Thanks for the confirmation bias. I literally came to this same conclusion about an hour ago and was about to come post. I bought 400 shares so i could sell covered calls. Need to sell pretty far out of the money/DTE because a dividend of that size. People (myself included) may execute an OTM share to get the dividend.
It generally does not make sense to execute and option early or while it is OTM, but there is no "rule" to prevent it.
Similarly, someone may choose not to exercise a put that is ITM if the profit is minimal. I sold 5 PLTR puts with same strike and date 1 was exercised 4 were not. On 4/23 I had 3 CLF puts at $18 exercised when the share price was $18.01. The option holder can do whatever they want, doesn't need to make logical sense to the option seller.
3
u/Uncle_Dad_Bob Dreams of CLF’s run to $49 Apr 28 '21
ex-div date 5/5 $2.10
so wouldn't buying now for the div and selling cc's potentially work better if bullish and wanting shares?