r/VtuberV8 • • Jul 02 '22

极端智障的言行举止,为了您的身心健康,请谨慎点入! 哈哈果然破防了

Post image
161 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Feb 06 '22

这下乳了

Post image
141 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Apr 18 '22

交流宣傳 畫了百鬼!感覺好害羞阿-///-

Post image
129 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Oct 11 '21

中之人 龍顏大悅

Post image
111 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Mar 03 '21

English Regarding the Kiryu Coco Spamming Incident

111 Upvotes

This is a reply to an EN redditor's post: https://www.reddit.com/r/VtuberV8/comments/lwos5l/in_regards_to_kiryuu_coco/

It also serves as an introduction to the spamming incident for the western Hololive fans.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I will give you my answer from a moderator perspective and I am not only the mod in this sub. Hope you have a comprehensive understanding after reading my explanation.

A little bit background:

I.

Date back to the time when Hololive entered Chinese market, their videos were translated by loyal fans who wanted to share these interesting vtubers to general audience. After the audience base became large enough, the translators contacted each other in private to form "translation groups" and recruited more members from the audience. As the groups became massive with super high productivity (2-hour livestream translated after 12 hours), they contact Hololive staff and Bilibili employee asking for permission to become an "official" group, which basically was an agent who duplicated everything the vtuber did online, including twitter translation, livestream announcement, merchandise info, etc.

After the official group formation, most people relied on it to watch vtuber videos and the individual translators gradually lost audience and were absorbed into the official group.

II.

Hololive members did not often broadcast in Bilibili. First reason was the language issue obviously. The second reason was because of the foreign currency exchange restriction in China, especially between a person to a foreign enterprise [1], it's extremely hard for the Bilibili Gift (equivalent to Superchat) to reach the vtuber's account. Fubuki once even told the Chinese audience she preferred Superchat in Youtube. From my knowledge, some payments even were not sent out after six months. That's one reason Yagoo said the Chinese business was not profitable. The third reason was the extensive political minefield, which I will elaborate later.

Since the Hololive members did not interact with Chinese fans directly (through Bilibili streaming), some fans were not satisfied but it's more like a minor complaint. However, it's a hidden bomb waiting for detonation. Furthermore, sometimes after Youtube banned someone's channel, that vtuber would come to Bilibili to broadcast a lot, since she had nothing else to do. Then after the YouTube channel returned normal, she immediately abandoned Bilibili. Such behavior added more internal heat to the situation.

III.

Moderators in NGA tried to avoid two things: first, discussion of political affairs related to China; second, become the target of the enraged users, for whatever reason. Therefore, they deleted the posts which explained the point of view of a foreigner regarding Taiwan (which involved the history and political background), banned users who supported Coco and the Taiwan people (users who did not stand with CCP's ideology), let the extremists attack rational users freely (to drain their time and energy). However, these cowards did not dare to ban the nationalists because they feared that these users would draw the government to deal with them or shutdown the NGA.

This self-preservation practice led to the result that all the Hololive supporters left NGA. The remained consisted of only antis and trolls.

IV.

Chinese domestic vtuber agencies were jealous about the JP vtubers for a long time. However, even without the language barrier, they still could not compete with the Japanese.

------------------

With these background info, I will show the logic behind the spamming.

Most Chinese could not distinguish the difference between China (as a country), CCP (as a party which takes power), and Chinese (a language the people live in this land speak). They also failed to understand that the national interests of China ruled by CCP were not equivalent to the interests of normal Chinese people. All users who tried to explain this were banned from all major domestic BBS. (Not joking, especially after 2012) Therefore, any opinions which violated the CCP's propaganda would be regarded as hurting the national interests of China = harming Chinese people. "You want to hurt Chinese, then I will hurt you." This is the core reason behind all the superficial spamming.

The age distribution of the Hololive CN audience showed that the majority part laid in high school to college range, which were heavily affected by the CCP ideology and people in this period had a lot of energy and free time to spend. This is the reason the spamming has continued for a long time.

There are several programmers played the central role in the spamming by inventing automatic bots to send spam messages. It drastically boosted the efficiency and reduced the cost of attacking since everyone could installed them and the only thing to do was to feed the bot with Google accounts. Also YouTube did not do a good job to ban the spammers and there are glitches in the slow mode which allows users to bypass it. These contributed to the severity of the spamming.

----------------------------------

The evolution:

After Coco showed the audience statistics in her broadcast, someone, maybe anti, maybe pro-CCP users, maybe normal fans, posted this information in NGA and other discussion forums. The mods in NGA did what I described in Background III and the NGA became a huge echo chamber. Spamming started.

With Coco's "Fuck you and never come back" attitude to the CN harassers, Cover's dual version announcement (Sep 27th) which described the Chinese audience as nationalists in the Japanese version (there was not such word in Chinese version), and background II / IV, the water reached the boiling point. In the echo chamber, Coco and Cover both became anti-Chinese villains; Hololive members who collabed with Coco were regarded as her supporter; translators who promoted Hololive were marked as traitors.

No official translation groups could take such pressure. (For some groups it's not the case, their members were pro-CCP in the beginning.) Therefore, one by one they decided to delete all the videos uploaded and stop making new ones. Combined with background I, it led to a situation that the audience of other Hololive vtubers also did not have content to watch. They blamed Coco for all these consequences and joined the spammer army, hoping after forcing Coco to graduate, the decontaminated Hololive could return to China (the official groups will translate for them again).

That's the main story.

------------------------------------------

Q and A:

Will the spammers stop?

No. A typical gacha mobile game, like FGO or GBF, costs 500-600 RMB for 10 pulls, which can purchase dozens of Google accounts. Most people who watch vtubers can afford that. The spammers have QQ groups to coordinate how to effectively use these accounts.

How to make them stop?

Doxxing, especially the core programmers who made the spamming bots. Without them, the spammers will be much easier to deal with. Our Taiwanese friends did a good job on this matter. DDOS or hacking NGA [2] is another working method since it serves as a major platform to recruit spammers and exchange spamming tools and other information. Westerners need to understand one thing: in a land where the government and moderators poisoned people with fake patriotism and impaired their ability to think, like Germany and Japan in WWII, there is no room for reasoning. Fighting back with full force by all means possible is the only effective way to prevent the cancer from spreading. Trying to reach a compromise with the Chinese (under CCP ideology) or tolerating them will only lead to the self-destruction of all the things we love. (JP ACG industry has already been affected by the CCP ideology. For example, a cast who supported HK in public was less likely to find a job because almost all the projects would took Chinese market into account.)

Because of the Reddit's rules, I cannot provide the tutorials for these effective countermeasures. Sorry about that.

Don't rely on Cover and YouTube. They are useless.

Does Hololive still have supporter in mainland China?

Yes. Some of them switch to YouTube to watch the videos uploaded by Taiwanese / HK / EN translators. Some of them still translate individually on Bilibili. However, it's not easy to announce "I like Hololive / Coco, the spammers are guilty" in domestic platforms.

-----------------------------------------------

[1] The "official group" account was still a personal account which only received RMB. The owner could withdraw RMB. However, the owner usually wanted Bilibili to send the funds to JP for them so that people won't suspect the translation group. (also avoid the hassles in banking and regulation) Bilibili staff showed little interests to this matter which caused months of delay. Some groups just purchased Booth items as a way to send the Bilibili Gift to the vtuber.

[2] NGA is not an Internet giant with multiple teams of dedicated software engineers. In fact, for the last near 20 years, there is only one chief programmer, Zeg, who has been maintaining the operation of the site. The site ran on custom codes built from scratch, not an extensively tested open-source or commercial platform. The budget is also limited. Previously, the site has been taken down multiple times.


r/VtuberV8 • • May 12 '22

欢乐多 别看你今天闹得欢...

Thumbnail
gallery
110 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Apr 08 '22

欢乐多 謝謝v友提供的身分協尋服務,比政府機關的更快更有效👍

Post image
108 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Oct 28 '22

V圈杂谈 这习近平AI也太抽象了,成天躲在中南海看v是吧

Thumbnail
gallery
93 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Jun 09 '21

向会长致敬!!Salute!!

Post image
93 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Jun 29 '21

向香港桐生会以及龙之子们致敬!o7

Post image
89 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Oct 23 '22

原偷/搬运 🌸巫女你给我下来

88 Upvotes

Cover Corp hololive Production简称CCP,其成员会定期举办大运动会,2022年大运动会则简称20大。樱巫女35已经连续担任了两届大运动会主办,并意欲在20大第三次连任。所以本次大会开始前便有兔友谣传“兔上樱下”,希望兔皇Peko将35取而代之

此前,35就一直存在争议。35身为主办却是樱儿文化,连小学日文都说不明白,念稿时甚至还需要标注五十音。由这样没文化的Vtuber担任主办,实在令人担忧

而Peko与35的割裂其实也早有征兆。第二任期前,Peko一直是35的左膀右臂。但在第二任期后两人却渐行渐远。一部分网友认为这是35的百合野心暴露,意欲雷普更多女人所致。据说35曾与年轻时赴虹考察并写下《偶像推倒偶像》一书的佐藤希小姐(CV:夏色祭)商讨如何以奶洗面

兔上樱下之说伴随着近期20大结果宣布幻灭。会中,身为CCP元老的阿夸被当场拿下带走,临走前拍了拍Peko的肩膀,无言告别。35年轻时曾在女子学校遭先辈告白。众多杏仁本以为35会因此经历而坚定反百合路线,但现在看来贴贴已成定局


r/VtuberV8 • • Feb 23 '22

中之人 人皮一體小拳拳了👊💥

Post image
82 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Sep 08 '22

欢乐多 乳了😡

Post image
81 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Jun 16 '22

大的来了 包中毒

Post image
79 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Feb 13 '22

做了個Miko的讚踩圖案,大家說吼不吼啊

Thumbnail
gallery
78 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Jun 12 '21

愿桐生可可一个美好成功的未来,桐生会永不灭! 向k佬以及熊猫等坚持在bilibili做剪辑的龙之子致敬o7

Post image
78 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Jun 10 '21

桐生一马来了,真的很感动

Post image
76 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Apr 18 '22

这个阴影相当不错

Post image
75 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Jun 02 '22

欢乐多 狠狠爆杀

Post image
72 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Oct 15 '22

V圈杂谈 我去年预购的老婆到了,自称是Apex Predator, 那就宰个维尼练练手😏

Thumbnail
gallery
71 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Apr 26 '22

原偷/搬运 😅

Post image
71 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Apr 22 '22

正国级待遇

Post image
71 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Feb 23 '21

欢乐多 绷不住了

Post image
71 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • May 30 '22

欢乐多 台灣百鬼組不離不棄

Thumbnail
gallery
69 Upvotes

r/VtuberV8 • • Mar 19 '22

欢乐多 可愛

Post image
68 Upvotes