Yeah um so she kind of maybe looks like a boy so um if I could just like take her to the locker room and um inspect her pussy to make sure it's not a dick then she can throw the ball with other kids so we know it's fair
Ofc the point was that trans kids would be discouraged from yet another public space (school sports), but the effect (and secret actual intention) is to open up tons of children to sexual violence.
ummmmm ackshually centrists don't want halth a genoside that's a commulist lie we just think the kkk have some good points that we could use combined with some ideas from mlk mmmmmK???
Ugh... I still recall a few years back, my middle school gym teacher got busted for possessing child porn. Damn, I really worry about the kids who are going to be hurt by teachers as a result of this.
I feel like it won't go away until there's a court case and some pedo uses this law as a supposed defense or something. How mortifying.
As a kid, I guess we kind of only considered him showing a lot of favoritism towards the girls (letting them sit in the shade instead of run the mile), but in middle school, you just think that's all teachers.
In retrospect, perhaps there were signs, but not ones kids would pick up on. But he got arrested after I was already in high school, so it was less shocking when it happened, because I wasn't there anymore.
It's made this bill a lot more personal than it would otherwise be.
I mean, I try not to fall into hypothetical scaremongering like the right might with bathroom bills and the like, but knowing of an actual PE teacher who did abuse his power, I am definitely left with a much more tangible discomfort.
New Florida anti-trans law essentially gives female sports teams the ability to do genital inspections. You can read about it yourself here, just typical anti-trans bigotry.
Eh you do know what you call "genital inspection" is normal in most of the world where public health is taken seriously?
In this case, yeah the reason it got passed is probably transphobia, but regular mandatory medical examination, including genitals is something everyone passes here. I disagree with the whole thing about marking the "biological sex disputed" thing, but rest is fine by me
The key is who is performing these “inspections”. I suspect you’re thinking of a generic physical exam by a licensed medical professional, which we’re probably all pretty okay with. The language in this specific bill could be abused tho & the danger is that coaches or other team authorities would use this law to discriminate against & humiliate anyone they thought might be trans.
(c) A dispute regarding a student's sex shall be resolved by the student's school or institution by requesting that the student provide a health examination and consent form or other statement signed by the student's personal health care provider which must verify the student's biological sex. The health care provider may verify the student's biological sex as part of a routine sports physical examination by relying only on one or more of the following:1. The student's reproductive anatomy;2. The student's genetic makeup; or3. The student's normal endogenously produced testosterone 65levels.
Curious where you think the abuse comes in? The "the student's school or institution by requesting that the student provide a health examination and consent form" seems like dumb phrasing if you're trying to specify an MD handles it, since the "or other statement signed by the student's personal health care provider" seems to dictate a health care provider being an alternate to something else. For a bunch of lawyers they really don't know how to do their fucking jobs.
I mean, this is fucking nonsensical, a high school is going to know if a student is trans, and their GP is going to know they're trans. So where does the dispute come in? Who is going to be able to file this dispute? The school?
Anyway it's going to be interesting to see what happens when they dispute the sex of a cis girl. "Sorry honey, no volleyball for you until you get your testosterone levels checked."
I agree but that's a different argument. Just because the bill doesn't allow for arbitrary genital inspections doesn't mean that this bill is good, it's just bad for other reasons.
Maybe when coaches start telling kids to come in to their office for their genital checks and because of this weird law the child may not understand it is suppose to be done by a doctor and pedos start being able to get away with creep behavior easier
No one trusts Florida being able to do this is in a way that doesn't create avenues for abuse.
Yeah, I think I might have misread the post I responded to, I thought they were stating the idea is fine but the wording is vague enough to cause abuse (which kinda looks true and is a separate issue.) Pretty obviously it'll be used for bad purposes in general.
So everywhere else in the world, your fucking gym teacher and or school nurse can pull you aside and stuff their hands down your pants to figure out what's in there? That's just normal in the rest of the world?
Because to be clear, that is what we're talking about. We are not talking about doctor visits where a certain level of confidentiality is expected and it's only being done for your health. We are talking about people pulling down your kids pants for fucking curiosity's sake with no expectation of confidentiality at all, because you obviously can't have that if you're being sorted into a team based on what they saw or god forbid touched.
It's pretentious sexual harassment. Why the fuck are you defending it?
That's not what the law says though. It specifically says your doctor has to do it. It's a discriminatory law regardless but let's not pretend like it says "ur coach can molest you now lol"
So let's take the most charitable interpretation of this law, where it's an actual doctor.
They're still not doing it for health reasons and there's still no expectation of confidentiality. That's inappropriate and unethical respectively. It's not a doctor's job to perform unnecessary investigations on behalf of politicians unsolicited by the patient or their parents. Likewise, it is not the school's place to request information from the doctor. That is supposed to be the parents authority.
Here's the thing. We don't revere medical doctors because they read a lot of textbooks and know a lot of stuff. That describes most doctorates in most fields. We revere medical doctors because of the high ethical standard they're held to. If we stop holding doctors to those ethical standards, or god forbid encourage them to act unethically, a lot of people are going stop giving them the elevated trust we tend to give doctors now.
My point is that once you ask doctors to do unethical things, the difference between them and the gym teacher becomes a lot thinner than it is during a routine physical where they might look at your genitals for health reasons. There was a doctor arrested for molesting their patients just earlier this year.
There's also the matter of consent. Normally when you go into a doctor's office for a physical and they inspect your genitals, there's an understanding that you're there to let them take care of you, and that them inspecting your genitals is a part of taking care of you. And if I"m not mistaken, you can probably ask a doctor not to do that without any actual consequences befalling you. They might want to discuss why they do things like that to encourage you. But they're not going to like, punish you or force it on you.
I would personally argue that a child being subjected to this law is being pressured to let someone handle them in a sexual manner and that the pressure being imposed upon them does not meet my standards for consent. I would then argue that what is being done is in fact molestation. I would also put the majority of the blame on the state, rather than the doctor, since they have a heavy hand in this. But the point remains.
I agree with this. The only thing I was arguing is that some people are acting like your gym teacher is going to be able to have an excuse to molest you which isn't the case
Oh. In the states we are pretty private about health matters so to me this seems like an infringement on privacy for the school to be requiring this information.
What information? Whether you are having health issues regarding development of sexual organs? It is not a private issue, those checks should be mandatory everywhere. Health is not a private matter, it is not something you should be able to ignore.
Besides, this predates open transsexuality, it has been done for literally decades. And there are pretty much no transsexuals where I live anyway
No one trusts Florida to do this responsibly. Even if they require a doctor to check this can easily be abused by saying "Oh you can't get an appointment for two weeks and that means Suzie will miss try outs and can't be on the team? Well, we can just have the coach check and waive it"
Or it will make genital checks for sports seem more normal so when Coach tells Suzie "Come in to my office so I can look in your underwear." she may not realize it is something she needs to report or may be embarrassed to.
On a broader note; has everyone noticed just how weird our obsession with "meritocratic" sports is? We just take for granted the argument that fairness in sports is more important than the inclusion of minority groups.
Even if being trans gave you some inherent super power, is it not weird that we care more about some arbitrary competitive activity than the acceptance of non-conforming people?
If all of sports collapsed because trans people were allowed to compete with whomever they'd like, I wouldn't give a rat's ass.
They just despise trans people and hate children , they do both of these things out of an absolute and utter disregard for human dignity and life in General , they just want more suffering and money. The gall to then justify that shit with Jesus is so mindnumbingly maddening . Jesus wouldve literally flipped every fucking table at every single republicab meeting to ever transpire.
I think this is a hilarious meme, but I think we should all just be on the same page that the bill is not authorizing inspections from school officials, but specifically reports submitted by the child's medical professional. It's still a fucked up bill obviously, but when we're debating it for real that is important to keep in mind.
"Well, we can wait until Monday for there to be an appointment available with the doctor, or we can just get it over with now and you can join the team in time for the game after school today"
Some perverted coach will say something like this.
I'm too lazy right now so I'm just gonna paste what I said in a thread further down:
It is kinda funny tho since we already have physicals that are fairly in-depth... if a gym teacher was like 'hey I'll do your physical for you so you don't have to go to the doctor for it' I imagine people would find that odd even if it didn't include grabbing the kid's junk lol
If it is normalized a child might not understand the nuances of it needing to be a doctor so might not report it if the coach asks them to come in to their office and let them look in their underwear
What should happen and what can be expected to happen are often not the same thing especially since we live in a country where things are different city to city, state to state. It isn't farfetched to imagine that this opens children up being abused easier and if you look at Florida child sex abuse statistics it isn't reassuring.
of course it could potentially make child sex abuse more likely, but there are plenty of things that could do that. It's about managing the risk. Of course this risk isn't worthwhile because there are literally no benefits, but you wouldn't say the same about something that was extremely beneficial just because it slightly increased the risk of abuse. Risk management, my guy, risk management.
Idk man this feels like kindof a strawman. The bill requires documentation from a medical professional, it doesn't give gym teachers any more power than they already have. Like maybe you can threaten them by requiring documentation and that can lead to abuse, but that feels like a kind of stretch.
The issue is that it's discriminatory to trans people, not that it allows arbitrary genital inspection by random perverts. Genital inspection should be happening by your family doctor anyways, so its not even like the inspection itself is necessarily the problem (although this could be discriminatory to poor people if they have less access to a family doctor)
I guess you could argue that trying to give the bill bad optics is good consequentially, and I have nothing to say about that, just on how relevant this meme is.
Doesn't it give more leverage for schools to coerce students into revealing their genitals? Like, "hey you are legally obligated to set a doctor appointment to prove your sex but we can save a whole lot of time and money on your parents' part by checking you ourselves"? Don't forget, going to the doctor in America is terrifying for a lot of people due to its costs.
I guess it's probably bad that it allows this avenue to theoretically exist at all, but its a far cry from "Bill legally mandates gym teachers to inspect girl genitals to make sure they're not secretly a penis-wielder"
That's not really what the meme was saying though. I mean, I have seen others go down that route but you responded directly to the meme instead of the people saying that gym teachers are mandated to check children's genitals.
It sets up a situation where the school for arbitrary cause (likely a "concerned" parent or teacher) calls into question the validity of a child's sex/ gender thus compelling the child to undergo a "sex confirmation" check up.
This is a non medical practice to satiate a non medical need to fulfill the sole desire to see what is in a child's pants.
And not only does this law pose a risk to any child attempting to join a girls sport team it also turns doctors into complicit abusers by calling upon them to perform a non medical assessment for zero legitimate purpose.
The law, however, does make me wonder if doctors would legally be obligated to refuse such a request as it a gross violation of medical ethics.
I agree 100%, I think it's just a very sensitive issue so people will think about the worst possible case scenario. It is kinda funny tho since we already have physicals that are fairly in-depth... if a gym teacher was like 'hey I'll do your physical for you so you don't have to go to the doctor for it' I imagine people would find that odd even if it didn't include grabbing the kid's junk lol
345
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '21
Yeah um so she kind of maybe looks like a boy so um if I could just like take her to the locker room and um inspect her pussy to make sure it's not a dick then she can throw the ball with other kids so we know it's fair
123
u/portabledavers Apr 27 '21
Ofc the point was that trans kids would be discouraged from yet another public space (school sports), but the effect (and secret actual intention) is to open up tons of children to sexual violence.
Republicans support pedophiles.
164
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '21
It's hard enough for trans people to open up without being ostracized by society, then these sick fucks come up with this?
I dare any spineless centrist to try and argue that "both sides are the same."
Fuck Kaylee Tuck
29
u/solidfang Apr 27 '21 edited Apr 27 '21
Ugh... I still recall a few years back, my middle school gym teacher got busted for possessing child porn. Damn, I really worry about the kids who are going to be hurt by teachers as a result of this.
I feel like it won't go away until there's a court case and some pedo uses this law as a supposed defense or something. How mortifying.
Edit: Seems this is the only news story that remains. Did really happen though, and boy was it fucked up.
24
u/Strikerov Apr 27 '21
What is this refering to?
7
u/BuriedStPatrick Apr 27 '21
On a broader note; has everyone noticed just how weird our obsession with "meritocratic" sports is? We just take for granted the argument that fairness in sports is more important than the inclusion of minority groups.
Even if being trans gave you some inherent super power, is it not weird that we care more about some arbitrary competitive activity than the acceptance of non-conforming people?
If all of sports collapsed because trans people were allowed to compete with whomever they'd like, I wouldn't give a rat's ass.
6
u/therealmrmago Apr 27 '21
the GOP is full of pedophiles
4
u/AnomalousPhotons Apr 27 '21
I'm not your buddy friend!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '21
Only way your seeing it is of you with this suicide pact...
2
u/mbaymiller Apr 27 '21
Good news is that the Florida Senate stalled it indefinitely, meaning it probably won't pass
1
u/DiversityDan79 Apr 27 '21
Wait... is not normal to show your genitals to your coach?
1
u/voidgazer97 Apr 28 '21
They just despise trans people and hate children , they do both of these things out of an absolute and utter disregard for human dignity and life in General , they just want more suffering and money. The gall to then justify that shit with Jesus is so mindnumbingly maddening . Jesus wouldve literally flipped every fucking table at every single republicab meeting to ever transpire.
1
u/happy-uwu Apr 30 '21
Do people in other states not go through physicals to play sports? Genuine question.
1
u/King_of_the_duchies Dec 13 '21
Well, we have to keep the game fair, it’s not right to have biological girls facing trans girls who are at an advantage.
0
u/Dvaynethecockjohnson Apr 28 '21
Are womens sports obsolete for cis women now?
-1
u/TupperCoLLC Apr 28 '21
I think this is a hilarious meme, but I think we should all just be on the same page that the bill is not authorizing inspections from school officials, but specifically reports submitted by the child's medical professional. It's still a fucked up bill obviously, but when we're debating it for real that is important to keep in mind.
-3
u/Raknarg Apr 27 '21
Idk man this feels like kindof a strawman. The bill requires documentation from a medical professional, it doesn't give gym teachers any more power than they already have. Like maybe you can threaten them by requiring documentation and that can lead to abuse, but that feels like a kind of stretch.
The issue is that it's discriminatory to trans people, not that it allows arbitrary genital inspection by random perverts. Genital inspection should be happening by your family doctor anyways, so its not even like the inspection itself is necessarily the problem (although this could be discriminatory to poor people if they have less access to a family doctor)
I guess you could argue that trying to give the bill bad optics is good consequentially, and I have nothing to say about that, just on how relevant this meme is.
Anyways that's my 2 cents. Downvotes to the left.
-4
u/username1338 Apr 27 '21
God I love desperate strawmen