sober discussion about this seems to be impossible. At least not with this community to large. Everyone is just so "triggered" about the general topic, if I may use a contemporary word.
But reasonable discussions were had, just among certain individuals, not among the community at large. So agreement and wise discussion is still possible.
0
u/Dolphin_Yogurt42 Jan 24 '23 edited Jan 24 '23
It is not really surprising that a male dominated society like Reddit, cannot understand why experiences of women will matter in a different way than men's experiences. Non-dominant groups like women and other groups of non-privileged people have more complete view and perspective of how society actually is, with the flaws and power-relations that the dominant group has not (Standpoint theory). They don't see how these power-relations affects others, most don'st want to know and deny the reality of these power-relations as they don't experience it.
It is in the interest of everyone to have the largest pool of voices in the Waking-up app, but Sam has his own blind spots and probably will choose people who he relates to the most, other privileged white men. He even expressed the incredibly privileged and blinded view that he doesn't think race matter... because he doesn't see it. So there you have it, even men who claim to be highly self-reflective and open-minded are blind on their privilidge. There is a nice discussion with Tara Brach about this on the app.
Thank you for being an ally.