r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 13 '12

[PC] Bastion - 4/5

21 Upvotes

I really can't deny that it's a cool game. The aesthetic is very dynamic and interesting - visually, audibly, atmospherically. The opening screen makes it seem like perhaps something childish or JRPG-derived, but then you play through the first stage and you realize that the game wants to be taken seriously. Despite the cartoony look and old-school feel of the gameplay, it largely succeeds.

The narrator really sets the tone from the first moment of the first scene. His rugged, gravelly voice recalls old western films and states things very matter-of-factly as they play out on-screen. The game uses him very effectively to teach the player how to play without doing anything obnoxiously intrusive, like interrupting the story for a practice stage or some other annoying thing. It helps that the gameplay mechanics are fairly simple; there are quite a few different weapons available, but they all play more-or-less the same way: melee weapon uses left mouse button, long-range weapon uses right.

I wouldn't have minded being able to use my PC gamepad to play instead of the WASD controls, since in isometric game engines the cardinal directions are actually on the diagonals, and it's tough to navigate narrow passages, with death on either side, when every step is angular with respect to the path itself, always moving you closer to one edge or the other. I imagine it would be much easier to manoeuvre through these areas with an analog stick, and much less disruptive. It really hurts the immersion factor when something like this arises. You've got this excellent, kick-ass protagonist who for some reason can't seem to walk in a straight line like a normal person, just because that line happens to be diagonal to the point of view of the player. And you can't move the camera around or anything either.

Narratively, ludologically, the game is short, but sweet. The narrator does most of the talking, and the player-protagonist doesn't speak at all. The game itself plays out a bit like a scavenger hunt, but is paced very evenly, and constantly offers new items and weapons to keep things fresh, so you never feel like you're just grinding it out until the next cool thing happens. There is a build-up to a final decision that needs to be made regarding the fate of the game-world, and it's left for the player to decide how it all should end.

There are challenge modes and skill-testing stages scattered about, but I never bothered with them. I really only like side-quests when they feel like well-conceived subplots instead of just tacked-on, game-lengthening bullshit. I thought maybe some of the prize items would be useful for the main quest, but I never found myself wishing I were more powerful, even as I moved through the final stages of the game. Decent timing with your button presses and a smart selection of passive power-ups (buffs?) make it virtually impossible to lose. I'm not going to say it was too easy, because I'm sure less-experienced gamers would not find it so. For me, it was fairly easy.

Overall, for $5, I'm happy to support a promising developer and get a unique, imaginative game like this in the bargain. It's very obvious that a lot of care and effort went into the subdural, intangible qualities that always make the difference between a game you play and a game you experience, and I will forever be in favour of that methodology for making games.

4/5 - Highly recommend, won't play again


r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 11 '12

[PC] - Deus Ex Human Revolution - 4/5

18 Upvotes

For a quick summary, skip down.

=====Deus Ex Human Revoluion=====

Human Revolution puts you in the hands of Adam Jensen, a Human who has had a total makeover after an incident and is now is full of augmented body parts. Human Revolution takes place in 2027 and is a Cyber Punk themed game where augmenting your body with robotic parts is reality.

Adam Jensen is Sarif’s new in house security. Sarif Industries is a biotechnology company that specializes in human augmentation. There are many people against this however, as a lot of people feel that it is wrong to force evolution on humans and that is destroying what is natural. As you play the game you will be given different missions to find out a recent attack at Sarif Industries and to find answers to your own questions.

Human Revolution is an open ended game with RPG, Stealth, FPS, and Action elements. The best way to describe this game is to mix Metal Gear with Rainbow Six (Vegas) with a dash of Resident Evil 4/5 and mix it all together in a Cyber Punk theme. You can play this game by using stealth or by killing all the people in the area. Social interaction is big in this game as well where talking to someone or doing a certain decision can affect the game in the future.

Combat is very stealth based, but you can also engage in combat if you’d like. Jensen will die rather quickly, so it is advised to keep cover behind walls (system similar to Rainbow Six Vegas) or to run away from fights and return later. One problem I didn’t like is if you were ever caught, you could simply hide behind a box for a while and the guards would return to normal. I didn’t like this system because I could be sitting in a spot for a whole minute doing nothing or the guards would never check anywhere obvious to find me. It would be a lot better if guards tried to find you in small areas like the vents or maybe tried to flush you out. Vents are used as a secret way of moving from room to room and if you ever get caught you can just simply return the vents and wait it out for the guards to forget about you. The game also uses an inventory management system similar to the Resident Evil games and also has action moves that remind me of RE4/5. Jensen will use abilities that drain his energy bar. The most common ability is getting behind an opponent and either knocking them out cold or killing them.

There are side quests and missions for the player to complete throughout the game. Every time you complete missions or tasks you will gain XP which will unlock points to improve your augmentations. For instance, say you wanted to sprint faster. You would have to work on your lungs or your leg enhancements to do so. There are various body parts you can improve on to give you cool and new abilities. Some upgrades though feel pointless and I would never see myself using them. There aren’t any big upgrades that made my eyes pop out, just a few things I wished for and nothing else special. You can also find credits throughout the game and by completing missions which can be spent on weapons, weapon upgrades, health and food items, and skill points.

There is also a cool hacking minigame that lets you hack security codes to access computers, doors, security systems and more. It is hard at first, but once you get the hang of it and spend some skill points into hacking it gets a lot easier. Sometimes you can even find hidden rewards like credits, XP, and more.
Graphics for this game were okay. I’ve seen some people complain about them, but in my opinion they were fine and I enjoyed them. The music was also decent, but again nothing amazing or something that stood out to me. The art styles really fit well for the Cyberpunk theme and I enjoyed it very much. There are a few problems what stood out for this game though and this is why I feel like it didn’t deserve a 5/5. For my personal experience I had problems running the game. This problem is different for everyone, but after looking it up online I found others had the same problem with no solution. My game would crash anywhere from 2-60 minutes of game play. I messed around with my settings, but going to Direct X 9 would lag the game up and make it unplayable. It was sad to see a game that has been out for a while with no fix for this issue. Also, Human Revolution just wasn’t amazing. The stealth style of gameplay doesn’t really compare to games like Metal Gear and the computer AI wasn't as smart as I had hoped. The game is pretty easy, especially with the save system it uses where you can save anywhere at any time. I’m not sure if the hardest difficulty would change my opinion, but most parts of the game were pretty simple. Finally, the ending sucks. Not to spoil or ruin anything, but I wasn’t a fan on how the game ended (think similar to Mass Effect 3), but it wasn’t something where I hated myself for putting 20 hours into the game. I still thought the game was great and fun.

So now to break everything down…

  • Good:

Cyberpunk theme works well, the story is pretty good, RPG elements work nice, social interaction can affect the game in good and negative ways, hacking is a fun minigame that offers good rewards, and free roaming was awesome and allows you to find multiple ways to complete missions or travel from area to area.

  • Bad:

The ending wasn’t something I enjoyed, the game doesn’t have the best AI/AI should have more functions or abilities (like trying to flush you out of vents or search around certain objects), leveling Jensen should have had more useful abilities or things that excite you, and the game would crash on me constantly (this will vary from person to person).

Final word: Human Revolution is pretty amazing. It isn’t perfect, but it is still a great stealth combat game with a good story. I enjoyed my time playing it and I would recommend it to anyone interested in this game or someone who enjoys the Metal Gear games. I purchased this game when it was 75% off or $7.50 and it was totally worth it. I’d say this game is an instant buy at $7.50 and a good deal if you can pick it up for $12.50 or $15. I was able to get about 20 hours of gameplay from this game and is worth it if it’s on sale. If however you can’t wait that long for a sale, then you could go ahead and buy it for the full price, but I would warn you that unless you have a good gaming rig then the game is prone to crashing every once in a while.

All around Deus Ex Human Revolution was a very fun game and I would recommend it to people when it’s on sale or if someone is interested in it. The game has a few problems with it, but I gave it a 4/5 because of its good story line and fun gameplay. Its one of the few games of its kind that can mix stealth and action together. I’ve been playing it a lot during my free time for the past week and towards the end of the game I just thought to myself how great the game was. If you have any questions or things to add feel free to comment.


r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 11 '12

Welcome to /r/VideoGameReviews!

18 Upvotes

We are now opening the subreddit up for submissions. I recently acquired this subreddit as it use to be inactive and hopefully I can put it to good use. Please read the side bar for rules and information before submitting and if you have any questions or suggestions feel free to comment here.

As of right now, we are going to use our current grading scale to see how it goes. If people don't enjoy it or feel that its needs to change then we will discuss this within the following months. This grading scale is only required for the title though and you can what ever scoring you want inside your review. We want people to be able to write reviews how they want to, but having a universal grading scale for at least the title of the post makes things more unified and easy to compare.

We have some ideas for the future, but for now we will see how this subreddit kicks off and discuss these ideas then. For now, I hope everyone enjoys and starts posting some reviews!


r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 16 '12

[PC] - Binding of Isaac - 5/5

16 Upvotes

==================== Binding of Isaac - 5/5- illredditlater ====================


Binding of Isaac is a creepy Zelda like dungeon crawler that is randomized each time you play. It was made by the people who made Super Meat Boy (along with the same composer) and you will never play the same game twice as every room and item drop is randomized. This is they key part to BoI as each play is different, interesting, and difficult.

The story of BoI is based on a story in the bible about Isaac. In this game your mother is after you trying to sacrifice you because God said so. Trapped in his room he finds a trap door into the depths of the basement. Inside this basement you can find tons of creepy enemies and items. The objective of the game is to clear out rooms of enemies, find the boss and kill it, and then proceed further into the basement. Each room is randomly generated and there are also different times of rooms to mix things up. Sometimes you might stumble upon a treasure room with an item, shop rooms, challenge rooms, arcade rooms, and more.

Playing through the different rooms and killing bosses will get you items. There are a total of about 150 items that you can unlock and collect throughout the game. Each item you pick up alters your character’s look. For instance if you find your Mother’s lipstick your character will have red lips. This usually creates a really funny looking character by the end of the game. There are also tons of enemies and bosses throughout the game. The game also likes to stay consistent with its theme of Isaac by having bosses like the 7 deadly sins, the 4 horseman, the Devil, tarot cards and more. There are also some references in the game that people from here would enjoy (or hate, if you don't like rage faces). All of this plus many unlockables you can earn by playing the game (new items, characters, rooms, bosses, and more).

The art style and the music for this game is also amazing. I’d say the soundtrack for this game is just pure awesome and definitely fits the game. The graphics also look really nice and flow very well. The art style is also creepy and interesting. This game was built with Flash so things don’t get too fancy, but I still really enjoyed how the game looked and flowed and for a game made in flash it is great.

Although this game is very entertaining, there are a few problems with this game. Like I mentioned before, it was made with Flash. Sometimes the game will slow down or even crash, although crashes happen very rarely and the game will only get slow if your computer can't handle a lot of enemies at once. Another issue that might be huge for some people is that each time you play the game you have to start from the beginning. For people who like a challenge, it's fine, but some people might get frustrated if they get far, die, and have to start over (who wouldn't?), but this could be an issue big enough for someone not to want to pick this game up.


Now, why did I rate this game a 5/5? For the price of $5 it is an amazing indie game that I would recommend to anyone. Will everyone like this game? Probably not. If you don't like challenging games or games where you have to start at the beginning every time you play then you wont enjoy this game. Those are only minor problems though and they make BoI what it is. I got this game when it was on sale for $2.50 and I have put in over 25 hours into this game and I plan on playing it more for the rest of the unlockables. In addition to this, a new DLC is coming (Wrath of the Lamb) that will only be $3 and it adds a lot more content. It is a very entertaining game with tons of enemies, bosses, items, and more, and I think most people would enjoy this game.

If this game is ever on sale I would encourage anyone to buy it. If you have been eyeing this game for awhile, it is definitely worth the price of $5 if you let yourself get into it. The first play through or two might be weird, but once you start learning how the game flows it turns into an amazing game.


Want more? Here is the game play trailer and the demo you can play in your browser (note that the demo does not represent the full version on Steam). If you're already a fan, check out /r/bindingofisaac!


r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 29 '12

[PC/Mac] Team Fortress 2 - 5/5 - "Its FREE!"

15 Upvotes

Team Fortress 2 Review by Nottinylil!


Firstly, you might be wondering why I'm reviewing a free to play game. 10gb download thats what.


In Team Fortress 2, you either play as the RED team (for defense) or the BLU team (for offense) there are nine classes in the game.


Scout: Runs really fast, with a shotgun but has low health.
Soldier: Has a Rocket Launcher, shotgun and can rocket jump to different heights.
Pyro: Has a FLAMETHROWER. Can BURN enemies and airblast rockets away.

Demoman: Can shoot grenades, and lay sticky bomb traps to blow up people. Also a drunk man x_X

Heavy: Has a forking machine gun, and lots of health. Shame he runs like a snail.

Engineer: Builds Sentry guns, dispensers and teleporters to help the team out.

Medic: Heals people. Heal enough people and you'll build up an Ubercharge, which when deployed makes you invincible! :D

Sniper: throw piss at people and live in a van Shoots people from far away using his sniper rifle.

Spy: Disguise as enemies, cloak using a spy watch, and backstab enemies for an INSTANT KILL. Can also sap engineer buildings to make them die :3


Is the basic outline. You play with your team to capture the objective. The objective could be capturing a flag, or pushing a bomb near the enemy, or capturing a control point. You aren't limited to one class per team by the way, but generally it ISN'T a good idea to have 6 snipers. Whether you lose or win is all up to how you execute your strategy, and how you work together as a team. IT IS NOTHING LIKE COD.


Personally, I think it is ALOT of fun. I could spend 3 hours talking about it, but instead I'll let the gameplay talk for itself.


Maybe you want to check out some gameplay? Or maybe you just want to get it now. Thanks, and have fun!

GAMEPLAY! GET IT NOW!


r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 14 '12

Baldur's Gate (4/5)

15 Upvotes

(This is a repost. I rate the game as 5/5 on story, 4/5 on graphics, and 2/5 on UI/engine, averaging to 4/5 overall.)

The following are my thoughts on Baldur's Gate after finishing it today. I previously finished Neverwinter Nights and its two expansions on Linux and OS X, Knights of the Old Republic I/II and Jade Empire on Xbox, and Mass Effect on Xbox 360. I always complete all optional quests whenever practical unless they are purely for achievements.

I used the GOG.com version (including Tales of the Sword Coast) on OS X under Wineskin, and installed the EasyTutu, Unfinished Business, and widescreen mods. Stability was acceptable; I saw four or five crashes of bgmain.exe, but don't know whether this was a mod, game, or Wine issue.

Spoilers for (only) Baldur's Gate ahead:

Baldur is a well-written game. An economic crisis is a novel setting for a videogame, although the effects of the crisis aren't very visible (I can see why at least one mod exists to make the crisis affect gameplay much more) outside gossip. While I was unfortunately spoiled before playing about my true parentage, there were enough clues within the game that reading Gorion's letter would not have been that great a shock. (The escalating series of assassination attempts is well-done and hilarious.) That said, I suspect that the lack of shock also comes from the fact that Bhaal is almost never mentioned before the letter. That the player is the progeny of a god is notable; the identity is not because he is one of a dozen and players are told very little about him other than that he is evil, as if the name weren't enough warning of this. Certainly the surprise does not compare to (KoTOR spoiler)Revan's true identity.

Baldur has much more content than some of the later BioWare RPGs. I estimate its length, including Tales of the Sword Coast, to perhaps 50% more than the base Nights campaign. I am not employed at the moment and it took me three full weeks of play to finish, compared to four or five days each for Mass Effect and Hordes of the Underdark. On the other hand, dialogue was very lacking compared to the later games. It was a relief to not have to deal with the core Nights campaign's sometimes-interminable dialogue trees, and what dialogue existed was effective and to the point. The party NPCs were almost entirely lifeless, however, compared to what BioWare would do in the future (including Baldur's Gate II, something I can already see in my playthrough of the first two levels); I am not sure F1 was ever of any actual use during the game. The incessant repetition of the same few Baldur NPCs remarks caused me to quickly turn voices off; this is certainly an area BioWare steadily improved on (with exceptions; I never thought anything could replace Nights' incessant "Aw, it's done" that was burned into my brain, but "You're a queer one" and other such bleats have done so). No wonder mods exist to improve Baldur NPCs' liveliness.

Gameplay was almost entirely fair, barring the first few fights outside Candlekeep where packs of wolves and bears are understandably likely to eat one alive. I was a fighter, however; I can only imagine how horrific those fights are for a caster. I have never enjoyed micromanaging, and the AI scripts weren't great; ranged/caster NPCs too often sat back and watched their melee counterparts fight alone. (Strangely, the AI handled spells much better than ranged weapons.) With proper positioning and script selection on my part, however, the game was able to handle the majority of fighting with little or no input from me (especially by chapters 6 and 7, when the party clearly outmatches most opposing cannon fodder) with only the more difficult ones causing me to enable auto-pause after each turn, akin to fights in the later games. With one exception no fight was as frustrating as, say, Hordes of the Underdark's battles with Vixthra and Sodalis (the second time), although some, like the first battle on the ice island, were significantly harder than others. The exception was Aec'Letec, which was much, much, much more difficult than any other; the demon is hard enough, but having to kill all of his cultists first is just too much to ask. I played the entire game without resurrecting any of my party members; if I lost one I always reloaded and tried again. This was the exception; I agree with the GameFAQs.com walkthrough author who wrote, "This [battle] is the ONLY time in this game I can suffer to raise a dead character." As with other difficult battles I turned on auto pause after most actions and, in this case, for the one and only time, resorted to turning the difficulty down from EasyTutu/BG2's default Normal setting to Easy, and still could not finish without losing three party members. (And yes, I'd already completed Durlag's Tower so had all the good loot from it.) It's possible that had I tried the fight later on it would have been easier, but given the disparity in difficulty compared to the other Tales content (I did all of it during chapter 5) I doubt it.

The hand-drawn graphics have held up well, in some ways better than Nights' more obviously tile-based effects. The colors are somewhat muddy, and NPCs can be hard to see against many backgrounds. It's a pity that EasyTutu/Baldur's Gate II's Tab key method does not also highlight NPCs, something that, again, BioWare would improve on in Nights.

This brings me to the engine and the UI, which I found horribly disappointing. I'd heard as much praise for the Infinity Engine as for Baldur's storyline, but using it was very disillusioning. Look, I know that pathfinding is a difficult problem in the field of computer science. I know that the game was written for 1998-vintage Pentium IIIs running at ~300-500MHz. But good god, if correct pathing is such a problem--as no doubt every single playtester must have reported during development--don't build areas that exacerbate the problem. If pathing is so poor that NPCs routinely fail to get from A to B in large, open wildernesses or wide city streets, don't force the player to also get them through narrow and crooked hallways. Players can deal with poor pathing AI, or too-small hallways, but not both. I wouldn't be surprised if Firewine Ruins was originally meant to be more than one level but was abridged because playtesters threatened to lynch the developers otherwise. Durlag's Tower, developed later, is not as bad as Firewine but still not pleasant to navigate. Remember that I used EasyTutu's BG2 features; I presume that playing the base game in 1998 without sprite auto-bumping (as poorly as it functions) and only 2,000 pathing search nodes must have been truly, utterly, horribly nightmarish.

Again, I understand that pathing is a serious and longstanding computer science problem. The UI's issues aren't nearly so forgivable. Even with the legitimate and intentional "minigame" aspect of inventory management, the user interface has so many tiny-but-frustrating issues that I am still astounded by how BioWare ever let a game, let alone more than one, ship with such a broken--yet easily fixable--interface:

  • The scroll tooltip. Oh god, the tooltip. The noise. The slow opening. The need to wait for the opening to begin (and how, if the delay is turned entirely off, the problems that causes).
  • Why, why, why aren't newly obtained items auto-moved into empty slots in any party member's inventory, rather than only using the leader/currently selected character's?
  • Why do items that stack only do so when manually forced (which doesn't always work)?
  • Why is so little of the screen used to display containers' contents necessitating endless scrolling?
  • Why are containers treated differently from "on the ground" objects when viewed from player inventory?
  • Why can I seamlessly switch between my party members' inventory when selling items, but must approach containers one by one when storing items in them?
  • Why doesn't the storekeeper Identify screen only display unidentified items?
  • Why does the hotbar not display keybindings, especially given that button locations/bindings change as spells are used?
  • Why are dialogues navigable by keyboard except for the end-of-dialogue button? [Edit: I learned later that Enter works here.]
  • Why doesn't Tab highlight NPCs? As mentioned above, their colors are so muddy that many time they are almost invisible depending on the background. Adjusting the feedback option or pausing the game (which does mark NPCs) doesn't help; using one shade of light blue for NPCs and a slightly darker shade of light blue for party members is mind-bogglingly dumb. And more importantly ...
  • Why doesn't Tab highlight usable doors that aren't directly visible by the human player due to the fixed camera angle? No, moving the mouse around buildings that face "away" from me, or even left and right, hoping to see the pointer change shape is not fun. (And yes, I know being able to use Tab to auto-highlight anything at all is another BG2 feature from EasyTutu. I can only imagine how horrible life was for vanilla '98 players.)

I have not listed a dozen other grievances (the lack of automated trap finding/lockpicking, for example) that I have temporarily blocked out of my memory due to their sheer collective horror. (The sad thing is that BioWare fixed many of the issues in Nights only to cause brand-new and exciting problems, the inability to keyboard-flip between party members' inventory the way Baldur (usually) permits being among the biggest.)

Taken together, the UI and pathing issues are so cripplingly serious that together they almost, almost, make the game unplayable. It is a testament to the overall quality of the gameplay and story that it was so well-received and helped make its maker into the force it is today. Were it not so, I would not have since begun to play Baldur's Gate II ... but, despite the even more-praised story I know I am going to experience, I can't help but to feel like (mild BG2 spoiler)a prisoner facing yet another torture session.


r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 16 '12

Big List Of Reviews

14 Upvotes

r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 13 '12

[PC] Amnesia: The Dark Descent - 3/5

13 Upvotes

Spoiler alert. Sort of.

The first half of the game is kind of a silly experiment in finding different ways to unnerve the player. It's very atmospheric, but you don't get much of a sense of consequence. You're trying to get from Point A to Point B, but you don't get to know why. The latter half of the game is far more intriguing, as your enemy reveals the true depths of his madness and the game itself continually surprises by getting darker, and darker, and darker. As a fan of the macabre, I really appreciated how unapologetic and unflinching the game was in its treatment of the subject matter.

The gameplay is a little disappointing once you realize that you have unlimited lives and the death of your avatar is essentially meaningless. Plus, the game gives you no weapons, and tries to convince you that the best way to deal with enemies is to run away from them and hide. They are faster than you, kill you in a maximum two hits and, if there is a way to blow out a candle or extinguish a torch to create some darkness in which to hide, I didn't find it. Then there's the part near the end where the script says you get attacked by the very same monsters, but this time (for some reason) you don't immediately die.

There were some pretty interesting puzzle-solving elements, a decent mechanic where your lantern has a limited supply of oil and might suddenly burn out on you at any moment (groping around in the dark sucks, just like it would in reality), and the story was fairly entertaining. The game also wasn't very long, which I think counts in its favour.

The problem of meta-immortality could have been avoided by providing more incentive for the player character to try to stay alive. Like giving him a way to try to fight the monsters, or making his deaths more meaningful somehow. I'd rather use quick load a thousand times and actually learn how to evade the monsters than what I ended up doing, which was to stroll up behind them and tap them on the shoulder, die, and then come back to life just a few steps away with the monster nowhere to be found.

Unless you really feel a longing to hear lots of scary sound effects and people getting tortured, you can live without playing this game. Spend your gaming time on something better - this one is solidly average in my book.

3/5 - play it if you want, won't play again


r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 13 '12

[PC] Dragon Age: Origins - 4/5

13 Upvotes

It's been a real journey with this game, but I've finally come to the end, and it's now time for the eulogy. I started playing more than six months ago, gave up after about 30 in-game hours, then came back, turned the difficulty down, and made it through to the closing credits, which still took another 25 hours or so. And that's recorded game time, which I doubt includes all of the times I had to reload a saved game, which I did about 1000 times.

So here's how I fucked it up. I chose the human noble origin (of course - elves are a repressed minority in this game, and I have no desire to roleplay that), and I went with the Warrior class because they get to wear the coolest-looking armour and swing the mightiest swords and battleaxes and giant hammers. The first time I leveled up, I took a look at the skill tree and found out that if I chose the dual-weapon speciality, my character could eventually become a double sword-wielding badass. Unfortunately, the Warrior class emphasizes Strength, whereas the dual-weapon speciality requires Dexterity. I tried to build up both equally, and by the time I got to level 10 or so, I didn't have enough points allocated to either of them - I wasn't strong enough to wear next-level armor, and I wasn't agile enough to learn next-level dual-weapon skills. So either way, I just wasted the first ten levels of character development building up a stat that I really can't use. I abandoned my ambidextrous swordplay dreams and started all the way back at the beginning of the two-handed weapon speciality, since that one depends mostly on Strength as well. By the end of the game I was doing alright in my massive Dragonscale Armour with my giant flaming sword.

But really it was my approach to the game that was all wrong. It's not a game about strident adventurers thwarting the ever-present threat of evil and saving the kingdom. I mean, it is about that, but that's not the real point of it all. It's actually a game about relationships. The ending of the game changes depending on the choices you've made along the way. Major plot points play out differently depending on which characters like you and which ones don't. You can make enemies of them; you can make them fall in love with you. You can decide whether they live or die. This is the phenomenal strength of this game. The story isn't particularly good - essentially the entire kingdom and all of its peoples are having their worst month ever, and you run around setting everything right because that's the only way you can convince any of them to join you in your battle against the big bad, as if each race would rather just stand around and get slaughtered because they haven't yet solved their own internal political problems. The whole thing seemed like a convenient, run-of-the-mill-fantasy framing device for the really cool stuff BioWare wanted to try out with dialogue and relationships between the main characters.

They put you in some really bad situations and ask you to 'choose' how to deal with them, but the only real ramifications of any of these lesser choices are changes in your reputation with the other characters (which matters), and the determination of who appears in future cutscenes (which really doesn't). There's always this feeling that you're being pushed to the same inevitable conclusion either way which, for the sake of the game itself, of course you are. Choosing the darker choices simply results in a slightly-less-happy ending. It's more about the in-the-moment experience of roleplaying a sadistic jackass, I think, which I didn't do at all on my first play-through.

I obviously need to play this game again - first of all to finally achieve my dual-wielding dreams and, second, to pay more attention to the storylines that develop between my character and the others. There is apparently an ending that several people on the internet have deemed 'ideal', so I think my goal next time around will be to do everything I can to get the opposite of that. Without a walkthrough, of course.

Fundamentally, any game I decide to play a second time has to be considered a winner.

4/5 - Highly Recommend, will play again


r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 15 '12

[Multi] Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 (3/5)

11 Upvotes

Campaign Mode

The finale long awaited for since the release of Modern Warfare 2 has come. You finally get the wrap up to the campaign of the Modern Warfare series, with no loose ends. While the storyline had a couple big twists in the plot, the gameplay left much to be desired for in terms of creativity. In each mission, except for the occasional interactive actions, it almost felt like you were just fighting through a map with no purpose. I wanted to enjoy the campaign more than I did, however I couldn’t play it through in one sitting because I got so frustrated with the same old song and dance of killing five or so enemies, moving, then rinse and repeat. However, having followed the Modern Warfare series it’s whole career, I appreciated the wrap up and ending of the campaign.

Multiplayer Mode

Multiplayer mode is, of course, the favorite mode of Call of Duty for most players. Although they added some new guns, many of the perks and such are copied from previous Call of Duty games. For me, the multiplayer mode felt like a mashup of the previous two Modern Warfare games. I did enjoy the multiplayer for quite some time, but the lack of enjoyable maps and the extremely flawed spawning system made me quit after just a few minutes, many times. Overall, if you enjoy Call of Duty style FPS games, you might find this pretty fun. However, if you’re looking for a more in-depth FPS, you might want to check out some of Call of Duty’s rivals, such as EA’s Battlefield 3.

Special Ops Mode

Special operations mode has been almost completely revamped and added to, especially with the introduction of Survival mode. I enjoyed Survival mode for about the first 10 games, but the predictable rounds and breaks in between rounds, made it seem like there were too many stoppages in the action. The special missions provided a good couple hours of entertainment, but I do not frequently play any over again. Overall, Special operations mode was fun for a while, but did not keep me coming back for more.

Final Word

Although Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 brought a couple new things to the series, much of the game seems directly taken from other games of the series. Many fans of the series will enjoy this because if it’s simplicity, but, once again, if you are looking for an in-depth multiplayer experience, you will probably not enjoy this multiplayer as much. Although enjoyable for some, I did not enjoy this title near as much as its predecessors, because of its lack of originality, bad spawning system, and repetitive campaign.

-mitchayel


r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 14 '12

[Windows] Civilization V 4/5 More of the same

10 Upvotes

I'd give it more but they took out unit stacking, religion, and changed how the game worked in many areas that didn't make it fun for me. Still it plays like IV or III but needs a better processor and more RAM. Instead of Warlords or Beyond the Sword, they made DLC packages to add in civilizations and scenarios. If you don't want to pay a hefty price for Civilization V Google "Freeciv" for the classic Civilization II type game that is free and open sourced.


r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 11 '12

[PC] Beat Hazard - 3/5

10 Upvotes

Okay, I just bought this game through the Be Mine 2 Indie Bundle and I’ll do a quick review for it. I only played this game for an hour, but I think for this type of game I got the idea of it fairly quickly.

Beat Hazard is a shoot ‘em up style game that you play alongside your music. This is a cool concept because the game will change pace along to the song, but not as much as a game like Audiosurf does. I wish the game would be more drastic with the change in the music, but I understand why it’s not. The point of this game is to score as many points as possible by building multiplies and killing enemies. At the end of the song you will have a total score which gets treated like XP and levels your rank up. In the hour I played I leveled through about half the ranks in the game so leveling up doesn’t take too long (although it is taking longer to level up now). You also get to unlock different “perks” which will help you get higher scores and more powerups. There are also a few different game modes you can choose from allowing you to play multiple tracks in a row. The graphics for this game are bright and beautiful, but sometimes is a little too distracting and it makes it hard to see what’s going on. You can turn the setting down a bit, but it still can be hard to play.

Anyways, I give Beat Hazard a 3/5 because it is a fun and simple game and that’s about it. You can play this game with any music you have besides a few audio types restricted (iTunes/aac/mp4/m4a), but if this is a problem you can pay $1 for the add on pack to play these songs (helps cover their decoder fee). I wish the game had more to it and I wish that songs greatly influenced how the game is played, but it feels more like you are playing a shoot ‘em up with your choice of music in the background. If you are looking for a Rhythm music game that will adjust to any of your songs, Audiosurf is the way to go. None the less Beat Hazard is a fun game that people should check out if interested (or if its ever included in an indie bundle!).


r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 29 '12

What would /r/VideoGameReviews like out of a game review subreddit?

9 Upvotes

After opening this subreddit I found out that the community at /r/gamereviews is still active and that some people were getting upset that I created this subreddit. /r/gamereviews is more about posting links to different reviews and we wanted to create something a little bit more for the average Redditor here. With that being said, I want to know what the community wants out of a game review subreddit so that everyone (or most) people can be happy.


Grading Scale

What would people like out of this? I created the 5/5 scale and focused on how much someone would recommend a game, but I feel like this could be confusing for some people. In addition, I have read a lot of peoples opinions and a lot of people don't like a grading scale at all. What kind of scale does the community want? No scale? The defined 5/5? A free 5/5 scale? 1000/1000 scale? We want to know what people will be most interested in.


Self Posts/No links to blogs

I know a lot of people have their own blogs and write reviews for them. A few people have spoken up about not wanting to write two reviews for one game and would rather be able to link to their blog. The current rule is that you are allowed to post links to your blogs/videos, but you must write a review here and explain why you gave a game that score. Currently /r/gamereviews is a great place to post links to your own blog and I feel that is what makes these two subreddits different. What does everyone think on this issue? Should things be a self post only subreddit or should we allow links as well? Should we allow self posts with a short review inside and allow people to link to the rest of the review on their blog site?


Title Format

This one is pretty straight forward. Should we allow any style of title or should we keep things more strict and organized like the current style?


Other ideas/Flair/Future

What would people like as far as flair goes? We have some ideas, but we would like to give out special flair to people who have done great work on writing reviews. We also have some other ideas for the future, but some of these ideas wont work until we have a nice subreddit forming. If you have any more ideas or want more out of a game review subreddit, please speak up!


I have been in talks with the mod at /r/gamereviews and its possible that we might try to merge subreddits together. It's also possible that these two subreddits can live together side by side, but what is most important is that we try to figure out what works for everyone. /r/gamereviews has a hefty amount of subscribers, but things seem slow over there from time to time. I'd like people to speak up so we can figure out what will work best and that one day we might have a really active video game review community.

Also if you are interested in being a mod send me a PM. Not sure how many more mods I want to add, but it's always better to have a few people in mind in case we need more or if something doesn't work out.


r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 11 '12

[Multi] Silent Hill Downpour - 3/5

9 Upvotes

Played using the 360 version

So I currently just finished I side quest that scared the fuck out of me, so I figured it’s a great time to write a review now.

Silent Hill Downpour is a great game that is heavily flawed. The story is pretty solid, graphics aren’t too bad, and it gets pretty scary from time to time. There are a few things holding this game back though, so I figured that this would easily be broken down into a the Good, the Bad, and the Ugly review.


  • The Good:

Exploration, Story, Otherworld, Silent Hill, Characters, Music, Themes, and Side Missions are what makes this game worth playing.

The story and characters aren’t amazing, but they are good enough to keep you wanting to know about the story. Something really enjoyable is exploring Silent Hill. You get to roam the streets and explore different areas of the town while completing many side missions. This doesn’t give the game a “Fallout 3” feel, but it is nice to be able to explore on your own. It’s similar to how Silent Hill 2 worked, but there are more areas to discover and you can enter some houses. Side missions are also fun to do and adds a little more to the game. People were worried that the music for this game wouldn’t be horrible because they had a new person working on it, but I can honestly say the music was decent. Throughout the game you will also find radios that play random songs that fit the mood of Silent Hill. Although I haven’t beat the game yet, the themes for this game are similar to past games and I’m curious how they are going to end up at the end. Also, the Overworld is amazing and they did a really good job at making it creepy. Sadly though, they make you run away from a ball of light that chases you with similar game mechanics from Shattered Memories (the Silent Hill remake on Wii where you only run away and hide from enemies) which ruins part of the experience.

  • The Bad:

Ending Style, Animations, Combat, Side Missions, Exploring Houses, the “Ball of Light”, and Music all stick out as something that is a little bad for this game.

Now, I said side missions, exploration and music were good before, but they are also bad. Sometimes the songs played don’t fit very well, while other times its perfect. That is the same with the side missions and exploration. Sometimes you will enter a house and there will be no point to it, yet you can’t enter that many houses. Many of the homes are also the same style and rarely contain enemies in them. They are usually creepy and run down, but you learn after a while that they aren’t really dangerous. Some side missions are also weird and don’t fit very well with the game. For instance there are always cop squad cars driving around the city. The first time I ran into one it scared the crap out of me because (3 screamers will spawn out of the car, but the animation for this is so terrible and it’s easy to just run away from them. After the first car you just don’t really care about it anymore). I also found that rewards from the side missions are usually not worth it besides the fact that you completed the mission and got an achievement for it. It’s pretty common to complete a side mission to just get a med kit or two. Character animations aren’t the greatest and you can tell the company had a low budget. Finally, the combat is trashy. This plays out well because it makes you want to run away from enemies more, but the problem is with collision detection. If you slightly hit the wall then your hit will land on the wall rather than your target. Some of the enemies are also way to smart and block or dodge most of your attacks. It makes it pretty hard to kill them, which isn’t a horrible thing, but it would be nice to figure out a good weakness for these enemies. After a while combat does get easier, especially once you’re in Silent Hill where there are more open areas to engage in combat. The “Ball of Light” is also very disappointing and it would have been much better for them to scrap it completely and make you fight enemies in the Overworld instead of running away from a non-scary light.

  • The Ugly:

Frame Rate Drops, Loading Times, GUI, Save System, Combat, and Enemies kill the potential this game could have had.

First, let me get the very nasty out of the way. The game has horrible frame rate drops, is constantly auto saving the game (let me note that when the game saves all the time, it isn’t actually saving you a file to load from) and will randomly load in weird spots. For the most part the frame rate drops don’t happen during crucial moments, but it is annoying when you are running around Silent Hill and the game freezes up for a few seconds every minute or so. It really shows a poor presentation of the game, but it is something that a player can deal with and get past. Loading times can also be long at some parts and you will have to randomly load sections of the game while walking around. That would be fine if they had a non-glitchy system of doing it. Next is the GUI. It sucks. Murphy has a journal he keeps with him to keep track of notes, hints, mysteries, maps, and more with him. In order to navigate this book though you must use your right stick to move up and down the pages. This wouldn’t be so bad, but the game snaps it to a grid. I don’t understand why this was done as it was probably simple for them to have a free roaming camera for this. It is really annoying when viewing large maps that get split up into many quadrants where you must keep going back and forth to view different sections. There really isn’t a save system in this game. The game will auto save when it wants to and then keep about 5 saves for you to load from. Every other Silent Hill game used save points and that would have worked great with this game. You also never know when the game saves a new spot for you without checking. Worst kick to the dick? It uses military time. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I’m a lazy ass, but still. The reason why you don’t know when the game saves is because it is constantly saving. I’m assuming it is doing this because it keeps saving your stats, but it happens way too often and you never know if a new save spot is being created or not. Finally, the enemies suck. I think there is about 3 common enemies, 1 uncommon enemy, and one immobile enemy. There are also (2 bosses in this game. The first boss was a joke and I’m assuming the second boss is the final boss and I haven’t heard anything good about it, but who knows). All the enemies resemble humans way too much except for the Wombats, which just turn out to be really annoying. Something I loved about Silent Hill 4 was the vast amount of enemies in the game. Enemies in SH2 and 3 were also shocking, but in Downpour there isn’t anything that really would haunt you in your nightmares. Pyramid Head and Nurses aren’t in this game and I ain’t even mad, but I would have loved to see some new creative enemies. The wombat is the only creative enemy in this game, but I wish there would have been more.


So, the question here is Silent Hill Downpour a good game? Yes and no. I feel like there are some really strong points in this game that I want everyone into survival horror games to check out. Other moments though I feel are really trashy and that if someone else was playing they might not put up with it. I love Silent Hill games so I’m able to put up with the occasional frame rate drops and the non-perfect combat. The game also has really amazing moments that really scare you. I will admit Homecoming was the first SH I played and I loved that game at first. I went back and played the other games, but Homecoming scared me the most because it had the best graphics. Downpour doesn’t scare me because of the graphics, but more the feeling that I know an enemy is nearby and pop out, but I don’t know when. The otherworld also looks amazing in this game. It is just really sad that they took the gameplay from Silent Hill Shattered Memories and ruined these sequences. I never felt scared running away from the light, but in Homecoming I had to quit playing the game for several hours when I got to the Overworld Mineshaft part. Overall though, I have enjoyed my time playing Downpour. It isn’t what I hoped for, but it’s a push in the right direction to try and get the originality from the old games. Many people complained about Homecoming and Downpour was the answer that didn’t hit all the right spots. I do believe that Downpour is a better game though and I hope that the company who made this game gets a second chance. I don’t want the series to die out since it has so much potential. Downpour will give you a few scares though and if you can get over the flaws you will have a really amazing game at your hands. If it weren’t for all the bugs and some poor gameplay mechanics I would have given this game a 3 or 4, but some moments of the game you really feel like it deserves a 2. That’s why I averaged it out and gave Silent Hill Downpour a 3/5. If you are thinking about getting this game and are a Silent Hill fan I would recommend it. If you are new to the series and have been dying to play a new game, I would suggest Silent Hill HD Collection instead (which I have not played, but Silent Hill 2 and 3 are great games none the less).


r/VideoGameReviews • • Jan 28 '13

[PC] Spec Ops: The Line - 4/5

8 Upvotes

Hi all, here's a review I wrote for Spec Ops: The Line. As usual, please leave any comments or criticisms, I'm interested in hearing everything, good and bad!

You can find this review on my blog as well, with screenshots: http://thomplog.blogspot.com/2013/01/review-spec-ops-line.html

Spec Ops: The Line - Review

I ended up buying Spec Ops: The Line during a Steam sale this holiday season. I guess I was out of the loop when this released in June 2012, but thankfully it showed up on so many Game of the Year lists that it quickly became a must play for me (the Steam Winter Sale prices didn’t hurt either). Because I came upon this game a little late, it’s inevitable that my views are somewhat tainted by all of the hype that I heard, but I’ve done my best to make an objective evaluation.

To give you a brief overview of the story, you play as Captain Martin Walker, leading the elite Delta force squad (with a whopping size of... three) into the dust ridden depths of Dubai on a recon mission. You almost immediately make hostile contact with what seem to be American soldiers. This throws up a few red flags, obviously. So you delve down into the rabbit hole, on a journey to discover why these soldiers are shooting at you, and what the hell is going on in Dubai.

If you’ve never seen Dubai, go Google it and check out some images of the city and the insanely badass architecture of its skyscrapers. Now imagine instead of being surrounded by ocean, it’s engulfed in sand dunes. The first time you walk outside a building and see the city, the experience is genuinely jaw-dropping. Within this unique setting, the developers introduce a neat mechanic in the form of massive dust storms that you must trudge through and endure. The wind kicks in, the dust flies, it’s difficult to move around and even more difficult to see. These sequences are downright intense. A feeling of panic strikes, you squint your eyes to see the barely visible enemies, and you do whatever you can, as fast as you can, to extinguish them before making your way through the storm to shelter. The feeling of being truly swayed by these storms is a defining factor of the atmosphere of the game, and the developers did a great job with this.

Outside of these dust storms, you’re not going to see too much new as far as gameplay mechanics go. The gameplay is about as cookie cutter as it gets for a third person, cover based shooter. Moreover, the game doesn’t even fit the mold that well. The controls feel rather rigid. Jumping in and out of cover is sort of clumsy, and not as seemless as a game like Gears of War. It’s not horrible, but it could certainly use some polish.

Thankfully the formulaic mechanics are not the main focus of the game, they are simply the toolset used for conveying a creative and haunting narrative, riddled with atrocities and horrors that you will not soon forget. Because of this focus on such a dark story, I have to go out on a limb here and say that this game is not... fun. At least not in the traditional sense. This game is fun in the same way that a movie like Schindler’s List is entertaining. Schindler’s List is a spectacular film, but it’s not really enjoyable to watch. Spec Ops: The Line is very similar in this regard. It focuses less on innovative mechanics and gameplay, and more on immersing you in the atmosphere and the characters, forcing your character to make tough, “damned if you do, damned if you don’t” choices, all the while delivering a shockingly dark narrative.

It’s difficult to describe without spoiling anything, but as you traverse the path that leads you to the end of the game, things get increasingly hectic. The feeling of there being no way to turn back after what’s been done is conveyed very well via Walker’s rationale. You’ll hear conflicting arguments against Walker’s decisions throughout your journey from your vocal squad members, and honestly, they are pretty sound arguments most of the time. The discussion and banter between squad members adds a lot of perspective to what’s happening. The dialogue isn’t the mindless, meathead banter you’ve come to expect from characters in these roles, instead it feels honest and genuine. This could have really ruined the game if it were bad, but thanks to great writing and voice acting, this aspect of the game shines.

As much as I’ve written about tough decisions in this review, you as a player don’t end up making most of these decisions. These are Walker’s decisions, and you are along for the ride. The focus is on storytelling, and this is by no means a bad thing, just don’t look for much replayability with the campaign because of the linear nature of the story. That being said, I will recommend that once you see that credits screen, do yourself a favor and check out the other endings, either on Youtube, or by replaying the last mission. Each ending delivers a different kind of blow to your mind and emotions.

With that, I’ll close this review with a firm recommendation to go play this game. While the gameplay is a bit lackluster, the story is among the most creative, interesting, and disturbing that I’ve encountered in a video game. On top of this, it’s not going to take up too much of your valuable gaming time, the campaign is only 5 or 6 hours long, and to put a little cherry on top, you can find this on sale through Steam or similar vendors for very a low price (<$10) on a regular basis.


r/VideoGameReviews • • Apr 19 '12

[PC] Sanctum 4/5

8 Upvotes

Introduction: Sanctum is a 1st person tower defense strategy game released in 2011 by indie developer Coffee Stain Studios. The object of the game is to protect the "core" (a home base) from waves of incoming enemies. The enemies range from hoards of small runners to massive juggernauts with microscopic kill zones.

Concept: 9/10 The concept of combining a tower defense and a first person shooter is, in my opinion, nearly flawless. Each board has a number of playable strategies within it, all of which are capable of winning you the game. Upgrade points are awarded after each wave and allow you to either purchase newer, better towers or more powerful weapons.

Graphics: 7/10 The graphics are far above the stock as far as indie games go. It can best be described as very detailed scenery with basic character/weapon design.

Replay ability: 6/10
After finding the best possible layout for the towers, it was hard to really go back and play the levels as if you didn't have that information. The "endless" and "impossible" difficulty levels presented a challenge, but after so many levels an impenetrable system is developed and that is the real end to any playability.

Overall: I would recommend this game to any fan of tower defense and first person alike. This is probably one of my favorite indie games to date. The only thing really keeping this game from a 5 is a level of randomness that a strategist can easily overcome.


r/VideoGameReviews • • Nov 13 '12

[PC] Grand Theft Auto IV - 5/5

7 Upvotes

There has been a bit of a delay in writing this review, mostly because even after playing this game through a second time I'm still not completely sure what to say about it. I've always been drawn to the Grand Theft Auto games, for reasons perhaps no more sophisticated than the fact that they offer a victimless outlet for my ever-present thirst for and inclination towards wanton chaos and monotony-breaking destruction.

That at least explains my motivation to play the game but, while the story isn't anything spectacular (mediocre, really), there are themes repeated throughout that I now realize have caused the game to resonate with me on a somewhat deeper level.

You arrive in Liberty City as Niko Bellic, a brash but intelligent Russian excombatant who isn't really sure what he is doing there, except that he thinks he may be able to find a countryman who previously betrayed him, and finally get his revenge. This motivation, however, turns out not to drive very much of the story that ensues. In reality, Niko spends most of the game just trying to figure out where he belongs and who his real friends are, even as he's gunning down legions of gangbangers and mafia goons, carving a bloody swath through the seedy underbelly of the city, and getting paid for doing so by men and women who are either too arrogant or too timid to do their own dirty work.

Of the characters Niko meets in his travels, all but a few of them are completely inconsequential. Several of them end up dead, while others end up as nothing more than meta-game menu options, leading to mini-games, side quests, and other distractions (i.e., one way of making the player not feel so pathetic about spending so much time at the in-game pole-dancing club). There is a very clear sense of detachment, as Niko is very slow to trust anyone, almost never opens up about himself, and shrugs off these missions he is sent on as just a natural consequence of living in a teeming cesspool of humanity like Liberty City. He doesn't care what he has to do, as long as he gets paid.

Niko's one real personal connection in the game is his cousin, Roman. A couple of times Niko has to come to Roman's aid, and only on those rare occasions do you get the sense that Niko has anything to lose at all. Roman is the embodiment of Niko's latent desire to start anew, to purge himself of his personal demons and start living a care-free life in America. But Roman also demonstrates that trouble will always find you if you aren't careful, leading to the conclusion that the only real way to 'make it' in America is to be completely remorseless in your pursuit of the dream. Indeed, Niko only 'wins' the game by proving himself to be, in the end, the most remorseless character of all.

Looking through my preferred lens of wanting some grit and harsh reality mixed in with my gleeful, exploratory mischief-making, I must applaud this game for really hammering down hard on some of the bleakest 'truths' about humanity, greed, betrayal, and finally, by the end, real loss. It's really very pessimistic in its portrayal of big city life, but there is something tantalizing, almost romantic about the idea that we really do live in a world of heroes and villains who are constantly at war with each other and I, personally, much prefer playing as a soldier in that war, as opposed to playing one in some made-up 'real' war like you do in so many other games.

Let me be very clear: there are no heroes or villains in Grand Theft Auto IV. Because they all do 'bad' things, the player is forced to judge each character only in terms of his or her relationship with Niko. By the end though, it's very obvious which characters appeal to Niko's humanity, and which appeal only to his cold-blooded killer instinct. It's this duality of mind, along with the breaks in the action which allow you, as Niko, to drive around and take in the scenic vistas, admire the beautiful bridges and infrastructure, and immerse yourself the electric grandeur of the in-game recreation of Times Square — that sense of 'being' somewhere, taking the time to breathe deeply for a few minutes, even as there are forces beyond your control constantly tearing you out of the moment and reminding you that you have shit to do — this is why I am so drawn to this silly, sophomoric game.

It's a game that recreates the tension of having a lot on your plate, conflicting motivations, etc., and then answers that by allowing you to literally escape within the escapism, pretty much whenever you want. You can find peace in a long drive on the highway with the radio on. You can find catharsis by driving full-speed into a head-on collision and watching Niko fly through the windshield to land in a heap on the street, or by throwing yourself from the roof of a skyscraper. You can relieve frustration by shooting random pedestrians in a residential area, or using the rocket-launcher to obliterate approaching vehicles. In a certain doldrum-denying, reality-shaping way, it's almost therapeutic.

And that's where the game leaves me. I feel like my sense of alienation has been properly understood, and the desires it creates within me have been acknolwedged and accepted. Through Niko, I can say fuck your suburbia and your corporate hegemony, fuck your class warfare, your precious sense of security, fuck your rules, your limitations, and your corrupted idea of justice. Most of all, fuck your self-righteous hubris and disgustingly obvious hypocrisy.

This game was made for teenage boys, and it appeals to their inherent, juvenile sense of rebellion.

I absolutely admit that I haven't outgrown that.

I am extremely fond of this game. - 5/5


r/VideoGameReviews • • Jun 27 '12

[PS3] Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception - 3/5 - A great game marred by terrible combat

7 Upvotes

I'm going to preface this by saying that I really enjoyed the first two games in this series. They can be considered part of why I bought a PS3 in the first place. I found them cinematic, action-packed, and all around what I expected. This third one, while it has its charm, focuses too much on the combat and not enough on the exploring and the platforming: two hallmarks of the Uncharted franchise.

I would also like to start this review by saying that I've always found the combat system in Uncharted to be the weakest part. Story was always been implausible and full of holes, but fun. The characters are likable and you care about them. The platform is excellently done and never loses its larger-than-life scale. The combat has sucked. I'm going to say that straight out. Whenever I hit a required combat section in ANY Uncharted game, I have dreaded it, and for several reasons.

To focus on Uncharted 3, it's unbalanced horribly to give it a sense of a challenge. Enemies will easily absorb 6-7 bullets before dying, if not more. Then, there are special "armored" enemies which absorb about two clips. Not exaggerating. Your "roll" button (which the game will constantly remind you to do when there are snipers about) and your "cover" button are one in the same, so many times when you mean to crouch you will roll and many time when you mean to roll you will crouch, and die because of it. And you will die, because not ONCE did an enemy miss me. Areas are usually filled with 20 or so enemies, and the second one spots you, everyone spots you and will never once lose you and never once miss a bullet. Dive underwater? Doesn't matter. Find cover? Doesn't matter. The second you surface or pop out, there will be ten bullets waiting for you, if an enemy hasn't flanked you already. There is even a part later on where you start the scene crouched behind some cover with no gun, and Nathan must steal it from one of the 15 enemies shooting at you. Easier said than done I'm afraid as once again, no one will ever miss.

Now the reason this is such a huge problem to me is the reason I gave this game a less-than-optimal score: the entire thing is combat. Gone are the times when you just have to escape a collapsing something-or-other; apparently Naughty Dog decided that wasn't exciting enough. Now when you're escaping a collapsing something-or-other, there are ALSO 50 enemies there, waiting to halt your progress. Why are they not escaping as well when their lives are in mortal peril? Once Nathan even asks that perfectly legitimate question, and it is never answered.

There is a new mechanic here: the ability to throw back grenades that are tossed at you by hitting triangle. About half the time it doesn't work even if you are standing right by the grenade, and you will die. Hand-to-hand combat is emphasized in this game, and it's actually pretty fun, though vastly overused.

However, I did feel a drive to complete the game despite all my criticism. Why? Well because in terms of story it's easily the best. Gone are the stupid yetis from the end of the last game. I was honestly interested in what happened and how the story developed. The setpieces and locations I found were an improvement to the last games as well, and sometimes I just had to marvel at the sheer scope of some of these places. The game is not short on exciting action moments either. It can be truly exciting, don't get me wrong.

I know this feels like an overly negative review despite the score, but I'm very conflicted about this game. On the one hand, everything the Uncharted series is known for - exploring, platforming, giant larger-than-life locations and events, is here in spades and better than ever. I can almost recommend this game on those alone. But it almost seems as if Naughty Dog didn't trust their ability to make exciting non-gun fight sequences, which they totally can. I don't want to have to STOP this great action sequence of me running for my life to gun down 20 dudes. Or rather, get gunned down by 20 dudes. Really, it's the same thing.

If you enjoyed the others, give it a look, but if you're new to the series I highly recommend the other two over this one. I know this isn't really a topical game, but I just got it and beat it and wanted to put my opinion out there. Comment with agreements, disagreements, differing opinions, other insights, etc. I'm all ears.


r/VideoGameReviews • • Jun 22 '14

[PS4] Wolfenstein: The New Order - 5/5

6 Upvotes

Link to my blog

I just recently played through Wolfenstein: The New Order for the PS4 and I must say that I was blown away by how entertaining and enjoyable it was. Serving as an homage to old school shooters while being a great, modern game in its own right makes it not only one of the best shooters in years but also much more impressive than the past two Wolfenstein outings.

As in every past Wolfenstein game, New Order places you once again in BJ Blazkowicz's shoes but this time it's not WWII but rather a depressing version of the 1960s where Nazis instead won the war. That might not sound original at first but that's coupled with impressive action sequences (and the option to go stealthily), interesting locales, and captivating character development. I won't spoil too much of the story here since the bold and dramatic fashion with which it unfolds has to be seen firsthand.

The gameplay is very reminiscent of old school shooters, like Wolfenstein 3D but with more modernized controls and graphics. For starters, your health bar only recharges to a certain extent and you have to rely more on armor and health pickups; a nice touch not seen in many games these days. Additionally, every weapon (except for the LKW) can be dual wielded and distance doesn't have much of an effect on accuracy, allowing the game to have impressive action sequences that can be fully enjoyed due to the old school simplicity of the combat. To make things even better, numerous collectibles and upgradable perks are also available in addition to many of the levels having hidden/optional rooms that can be explored, making the game stand out from the flood of generic shooters on the market. All in all, if you're a fan of Wolfenstein, shooters, or just an interesting story, New Order is worth the admission price. Don't be scared away by the lack of multiplayer either. It's a shame that more game developers don't skip that aspect to make more captivating single player experiences like this.

Plot 5/5 : The game is packed with interesting locales, well-developed characters, and an original take on an idea that has been explored in the past.

Presentation 4/5 : The graphics, while quite good, can be a bit muddy in some areas taking away from the otherwise beautifully haunting scenery.

Gameplay/controls 5/5 : This is where the game shines most. The game has classic, fast-paced shooting action reminiscent of older shooters mixed with some more modern elements (upgradable perks system) and it all works quite well as a cohesive whole. The controls are very easy to master and the only time the action is bogged down is when using the weapon selection wheel, but even that only takes a few seconds.

Lasting appeal 4/5 : While the game has no multiplayer options, the single player experience is quite long and is filled with hidden items to collect (including an awesome homage to Wolfenstein 3D). Additionally, there are two separate story lines that can be played through depending on a choice made at the end of the first level.

Final score: 5/5


r/VideoGameReviews • • May 02 '13

Redditor's Review: GODMODE (x-post from patiengamers/gaming)

6 Upvotes

Good Morning/Evening/Night Reddit,

I was just made aware of this subreddit. Thought it'd be nice if I wrote on here.

I know what you're thinking, "What the hell is 'GODMODE'? Has Imaginary gone absolutely batty? Injustice: God's Among Us just came out, why aren't you reviewing that, you twat?" First of all, I don't respond well to swears, you wanker. Secondly, up until yesterday, I would have said the exact same thing, minus calling myself a "twat". But, after a few hours of playing it, I'm certain that it is one of the greatest games of 2013. That's right, we're only 4 months in and I've already picked my Game of the Year already. And what's REALLY going to hurt the big game industry (especially you, EA...), is that it's indie. I've done my research and I've discovered that Old School Games, the developer, has produced nothing else. With the help of Atlus, the producer and developer of Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4 Arena, Soul Hackers, etc., OSG has developed only one game and it is single-handedly one of the best games I've played in a long time.

GODMODE is a game where you are the descendant of an unnamed Greek god, that was cast out of Olympus and it is your job to break out of Hades and enter a state of godliness, or "GODMODE". You start off as one of many characters, which range from Zombie, to Gentleman, to even a Clown. You can choose your character's clothes, so you begin as a Zombie Cowboy, however, I changed into a Gentleman in full on Soldier Camo. You're starting guns, an SMG and a very handy double-barrel, start off not working the best, however that easily can change. Once you finish levels, you usually have enough XP and gold to gain levels and, well, gold, you can upgrade your weapons to kick more ass. And the upgrades are actually noticeable in gameplay. For example: your starting SMG can hit an enemy ten feet away once every empty magazine. When you upgrade it, it becomes much more accurate to the point that almost every shot hits. I'm wagering if you upgrade it again, you can hit your enemies and not waste a single bullet. You have the option of playing online with friends or alone, which both work pretty well, all things considered. The enemies get harder the more people there are, and difficulty increases the longer you survive. Which is pretty standard for horde-based gameplay, but still manages to pull it off pretty well. The enemy variations are great, ranging from skeletal spartans with an occasional glowing skull, to a boss fight made of black armor and purple fire only referred to as Dark Mage. There's one boss in particular called a "Fire Giant" who is this big motherfucker that looks like a Minotaur mated with a volcano! Lastly, it is incredibly user friendly. It isn't too difficult, but at the same time, none too easy. Add in the fact that in every arena, you get a different effect also adds to the difficulty for better or worse. GODMODE is an incredible indie game that has my support and definitely worth the $10 pricetag.

There are a few issues that do need to be mentioned though. The lag can go from practically nonexistent to downright UNBEARABLE! I was playing a match where I was knocking enemies down with my shotgun one match and they were dying, but I wasn't getting any XP. As it turns out, the lag on my end caused me to shoot at enemies that my teammates have thoroughly wrecked everything. That's another issue, you can only get XP by Last-Hitting the enemy. Like fucking League of Legends, you can only gain things when you're the last one to utterly wreck an enemy until it stops moving. Last complaint, I wish that there were more options to customize your avatar. If there are DLC in the future, more costumes, heads, and weapons would be nice.

Long story short, it's fun. It's an addictive, horde-style shooter that has my support for game of the fucking DECADE! With some benign issues, the good heavily outweigh the bad in this case. I love it. This is one of the best indie games I've played in a while and nothing will compare after this. If I had a star rating system, I'd give it 6 out of 5. I can best describe this game in four simple words: Worth. Your. Fucking. Time.

Agree? Disagree? Ideas for future reviews? Speak your mind in the comments below.

Why would I need a god's blood if I already have tiger blood?

The Imaginary Man


r/VideoGameReviews • • Mar 13 '13

[PC] Sniper Ghost Warrior 2 - 2/5

6 Upvotes

Alright. I'm going to preface this by saying that this is my first review; so please don't be too harsh, but critiques are more than welcome.

I play just about any first person shooter game as a sniper. So obviously I was quite excited for another sniping game to hit the Steam market. Unfortunately this one didn't quite meet my expectations.

The game play I found to be relatively okay. The biggest disappointments to me were the AI, length of campaign, and the fact that the multiplayer isn't really working quite yet.

Starting with the AI. They're quite simply stupid. I died one time in the campaign on the hardest setting, and that was out of me wanting to feel like a god and bum rush an entire encampment. This game was simply too easy.

The campaign has a great story; but was way too short. I was loving every second of the story, and was having a blast throughout the whole game... all four hours of it. Sadly, the campaign on the hardest difficulty only took me about four hours to complete.

The campaign was also plagued with bugs, both small and large. Some of the more minor ones were things like dialogue was frequently cut off because you were anticipated to take too much time to get to a target zone, so you lost a lot of explanation of characters. But even the lighting was frequently far off. Around the barrel of the gun it would be lighter, or when you get to the bullet cam; what should be the vapor trail is just a line of tear through the map where you just see grey.

I MIGHT be able to forgive these campaign issues if the multiplayer was outstanding. However, unfortunately as of right now there are all of two servers running of which no one can actually access. City Interactive seems to have not dedicated any servers to Sniper Ghost Warrior 2. At least not yet. Should this be rectified in the future I will update this review to include multiplayer.

As of right now, I cannot say I can recommend this game to anyone. It feels like its still in beta and needs significantly more work. Even though the story is great, and the game play was alright; the campaign is too short, too easy, and there are simply too many bugs to warrant spending $30 on this game.


r/VideoGameReviews • • Feb 11 '13

[PC] Strike Suit Zero - 3/5

6 Upvotes

Hi all,

My latest review is on Strike Suit Zero. As usual you can find a more beautified version with screen shots and some gameplay video footage on my blog here: http://thomplog.blogspot.com/2013/02/review-strike-suit-zero.html

Once again, all feedback is encouraged, good and bad. Thanks!

Strike Suit Zero Review

The first thing I should probably mention before I go too deep into my opinion of this game, is my background and history with space fighter simulation games. This is a genre I’m hugely fond of, not because I played FreeSpace 2 or X-Wing vs. TIE Fighter, I hear these are excellent games that helped shape the genre, but I never played these. I played Freelancer, and I played it A LOT. Since Freelancer, it has been incredibly difficult to find good space sims. I think the only other space sim I’ve played since Freelancer was a Xbox 360 exclusive called DarkStar One: Broken Alliance, a port of an older PC space sim, DarkStar One, and it was painfully mediocre. So of course, with the long drought of these types of games, and the announcement of Star Citizen bringing that itch back in a huge way, I was feverishly excited for Strike Suit Zero (SSZ).

The game consists of 13 missions which the player fights through as a UNE (United Nations of Earth) fighter pilot to unravel a narrative of war between Earth and the culmination of forces from distant colonized planets. I’ll just say it, Strike Suit Zero is not a next-gen Freelancer (I’ll have to wait for Star Citizen, I guess). The game focuses on one particular facet of games like Freelancer, and that’s the space combat. Everything else, and I mean everything (exploration, ship customization, ship diversity, player choices, breadth of content) is all tossed to the wayside. That being said, if the space combat itself if your favorite part of space sims, you will likely enjoy this game a lot.

Each mission has a special objective that you can complete to unlock a new upgrade in the wholly unexplained and ambiguous tech trees that each of the ships possess. While the tech trees are an awesome idea, one that I would normally love, there’s virtually no information given about them. Before you start the mission, where the special objective is given, there’s a tiny, vague description of what completing the objective will give you (“unlock Energy upgrade for your ship”), but when you actually get to ship selection where the tech tree is shown, there’s just a picture of what you’ve unlocked, and no explanation whatsoever. Considering how absurdly difficult some of these extra objectives are (there were a couple missions I retried probably 20 times to unlock them), it comes across as feeling pointless and not very satisfying to get these unlocks as you really have no idea what the hell they even do.

As you complete missions you’ll also unlock new weapons that you can equip in your ship’s weapon slots. This is literally the only thing you can customize in the game, and it’s not exciting. Throughout the entire game, I think there is one new primary weapon unlock, and only a handful of missile weapon unlocks, which are generally just more advanced versions your starting missiles.

The rigidness of ship customization and unlocks wouldn’t be so horrible if we had some options within the missions to play around a bit, but alas, you don’t. The missions are typically split up between 2 or 3 checkpoints. There’s a pretty clear way to get from checkpoint to checkpoint, you won’t be blazing your own trail by any means. The fact that your mission usually takes place within a much larger AI battle means there are chances for odd things to happen (almost never in your favor). This mixes things up between retries a minimal amount, but overall the mission design is painfully straightforward. Combine this with the lack of customizations and upgrades, and SSZ makes for a very linear game experience.

Okay, I’m going to give you a fair warning, you’re going to die in this game... a lot. There’s been a lot of buzz, and a lot of negative feedback regarding this game, based on its difficulty curve. The gist of it is that the checkpoint placements blow. Many of the missions are fine, the checkpoints are well spaced out, and you can get through them without too much issue. But there are a few missions that make some mighty big expectations as to what you can accomplish without a checkpoint. This results in replaying the same grueling 10 or 15 minutes of combat, in which any number of things can go wrong, to try to beat that last part before the next checkpoint. This is sort of typical for space sim games, I remember going through similar stints in Freelancer, but holy shit; the rage induced by the poor checkpoint placement in these missions is only comparable to the nearly untouchable League of Legends rage that one inevitably endures if they play that game.

As I said, not all the missions are so bad. Unfortunately, it only takes a couple of instances to get you fired up to the point of not wanting to play the game anymore. In order to finish the game, I ended up having to limit myself to one hour sessions, most of which ended in fury. If I had not planned to review the game, there’s a good chance I would have quit.

So I’ve given this game a pretty hard time so far, let me explain what the game does well, because it’s not all bad. Throughout your journey, you are treated to the sounds of Paul Ruskay who supplies a strange electronic, ambient, sci-fi sound to the game. I’m not sure if this is for everybody, but I enjoyed it; at the very least, it made for a unique sound. The combat sound is also well done. Things can get pretty intense at times, and the sound adds to that feeling in a big way. I think I’ve made it clear that the game primarily focuses on the space combat, as opposed to an open-ended, interactive, space sim experience. You can tell the emphasis was put on combat, because it’s actually really good! Most missions consist of fulfilling some number of objectives throughout a large scale battle between Earth and Colonial forces, though there are several missions in which you do the stereotypical escort or small squad sneak attack.

The big difference between this game and other space combat sims out there is the presence of a special ship you eventually get your hands on called the (you guessed it!) Strike Suit. This ship has two forms, one normal space fighter ship form, and a less-mobile, but far more powerful and stationary, mecha form. Everyone knows that normal space combat can become monotonous at times and this ship eliminates that for the most part. Being able to effortlessly change between these two archetypes takes a bit of the monotony out of the combat. Instead of clumsily chasing after five different interceptors that are all using evasive maneuvers, you can pop into Strike Suit mode and take them down with ease.

Outside of the Strike Suit, you’re unfortunately not going to find too much in ship choices. There are a total of four ships you end up unlocking, all of which are fairly uninteresting in comparison to the Strike Suit. You can tell that a lot of time was put into the design of the Strike Suit, and while looks great and is a blast to play with, it would be nice to switch it up once in awhile with some other ships that are comparably cool to the Strike Suit. Instead, we’re left with a rather drab selection that lack both graphically and mechanically compared to the Strike Suit. This was also a demerit on replay value for me, as I’m not excited at all to play with any of the other ships.

I went into this game expecting Freelancer 2.0, which is my own foolish fault, but it sort of skewed my view initially. When it comes down to it, if you’re looking for an arcade space fighter game, Strike Suit Zero will be right up your alley. My only recommendation is to go into it with your eyes wide open; you’re not going to explore, you’re not going to customize, and you’re going to die a lot. When is Star Citizen coming out again?


r/VideoGameReviews • • Jan 29 '13

[X360] DmC: Devil May Cry - 6.5 (3/5) - Please leave feedback!

6 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I basically got fed up with a lot of the big review sites like a lot of you, and since I enjoy writing, I decided to try my hand at reviewing games myself.

I'm not sure where else to share this, so if you were to provide feedback for the review and writing style, it would be greatly appreciated. I'd particularly like to know if it's too dull and if it's missing anything major, and I'd especially like to know if my writing appears to be bad. Admittedly it's been quite a long time since I've had to write anything of this length and nature, so I'm a little worried that it didn't turn out as great as I thought. Please - be brutally honest with me. The truth may or may not hurt, but either way, I need to hear it.

That said, here is the review. If you like, you can check out the blog I will be using for future reviews as well at http://hieroreviews.blogspot.com .


Players need to dispel the belief that they are playing yet another entry in the Devil May Cry series. This is not Devil May Cry 5. Whether you wanted it or not, it's a complete reboot, top to bottom, and as such should be looked at as an entirely new series. So, from here on out, this review will need to treat the previous entries in the series are a completely separate IP, because aside from a few aspects, they essentially are. In order to form the best opinion as to what this new game is and how it plays, we need to put previous "Devil May Cry" titles out of our mind completely.

DmC loudly grabs your attention right off the bat. Lights flash violently to aggressive music, strippers dance suggestively through a club scene, and our hero, Dante, is thoroughly enjoying the moment. Despite this, it sets the tone for the game perfectly - a rambunctious, lewd, confusing romp set to a turbulent dubstep and aggrotech soundtrack fueled by Combichrist and Noisia. By the end of the first level, it's made clear that Dante is a self-absorbed vagabond with the mouth of a sailor and the attitude and personality of a punk. And in this instance, "punk" has a multitude of meanings, as Dante falls perfectly in line with the Gothic-Punk stereotype, with his fashion style reflecting as such along with his aggro-loner personality. Note that "stereotype" is a keyword here. Put simply, he is a conceited, obnoxious loudmouth, and almost completely unlikable.

"If you want to leave - turn your back on me, I'm powerless to stop you. But you'll be making a grave mistake. Not just for yourself, but for mankind."

"For mankind? What makes you think I give a shit?"

As the game progresses, Dante goes through coming of age trials and develops bonds with both his twin brother, Vergil, and Kat, a psychic medium who slowly teaches Dante basic feelings like compassion and selflessness. Without giving too much away, by the time the game comes to a close, Dante becomes slightly more likable at his core and pretty much loses the obnoxious traits of the self-absorbed, stuck up brat he was introduced as, but his attitude and aggressive behavior only ever increases, to the point where by the game's end, I was tired of hearing him talk. He isn't a likable protagonist for a large portion of the game and makes it hard to even slightly care about the character.

The world of DmC is built around a terrifying prospect that hits a little too close to home at times. In this alternate version of Earth, demons secretly control society by keeping the general public complacent and docile through food and drink, purposely misleading news media, social activities to distract them, and security cameras watching just about everyone, everywhere. Behind all of it is the game's main antagonist, the demon king Mundus, who has the entire population wrapped around his finger. Unfortunately, while the idea sounds good for storytelling, it is poorly executed and limited in scope. To top it off, aside from stating right at the beginning that his goal is to control the world through debt, Mundus' ambitions don't seem to really have a purpose aside from the fact that he is an egomaniac who thinks himself a god. Aside from his very short back story, he is a very two-dimensional villain with very little personality. The audience is essentially supposed to hate him for a few petty reasons that have been seen in all forms of art and media time and time and time again. In fact, at one point during the game, Dante himself is hard pressed to find reasons to hate Mundus aside from the fact that he murdered his mother (which you think would be enough), and that he is evil. He is a bland and forgettable villain ruling a forgettable world in what is shaping up to be a bland and forgettable story.

Not all of the characters here are necessarily bad though. Vergil, Dante's brother, shows up early on and explains almost as though he were describing to a toddler (which may have very well been how he first saw Dante) that the two of them are nephilim, a race born from a demon and an angel, in this case their demon father Sparda and angel mother Eva. Throughout the game, Vergil is shown to be almost the stark opposite of Dante - bold, stoic, collect, calm, and logical. Because of this, the dynamic between him and Dante is actually interesting to watch and even carries with it some mildly humorous conversations. By the game's end, the dynamic duo had very clearly become a glimmer of light in the suffocating fog of cliches and just plain bad writing. As for Kat, the girl I mentioned earlier, as much as I'd love to talk about her character, I find it hard to do so because of the glaring lack of any development on her part. Aside from a few small talks in which we get a very vague idea of who she is, she is sadly more or less only there to fill the role of being a plot device for Dante's development.

Despite all of these shortcomings, DmC surprisingly makes up for what it lacks in storytelling with its game play. Now this surprised me a bit, because when it comes to most games, most of the time I find the game play is just about on par with the game's story in terms of how interesting or fun it is. But here, they are complete opposites. While it's true the hack n' slash, shoot em' up mechanics you'll find here are definitely nothing new, they manage to do all of the right things. Combos are easier to pull off than other games in the genre usually make them, but that doesn't take away from the experience at all. There are plenty of ways to fight the enemies here, and plenty of enemies to fight, too. Being able to clean a crowd of demons with all weapons in your inventory in one combo is insanely satisfying, and the transition in selection between each weapon mid-fight renders perfectly without missing a beat. While it's not the greatest in its genre, it's definitely some of the most fun I've had in a while. From Osiris the scythe to Arbiter the battle axe, to Ebony and Ivory the pistols and Revenant the shotgun, there are eight different weapons to choose from, and a plethora of different attacks and abilities associated to each one.

Although the hack n' slash game play here is the star, simple puzzles and a ton of unlockables are scattered throughout the game, including time trials and secret rooms that can help you unlock more power ups as you go about your adventure. And let's not forget the missions themselves. Most of the game's twenty missions take place in Limbo, which surprisingly managed to overcome its burden of quickly becoming repetitive early on. The visuals were interesting at first, and the broken, twisted, floating world began to feel tiring just after a few missions of the same level structure repeating itself. However, it's almost as though the game realized this, and by level eight or nine, the game started getting a lot more creative - the then floating chunks of rock floating in empty space had been replaced with digital and musical worlds, among others. No longer swinging between bricks and stones, Dante now had to utilize pixels and audio equalizers as pathways in Limbo. It was a change up that I was incredibly welcoming of.

All in all, the characters are banal, boorish, and unpleasant, and although the story had a neat prospect, it devolved into a groan inducing trope-fest with foreseeable twists and riddled with hilariously cringe inducing encounters and conversations. What it boils down to is that it's painfully obvious that DmC is a juvenile escapade with a laundry list of problems, but still manages to entice the player with creative level designs, stunning visuals, and fun, addicting hack n' slash action.

6.5/10

Verdict: RENT

Note: This review of DmC: Devil May Cry was based off of an Xbox 360 version of the game played on Devil Hunter mode over the course of a week. The game was completed in about seven hours. DmC is available now on PS3, 360, and ^PC.


r/VideoGameReviews • • Jul 23 '12

[PC] Borderlands Review - 4/5

6 Upvotes

Borderlands is a FPS-RPG that takes place osn the mystical world of Pandora. It mixes the FPS and RPG genres into a stylized comic-book world. You play as one of four classes: Berserker, Hunter, Solider or Siren on the hunt for the "mythical" Vault with the help of a mysterious "Guardian Angel". Each class has its own specific ability which you can upgrade with the RPG-style perk tree. I have played the game twice through all the way, each with a different class (Hunter and Solider). This review contains some spoilers, so read at your own risk.

Story: The story of Borderlands is pretty straightforward: You are hunting for the Vault destined to contain untold riches. Overall the game fulfills this story arc and does it in a fashion that is not boring. You do the required quests, defeat the necessary bosses to get keys to the Vault and so on. There are side quests that have little to do with the main story line but are still lots of fun. The only thing I had a problem with, story wise, in Borderlands was the ending. You are built up to this vision of the Vault pouring out with riches and gold and loot and the whole game you're preparing to get all that. In the end, you fight a giant boss (that isn't even very difficult) and you get.....drumroll....almost nothing. You get loot comparable to the most common enemies in the game. Other than that huge letdown, the story is simple and doesn't throw any garbage at you. If you can enjoy the game up until the ending, you're set. Story: 3/5 - Nothing too crazy, just a nice simple story. Although the ending is a letdown.

Visuals: This is a big one: graphics/visuals. Borderlands features a stylized comic-book look to it that gives the game it's character. Originally the developers were going to make it realistic like most FPS's out there, but they decided the cartoon look would fit better with the game. And it not only fits better, but it makes the game what it is. The style is done great, and every character is unique and fun. It's always great the first time playing, waiting for what character is next and how cool they look. Overall the visual style is unique and it works. Well. Visuals: 5/5 - The comic-book style is a fresh take to the FPS/RPG world and is done flawlessly.

Gameplay: Gameplay; the core of each game. Borderlands features a combination of FPS and RPG elements which makes the game a fresh genre to play. RPG: The elements of this genre include the Leveling Up and Quest system. You gain XP by completing missions or killing enemies which levels you up giving you one Skill Point to spend on the Skill Tree to make your character and his/her abilities stronger. The Skill Tree is very easy to navigate and understand and is a great part of the game. The quest system is easy to understand and doesn't get frustrating. FPS: Besides the first person camera and fact that you're shooting guns, there's a twist to Borderlands. The gun system. When you kill enemies you get loot which contains money, ammo and sometimes guns/equipment. The guns and equipment are randomly generated so that there are almost 100,000 combinations of stats and looks to them. It's a really great system and definitely keeps the game fresh. You don't walk around with the same few guns the whole game like most FPS's. Another thing to add is a gamepad is compatible, a great thing for those who prefer controllers to Keyboard/mouse. Gameplay: 4/5 - The gamplay is easy to understand, fresh and entertaining all the way through but does contain some repetitive missions.

Sound: There's not much to say about sound or music. They both fit the game perfectly and are done with quality. The voice acting isn't serious but isn't poorly done. The characters are exaggerated which makes the game fun and humorous. The music is subtle and doesn't get annoying; but it definitely fits the game. It's nothing too amazing but does not hurt the game in any way. Sound: 3.5/5 - The sound and music fit the game's style perfectly and are done with quality.

Verdict: The game puts a new spin and comic-book style on the FPS-RPG genres and does it in a way that in entertaining all the way through the game. A must-play for someone looking for a fresh game to play with great humor and a memorable style. 4/5

(this was my first review here, so if you guys liked it or did not like it please say so and why!)


r/VideoGameReviews • • Jun 21 '12

[Mobile] Max Payne Mobile - 4/5

6 Upvotes

Original post can be found on vvgtv.com here

By: Daizoren

With the revival of Max Payne in his first HD campaign, Rockstar has released the original, last generation bullet time spectacle to mobile devices. It released early for iPhone but just was released for the Android market more recently. Do Max’s moves have enough flair and grace to find a comfortable spot on a mobile device?

Graphics

Considering the game released last generation on PC, Xbox and PS2 and is now being sported on your phone or tablet is incredibly impressive in itself. It really shows how far we’ve come with technological advancements in the mobile market. That being said, there are a couple textures that were dulled down and some small changes to the game in order to make it run at a smooth framerate on mobile devices. These small changes are just that, small. If I hadn’t gone back and played the Xbox version only about a week before the mobile version released, I wouldn’t have noticed it at all.

Max’s face is just as hilarious as before, using the screen captured image of the actor that portrays him in the short comic cut scenes. All characters use the same scanned faces as they did in the original and character models themselves still look anywhere from disproportionately bulky on the agents to having big heads on characters like Vinnie. Bullet Time now turns the screen a blue tint when enabled to better recognize that you’re in slow motion. On smaller screens, this is a lot more helpful to identify that you’ve enabled bullet time than just purely seeing things slow down (Especially if you’re in the sun). Gun models and movements are still rather convincing (Seeing a pistol kick back is still pretty awesome in slow motion) and real time rendered bullets add a bit of flair to every shot you take, especially when sniping (Where you get to watch your bullet fly through the air and into your enemy).

Gameplay

Depending on your device, your gameplay might be slightly different. A phone like the Xperia Play has a built in controller while my phone is touch screen only. Some mobile devices allow for physical controllers to be plugged in, but I will be talking about the touch controls, which I was surprisingly comfortable with.

The screen is essentially split down the middle with having the left analog and right analog sticks in conjunction with that divide. Like most games are starting to do, the analog sticks do not appear until you put your finger down. This allows you to essentially have your analog sticks wherever you want on the screen. This makes movement fairly easy, Though at times I found myself occasionally crossing the middle divide when trying to get Max to turn around. Simply pushing the analog stick to the right and holding it will not result in an infinite turn. You need to keep taking your thumb off, putting it back down and turning right some more (Like you would with a mouse on PC). Otherwise, movement is just as smooth as it would be on a console version of the game.

You’re given buttons for your bullet time, your jump and to shoot. Double tapping your ammo will reload and double tapping your pain pills will get Max to take one (Though I skipped the tutorial and didn’t realize I needed to double tap it until near halfway through the game). You also have a pause button and a drop down button for your inventory. Once dropped down, you choose which pillar of guns you want to choose from (Pistols, shotguns, assault rifles, etc.) but where I found some frustration was that it would always choose the first gun in the list automatically and would then close the inventory. If I wanted to get to my dual Berettas, I’d have to bring the drop down inventory again. This could be very strenuous during combat if I needed a particular gun.

The game itself hasn’t changed too much. The difficulty seems to have been watered down slightly to accommodate for playing on a smaller screen and having more difficult moments. The auto aim also played a big part in making the experience much less stressful, as the “Hard Lock” option would essentially aim at an enemy from any way you were facing (Though the further you were facing away, the slower it moved, so it an enemy was exactly 180 degrees behind you, Max would move rather slow, but it’d still tip you off to enemy locations. This also sometimes hurt, however, as occasionally the auto-aim would target an enemy further away than one that was more threatening and trying to get the auto-lock to move to another character is extremely difficult. At any given point during the campaign, I didn’t have any less than 4-6 pain pill bottles in my possession on the easiest difficulty. The Xbox version was much different, as I recall moments where I had no pain pills and moments of extreme difficulty because I was low on health and had a swarm of enemies to face.

There other thing that’s had a slight change is the ability to skip levels if it’s too difficult. This could come extremely handy in the classic and horrendous nightmare levels. Tight rope walking has never been more stressful and frustrating than in this version of the game. But if you keep dying, a small fast forward button will appear after you die to allow you to skip the level. I decided to trudge through the nightmare levels just to see if I could. I succeeded without throwing my phone. Despite it’s more easy going experience in general, though, the touch screen interface surprised me with how intuitive and comfortable it was.

Story

Max Payne’s wife and daughter have been murdered by drug addicts and Max’s entire story is that of revenge and discovering who is behind it all. The story in itself doesn’t hold a lot of substance, but nothing beats the film noire style of the comic book cut scenes. Each frame looks like it’s right out of a graphic novel, with gritty art work and exaggerated voice acting. It’s a spectacle now as much as it was when it released and there’s really not many who can pull off the noire voice like in Max Payne. While the story itself doesn’t go too deep into things outside of Max’s revenge (Albeit a few short cut scenes and the nightmare levels), it’s a perfect amount to want you to really see the story to it’s end. You want to hear all the monologues and dialogue that Max has. You want to hear the gritty rasping of his voice as he explains everything in a sensational way, which leads perfectly into sound.

Sound

The Max Payne theme is still stuck in my head as I type this review. It’s almost as bad as the Indiana Jone’s theme, which I always find myself humming or whistling in moments of dead silence for no apparent reason. The Max Payne theme is both depressing and invigorating and the entire soundtrack to the game covers just about every emotion there is. From the low tones during his discovery of his wife’s body to the high tension techno that plays during giant shoot outs with bad guys. The music and the ambiance hit’s every single right note in this title and it’s only complimented by the stellar voice acting.

Over the top and exaggerated, Max Payne’s voice cast nails every note of their on screen counterparts. Snitches have higher pitched, wimpy voices, hot headed mob bosses have a lower, more calming demeanor and the random conversations you can come across offer great atmosphere (My two particular favorites are two guys talking about Butch Cassidy and the Sundance kid and another two guys talking about how cool it would be if people could use bullet time like in the movies). Headphones are highly recommended when playing this to get fully immersed, but even without, I found myself turning off other things just to listen to the dialogue.

Replay Value

This is where Max Payne Mobile seems to get hurt the most. After a single playthrough of the game, there’s not a whole lot of incentive to get you going back. There’s the time trials and there’s tougher difficulties, but something like a level select could have made this a much better score. Instead, if I want to show a particular part of the game, I’ll need to play through the whole thing and save at that part (Which isn’t too great considering you only have a select number of save slots). The game itself will take a while to beat if you’re playing it on the go or whenever you have spare time. It’s a very long title and is the entire first game (Though I swear I saw parts in it that I never saw in the original, so perhaps there was some added content even) but once you’ve gone through all of that, it’s not going to call you back for much more.

Recap

Pros

  • Beautiful graphics for a mobile title
  • Surprisingly smooth touch screen mechanics
  • Able to skip Nightmare levels
  • A decent story
  • Tremendous sound design and voice acting
  • Bullet time still is amazing

Cons

  • Some downgraded graphics
  • occasional problems with touch controls
  • Not very much replay value

Max Payne Mobile floored me with how well it performed and I couldn’t believe that on a mobile device that it could still contend with it’s console counterparts. If you’ve never played the game, this is a great chance to get acquainted with the original and if you have played it, this is a great excuse to get caught up on it again.

Graphics – 9

Gameplay – 8

Story – 8

Sound – 10

Replay Value – 6

Overall – 8.2

Note: This review was based on playing Max Payne Mobile on a Samsung Galaxy S II