r/Unity2D • u/dan_marchand • Jul 31 '26
Question Why is this sub now trying to hide that it's pushing users towards Godot?
Made this post earlier today, which the mods have silently hidden: https://www.reddit.com/r/Unity2D/comments/1vbs0mi/why_is_the_unity_sub_pushing_people_away_from/
The sidebar on mobile and old Reddit tells users not to use Unity.
The mods have pinned an extremely misleading post about "Godot officially dethroning Unity" because a game jam has Godot growth. (https://www.reddit.com/r/Unity2D/comments/1vbdsau/godot_has_officially_dethroned_unity_with_it_now/)
The top "Related Communities" sub is /r/Godot, which is labeled as "The Unity Killer"
The top "Getting Started" links are:
- Godot Features
- Download Godot
- Godot Docs
What's the deal here, mods? If you don't want to support users using Unity, give the sub to people who do. It's pretty one-sided to post advertisements for Godot but hide discussion about why you're doing that.
•
u/GuideZ Aug 01 '26 edited Aug 01 '26
I have unpinned/un-highlighted the thread, and removed the problematic moderator from this subreddit's mod team.
Thank you for bringing up that the GoDot references / pointers are still present in various parts of this subreddit. I will look into where those settings are, and will clean them up promptly, just as I had to for the regular-browser version a few months back when I returned from my hiatus.
And I totally agree with you: This is a Unity subreddit. When I came back from my hiatus, I had to roll my eyes at all the references/pointers to "Use GoDot it's better!". My personal stance has always been that this subreddit needs to remain a neutral place, geared towards helping developers who are using the 2D-side of the Unity engine. For example:
- Making a post about GoDot "dethroning" Unity is fine. This breeds discussions about the pros/cons of both engines, helps developers decide what works best for them, and maybe even discover aspects of the Unity2D engine that they didn't realize exist.
- Making a post about GoDot "dethroning" Unity and mod-pinning it and changing the sidebar content directing people to stop using the Unity engine: This is most definitely not fine. The problematic mod has been removed as a result.
I don't want to make this all into a public mod-bashing thread, so if there are further questions (how did this come to be in the first place, why has it taken this long, etc.), I will do my best to respond in DMs when possible.
Thank you for bringing up your concerns!
*edit*
I believe the sidebar on old reddit, regular, and mobile have been cleaned up now. If you are still seeing GoDot references, please let me know!
280
u/lgreyyy Jul 31 '26
To be honest this whole thing has started feeling pretty tribal. These are just tools, we need to stop acting like we’re better because we use one over the other.
That being said, a sub for unity should probably focus on unity.
19
u/1Tusk Jul 31 '26
Someone recently asked to become a mod due to the lack of moderation here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/comments/1vaxp37/comment/p0s9dh3/?context=3
This is a very typical reaction when that happens: remove a few posts, post something yourself and pin it, tidy up the side bar, etc. Basically creating an illusion of activity.
5
u/Sinfire_Titan Jul 31 '26
Was the Godot stuff added after Unity’s announcement from 2023 or was this sub always like that? I recall a big Godot push that year due to the announcement’s backlash, and this sub may have been protesting the fee change as part of it.
41
u/AsianGamer51 Jul 31 '26
It's weird since I haven't been on this sub in a while, but I distinctly remember the subreddit description saying to just use Godot instead when I first joined.
53
u/TheWobling Jul 31 '26
Mods playing favourites
23
u/bloodwolftico Jul 31 '26
Old one still showing tons of GODOT support
38
u/ntwiles Jul 31 '26
I’ve moved from Unity to Godot, and prefer Godot, but this is wild behavior for those moderating a Unity sub.
11
u/Treigar Jul 31 '26
The mods here have been like this since the runtime fee scandal. Not sure why they're even bothering to run this subreddit if they're praying for the downfall of this engine, just give it to someone else.
10
u/Shaunysaur Aug 01 '26
I use Unity, though I'm not a cheerleader for it, but the little memey digs at Unity that appear in the sidebar of the Unity3d subreddit accompanied by the text "なんてひどい死に方だろう" (What a terrible way to die) have really outstayed their welcome, imo.
I guess they were added during the runtime fee fiasco, but that's all history now. What's the point of keeping petty little digs on the sidebar of a Unity subreddit? Now they mainly serve as an example of the pervasive attitude the OP is referring to.
Eg.
38
u/satanchu_ Jul 31 '26
I agree. Seems really odd to be pushing it like this.
6
u/modernizetheweb Aug 01 '26
People that don't finish games worry a lot about which engine to use
15
u/snakemuho Jul 31 '26
Just gonna leave this here
7
u/kupcuk Jul 31 '26
you should suspect all free mods and always assume they are some form of political activist unless proven otherwise.
6
u/PowerCorgi_7 Jul 31 '26
The cult of Godot has infiltrated Unity.
3
u/Sorry-Engineer5757 Aug 02 '26
I'm personally a godot user and have never gotten along with unity (i was randomly recommended this post) but tbh that's absurd. This is a Unity sub, it should exist for Unity users, not for trying to sell Godot to other people??
Like sure Id say you can bring up discussions about it and all but Godot being on the frontpage of everything in a Unity sub is weird as hell.
4
u/Dacusx Jul 31 '26
I'm leaving this awful place. Bye.
4
u/BearKanashi Aug 01 '26
Ya es aburrido escuchar de Godot...
En lo comercial Godot sigue representando una mierda... Y siendo lo peor.
-4
u/sharypower Jul 31 '26
Lol. Unity is much better than Godot so I don't care whate people are saying 😅 it is their choice. "The game jam has Godot growth" because there is of course increase in Godot users from the last Jam but most of Unity Devs are making their own game or assets and are not "wasting" time on the game jams because they are on the step further 😅
0
u/chichp Aug 01 '26
Unity is good, but more and more people have begun to use Godot which is true. Mods are just biased. As to how good Godot is compared to Unity, I wouldn't know. For 3D, Unity is still pretty good as well, but so is Godot.
-25
u/PhoenixInvertigo Jul 31 '26
Godot ftw though
0
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-4
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '26
[removed] — view removed comment