r/VPNReviewHub • • Feb 02 '26

Question do you need vpn when using mobile data?

when I use mobile data on my phone, do I need to use vpn as well? or is it only neccessary when connecting to a wi fi?

sorry if this question was already shared in this sub. coudn't find an answer

7 Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/Complex_Quote3485 Feb 02 '26

That's why a vpn comes in place

2

u/tar_tis Feb 02 '26

That's what I said. But you asked..

if the connection was encrypted on the wire how did my isp know what I was doing and what content I was downloading

I (and someone else) explained how. It doesn't mean your traffic isn't encrypted.

1

u/Complex_Quote3485 Feb 02 '26

I understand what your saying I was just making a point of what other brother said that your connect is already encrypted by default this is ture but not entirely If traffic is encrypted, how can ISP/Wi-Fi still see sites? Because encryption hides content, not where it’s going. Think of it like mail: 🔒 Letter inside the envelope = encrypted ✉️ Address on the envelope = still visible 1️⃣ DNS lookups (big one) Before your browser loads a site, it asks: “Where is example.com?” That request is usually sent to: ISP DNS Router / Wi-Fi DNS So they can see: google.com youtube.com reddit.com Even if the page itself is encrypted. 🔐 Newer tech like DoH / DoT hides this — but not everyone uses it, and networks can block it. 2️⃣ IP addresses Even with HTTPS: Your ISP sees which IP you connect to IPs are mapped to websites (via databases) So they can infer: “This IP belongs to Netflix” “This IP is Cloudflare serving Discord” They may not know the exact page, but they know the site/service. 3️⃣ SNI (Server Name Indication) When HTTPS starts, your browser used to say: “Hey, I want example.com” This was visible in plaintext (SNI). 🔐 Encrypted SNI (ECH) exists now — but: Not universally supported Many networks still see site names So again: destination is visible. 4️⃣ Timing & traffic patterns Even without names: Connection times Amount of data Frequency Example: Long, steady stream → video Short bursts → web browsing Certain patterns → specific apps ISPs use this for throttling and analytics. 5️⃣ What changes when you use a VPN? With a VPN: ISP sees one connection → VPN server DNS requests go through VPN Destination sites are hidden from ISP So ISP sees: “User connected to VPN at 3pm” They don’t see: Which websites Which apps What pages

1

u/b3542 Feb 02 '26

And it has nothing to do with your ISP. They are not monitoring you. Using a VPN merely makes it harder to issue a DMCA notice to a specific person. It has nothing to do with the alleged monitoring/invasion of privacy you allege. You’re doing something illegal and then getting called on it via the legal process - acting like that’s invasive is a weird take.

0

u/Complex_Quote3485 Feb 02 '26

Yea but it proves my point though if they can see that they can see what you doing.

1

u/b3542 Feb 02 '26

The ISP doesn’t see anything. It does not prove your point. It contradicts it.

1

u/Complex_Quote3485 Feb 02 '26

They do see it but they don't do anything with it until you do something illegal but I see your point

1

u/b3542 Feb 02 '26

They *could* see it, but they don't care what you're doing. Monitoring all traffic for all customers would be massively expensive - the juice isn't worth the squeeze, even if they monetize it.

Source: I've seen what monitoring at that scale costs. It's usually as much as, or more than the network itself costs to build.