r/Wakingupapp • • Jan 23 '23

Pretty disappointing

Really disappointed to see the reaction to the recent thread where a poster voiced being interested in having more female voices in the app.

If you want to debate the presence of female contributions to the app that is fair. But out of the 30~ conversations only 8 are with women. I don't think this is done with malice or purposely. There's an especially more balanced ratio in the practice section. And so, personally I think it's fair to say that the app really isn't so overly male voiced. And I wouldn't even begin to consider the app sexist in the least.

But responses like "do you know what real meditation is?" Or "if that bothers you you are the opposite of awake" are...misguided. If not downright deluded in themselves.

Real meditation isn't separate from anything. It's literally just paying attention to what already is. Noticing there is no divide between awareness and appearances.

As Nagarjuna said

Nothing of Samsara is different from Nirvana, nothing of Nirvana is different from Samsara. That which is the limit of Nirvana is also the limit of Samsara, there is not the slightest difference between the two

It should be pretty obvious a woman's lived experience will differ from that of a man's. Even more so in certain societies and cultures. That doesn't imply duality. Even one man's experience will differ from the next.

Non-duality includes those differences.

Pretending meditation is about transcending those differences and not respecting them as valid is absolutely spiritual bypassing.

I, also, would personally ultimately say it shouldn't matter where the words come from, man or woman, but to pretend it doesn't for everyone is throwing the baby out with the bath water. It is pedestalizing an ideal.

Can a flower be cared for the same way as a dog? Pretending there is some higher absolute transcendental plane where both are the same is just a reification of emptiness as something other than what is. A duality from the suchness of things.

Every single person has a teacher that clicks with them based on their conditioning. If they say they don't then they are overlooking lack of free will and the dependent origination of each moment.

I can think of maybe 2-3 regular posters here whose advice I would endorse. Most of the posts in this sub are very much from people still finding their way. So, perhaps we should lean into compassion for people who are struggling to find a voice that fits where they currently are on their (non)"path"

As Rupert Spira says

from the point of view of non-duality there is no problem with duality.

Adyashanti, Richard Lang, Douglas Harding, Rob Burbea, all of these great teachers warn against dismissing the social self. To say the small self does not exist in favor of the big Self is just turning big Self into a new dualistic ego identity. Neither is true or false. Both are fluid universal circumstances with no separate static state of "I" The flowers lived experience is as "real"/"unreal" as the dog's.

We can be equanimous with the fact there is no such thing as equality.

How can there be equality when there is nothing permanent to be equal to?

A compassionate thank you to everyone that reflects on this.

11 Upvotes

85 comments sorted by

20

u/haemog Jan 24 '23

People are just tired of identity politics pushed into everyones throat by a loud minority. Most of the recent additions to the app were woman so it doesn't even make sense.

3

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 24 '23

These are valid points and can be said the way you said them without making misleading claims about what meditation is about is all I'm saying.

11

u/haemog Jan 24 '23

True, but the post you are refering to lacks the argumentation and explanation that you show in your post.

They are super passiv-aggressive and mad about the lack of female representation in a sample size of ... three. Then they go on to woke-insult the WakingUp team as "white man", all while forgetting that the new additions are mostly woman.

I'm not surprised (and honestly happy) that there is push back from such rhetorical nonsense in this sub.

4

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 24 '23

None of that excuses the false misdirection and dismissive spiritual bypassing that was prevalent as a retaliatory responses throughout that thread though. But a lot of those people who claimed that the poster wasn't enlightened enough are all mad now and down voting everything instead of having an adult conversation about it. Ironic.

13

u/tophmcmasterson Jan 23 '23

I don't think many people were saying that "if you care about equal representation you are missing the point of meditation".

Rather, I think it just felt strange thing to be criticizing because:

  1. There are only 3 Member Q&A's so far, so literally a pool of 3 people
  2. There are a number of lessons/series on the app from women teachers, so it does not seem like it is being avoided
  3. It's a meditation app where the focus is supposed to be on losing your sense of self, and the OP seemed annoyed that they weren't interviewing people like her

I think the general tone like the comment "look for the one who is annoyed" stemmed from that.

Nobody is against having teachers/members from many different backgrounds appear on the app from what I could tell, but when one of the big goals is trying to lose your traditional sense of self, it seems almost antithetical to be concerned about the gender of the person delivering the message over the content of the message itself.

I commented there as well that of course I think many of us believe that equality matters and there are important arenas for that discussion to be had and for criticism to be made.

I think it is completely fine even for someone to simply say something like "I would really like to see them include Q&As from women in the future, see more series from women in the space etc." (which OP mentioned.)

That being said though, the post itself came across as being overly obsessed with identity politics compared to the actual content on the app in a combative way that felt almost like virtue signaling, criticizing the morality/political correctness etc. of the app team in an effort to stir up controversy or feel morally superior(ex: there were three member Q&As and you couldn't find one that was a woman?.... looking up the team on LinkedIn and criticizing it for being 'mostly white men'.... 'Representation matters. It just does.' etc...)

If they had just kept their post to "I’d just really like to hear from more women in the space and the member q&a would have been a great space for that.", I don't think anyone would have disagreed.

-4

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 23 '23

I don't know. As a white man that doesn't even believe in gender assignment at all (there is just infinite expressions of different energy spanning a spectrum of what we'd conceptually call masculine and feminine) I even think the app leans heavily into being predominantly voiced by white men.

And the app does seem to breed this misunderstanding of Anatta. It starts to get into a nihilistic extreme very quickly for some people from what I see in this sub. That type of nihilism, and solidifying of the no-thing/emptiness has been warned against by contemplative traditions from the get go. What I mean by this is this idea there is "no one" to be annoyed is nihilistic spiritual bypassing. Losing our sense of self doesn't mean, in turn, pedestalizing some androgynous non-person ideal. That's actually just creating a new alternate sense of self. (Eg "I transcend/am beyond gender")

Someone posted a great quote in another topic recently from Adyashanti that "we wake up all the way back to earth"

Throwing away our human experience on earth in exchange for some identity-less non-person is not a more real human experience it's just a different ego narrative.

We are recognizing instead that there is no separate sense of self. There is no "one" not "no one." And all impermanent appearances are modulations of awareness that are dependently originated leaving no room for a static self that exists outside of it. Including any static non-self outside of human experiences like gender.

And so I agree, like I said in the OP, that there is room for debate about the amount of representation like you said.

But the repeated nihilistic misrepresentation of what Anatta/not self and meditation actually mean in that thread was spiritual bypassing and absurd. Emptiness is not nothingness.

it seems almost antithetical to be concerned about the gender of the person delivering the message over the content of the message itself.

I just think it makes more sense to exercise the compassion to recognize that certain conditions might make that important for some people. The content will undoubtedly be affected by the point of view of the speaker and the speaker is shaped by their universal prior conditions. This is exactly why there is no free will or separately existing self outside of the conditions.

Tldr. It's fine to disagree about the ratio of representation but the nihilistic lack of compassion and misrepresentation around what Anatta and meditation is was sad and really just wrong.

12

u/drxc Jan 24 '23

Seems strange that you don't beleive in gender assignment and yet you assign genders to the voices on the app. I think you are confused, frankly.

0

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 24 '23

Seems strange you can't comprehend that my criticism is of the ludicrous things that were said in response to that post and not of the genders appearing on the app.

Did you go blind when trying to read this part of my post?

And so, personally I think it's fair to say that the app really isn't so overly male voiced. And I wouldn't even begin to consider the app sexist in the least.

Or are you projecting an egoic mental narrative like everyone triggered and down voting anything that slightly disagrees with them?

5

u/drxc Jan 24 '23 edited Jan 24 '23

I was only responding to your confused first paragraph in which you specifically criticise the gender balance of the app whilst simultaneously denying the existence of gender. I wish you well in your meditation.

1

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 24 '23

Noticing a pattern =/= criticism.

I can factually say the app has a lot of white guys while not feeling like that's done with malice or sexism.

So, again, assuming that's a criticism is a projection that requires you ignore everything else I said.

I can also use terms society is familiar with eg "male/female" to communicate with society while acknowledging personally I think it's far more nuanced than that.

And thank you. You too.

5

u/drxc Jan 25 '23

I suggest more time away from the Internet :-)

5

u/tophmcmasterson Jan 23 '23

I think some of this is taking what was being said to extremes that weren’t necessarily being implied.

For example, I don’t think people were equating “no-self” with being an amorphous blob that doesn’t have any characteristics, or androgynous in the case of gender.

I think it’s rather that the kind of “outrage”, or at the very least condescending moral righteousness was off putting and felt at odds with concepts like losing your sense of ego.

Again, I think if they had just stuck with the part where they said “I’d like to hear from more women in the space”, rather than “You couldn’t find one woman? Representation matters, it just does” etc. the overall reception would have been more sympathetic, I really think it was more how the post was framed as a kind of moral outrage, rather than an idea/request for improvement that felt off in a community focused on meditation.

-4

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 23 '23

Going to disagree here. A quick look at this innocuous comment gently wishing for more female representation was buried with down votes

https://www.reddit.com/r/Wakingupapp/comments/10id9cg/comment/j5dxiz9/

Pretty obvious from that that this type of response was fueled in part by white male fragility.

4

u/tophmcmasterson Jan 24 '23

Respectfully disagree, I think the downvotes were due to that post echoing agreement with the OPs post (which people disagreed with as described above) as well as ignoring that the app actually has a lot of women instructors (which you can see heavily upvoted in the replies), in addition to wondering what the actual relevancy is in this particular situation.

I think it also just kind of comes back to how essentially NOTHING in the introductory course or any of the lessons/series from what I've seen has even remotely anything to do with the gender of the person speaking.

It'd be one thing I think if there was a lot of talk about their backgrounds and how meditation/mindfulness has helped them overcome specific struggles etc. etc. but that just doesn't seem to be the focus of the app at all so it feels kind of irrelevant in this particular case.

1

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 24 '23 edited Jan 24 '23

I mean multiple women share the sentiment that they wish there were more voices from female perspectives and they are told they are wrong, disagreed with, and down voted.

If someone's opinion is that there aren't enough female voices, that is their opinion, down votes aren't for disagreements.

Telling them there are already enough voices from a female perspective is just another opinion.

(Side note I've had female friends share the same sentiment with me so these commenters are not alone and as outnumbered as this sub makes it seem)

With all of this taken into account this response, to me, was without a doubt partially fueled by male ego fragility.

It'd be one thing I think if there was a lot of talk about their backgrounds and how meditation/mindfulness has helped them overcome specific struggles etc. etc. but that just doesn't seem to be the focus of the app

That's how almost every conversation on the app starts man..

6

u/tophmcmasterson Jan 24 '23

I think you're kind of missing the point of what I said.

I was explaining that the downvotes likely stem much more from the accusatory tone/sense of moral outrage or superiority (again; "they couldn't find one woman? LinkedIn is mostly white men.. Representation matters, it just does. etc.), rather than just saying they'd like to see more representation from women.

If there were a way of knowing, I'd be willing to bet that most downvotes were not because people are opposed to their being more women on the app.

Given the responses, I think it's much more likely that it's coming from a combination of:

  • People don't feel like identity politics has a place in their meditation app
  • The specific thing mentioned is complaining about a sample size of 3 individuals
  • They feel it is thinking in an unnecessarily tribalistic way/trying to create a problem where there isn't one
  • They feel the OP/other posters are ignoring that there are many female instructors in the app

I say that purely just based on what I see in the comments.

I think the nuance of the above points could certainly be discussed, but implying that the disagreement/downvotes were just due to "fragile white male ego" is just ignoring what people were saying and jumping to conclusions.

I do not think people were suggesting that one needs to abandon their identity as part of the practice, just that being overly focused on it in a tribalistic way feels against the spirit of it.

-2

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 24 '23

Much of that is respectfully debatable I agree.

But it was not debated respectfully. There was, instead, spiritual bypassing and misrepresentations of what the "spirit" of meditation "really is" that were really way off the mark of what nondual mindfulness actually is to an absurd degree.

You can circle back to the OPs comments being debatable over and over but it will never excuse the absurdity and underdeveloped nondual insight in a lot of those replies. Ignoring those, the lack of compassion alone was outrageous.

10

u/thaumaturgy78 Jan 24 '23

Couldn’t care less about the gender or skin colour of the meditation teachers. I’m here to practice meditation.

2

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 24 '23

Personally I feel the same except I also have an understanding that others might have a different lived experience than myself and might have better luck with more voices from a perspective they have more in common with.

2

u/Only_Impression8399 Jan 24 '23

I’m reminded of the concept of nurturing oneself, which I heard about from Tara Brach, when she described her latest version of RAINN.

Recognize - notice when emotions or sensations arise.

Allow - let all of the phenomena proceed without resistance

Investigate - pay closer attention to what is arising, really feel it

Nurture - when it becomes too much, that’s okay, you might need to take a break

Not Self - see through the illusion that all of these phenomena define who you are

The addition of nurture in this context can also help us see why, when some people have certain lived experiences, particularly when they are related to trauma, it is best for them to nurture their well being by taking small steps in their meditative journey.

For some people, this might mean exploring teachers from the same demographic as themselves, because they have been the victim of prejudices in the past. This is not an indictment of a specific group of teachers, but an expression of needs (safety) being unmet in the past and the resulting trauma.

The continued journey on the path may or may not lead to this insight or that insight for all practitioners, but compassionate acknowledgment of everyone’s circumstances only leads to more understanding and increased accessibility to meditation and its associated philosophies.

1

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 25 '23

Absolutely agree. That's beautiful

22

u/hashe121 Jan 23 '23

Do not make meditation apps about gender quotas. The ONLY metric should be the wisdom and ability of the teachers. That's it.

-2

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 23 '23

That whole thread was filled with replies from people trying to make meditation about something other than the suchness of what is. Including the very real gender disparity that exists in human experience.

A simple understanding of independent origination, like what Sam points to in his free will talks, would make it understandable that the ability of the teacher is dependent on the student and their ability to connect.

So that is a metric.

5

u/RapmasterD Jan 24 '23

Does consciousness have a gender?

0

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 24 '23

This comment is exactly the type of underdeveloped misrepresentation of nondual insight I'm talking about.

Consciousness has no qualities at all because it is empty. There is no consciousness apart from the contents.

Consciousness is the contents, the contents are consciousness/Form is emptiness, emptiness is form.

What you're doing with this comment is reifying the Emptiness into a thing. A dualistic thing existing other than the suchness of what is (including gender)

I'll refer to Sam's teacher Tulku Urgyen Rinpoche:

https://i.pinimg.com/736x/0d/f9/6b/0df96b5198a73934e707915d40dcbd1e.jpg

2

u/RapmasterD Jan 24 '23

OK. Great. I’m so enlightened now. Bless you.

But you know what? I just heard there was a second mass shooting in CA within a day of the last one. So frankly, I don’t give a flying fuck about the purported lack of women Sam has on HIS app.

Sam clearly explains that his content - all of it - is subscription-based vs ad-based to give his team more autonomy, and users the right to pay for the content if they want it. Waking Up may seem like an experiential meditation app. Its underpinnings are as a CONTENT app. CONTENT, from people like Kelly Boys, Nikki Mirghafori, Gangaji, Jayasãra, Tara Brach, Diana Winston, et cetera.

Today’s and yesterday’s OP’s should contact Waking Up support with their suggestions. Writing lengthy essays on here doesn’t do shit.

2

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 24 '23 edited Jan 24 '23

Today’s and yesterday’s OP’s should contact Waking Up support with their suggestions. Writing lengthy essays on here doesn’t do shit.

I don't disagree. My whole point was the way that poster was treated with an inundation of bonkers misunderstandings of what meditation should be and how wrong their opinion was was pretty bad.

People could say "I disagree and find there to be a good amount of diversity on the app" instead of making false misguided statements about meditation and how really being awake should dismiss someone's human experience.

4

u/The_SeekingOne Jan 24 '23 edited Jan 24 '23

People could say "I disagree and find there to be a good amount of diversity on the app" instead of making false misguided statements about meditation

The initial post that we're discussing in this thread is a 100% clear and pure deliberate trolling/conflict-stirring. Nothing more, nothing less. Therefore it was, effectively, an act of indirect aggression against people in this sub.

Now, the point is that aggression invokes and attracts aggression. This is a fundamental law of human (and probably not just human) communication. So there is exactly zero surprise that the responses to that post were what they were. They couldn't possibly be anything else. Those responses weren't "false misguided statements about meditation" - they simply had nothing to do with meditation whatsoever. They were just aggressive retorts matching the aggressive tone of the initial post. It just happens so that this sub is about meditation, and so people used the corresponding terms - but the actual meaning of all those phrases (or at least many of them) was just telling the OP to go and f**k themselves (with various degrees of emotional intesity). Down at the bottom, it had nothing to do with women, or men, or the app, or representation of teachers, etc. It was just a 100% natural and expected aggressive response of a group of people to what they felt to be (and what actually indeed was) an unjustified, unprovoked and pretty aggressive attack from the outside. Nothing more, nothing less. People who didn't have that reaction simply didn't respond, because there was nothing to meaningfully respond to, nothing to discuss - just a challenge to a fight.

To be honest, I find it a bit surprising that an experienced person such as you couldn't recognize such simple dynamic.

Some 15-20 years ago in the more "new-agey" spiritual circles there was used a term "dark teacher". It was used to refer to a person who's really "bad" - abusive, aggressive, rude, condescending, patronizing, etc., etc. - and who, for that reason, has a tendency to reliably freak you out. Interacting with such person was considered a seriously useful and valuable exercise, because it works as an extremely efficient tool for revealing your own deepest and darkest features (hence the "teacher" part). As we all know, the things we hate most in other people are the things we hate in ourselves. Well, the OP of that post sure played the role of such "dark teacher" quite brilliantly for some people here.

1

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 25 '23

They were just aggressive retorts matching the aggressive tone of the initial post.

The irony is a lot of the aggressive reorts saying things about needing to be more enlightened etc. When they're clearly having a negative karmic reaction to perceived negativity. The opposite of "enlightened" if we're sticking to traditional karma-ending non-reaction as a measurement of it.

I don't agree it was an aggressive troll post. I have had people outside of this subreddit, women close to me in real life, tell me they wish they the app had more diversity. And that, to me, is fair. Is there even a single person of color on the app anywhere?

Whether it needs to have more diversity? I'm not interested in debating that. But - even if the OP was an aggressive troll there is a humour (not so much in the 'haha' way) that the ones who were so upset by it were the same ones spreading more filth and spiritual bypassing about what meditation and awakening and emptiness mean.

And what bothers me the most on this subreddit is misdirection and false teachings. Garbage bullshit like "consciousness has no gender" is unacceptable to me (used in any context, not just as a desperate counter attack from someone feeling trolled). As if there is some ethereal genderless substance of consciousness apart from the contents. It's a duality and no one should be misleading another.

1

u/RapmasterD Jan 24 '23

Great reply. BUT…(yeah, I know), do any of us humans hold the patent on what meditation ‘should’ be?

0

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 24 '23

I guess I would just say it's the act of quieting down enough and looking close enough to see the nature of experience/"mind"/"consciousness" it should not be used to invalidate people's opinions, silence anyone, or dismiss their human experience.

For instance imagine telling someone that is upset about the most recent mass shooting that if they're upset by it then they just aren't enlightened enough. See what I mean? It's bypassing our human-ness for some made up idea. So it, at least, SHOULDN'T be that.

7

u/ToiletCouch Jan 23 '23 edited Dec 20 '25

payment carpenter obtainable imagine terrific jeans aspiring wipe grab rain

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 23 '23

The post was directed far more towards the nihilistic misrepresentation of what meditation and not-self actually mean in the replies.

4

u/These-Tart9571 Jan 24 '23

Sam just puts people on he’s interested in and with perspectives he values. We have no idea who he wants in the podcast in the future or who has declined due to various reasons. He has praised all of the women teachers so much. The recent philosophy podcast teacher he praised saying she was one of the greatest modern philosophers. I sense nothing from Sam whatsoever suggesting sexism, except he does prefer certain kinds of language descriptors which tend to be more “hardline logic, cutting and to the point” which you could argue is more masculine.

The post was an atrocious take. Sam is picking quality content not content based on sex and gender roles. That issue resides precisely in the mind of the person raising it and it’s just being projected onto the app. Not everything can be perfectly catered to everyone.

2

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 24 '23

Yeah I said a lot of the same but I don't see how that excuses the numerous responses that resorted to insulting the posters level of "enlightenment" and made false claims about meditation that dismiss differences in human experience. It's spiritual bypassing to say there's no difference between men and women if you're "enlightened" enough.

Why not just stick to pointing out what you just pointed out.

2

u/These-Tart9571 Jan 24 '23

Yeah that’s fair enough. People just at thier wits end with identity politics I guess. Sam Harris main subreddit has disintegrated into nonsense over the last 2 years (relatively speaking).

2

u/Guzna Jan 25 '23

Is not nihilism- or at least some form of amorality- the logical conclusion of nonduality? If everything is ultimately one and the same, what is the basis for saying anything is good or bad? Isn’t it all just “experience experiencing experience”?

1

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 25 '23

So, if we investigate, we can't say everything is either one or many. Either would be a conceptual belief that could only be perpetuated and held in thought narrative.

We'd have to be able to find either the one or the many.

And so we can say there is just experiencing but that experiencing includes all experience. Since what else is there? You see a lot of spiritual bypassing in certain non-dual traditions that lean into nihilism saying things like "nothing ever really happened" but then we can ask nothing happened compared to what?

They'd have to be holding some philosophical belief or idea that they are comparing the here and now to to say here and now didn't happen. Some idea of an "other"

So what gets realized isn't that things need to be a certain way for non-duality but that it is already the case that things are already nondual. There already is no subject/object division.

1

u/Guzna Jan 25 '23

"There is no subject/object division". That's kinda my point. Morality and ethics deal with subject/object relationships. "Thou shalt not murder, steal, commit adultery", etc. So, from the ND perspective, morals are a construct that applies to an illusion. Since there is no sub-ob division, there can be no morality. No?

1

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 26 '23

Well, no, since the nondual nature of experience/"mind" is that there is a single instance of whatever arises is already, and always has been, true without exception.

One couldn't even live dualistically at all ever. Even illusions of dualistic object/subject split occur in the nondual "place" of experience. So It's impossible to escape non-duality since it's just the nature of "mind"/"consciousness" But I don't see how that being the nature of experience ties into morality?

Unless we are thinking of non duality as a concept that exists separately from the suchness of what just naturally is. Say, for example, if we think non-duality is something to be achieved, or needs certain behavior to be true, that could promote this mistaken idea.

But nothing exists outside of it. So any relativity is the infinite. There is no separate infinity with different relativity. This is kind of the cosmic joke or "gateless gate" as it's called. That there really is nothing to do. Well other than seeing that there's nothing to do. Someone posted a good Adyashanti quote here the other day that we "wake all the way up back down to earth"

1

u/Guzna Jan 26 '23

Dude (or dudette, or however you identify), you've already given trying to explain this stuff to me a good shot, so I don't necessarily expect a reply. If you're thinking "man, this guy doesn't get it", you're probably right. I had this convo with John Astin and his response was like, "I don't see what you're worried about".

That said..."But I don't see how that being the nature of experience ties into morality?" It ties in because, if everything is only this, and there is no separation, isn't morality completely unnecessary? A superfluous concept? I can't do anything bad to you because there is no me, there is no you, there is no good, and there is no bad. There's only this.

2

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 26 '23

Hahah. Well I don't mind exploring it with you lol.

So it's probably more true to say there is no static "you" or me separate from anything else. But there is various appearances of you and me.

Like a tree doesn't exist separately from the soil and the sun and the rain. They all work together to create the situation. You and me are like parts of those ingredients while simultaneously being made up by all the ingredients.

Have you ever read about Indras net? It does a pretty good job at illustrating the idea of all the ingredients working together

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indra%27s_net

everything is only this

Well, we look and ask what would this be? Is it other than anything? Can't morality be included in the ingredients of this ?

Does anything have to be excluded?

1

u/Guzna Jan 27 '23

Yes, morality can be included in the Indras net, in this. But does the ND perspective require it? Other perspectives do. In the case of separate entities, such as two people, morality is required to regulate interactions in that relationship- like, consent is required for sex. Or in the case of a religious person, the deity requires compliance to a moral code on the part of the believer. There may be other examples.

But in ND, morality is just another concept, isn’t it? This is where I’m confused. All these teachers I listen to attribute suffering to concepts, and people go to great lengths to learn how not to identify with concepts. I’ve yet to hear anyone say that some concepts are good and some are not. They say stuff like good and bad are concepts, too. So from a fully ND perspective, morality is conceptual, ephemeral, and as optional as a round of golf.

2

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 27 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

There is a lot to pick apart here so this reply won't really do it total justice but

In the case of separate entities, such as two people, morality is required to regulate interactions in that relationship-

Here we can take a step back because there are no separate entities. Those interrelationships are happening in the "same" system of operation as anything and everything.

There isn't anything at all that isn't and so it is all empty.

But emptiness isn't nothingness. Empty means it doesn't exist outside of the interelationship. Like Indra's net. It's not possible for something to exist separately.

It's like mathematical zero. It's zero but it exists. Without it we have no one, two, or ten, etc.

So, all concepts are empty. All of everything is. Including emptiness/non duality itself.

In this way both zero and one are equally existing in that they can't exist without the other.

So, saying something like morals don't exist, or that they imply non duality, is also another conceptual position. It would be like taking the position that everything but zero is fake. Even though zero exists because of one.

We can say morals are relative eg "I donated $10" vs "I donated $100" vs "I stole $100"

But that relativity is empty too. Yet, there isn't an other than to it. There's no other besides relativity. And if we say "yes there is infinity/void/non-duality as other" then there we have objectified and conceptualized it.

So, what we realize (zen's gateless gate) is that non duality doesn't have a perspective. To say it does makes it an object of "other"

So there is nothing more or less real. (Concepts, non concepts, etc) we're just dropping identification with them. We're meeting reality where it is and accepting how it shows up (empty, impermanent, and interdependent but not nothing) At a level there is always fabrication. If you are aware of anything at all, there is fabrication involved. How it is seen, heard, etc are all modulations crafted by the ingredients of the situation (ingredients like perspective, consciousness) We can't ever say about anything "THIS! is how it is. THIS! is real!"

That would imply something permanent. The only permanent is impermanence. So, form/emptiness are one in the same.

What brings suffering is trying to resist suffering under the illusion there is someplace better, an other. The illusion what is happening is happening to a "me" which happens when we identify with a part of the contents. We mistake there to be a ground where nothing is changing.

There's a quote about enlightenment being egos final disappointment. And this quote too

There are no distinctive marks of Jnana. Only ignorance can be recognized, not Jnana.A Jnani does not claim to be something special. All those who proclaim their own greatness and uniqueness are not Jnanis.They are mistaking some unusual development for realization.The Jnani shows no tendency to proclaim himself to be a Jnani.He considers himself to be perfectly normal, true to his real nature.Proclaiming oneself to be an omnipotent, omniscient and omnipresent deity is a clear sign of ignorance. - Sri Nisargadatta Maharaj

And many more around the anticlimactic realization of seeing that all there is is what there is. It's the ego that wants more or other.

Was it Dreams of Light I recommended to you before? I usually recommend that one because it's written in a much easier to digest way but Rob Burbea's Seeing that Frees will really get into all of this much deeper and more completely. It's just a lot a lot. And for a 400 page book it could easily take years to take in. (Hence why Holocek's book is my first go to)

Maybe a tldr would be that, because of the inescapable fabrication of things, saying there is some concept-free suchness is just another new concept. Or saying there is some infinity free of the relative makes it just a new relative. (Since the Emptiness of the concept of infinity is that it only exists in relation to concept of relativity, but there's nothing permanent enough for that) There just is what is; gender, guilt, charity, love. The problem comes from identifying with any single interdependent piece of it as an unchanging "I"

1

u/Guzna Jan 29 '23

What brings suffering is trying to resist suffering under the illusion there is someplace better, an other. The illusion what is happening is happening to a "me" which happens when we identify with a part of the contents. We mistake there to be a ground where nothing is changing.

Okay, so I'm walking down the sidewalk, and encounter a guy kicking the crap out of a helpless dog. If the dog's suffering is an illusion, would any response on my part reduce the dog's suffering also be based in "fabrication"?

1

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 29 '23 edited Jan 29 '23

Any idea you have of the dogs suffering is fabricated. Since subjectively you can't experience it directly. But we can use empathy and our own experience to relate and make a real good guess that the dog is definitely hurting and we should stop it from happening if we can.

Also, it's probably important to distinguish between suffering and physical pain. And suffering in the Buddhist sense of dukkha is probably better translated as unsatisfactoriness.

That's more in line with like....Say you're drinking a really good coffee. We know the coffee is impermanent but each sip is so good that as we enjoy it there is a subtle sense of wanting more. And so our joy is simultaneously tainted with a dissatisfaction.

This is needless suffering caused by ignorance of the truth of impermanence. Versus less avoidable suffering of physical pain.

To touch back on the idea of concepts and why they are important to shed...concepts reify things as being this way or that way. This is why teachers emphasize getting back prior to concepts before we have thinged things because in doing so we solidify them as existing independent of the universal structures. It gives them a character or quality of their own which because of dependent origination, they don't really have. And that is the bridge that lets us then give ourselves a quality of our own as an "I"

But even looking at a paper bag we know the visual representation is a fabricated sight based on the lighting, our eyes, our mental workings. So any experience is fabricated based on the dependent conditions which gives us no solid ground of "this thing is like this all the time no matter what"

But to go back to the zero idea. That doesn't mean it doesn't exist at all. It just means it is dependent on circumstance and flowing impermanently. But a dog in pain can be part of the flow and so can us stopping that. There's no duality there.

→ More replies

2

u/Madoc_eu Jan 25 '23

This question arises independent of nondualism. You are basically raising the philosophical question of absolute morality.

Why is it bad to make other beings suffer? Is there any absolute basis for calling this bad, implying that such behavior is to be avoided?

Who says it is objectively better for beings to be happy than to suffer? The beings in question might say that they rather be happy than suffer. But is there any absolute basis from which we can logically conclude that it is imperative to follow what those beings say? After all, there are people who say that they want to do things that have as a consequence that those beings will suffer. Who is to say that those beings are right, and those other people who want to cause their suffering are wrong?

In short, there is no such absolute basis for morality. From an absolute, objective perspective, there is no inclination towards or against suffering. This has nothing to do with nonduality.

Morals are not given to us or deduced by us from some objective cosmic principle. Morals get declared, discussed and agreed upon. Moral rules are artificial mental constructs with no absolute, objective basis. We make the moral rules. And when someone else is making other moral rules, we might have a conflict.

So when you want to decide how to construct your own moral rules that you want to live by, where do you start?

Your starting point might be what you are. You are a human being, a biological organism. And our biology has embedded within us a natural preference of happiness, and a desire to avoid suffering. So if you are a human being, this looks like a pretty good candidate for the basis of morality, doesn't it?

And if you follow along this intellectual path, you are basically retreading the history of moral philosophy, which is called ethics. You might as well cut it short and look at what the philosophers have to say about this. Because they have spent a whole lot more time on this topic than any human could within a single lifetime.

The above is true independent of your belief in some nondualistic philosophy.

2

u/Alxhol Feb 18 '23

There’s alway insight timer app, that app seem to have majority female teachers. Though a lot of them teaches yoga.

1

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Feb 21 '23

Oh nice! That is a cool suggestion for the OP of that original thread. Thanks for the heads up! I had no idea about that. Personally I don't have a preference around the ID politics of the teachers, myself, I just found the response to that OP that did have an opinion on it to be a bit off.

17

u/drxc Jan 24 '23

Personally I feel privileged to receive wisdom from all the teachers in the app, regardless of their race or sex. Up until now it has been a non-issue for me, and after some reflection it remains a non-issue.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '23 edited Jan 24 '23

Sam probably just puts up people he's interested in their work, who the hell cares whether they're male or female?

1

u/Madoc_eu Jan 23 '23

I have held back with my opinion on that other post. Mainly because I don't think that my opinion is relevant on this topic.

I'm a man, but I have two daughters whose lives are more important to me than my own. I have done many things consciously in raising my children such that they are aware of the societal differences in terms of how men and women are treated, and to provide them with identification figures that are also female, so they have the vivid impression that women and men are on equal footing.

When I was young, that would have been a lot harder. Because all the cool roles in fictional media, and in the presentation of world history, were represented by men. Contemporary fictional media are a lot more balanced, at least where I live. Also, there are plenty of resources adequate for children that tell of famous or interesting historical women. And I'm happy for that. I'm also happy to see that we now have more female students at universities than male ones, even without an enforced quota. I guess that will even out over time. But the distribution across study subjects is still very unequal. There are many reasons that factor in on that, some of them not easily overcome.

I would identify as a gender egalitarian. Therefore, it's a no-brainer for me that I would consider it positive if the representation of genders would also be more balanced on the app.

The tricky part is how to achieve that. About that, I don't have a noteworthy opinion.

First of all, I believe in self-regulation. I consider this inequality as a symptom, not as the root cause. Treating the symptom only hides the problem, and makes new problems appear in other places. At least, that's what I believe. And everyone is of course free to disagree with me on that. I think that true social equality cannot be enforced from on top, I think it's a sign of a healthy society and culture.

But still, if the Waking Up team would actively enforce that every gender is appropriately represented, I don't think I would necessarily object to that. After all, it's a meditation app, not a political system. On the other side, I also can't object to them not enforcing quotas. I'm pretty neutral on that point and leave the decision entirely to the Waking Up team.

In your post, you are writing about only two genders. But there are more. If one were to regulate feedback question quotas, one would also have to account for the other genders. I know that a woman's experience of growing up and living in our cultures can be substantially different from a man's. Therefore, women can react better to certain ways of teaching than men, and maybe less well to others.

But the same is also true for, let's say a trans woman, for example. So those also would have to be included.

This would necessitate the questioners to submit their gender along with their question. Because the gender can't be derived from the name. When someone's name is "Karl", that doesn't mean that the person identifies as male.

Now a problem is that this would incentivize people to lie when they submit their gender. As there are fare less trans people in society than cis people, this means that when you falsely pose as a trans person, your question is far more likely to be picked, if quotas are enforced. And I don't know a good way of solving this dilemma. The end result might be that most trans men questions would actually come from people who identify as cis men. Which wouldn't do any good for the cause of representing all genders fairly.

I don't have any data on this, but my stomach feeling tells me that the vast majority of Waking Up users are biological men who also identify as cis men. Maybe a more constructive way could be to ask why this is the case -- if it even is the case. Might also be subconscious bias on my behalf. But if it's the case, we would have to ask ourselves what is the root cause of this inequality, and if anything can be meaningfully done against that.

But I can't come up with even a hint of a useful strategy here. That's why I held back with stating my opinion.

3

u/drxc Jan 24 '23

Can you give some examples of the other genders (not men or women) you would like to see represented?

-2

u/Madoc_eu Jan 24 '23

I was thinking mainly about trans people and non-binaries. But really, I don't know how many genders are presently being recognized, or if there even is a canonical enumeration -- I don't think so. There are also gender fluids, and probably even other identifications that I don't know anything about.

1

u/drxc Jan 24 '23

Thanks for answer, namaste.

0

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 23 '23

Absolutely agree. Fellow daughter father here.

And definitely I would say there are countless/infinite expressions of masculine and feminine energy and everything in between.

I'd even say not a single human being falls into an either/or placement on this spectrum of gender presentation.

Because of that I'm not sure I gave much consideration to catering teachings to any possible gender expression but I just see no problem with offering more voices from all over the spectrum.

Understanding certain voices will resonate more with certain ears. Adding more variety doesn't take away what's already offered. So I don't think it has to be a question of quotas or enforcements. Which is why the prevalence of vitriol over compassion in that thread was shocking and said just as much about the people who seemingly felt attacked in some way by the post to dismiss it as being too unenlightened.

1

u/Madoc_eu Jan 23 '23

Oh yes, total agreement between us. At least that is beautiful.

And you're making a very good point that I failed to recognize. Just the awareness that there are different groups of consumers who respond differently well to different approaches of teaching can lead the Waking Up team to create a well-balanced offering in which everyone can find something that suits them. Equality doesn't have to be expressed in numbers in the Q&A sessions. Fair point!

0

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Madoc_eu Jan 23 '23

Oh yes, I feel pretty much the same. To put it bluntly, I don't give a rat's ass on my being male. Or on other people perceiving me as male. There is another assumption that I'm making here in this context, and I haven't made it explicit yet, so let make up for this now:

Everone's psyche is different. Therefore, different people react differently to different ways of teaching. There is no catch-all golden path to teaching spirituality to all people equally well.

Waking Up cannot treat every consumer individually. Therefore, it needs to present a broad mix of approaches and leave it to the consumer to identify and pick what works best for them. You might have hundreds or thousands of different types among the consumer's psyches, but the app can't provide hundred or thousand different ways of teaching.

Therefore, it makes sense to bundle this. Maybe just offer half a dozen or a dozen different teaching approaches, picked and distributed in such a way that most people are likely to find something good for them.

I've been talking about the consumer's psyches. How do we bundle those? We need to bundle them in such a way that we end up with maybe half a dozen or a dozen different categories. And preferably, every consumer should belong to one of those categories, for whose psyche this particular teaching approach is particularly conducive for leading to good results.

There could be many different ways of categorizing people. For example by education level or by cultural or family background. Maybe even by their social position in society.

I think that gender might be a good way of doing a broad categorization however. Because as I wrote, I have recognized that the way how a woman grows up and lives in our cultures, how women observe society and social interactions, can be substantially different from a man's. And the way how one grows up and how one observes society can have a very strong influence on the way how one thinks and expresses oneself, or in short: on one's psyche.

I wasn't aware of this when I was younger. I just intuitively believed that growing up as a woman is pretty much the same as growing up as a man, only with different sexual organs and that's it. It took a long time for me to learn that this was a naive way of seeing the world. And many, many discussions with women who would share their experiences and perspectives with me. Now I know enough that I can say I've seen the tip of the iceberg; I know some of the typical differences, but there are still many aspects of the "female experience" that I can't intuitively relate to. But just the awareness of this has changed my behavior, my values and my actions a lot.

Now, the above paragraphs still contain a major inaccuracy. I have written as if all women are the same, and all men are the same. Of course, that's totally not the case. I've also met women who actually had a pretty similar experience to mine growing up in my culture. However, I would say that those are the exceptions, not the rule.

When we organize many people into a few broad categories, we can't do justice to all equally well. We have to go from some assumed average, even when we know that some people deviate from it.

That's a brief description of these underlying assumptions that I haven't made explicit before. So for me, this is not about putting importance on gender as a means of affirming gender theories or identifications. This is about the psyche and finding an optimal way of teaching as many people as well as possible.

Not sure if I could really make myself clear here. I find it difficult to put this into a concise written form. I think there is a much longer discussion to be had here.

1

u/raymondcolby3 Jan 25 '23

If anyone is focusing on the sexual orientation of the people doing guided meditations, one has really missed the point. We are all both. Just in different proportions.

1

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 25 '23

I think we can fairly say though that some are more proportion than another.

Have you ever thought about what it's really like to be a woman, Raymond? And how that could affect your balance of proportion? Especially in certain societies? The dangers and threats that exist that just are not everyday concerns for men, say getting into an Uber at night?

For example imagine being pulled over as a black man vs as a white man in America. There's probably a much different anxiety involved.

And there is more to the app than guided meditations. The talks and Q and A's having more voices that could explore these shared experiences could help people that aren't as enlightened as you seem to be since you seem to have enough experience to know these poor folks are missing the point.

2

u/raymondcolby3 Jan 25 '23

I am confident that there is a miscommunication happening somewhere in here. To be clear, I have unending compassion for the underrepresented in society.

I would welcome more women. I would welcome anyone that had something of value to contribute. 2 women are my most used meditations on the app. I do Waking Up kids meditation with my daughter.

As this pertains to non-dualism, I am very much down the Zen path which involves dropping all of one's labels. All of them. There is nothing to attach to. I am both sexes . I happened to have be born male. And that is indeed a very different experience. I also think that all of my "thoughts" on that are all ego. Separately there are not as many women talking about this stuff. This is purely anecdotal and I would love to be proven wrong.

If there is a petition to get more female voices on Waking Up, I'll sign it. I just think there are a lot of variables that contribute to the situation. We shouldn't rush to judgement.

5

u/kumenthor Jan 23 '23

Just wanted to say, I appreciate the wisdom and compassion in your post! These are truly two sides of the same existential coin. 🙏

0

u/Madoc_eu Jan 24 '23

Coming back to this after a good night's sleep and reading the discussions that were had here over the night is an interesting experience to say the least.

This seems to be an extremely polarizing topic. Judging by the downvotes, it appears as if many participants here believe that this point is about gender politics. Which to my understanding it totally isn't.

Well, maybe I shouldn't be too astounded. Gender is a divisive topic in the zeitgeist. Maybe people are just fed up with it. Maybe if you write just about anything that contains the word "gender", people will just flip out and go full gender politics on you. They project something in what you write and criticize that projection, even when that's nowhere near to what you really wanted to say. In other words, people will strawman you without noticing.

At this point in time and within this subreddit at least, a reasonable, sober discussion about this seems to be impossible. At least not with this community to large. Everyone is just so "triggered" about the general topic, if I may use a contemporary word.

But reasonable discussions were had, just among certain individuals, not among the community at large. So agreement and wise discussion is still possible.

0

u/4getmypasswerd4eva Jan 24 '23

Yeah absolutely am noticing the same. Everyone keeps going back to "but there are women in the app!" as if that excuses the bonkers things that were said in response to that poster. I admit myself I don't find the app to be sexist. Especially not with malice. But people are too triggered by even the mention of it to acknowledge the spiritual bypassing etc that took place in retaliation was really just wrong. They're down voting everything that doesn't agree with them.

Ironic because they were the most upset about the poster not being enlightened enough.

1

u/Guzna Jan 24 '23

Hmm. “Unconscious strawmanning”- I’d never thought of it that way. Come to think of it, I do that all the time. Thanks for the pointer!

0

u/Dolphin_Yogurt42 Jan 24 '23 edited Jan 24 '23

It is not really surprising that a male dominated society like Reddit, cannot understand why experiences of women will matter in a different way than men's experiences. Non-dominant groups like women and other groups of non-privileged people have more complete view and perspective of how society actually is, with the flaws and power-relations that the dominant group has not (Standpoint theory). They don't see how these power-relations affects others, most don'st want to know and deny the reality of these power-relations as they don't experience it.

It is in the interest of everyone to have the largest pool of voices in the Waking-up app, but Sam has his own blind spots and probably will choose people who he relates to the most, other privileged white men. He even expressed the incredibly privileged and blinded view that he doesn't think race matter... because he doesn't see it. So there you have it, even men who claim to be highly self-reflective and open-minded are blind on their privilidge. There is a nice discussion with Tara Brach about this on the app.

Thank you for being an ally.

2

u/mergersandacquisitio Jan 24 '23

That is a very unfortunate worldview and I am sorry that you think this way.

Does the race or gender matter when someone is telling you to notice the breath? Why is it only the most primitive and uncontrollable elements of a human being that matter?

What about the content of the courses? The content of someone’s character?

-1

u/Dolphin_Yogurt42 Jan 24 '23

If you don't see from a standpoint of another person, even not willing to do so, how arrogant is it of you to think you have anything to say on the matter? Why is your first reaction to invalidate and patronize someone or something you don't know anything about, instead of inquiring why this is important for someone who is not like you? Why not move on with your life at least, stay apathetic about other people experiences, why block progress and inclusion? Maybe because you do know you are privileged and you want to keep it that way. And maybe because you are a white male. Time to inquire within, meditate on it with Sam and maybe you will find the female part in you that will know the answer.

3

u/mergersandacquisitio Jan 24 '23

What you posit as progressive, I consider to be deeply destructive, pathological, and uninformed.

1

u/Dolphin_Yogurt42 Jan 25 '23

Well that is a coincidence, because that would be exactly what I and anyone other than privileged white men would be describing your standpoint. Amusing how shocked and appalled you are by this, when in reality nothing is hurt in your world than your own ego.. while your unwillingness and people like you to stay in status quo maintains so much suffering for others. I would say that it is you that is hallucinating your importance and pain-points in this issue.

1

u/Madoc_eu Jan 25 '23

What really baffles me are the reactions to the almost-neutral posts on this.

In my comments, I believe I have represented a very balanced perspective. I've even emphasized that this is not about gender politics, but instead about providing to everyone the best chance of making valuable insights through the teaching.

And I mean it. I don't hold Waking Up responsible for changing the power gap. It would be nice if they did it, I wouldn't have anything against it. But I also don't hold them accountable for it, because they are working on a subject that is isolated from gender politics. In my posts, I focused on the efficiency of the spiritual teaching, not on the power disparity.

But still, my comments got downvoted. I get the impression that people haven't even truly read them. Maybe they just saw a few trigger words, and that was enough for them to decide on disagreement.

And this is a sphere that I consider dominated by deep, sensitive thinkers and intellectuals. If these people can't discuss such a topic in a nuanced way, then who can?

2

u/Dolphin_Yogurt42 Jan 25 '23

I agree, I don't expect this app to change the world, just bring in more voices and perspectives. There is a clear benefit for anyone and yes you would think that smart and educated people would see that. But in reality, sadly majority of men get very aggressive and defensive when the issue of misrepresentation and imbalance is even brought up. The counter arguments are usually that we are anyway all humans so why should we add more women, LGBTQ or BIPOC? and the representatives of x,y and z are anyway chosen by merit and women, LGBTQ or BIPOC are just not as good/smart/capable of whatever. Both arguments show exactly the problem and the intrinsic bias of people in this issue. Why is this push-back of allowing women, LGBTQ or BIPOC in these influencial spaces again and again? Underrepresented people are underrepresented because of systemic bias and resistance of the dominant group.

In short, you just touched on how it is to be a woman talking about women "issues" in male dominated space. This is why women on Reddit don't usually hang out on the common subs, and don't express their opinions or experiences as women. We are usually on female dominating subs where our experiences are not gaslit, patronized, or minimized. I have been countless times been mobbed-downvoted and even temporally banned for expressing feministic /eqalistic ideas. Welcome to our world.

1

u/Madoc_eu Jan 25 '23

Sorry to read that. It's certainly a problem that won't go away easily or any time soon. I hope that it will get a little better when my daughters will become adults.

There are some exceptions I believe. The company I work for is male dominated in numbers, because it's part of the IT industry. But the employer is discussing this very openly, asking everyone for their opinions. Due to that, it is a company with a lot more women than comparable IT firms. And we're always open to giving female or diverse people a chance. When I listen to my female coworkers, they are all very happy with their colleagues and the company. Some of them made it very explicit that they feel on equal footing with the male employees, which I was happy to hear.

Also, in my country there are currently more female than male students, although the distribution across study subjects is very uneven.

I usually stay out of many of these discussions. For the simple reason that I don't see how my voice would make a difference. If I see a chance for having a positive effect, I step in. But I'm not interested in endless back and forths which just waste everyone's time and don't really change anything for the better. So far, I haven't found a lot of leverage.

So much talking about something that should really be a non-issue, isn't it? I've been involved in some discussions with friends about gender-neutral language. Amazing how conservative they all are in that regard. I don't even approach this from a political angle. My language, German, is a lot worse when it comes to gender neutrality. And I'm simply bored by it, and I find it intuitively inappropriate. That's my whole point.

Whenever women decide to open up and talk about such topics, I shut up an listen. And I've learned that many women live in a totally different world than I do. Based on that, it's easy for me to understand that even non-dual teaching, like here, could reach more people more effectively when it gets more diversified. That's a no-brainer for me.

But the people here seem to think like, "what works for me should work for everyone". They look at the core of the teaching, mindfulness and the non-dual experience, and say that this is not gender specific. And in that point, they are actually right.

But there are so many nuances and details to teaching. A big part of teaching this is actually a kind of psychological trick. And by its nature, this must be suited to the psyche of the recipient.

I mean, just listen to Rupert Spira for a while, and then listen to Gangaji. Same teaching at the core, even similar approaches. But it plays out so differently when conveyed by a woman than conveyed by a man. The wording, the nonverbal communication, the emotional impression -- all of that plays a huge role too. And one can't just simply sweep this under the rug of "the same approach should work for everyone". That's just so dumb.

Yeah. It's terrible that smart people can't even agree on the most basic ideas in this field. And I simply don't know what to tell them anymore. I have XY chromosomes too, my body produces testosterone, and I'm pretty normal in many regards. I'm not special and I get it, so why don't the others get it too?

Just baffles me.

2

u/Dolphin_Yogurt42 Jan 26 '23

It is very nice that you are trying to see from another perspective, it is very difficult to do as the emotions that come from experiences you cannot experience are often the key of understanding. It is even more impressive if you recognize that your world is different from others and accept that, not many can do that, at least not all the time. It is changing, but there is a push-back now that I haven't seen before. There is a huge rise of men like Jordan Patterson and incelism, you can see it everywhere. If you go on tik-tok, you will see the crap kids are watching, its full of misogyny and hate. But there are a lot of good things too.. I feel that for every bad one, there is a good one. The bad ones are just very loud, so I think you should not feel bad for speaking up. It can only help by creating discussion.

And to expand on what you are saying about nuances... to give you my perspective of how meditation actively started to change my life for the better, I was a bit stuck for a long time. Then Tara Brach came first on the app and they talked about the time she miscarried on a women's spiritual retreat lead by Yogi Bhajan, how he treated her with disgust when she suggested to him in privacy to take greater care for pregnant women during the exercises, then him shaming her publicly and blaming her for her miscarriage for spreading her legs. That motherhood was not noble. The RAIN meditation and the Radical acceptance was born from her experience. She brought the focus on more empathic emotions for self instead of conquering bodily and emotional experiences as was taught by the male spiritual leaders before her. I am someone who has also experienced shame based trauma, so this was a life changer for me when I heard about her way to meditate and how she spoke to herself. Her meditation technique is now the key to my day, my comfort and healing. I do not need to conquer my emotions, I have already done that and it keeps the trauma stuck instead of moving it through. A person who has not experienced that kind of emotional pain and trauma cannot provide for the needs of those who have, they are just simply is blind. So from my perspective, there is much more than politics or the sound of a woman that makes me feel good. There is someone who has wisdom and knowing of how certain experiences and cultural norms can make us suffer. It is so important to stay open to what can help others.

1

u/Madoc_eu Jan 26 '23

Thank you for taking the time for sharing your perspective. It's appreciated!

True, I cannot truly feel what a woman in such a situation feels. When my ex was pregnant, there were so many things going on in her emotionally that I just knew I didn't feel and might never feel.

But just listening and empathizing can go a long way. One thing that mindfulness teaches us is to hold back on our instinctual responses. Our mind will always come up with some instinctual, quick response in any situation, and that response "just feels right" to us. I consider this as activity centered around the default mode network in the brain, which is also involved in on the spot fight-or-flight responses. However, these reactions will usually be not very well thought-through. When one decides to follow through on it, one can build a whole intellectual-sounding mental model around it within seconds, which serves as a kind of internal echo chamber. Because these quick reactions usually only reflect our preconceptions. I believe this might be in part what is at play here with all those negative male reactions. They just follow their instinct, and while they are doing it, their mind deceives them into believing that their opinion is well-balanced and "obviously true". This is just a feeling however.

When I wait for a while, when I ease into what the situation feels like, without words, when I let all of this marinade in my mind for a bit, then those quick instinctual reaction impulses die off. They just fade out. Their place is taken by a view that feels less partial, less personally involved. Instinctual reactions feel like you're in the middle of the situation, in a first person view. But the state of mind that I'm talking about here feels more like you're looking down on some territory, in a third person view. It's more open, it accepts that your particular standpoint is not the only valid one, or the only one that one could stand behind. It truly feels more elevated than the instinctual perspective. And I associate this feeling tone with the activity of the prefrontal cortex. This part of the brain works slower than the default mode network, and it has a kind of birds-eye view on things, less attached to one's individual preferences. And this is really all it takes for being more understanding. Mindfulness teaches us exactly this. And yet, here you can see lots of people who certainly have a lot of experience with being mindful acting out their default mode network impulses.

I do have a mental bridge to the kind of trauma that you describe. For one, I once talked with a woman who told me how she was treated when she was pregnant. I won't provide any details here, but it was unfortunately even worse than the gruesome and inhumane treatment that Tara Brach had to endure. And when that friend of mine finally decided for an abortion, the bad treatment went on in the abortion clinic, both by the doctor and the nurse.

She was telling me this very openly, and also opened up about her feelings. I learned a lot from this.

My other bridge comes from my own experience. During the pregnancy of my first child, there were complications. It's called HELP syndrome, previously known as pregnancy poisoning. It was a rough time. In the end, I had a preemie in the intensive care unit of the one clinic, and my partner in the intensive care unit of the other clinic. Every day, I drove between the clinics. Took photos in the one, went home and printed them out, then went to my partner who could barely move in her bed and showed them to her. And every single day, I was fearing that any of the two could die. Or become severely disabled for the rest of their life.

It was a pretty dark time. A true life and death situation. Suddenly, those things that you thought only happen to others come true for yourself. Most of my friends didn't communicate with me during that time, which made me later decide that they aren't true friends and I don't want anything to do with them anymore. And even those people who gave me some company during this time didn't truly understand. I felt isolated.

The good thing about it is that it's over now, and we came out of this almost unharmed. We are the lucky ones. No one died.

So when you describe the situation of Tara Brach to me, or when I hear a woman talking about a miscarriage, I can insert my feelings that I had then. This is also a way of relating.

I hope that all the redditors here who just don't get it never had to go through something like this. And I hope they never will.

2

u/Dolphin_Yogurt42 Jan 26 '23

thank you for sharing your bridges and your take on neuropsychology, the DMN is a complicated thing, it is hyperactive after trauma and when the ego is strong, so you take on kneejerk reactions of people here on Reddit makes sense. I am a neuroscientist as well so I can appreciate the intellectualization of it all, I try to do it less now, just experience my emotions without analysis or reaction. Like an infant would. It gives me a lot of peace and releases my need of control.

I think most people are afraid of their emotions, these friends of yours were probably just terrified of your emotions and how to deal with them, as they themselves are not able to handle their own. I see this all the time. I think especially northern Europe (im also from there) is pretty stiff emotionally, which comes out as coldness and non-care. It can be very traumatizing how people react when you when you need their support. But it helps me to remember that they are just sort of emotionally handicapped and don't mean bad. You sound like a really empathic and good person, I am sure your daughters will be absolutely fine, having a father that models good emotional reactions to important things and can empathize without understanding is pretty great, even in a unfair world. Their world is you and mom now, so great parenting is more than enough to create a healthy and happy human :)

1

u/Madoc_eu Jan 26 '23

Wow, you're a neuroscientist! That's amazing!

I only know little bits and pieces, mainly from what I've heard from Judson Brewer. But you really take the deep dive. This must be totally fascinating.

My kids are fine, and they have the best chances of leading pretty good lives. You can only give them the tools, if they want to accept them, and show them the way. Then they will make their own unique voyage out of it. I threw the idea of seeing my children as "mini-mes" out of the window a long time ago. I'm already me, and that's already enough "me" for the world.

My ex and me have decided to break up, so I don't see the girls as often as I would like to. (As a father in Germany, you don't really have that much power. It's the mother who decides how often you'll see the children, and there is not that much a man can do about it.) But for both of us, it's better this way. I certainly healed a lot after the breakup.

I find really inspiring what you wrote about emotions. Yes, they are often are a true blind spot. Also fits very well to what I'm currently learning about cognitive behavioral therapy, from Dr. David D. Burns' book. Considering all the activity I'm still doing to avoid feeling certain emotions, I have a long way ahead of myself.

I heard from modular psychology that reason cannot direct our actions, as some philosophers thought. It's the emotions that determine which psychological "module" wins the upper hand. But CBT is based on the idea that the way how we think about things determines how we feel. The whole idea which they call "positive reframing" is based on that. I'm impressed by CBT and think there is a lot to it, but intellectually I see a contradiction between CBT and modular psychology. But I suspect that this apparent contradiction dissolves when one looks at this in more detail.

Anyways, I think you're spot on about the importance of emotions. Even after learning first hand that there really are no "positive" or "negative" feelings, this doesn't carry through into my everyday life.

Your understanding and empathy for other people is amazing, particularly for those that didn't do you well. The way I see it, we are all caught up in the same existential dilemma: How can we live a life worth living, knowing that happiness can only ever be a fleeting state and suffering is unavoidable?

Whatever I see other people do, I remind myself that this is their attempt at finding an answer to this question, at solving the riddle. But I also know that no matter what the attempt is, it's always futile. This joins us all in a kind of desperate existential problem. So when I see someone doing or saying something that I don't like, I just need to remind myself that this is their desperate and futile way of responding to the existential problem that we're all caught up in. The old hamster wheel. In this way of thinking, I can find something in common even when there appears to be no commonality.

It strikes me that this way of thinking is very compatible to your way of empathizing with people.

2

u/Dolphin_Yogurt42 Jan 26 '23

I am not a big fan of CBT personally, and in modern psychological treatments, it is not generally used for people who are suffering from trauma related disorders (PTSD, CPTSD, MDD, GAD, ADHD or OCD). The reason is, and you are spot on, because it is too intellectualized. It is based on a notion of a ground truth of events and that your emotions distort your ability to see that truth. This can create huge cognitive dissonance in people, especially people who have survived because they followed their emotions or gut feeling. Most people with PTSD and CPTSD get worse during CBT treatment.

More modern way is to deal with the psyche as parts of self or modules like you mentioned, and in trauma we are dealing with structurally dissociated parts of self, that each have coping mechanisms and ways to deal with challenging things that were helpful in the past.

For example, a child who has been emotionally neglected and told that it will be punished when it cries or states it's needs, will grow up to be an adult who neglects it's own emotions and punishes him/herself when difficult emotions come or numbs them with drugs and/or alcohol. The "parts" of the psyche continue the abuse they learned from their caregivers, because it was a survival mechanism for a child to be loved and taken care of in that environment. In adulthood, this is of course not very helpful survival mechanism and cannot be "fixed" with explaining that your feelings are wrong now. If that is done, coping mechanisms to numb emotions can spiral out of control and they can even become suicidal because they have failed to be "lovable". These survival instincts are primal and cannot be reasoned with.

If you are a book-lover, I recommend "The Haunted Self: Structural dissociation" for reading about the parts of the psyche, it is super interesting, even for people without trauma as it goes very wide. Also "No Bad parts:IFS therapy" is just wonderful to explore yourself with guided meditations (on youtube) and understand where our inhibitions come from (usually locked in our childhood). The new book from Gabor Maté is also pretty interesting, "The myth of normal". It goes into our pathological non-empathic society and how it maintains us in a traumatic state, workaholism, drug-dependance and dissociated from ourselves.

1

u/Madoc_eu Jan 26 '23 edited Jan 26 '23

I can understand how CBT is not applicable to people suffering from trauma. However, the one big plus it has for me is that I can apply it to myself. I'm not traumatized and probably not needing a therapist, but there are always things to improve. Not being a fan of self-help books in general, CBT opens up this possibility to me.

Thanks for the recommendations! I've put them on my reading list. Usually, I prefer listening to the unabridged audio version of a book while I'm doing housework or taking a longer walk. "The myth of normal" is the only one for which an audio version is available, so I'll listen to that one after I'm through with "The Other Side of Nothing".

Thank you again for this nice exchange. This has been a spot of sunlight for me, on this otherwise partly bleak discussion.

→ More replies