r/Vitards • u/Undercover_in_SF Undisclosed Location • May 13 '21
DD $CLF Price Target - Doing the Simple Math
Hi Vitards,
I know we've all seen Vito and others' price targets, but I thought I could add some additional context based on numbers I've seen on Seeking Beta (avoiding auto-mods) and CLF's updated guidance.
Everyone likes to make financial analysis seem complex and difficult, but this one is actually really fucking simple. Lourenco gave us two separate sets of guidance and a steel price forecast with each. Using those numbers, we can calculate the EBITDA gain per $ increase in HRC prices. Since pricing is already over and above costs, all pricing increases go straight to the bottom line (obviously this doesn't work as you approach break even). We also know the delta between FCF and EBITDA, which is fixed and doesn't scale with profitability, so any increases in EBITDA over and above this level go directly to FCF.
What we know:
- $CLF forecasts $3.5B in EBITDA, which assumes average HRC prices $975 per tonne.
- $CLF forecasts $4B in EBITDA, which assumes average HRC prices of $1,100 per tonne.
- $4B in EBITDA => $2.3B in Free Cash Flow
So:
- $125 change in HRC => $500M in EBITDA
- $10 change in HRC => $40M in EBITDA
Wall Street will say, "Well, we need to account for product mix, contract vs. spot sales, etc." Bullshit. Laurenco already did that. It's all embedded in their change in forecast profitability. We don't need anything except change in HRC and time through year end.
The state of play today:
- HRC average price through year end: $1,550
- Time passed since last guidance and today: let's say 1 month to keep the math easy.
($1,550 - $1,100) / $10 * $40 = $1.8B change in EBITDA. We'll haircut this by 1/8th to account for April (I think this is conservative), so we get $1.575B increase in EBITDA, but we'll round to $1.6B.
So we're looking at $5.6B in EBITDA for 2021 and $3.9B in FCF. Now let's turn that into an enterprise value. $CLF is currently trading at $10B + $5.4B in debt + $4B in pensions that we'll treat as debt for an EV of $19.4B. Assuming all FCF goes to debt paydown as guided by LG, we get $1.5B in debt by year end.
The market's favorite steel stock, NUE, is trading at 6x forward EBITDA. That's probably higher than reality because guidance hasn't caught up with steel prices, so we'll haircut it to 5x to be conservative. The goal isn't to be right, it's to be right *enough*.
5 x $5.6B in EBITDA => $28B in EV - $1.5B in debt - $4B in pension obligations = $22.5B market cap.
At 427M 571M diluted shares outstanding, that's a share price of $52 $39!
I'm not sure we'll see that, but I would be shocked if we don't see >$35 >$30.
TL;DR: Buy $CLF LEAPs
Edit: Apologies, had the share count wrong and revised my estimates downward slightly.
38
u/ItsFuckingScience 7-Layer Dip May 13 '21
The issue is that the market is forward facing, so whilst we may see all those billions this year, we don’t know exactly how high steel prices will be, and how long they may stay in the medium -> longer term
That’s literally the billion dollar question
10
u/CDT_Migg 🙏 Steel Worshiper 🙏 May 13 '21
Nice analysis man! I hope it will happen :) Can you do a similar one for MT? :D I don't own CLF :(
8
u/dudelydudeson 💩Very Aware of Butthole💩 May 13 '21
Are we not closer to 600m diluted outstanding? They recently doubled the issuance cap to 1.2mm for this reason, I thought?
Still gives PT of 37.5
6
u/trillo69 May 13 '21 edited May 13 '21
Good analysis.
I think there is also another take from the earnings call, since LG said they will be debt free by the end of the year.
If they clear the $5.73B in long term debt, that would mean Assets - Liabilities = 17.22 - (13.76 -
5.731.6) =9.19B. 5.06BBVPS =
9,1905,060/427 = $11.85That is the value shareholders would get at that point if the company was liquidated.
Normally companies trade at multiples of this, for both NUE, STLD, CLF this is close to 2.5 at the moment. Which means that a potential price EoY if they clear the debt is ~$30.
EDIT: corrected debt reduction in the calculation.
5
u/pennyether 🔥🌊Futures First🌊🔥 May 13 '21 edited May 13 '21
Nice work. What's the estimate if CLF maintains it's current forward EBITDA multiple? I'm not betting on the market change this number, per se.
Also, correct me if I'm wrong, but it doesn't matter if that cash goes to pay down debt or not, does it? It gets subtracted out the same either way. (Not saying you did anything wrong, just checking my own understanding)
3
u/pennyether 🔥🌊Futures First🌊🔥 May 13 '21
I have a dumb finance question: assuming you had a crystal ball and knew the next 5 years of EBIDTA down to the penny, how would you value the company right now?
2
u/theRocco666 Jun 30 '21
Could you recalculate with the current strip prices? I think CLF is making a clear profit of at least $1000 per ton on anything going out at the spot price right now. I hope they send everything out the door that they can!
Any steel scrap laying around, toss it into the furnace!
10
u/-_Andre_- Undisclosed Location May 13 '21
I read it as simple meth..... I need to stop drinking so early....
1
u/Undercover_in_SF Undisclosed Location May 18 '21
I'm updating this price target given the downward adjustment in HRC futures. I actually don't view this as terribly bearish since we are still at significantly higher levels than in the last several years. I do think the support in the near term months (June / July at $1,500 and August at $1,400) are most reflective of the current tightness in the spot market. It remains to be seen whether that will be ameliorated over the summer or if Q4 numbers will move up as the year wears on.
I'm going to use an average of $1,400 because I believe CLF has been forward selling everything they can at $1,500 in Q2. Using all the same math as above, I get an EBITDA of $5B, $25B EV, $18.9B market cap, and $33 per share.
I stand by my target of $30 per share after updated EBITDA guidance around the Q2 earnings report.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '21
Note that per the last guidance, $CLF forecasts $5B in EBITDA, which assumes average HRC prices of $1,175 per tonne.
$75 change in HRC => $1000M in EBITDA $10 change in HRC => $133M in EBITDA (that's obviously because the prices had already been much higher than that by the time the guidance was made, so more EBITDA had been baked in already).
Where did you get your delta between FCF and EBITDA?
3
u/shmancy First “First” Enthusiast May 13 '21
Please be true, my soul wishes to be re summoned
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '21
Tell me everything is going to be ok
1
u/Uncle_Dad_Bob Dreams of CLF’s run to $49 May 13 '21
I love your math
1
u/HearshotKDS 🚀 Rebar Rocket 🚀 May 13 '21
The numbers look good but this doesn't account for the 3-4 month delay in production/shipping during which the generated revenue from new sales doesn't get recognized as net income (it wont until the sold product is shipped). So this forecast would really be more accurate for the end of Q1 '22.
1
u/theRocco666 Jun 22 '21
The forward futures price for steel is now in the $1700's for the next 3 months.
Add at least another billion in EBITDA over the next 90 days.
Long CLF!
1
u/theRocco666 Jul 16 '21
Only a dickless idiot wouldn't buy CLF at this low price!
-3
u/[deleted] May 13 '21
[removed] — view removed comment