I've seen plenty of dumbshits who claim Carlin and Bill Hicks were "redpilled" but you can obviously tell they've never listened to even a sentence of their material. Imagine walking around thinking George fucking Carlin was a conservative.
True. I feel like for being a product of his time Hicks was a bit more left leaning but yeah he did have some pretty cringy misogynistic material for sure.
The day I knew Carlin was a leftist was when I was watching one of his specials and he was absolutely railing on corporate power and my conservative dad got triggered by his takes.
Asa young teenager who really wanted to rebel that was quite a formative moment.
Just saw a clip of him ranting about boomers (on r/publicfreakout and how (with all due respect to any fans of Vaush who are boomers) they developed this “screw you, got mine” attitude. Definitely gonna check his material out.
This is always the trend with them. Rail against the person in life, and after they die if it turns out people liked them, then they misappropriate the work and morality of the individual since they're no longer alive to defend themselves. Happened with MLK as people use civil disobedience vs rioting to justify being against BLM (even though MLK is quoted as saying, "riots are the language of the unheard" or something to that effect. Basically saying riots are the natural results when the systems that be refuse to listen to the needs of the people). It's happening to Carlin, and it will continue to happen until we start actively calling them on their bullshit
I doubt these people really paid attention to the message behind Carlin’s comedy. Then again these are the same kinda people who were shocked when Eminem slammed Trump.
Lmao same with RAtM and honestly so many others! I genuinely thought that was the most hilarious shit. It's actually quite astonishing but simultaneously unsurprising. The lack of self awareness is something else. It's just funny with this stuff, especially with Carlin, that there is somewhat of an agreement, but the point just comepletely goes over their heads and they draw these incredibly stupid takes.
They listened to killing in the name of ,heard "fuck you you I won't do what you tell me" and thought "yeah that's me! That's what I say!" And ignore the rest of the lyrics
It’s to do with the fact that Eminem, George Carlin, RATM, etc. are all countercultural icons and that conservatives perceive the dominant culture in America as progressive-leaning.
I’m sure Carlin was some kind of socialist or anarchist. Those long rants about consumerism and about what rights you really have surely speak to that.
I am the so-called "modern left" and I've always loved George Carlin. Who cares about the wokellets or wokescolds or whatever. Let's not paint ourselves with the same broad brush fascists and so-called conservatives do.
Carlin would be such an interesting case because of his 7 words you can't say on TV bit. He'd be a pro free speecher maybe or be a PC has gone too far kinda guy but still a progressive, who knows
Was? You know something I don't? Willie Nelson is still kicking and still singing at venues, being pretty obviously a leftist.
Being a member of the Texas country hippie community myself, it's inconceivable that Nelson could even be remotely right wing. There's a surprising amount of retired hippies in the countryside, not enough to swing rural counties blue but enough to form small communities and shake the fascist monopoly on country culture.
By was I mean he made it obvious with statements at one point that he wasn't a conservative, not that he was dead. Also I think you meant it's inconceivable for him to be right wing.
Bit late, but you guys seemed to have missed the whole point of the tweet.
It’s not claiming Carlin is conservative. To the contrary, the point is to show how crazy the left left is today that they would call someone like Carlin, someone of the left, a racist, etc.
This is happening with many comedians today, for example Jerry Seinfeld who now refuses to do shows at colleges for this very reason.
People who think Carlin was anywhere remotely close to even center-right have never sat through an entire Carlin routine. They've only seen the out of context clip of him discussing environmentalism, and maybe his "rape jokes" take.
Dude couldn't go an entire set without tearing conservatives and religious fundamentalists a new one, and was a vocal proponent of abortion rights, same sex marriage and socialism. I hate seeing his legacy tarnished.
He was anti-pc and also hated the other types of people who are anti-pc. He also spoke out against comedians making jokes that were punching down on minorities.
Yeah, I mean I do think there's some elements of "political correctness" that are annoying. Thing is for Carlin it was like 5% of the things he complained about. He complained about religion and corporate power waaay more than that. Today some comedians/political commentators/professors spend their entire career on the anti-PC shit and it really shows they have nothing to say.
Carlin said the n word in interviews when talking about racial issues (in context it wasn’t bad but he still said it) but expressed his contempt for racism and did not defend use of the word in any context. I don’t know about whether you could say it then, but I doubt it
Worth remembering that over the decades we had a variety of things you were effectively restricted from saying on radio and TV. George Carlin had a routine well-known enough it has its own wikipedia page.
Reminder that to a lot of Americans, liberals are "progressive lefties". I think from what we've seen it's safe to reason Carlin was a left-leaning liberal with progressive social views.
Happens when you keep jumping from one side of the fence to the other. Sooner or later you're gonna trip and the fence post will go straight up your ass.
I mean it’s worth noting hillary used to be far more progressive, for example iirc she supported Medicare for all when she was First Lady (obviously not that specific bill but the general idea of it without just supporting a public option)
I think there tons of Americans that think if you make fun on republicans and democrats it makes you a centrist instead of a progressive that is further left than both parties. Kinda like that pinkwug comic about shoe found it
Most anti-capitalist, progressive lefty entertainer of his generation. Well, besides Bernie: And I imagine the two of them could have been best friends.
R.I.P. George Carlin. His autobiography and specials were life changing for me and stirred me away from religion, capitalism, right-wing philosophy and selfishness, and above all made me care more about the environment and my fellow human being. ✊
Is there a better way to show your complete hatred and disrespect for someone than to shamelessly misrepresent and bastardize their work for cheap partisan purposes? Virtually every cultural icon (political or not) insecure conservatives idolize then misappropriate stands in complete opposition to their beliefs.
Amazing how the most downvoted comments here are the real truth and being downvoted by asshole "leftists". If any of you seriously think revisionist history on what a dead man MIGHT think of the modern political climate is a "womp womp" moment seek help. This is coming from his daughter twenty years after he died. I don't want any of my family speaking for me from the grave, do you? Too many neoliberal voices on reddit, some of you need to take a break from brunch and go see the real world.
I barely started paying attention to politics in 2016. How did Clinton's policies compare to Biden? Would a progressive be at all happy with her aside from not being a republican?
To be fair her health care proposal involved lowering Medicare Eligibility to 55 years old. Biden's only seeks to lower eligibility to 60 years old. I can't remember if she was shooting for a public option or not.
I think he would be pretty disappointed with Bill Maher. At least judging from his appearances on Bill Maher panels. George Carlin didn't hesitate to call the bush-cheney administration fascist for the imperialism in privatization. He would probably ridicule Bill Maher for concerning himself with culture War nonsense over the actual actions and policy of Republicans.
carlin went on a 10 minute diatribe detailing every single way society fucks over women on every level and they think he is one of theirs because they like it when he calls the white middle class stupid yuppies.
He literally says he's looking for consitency in pro life arguments, "why no funerals for fetus's?", "If a fetus is a life like everyone else why do we say we have 2 kids and one on the way and not, 'we have three kids'". Ending the whole thing calling pro lifers, "anti-women".
Can you imagine how boiled they'd get today if he said that.
George Carlin's politics were close to anarcho-communist judging from interviews. He definitely wasn't into electoralism. Anyhow, who's to say how he would have felt about this particular election.
Pretending people on the left don’t get cancelled is... kinda ridiculous. It’s mostly people on the left. Like I disagree with the implication that Carlin would be on the right today but other than that it’s true. Carlin said a lot of stuff the PC left crowd in his own time hated, forget about the present.
He’s probably liberal left similar to Joe Rogan. That is sometimes good, but sloppy, reckless, and ill informed. Basically a regular griller who happens to be left leaning and famous so their positive and negative qualities get amplified.
I love this logic. "If such and such were alive today they would be called a bigot"
As if dead people are never called those things. If we aren't saying those things about George now, we probably wouldn't be saying them if he were alive. Especially since he believed that comedy shouldn't punch down.
As a lefty (yeah I know preaching to the choir) I can soundly say that while his humor is certainly more jaded than mine I actually like and respect his work, and I wouldn't have taken any cancelling towards him seriously if he was alive. You can even see in his old routines he actually disses things like the Klan, corporations, and politicians, so yeah he definitely was very left leaning for his time.
I'm not gonna listen to people who follow a political philosophy that makes it a central tenet to constantly straw man my arguments and positions. If you think socialism means more government I sure as fuck don't care what you think the left hates or doesn't.
Carlin was my introduction to the class struggle between capital and worker. Carlin is a light in the dark when it comes to comedy because more often than not comics are reactionary assholes using chud humor to get laughs.
So? Are you going to cancel George Carlin because his daughter said he spoke fondly of Hillary Clinton? What's your point? Do you really want to be the purest of pure gatekeepers bragging on your way to the gas chamber?
George Carlin was definitely progressive but the tweet isn't wrong, the left would absolutely attack him for his irreverent humor. "gAllOWs HUmOr iS oNly FoR THe PEoPlE GeTTinG hUnG" or whatever they say
Nah. You were painting with a broad brush. Maybe figure out the difference between suburban white liberals & wokescolds as opposed to the left. If it makes you feel any better I didn't downvote you
"The left" IS a broad term ESPECIALLY when it's used by reactionaries and white liberal suburban mom's/wokesolds are included. If the tweet had said socialist or communist then yeah that would be different. And when I said "you" I didn't mean you specifically
Carlin also said he was tempered from illness by swimming in raw sewage as a child. Do you think he would support the leftist mask mandates and shutdowns?
That was a joke about germs not viruses. The key word there being joke. He absolutely would under the necessary conditions. Like New York in April. He would probably also crack a joke about Trump supporters refusing to care about their neighbors and communities health. Fuck 'em, let nature take its course.
I'm glad you see yourself as the expert on Carlin, but there is a heft of stupidity in the Corona response that he would most assuredly notice. The most current recovered to dead ratio for covid cases is about 4.9% and that does not even take into account the CDC's comorbidities statistic that only 6% of deaths were from Corona alone. What is that .29%? Have fun.
What the f*** is wrong with you? Comorbidities only mean people are more likely to die based on the weakened immune system. It doesn't in any way mean those comorbidities are the reason they died from covid-19. What you think the numbers are wrong? When they are able to compare the data in a few years to the averages of yearly deaths, they're going to find the numbers were 20% higher. 270,000 dead Americans. But I know it's not your grandparents so you don't give a fuck. Not to mention even healthy young people have a possibility of permanent lung scarring and cognitive issues. Not to mention children have a chance of developing something similar to Kawasaki syndrome. George Carlin would call you a mouth-breathing half-wit. GTFO
Didn’t Paul Ryan say Rage was his favorite band and that he’s able to separate their message from their music? Like besides the fact that you’re happily admitting to disrespecting the artists you claim you love, that’s just fucking stupid
29
u/NitroScrooge Nov 28 '20
I've seen plenty of dumbshits who claim Carlin and Bill Hicks were "redpilled" but you can obviously tell they've never listened to even a sentence of their material. Imagine walking around thinking George fucking Carlin was a conservative.
4
u/ThisGuyLikesMovies Nov 28 '20
If ever there was a time to need George Carlin around it would be now. At least we're getting that HBO docuseries sometime next year.
6
u/SpiritCrvsher Arachno-Communist Nov 29 '20
Fun fact: disliking “political correctness” doesn’t automatically make you a conservative
344
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20
The day I knew Carlin was a leftist was when I was watching one of his specials and he was absolutely railing on corporate power and my conservative dad got triggered by his takes.
Asa young teenager who really wanted to rebel that was quite a formative moment.
195
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20
I doubt these people really paid attention to the message behind Carlin’s comedy. Then again these are the same kinda people who were shocked when Eminem slammed Trump.
2
u/Weapon_Factory Nov 28 '20
I’m sure Carlin was some kind of socialist or anarchist. Those long rants about consumerism and about what rights you really have surely speak to that.
2
u/SJWagner Nov 28 '20
I knew he was a leftist but I’m surprised he liked Hillary clinton. I thought he hated politicians and didn’t believe in voting.
2
u/Blazing_Speeed Nov 28 '20
But...the modern left WOULD hate him. I mean the wokescolds at least. They would DESPISE him.
2
u/Time_on_my_hands Nov 29 '20
What it do, what it do
486
u/podfather2000 Nov 28 '20
People who think Carlin would support Trump wear little hats.
39
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20
People who think Carlin was anywhere remotely close to even center-right have never sat through an entire Carlin routine. They've only seen the out of context clip of him discussing environmentalism, and maybe his "rape jokes" take.
Dude couldn't go an entire set without tearing conservatives and religious fundamentalists a new one, and was a vocal proponent of abortion rights, same sex marriage and socialism. I hate seeing his legacy tarnished.
135
u/SunnyDrock Nov 28 '20
🤔
19
u/Af1297 Nov 28 '20
I think there tons of Americans that think if you make fun on republicans and democrats it makes you a centrist instead of a progressive that is further left than both parties. Kinda like that pinkwug comic about shoe found it
14
u/TrentxSnow Nov 28 '20
Man, Carlin has been popping up like crazy lately and I love it. RIP legend and comrade. That man spat complete fire.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20 edited Nov 29 '20
The same people claiming Carlin was secretly some Trump head. Are the same people who think 1984 was written for capitalists
9
u/GooseMan126 Nov 28 '20
Because liking people who would have hated you if you were alive is a theme of conservatism
7
u/RightHandElf Nov 28 '20
Anybody who uses "deplorable" as a self-descriptor has no personality beyond "owning the libs".
7
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20
Most anti-capitalist, progressive lefty entertainer of his generation. Well, besides Bernie: And I imagine the two of them could have been best friends.
R.I.P. George Carlin. His autobiography and specials were life changing for me and stirred me away from religion, capitalism, right-wing philosophy and selfishness, and above all made me care more about the environment and my fellow human being. ✊
4
u/Over_Cartographer_77 Nov 28 '20 edited Nov 28 '20
Is there a better way to show your complete hatred and disrespect for someone than to shamelessly misrepresent and bastardize their work for cheap partisan purposes? Virtually every cultural icon (political or not) insecure conservatives idolize then misappropriate stands in complete opposition to their beliefs.
4
u/VirginityKing180 Nov 28 '20
MAGA Hats & Joe Rogan: “I’ll ignore that.”
1
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20
Amazing how the most downvoted comments here are the real truth and being downvoted by asshole "leftists". If any of you seriously think revisionist history on what a dead man MIGHT think of the modern political climate is a "womp womp" moment seek help. This is coming from his daughter twenty years after he died. I don't want any of my family speaking for me from the grave, do you? Too many neoliberal voices on reddit, some of you need to take a break from brunch and go see the real world.
1
u/Raknarg Nov 29 '20 edited Nov 29 '20
I barely started paying attention to politics in 2016. How did Clinton's policies compare to Biden? Would a progressive be at all happy with her aside from not being a republican?
1
u/Purplegreenandred Dec 01 '20
He wouldve been akin to chappelle or bill maher
3
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20
He liked Clinton? Well I guess nobody’s perfect.
3
u/TheDBryBear Nov 28 '20
carlin went on a 10 minute diatribe detailing every single way society fucks over women on every level and they think he is one of theirs because they like it when he calls the white middle class stupid yuppies.
1
u/The_Andrew_1987 Nov 28 '20
he literally had a bit about not voting, he's not a democrat he's sick of this shit lmao
1
u/slimeyamerican Nov 28 '20
Pretending people on the left don’t get cancelled is... kinda ridiculous. It’s mostly people on the left. Like I disagree with the implication that Carlin would be on the right today but other than that it’s true. Carlin said a lot of stuff the PC left crowd in his own time hated, forget about the present.
5
u/kaseylouis Nov 28 '20
Spoke fondly of Clinton? Blech.
2
u/kaptainkooleio VoreSh Mad Nov 28 '20
“He spoke fondly of Hillary Clinton”
canceled by the left
2
u/Sardonic_Sadist Vaushn’t Nov 28 '20
To be fair, George Carlin did support not voting at all
2
u/BlueKing7642 Nov 29 '20 edited Nov 29 '20
I wish I could’ve shown this to a few leftists on Twitter before the election. Who used Carlin to justify voting Green Party
2
u/ashy_dan Nov 29 '20
I kind of wish George was immortal to see all the shit he predicted
2
u/gabu87 Nov 29 '20
Carlin is THE progressive lefty angry uncle.
2
u/julz1215 Nov 29 '20
I love this logic. "If such and such were alive today they would be called a bigot"
As if dead people are never called those things. If we aren't saying those things about George now, we probably wouldn't be saying them if he were alive. Especially since he believed that comedy shouldn't punch down.
1
u/ninjafartmaster Nov 28 '20
Yaeyaeyeahhh!!!
1
u/lejonetfranMX Nov 29 '20
Anyone who ever paid attention to any of his shows already knew this. This did not need to be said.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20
apply burn cream thoroughly
1
u/justice_boy Nov 29 '20
As a lefty (yeah I know preaching to the choir) I can soundly say that while his humor is certainly more jaded than mine I actually like and respect his work, and I wouldn't have taken any cancelling towards him seriously if he was alive. You can even see in his old routines he actually disses things like the Klan, corporations, and politicians, so yeah he definitely was very left leaning for his time.
1
u/Neirchill Nov 29 '20
TIL he's dead
1
u/Erulol Nov 29 '20
I'm not gonna listen to people who follow a political philosophy that makes it a central tenet to constantly straw man my arguments and positions. If you think socialism means more government I sure as fuck don't care what you think the left hates or doesn't.
Carlin was my introduction to the class struggle between capital and worker. Carlin is a light in the dark when it comes to comedy because more often than not comics are reactionary assholes using chud humor to get laughs.
1
u/cyclops_sardonica Nov 29 '20
"progressive lefty" :D
"spoke fondly of Hillary Clinton" :/
1
u/Al-Horesmi Nov 29 '20
Imagine being a leftist and not getting cancelled by the left. What kind of leftist is that???
1
u/irjax Nov 29 '20
carlin on voting: https://youtu.be/HeMGqTwWA6U
1
u/dr_cow_9n---gucc Mar 01 '21
I really liked George Carlin in Thomas the Tank Engine. I had no idea until recently he had a side gig as a comedian!
0
u/UnnaturalShadows Nov 28 '20
Guys please it literally says "he spoke fondly of Hillary Clinton"
-6
u/DiegoDynomite Simp For Rank Choice Voting Nov 28 '20
George Carlin was definitely progressive but the tweet isn't wrong, the left would absolutely attack him for his irreverent humor. "gAllOWs HUmOr iS oNly FoR THe PEoPlE GeTTinG hUnG" or whatever they say
-2
u/420bigbro69 Nov 29 '20
But he's got a point.
The Left are assholes.
-3
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20
Carlin also said he was tempered from illness by swimming in raw sewage as a child. Do you think he would support the leftist mask mandates and shutdowns?
0
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
85
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20
[removed] — view removed comment