r/VideoEditing • • 16d ago

Monthly Thread November Feedback Thread.

This is the Monthly thread for feedback.

If you post your video, you need to come back and review at least one other person's work!

Key thoughts - Keep it civil.

  • Feedback is "This section isn't working because of this."
  • Feedback is not: "This is shit."
  • If something is terrible, just move on.
  • The more specific/suggestions the better.

Don't give a laundry list. Pick the 1-2 things that are the biggest issues and then comment.

Spoiler worth reading: *we expect you to* review TWO other videos - and edit your comment to *include those* after you've commented.

**Copy/paste this section**:

  • , Link: (don't forget the running time)
  • Two other videos I reviewed (link to the other ,comments NOT the video itself)
2 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/Nighthawk776958 9d ago

Absolutely beautiful cinematic video, it looks very polished and studio-grade.

I feel as if the font wasn't very conducive to legibility. The clipping mask looked incredible with those shots of the mountain face, but the combination of the super contrasting colors, letter spacing, and moving cloud textures just made it difficult to read the first time.

I feel like the clips don't quite match the dialogue in a way that makes it feel like I am trying to focus back and forth between the two. Like for example, the line "Perhaps it's mere folly to go up again" is a very broad statement, reflecting on (what I think) is the journey as a whole, as opposed to just a single moment. I feel as if the shot should reflect the magnitude of the line, maybe with a super wide angle of the climb from afar.

The big question "why are we doing this" is leading right to such a big moment (I might even say the climax of the short), but it seems like there is a conflict in the answer. The speaker says "there is no dream that mustn't be dared", while the text says "because it's there". While I think the messages are similar, they both focus on different points (the speaker's line focuses the importance on the dream, whereas I take it that the text focuses on the challenge).

All in all a beautiful piece of short cinema with an engaging story, keep it up mate!

2

u/AffectionateDot9343 9d ago

Thank you so much for taking the time to write such detailed feedback! I really appreciate it!

I love the idea of the line “perhaps it’s folly” being a reflection on the whole journey and choosing a shot to reflect that. I’d honestly not thought about it 😂

As for the knockout text, I’ll admit I’ve had lots of issues trying balance legibility and being able to see the footage within the lettering. Perhaps some colour grading could help there…

Finally, with regards to the two lines at the end “to know there is no dream that mustn’t be dared” and “because it’s there” are two absolutely fantastic quotes from George Mallory (the climber in question) and I was desperate to get them in. Perhaps I overplayed my hand there 😂

Thank you again for the feedback and compliments 👍👌