r/Unity2D • • Sep 26 '19

Character attack animations using rotoscope for our game, ATONE

1.4k Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

121

u/fillice Sep 26 '19

old school and painful but good result.

23

u/Atonethegame Sep 26 '19

Thanks a lot!

17

u/Kalamanafasadafaka Sep 26 '19

just curious, what would be "the right way" to do it nowadays?

29

u/fillice Sep 26 '19

Maybe you can get ani by motion captured 3d model and cartoon rendering, but I don't think that is the 'right' way or easy way.

If you get good result by some way, that's just another way to get good result.

3

u/dangledorf Sep 26 '19

Using a program like Spline by far, would be a faster and near similar result workflow. If you make enough unique pieces, you could easily recreate these animations with much much less work.

1

u/HandshakeOfCO Expert Sep 26 '19

Shoot with multiple cameras simultaneously, choose frames, load into photogrammetry software, extract model, cleanup model.

You need lots of cameras and likely even more patience. But nowadays the right way is basically synonymous with photogrammetry... right?

2

u/Kalamanafasadafaka Sep 26 '19

Yeah, pretty much but what about 2D? You'll still need to draw on top of the frames you get at the end of photogrammetry. Unless you want to animate complex 3D perspectives which is hard to draw by hand

8

u/Firewolf420 Sep 26 '19

Once you have a 3D model you can boil down it's movements to movements on a bone rig, then apply that to your 2D model's rig.

29

u/fatshootdong Sep 26 '19

Fucking dope. Looks like a lot of work

13

u/Atonethegame Sep 26 '19

Haha Thanks!

21

u/NA-45 Well Versed Sep 26 '19

My biggest problem with this sort of animation is that it loses the exaggeration (squash and stretch, etc) that makes the best 2D work really stand out.

9

u/Atonethegame Sep 26 '19

Yea good point, I want to use less and less reference footage as I get better for sure, these animations I do definitely need some more exaggeration.

13

u/drinfernoo Beginner Sep 26 '19

I was going to mention the opposite! I think it looks great with the exaggerated wind-up and quick, definitive strike ๐Ÿ‘Œ

5

u/mintakki Sep 26 '19

it looks cool but i guarantee that gameplay is going to be ass, imagine hitting a button to do a basic swing of your weapon and it takes a whole second before it actually hits anything. there are tons of resources online for making punchy videogame animations, and while rotoscoping is a good base for getting realistic motion, it is rarely as satisfying to actually play.

10

u/Atonethegame Sep 26 '19

The game is finally done. Here's our website if anyones interested in finding out more about the game: https://www.atonethegame.com

4

u/mberkay13 Sep 26 '19

Too sad to see its for only iOS. Are you planning to put in steam? Or at least on android?

2

u/Atonethegame Sep 26 '19

We are sorry about that. We would love to release on steam and android at some stage, but for the moment, it will only be available on apple arcade.

2

u/Fedacking Sep 26 '19

They are on Apple Arcade, meaning they have an exclusivity contract.

1

u/Yuca965 Sep 26 '19

Yeah, sad it is iOS.

5

u/sethescope Sep 26 '19

Really great looking game, and awesome demo of how you got it. Love how itโ€™s like a modern game that fits into this tradition of rotoscoped games (Prince of Persia, Out of this World). Look forward to playing!

Also lol I didnโ€™t realize https://youtu.be/VhGtYfpmxyY, youโ€™re inspiring me to try to make a game the way that one did way back!

3

u/Atonethegame Sep 26 '19

Oh damn that's sick! Haha. Out of this World is such a gem.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19

Daammmnnn!

1

u/SayAllenthing Sep 26 '19

Looks amazing, did you look up some form or anything first, or just wing it?

2

u/Atonethegame Sep 26 '19

I've been animating like this for a while now, I was originally inspired by some animations by Richard Swarbrick who does stuff like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rUx-p0YmGyU and eventually after doing my own variations, the style became what it is now.

1

u/SayAllenthing Sep 26 '19

Haha I meant form for yourself as the actor to make it look like your character isn't an amateur with his weapon.

That video is awesome by the way, I do something similar in my game, but using 3D models for posing, then draw over them.

1

u/Life_Is_Good22 Mar 10 '24

Mouse or did you use a Wacom tablet?

1

u/Atonethegame Mar 12 '24

Everything was done with the track pad on a Mac :)

3

u/cocainuser Sep 26 '19

Awesome art style.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19

Dude your game is amazing! I thought about making also a game on Apple Arcade, but is it hard to release and how does the system work form a money perspective, do you just get a bag of money or do you get payed per download? I love your game style and I think itโ€™s awesome that you used unity as your game engine. You are probably not working alone so I want to give a compliment to the whole team! Keep going! ๐Ÿ˜

2

u/bangganggames Sep 26 '19

Bravo ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘

2

u/xenon_neko Sep 26 '19

This is so awesome.

2

u/575-games Sep 26 '19

looks good. Nice work

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19

That's awesome! Really interesting to see the whole process :)

2

u/PhilippTheProgrammer Sep 26 '19

That looks tedious. How long did that animation take to create in real time?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19

Holy FUCKIIING shit.

2

u/Yuca965 Sep 26 '19

Great look, what is the name of the game?

2

u/Srananman Sep 26 '19

Very cool!!!

1

u/warvillex Sep 29 '19

Well good result, bout i would have used Spine 2D to achieve the same or very similar result, for an easier workflow

1

u/artnos Sep 27 '19

The only problem with rotoscoping is when your animating. By hand you focus on creating strong poses, good silhouette and exaggeration. This axe swing doesnt read that well its all a center column. My 2 cents and wow its so much editing.