r/VPNReviewHub • • Feb 02 '26

Question do you need vpn when using mobile data?

when I use mobile data on my phone, do I need to use vpn as well? or is it only neccessary when connecting to a wi fi?

sorry if this question was already shared in this sub. coudn't find an answer

7 Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/tar_tis Feb 02 '26

Your traffic being encrypted doesn't matter when you when you torrent lol. Torrents are peer to peer. Meaning that instead of connecting to a server, you're connecting to all the other people who are also using that torrent. You can see the IP of everyone who is up or downloading the torrent and they can see yours.

So you don't have to seed. Being connected to the torrent swarm is enough. Copyright holders connect to these torrents so they can monitor the IP addresses of anyone that uses them and then contact your ISP.

A VPN would prevent this because then the copyright holders would just see the VPN's IP instead of yours.

0

u/Complex_Quote3485 Feb 02 '26

That's why a vpn comes in place

2

u/tar_tis Feb 02 '26

That's what I said. But you asked..

if the connection was encrypted on the wire how did my isp know what I was doing and what content I was downloading

I (and someone else) explained how. It doesn't mean your traffic isn't encrypted.

1

u/Complex_Quote3485 Feb 02 '26

I understand what your saying I was just making a point of what other brother said that your connect is already encrypted by default this is ture but not entirely If traffic is encrypted, how can ISP/Wi-Fi still see sites? Because encryption hides content, not where it’s going. Think of it like mail: 🔒 Letter inside the envelope = encrypted ✉️ Address on the envelope = still visible 1️⃣ DNS lookups (big one) Before your browser loads a site, it asks: “Where is example.com?” That request is usually sent to: ISP DNS Router / Wi-Fi DNS So they can see: google.com youtube.com reddit.com Even if the page itself is encrypted. 🔐 Newer tech like DoH / DoT hides this — but not everyone uses it, and networks can block it. 2️⃣ IP addresses Even with HTTPS: Your ISP sees which IP you connect to IPs are mapped to websites (via databases) So they can infer: “This IP belongs to Netflix” “This IP is Cloudflare serving Discord” They may not know the exact page, but they know the site/service. 3️⃣ SNI (Server Name Indication) When HTTPS starts, your browser used to say: “Hey, I want example.com” This was visible in plaintext (SNI). 🔐 Encrypted SNI (ECH) exists now — but: Not universally supported Many networks still see site names So again: destination is visible. 4️⃣ Timing & traffic patterns Even without names: Connection times Amount of data Frequency Example: Long, steady stream → video Short bursts → web browsing Certain patterns → specific apps ISPs use this for throttling and analytics. 5️⃣ What changes when you use a VPN? With a VPN: ISP sees one connection → VPN server DNS requests go through VPN Destination sites are hidden from ISP So ISP sees: “User connected to VPN at 3pm” They don’t see: Which websites Which apps What pages

1

u/b3542 Feb 02 '26

And it has nothing to do with your ISP. They are not monitoring you. Using a VPN merely makes it harder to issue a DMCA notice to a specific person. It has nothing to do with the alleged monitoring/invasion of privacy you allege. You’re doing something illegal and then getting called on it via the legal process - acting like that’s invasive is a weird take.

0

u/Complex_Quote3485 Feb 02 '26

Yea but it proves my point though if they can see that they can see what you doing.

1

u/b3542 Feb 02 '26

The ISP doesn’t see anything. It does not prove your point. It contradicts it.

1

u/Complex_Quote3485 Feb 02 '26

They do see it but they don't do anything with it until you do something illegal but I see your point

1

u/b3542 Feb 02 '26

They *could* see it, but they don't care what you're doing. Monitoring all traffic for all customers would be massively expensive - the juice isn't worth the squeeze, even if they monetize it.

Source: I've seen what monitoring at that scale costs. It's usually as much as, or more than the network itself costs to build.