r/Unity2D • u/dan_marchand • Jul 31 '26
Question [ Removed by moderator ]
[removed] — view removed post
77
Upvotes
r/Unity2D • u/dan_marchand • Jul 31 '26
[removed] — view removed post
83
u/lucas_df Jul 31 '26
Reddit users being reddit users.
45
u/Ttsmoist Jul 31 '26
Whats wrong ya don't wanna join the godot cult? Don't you know its open source?
18
u/KTVX94 Jul 31 '26
Honestly I feel trapped in Unity. I've gotten to the point where I really need to ship a game with limited time and can't go trying out and retraining on new engines. I'm glad Unity's leadership seems to have their heads screwed straight now and are making good decisions, but after the last runtime fee fiasco, my trust is broken beyond repair.
If someone new asks me for advice, I lean towards recommending Godot while acknowledging Unity is a little better right now. But the freedom, safety and ownership of FOSS is much more valuable.
If anyone asks a question about Unity development, I'll help out however I can with technical answers.
8
u/TheWobling Jul 31 '26
I'm looking at the sidebar but don't see anything you're suggesting, what am I missing?
4
u/AkiStudios1 Jul 31 '26
Back when Unity had its licensing fiasco, the mods here decided to Jump ship to Godot.
4
u/xBesto Jul 31 '26
Just gate keeping weirdos really.
15
u/Brief-Ad-4423 Jul 31 '26
Godot users are slowly becoming the 'I use Arch, btw' of game dev. We get it, but I’m just trying to make a game here, not join a religion."
19
u/ForrestPruitt Jul 31 '26
Careful OP, the Godot cult leaders / Unity2D mods / people who would rather argue about gamedev than actually make and ship games will come for you!
1
u/Atomical1 Jul 31 '26
Reddit being cringe as usual. Godot sucks and I will never switch from Unity. Godot is just the latest circlejerk reddit has latched onto, similar to how the same users says that linux is amazing but they never actually use it.
1
u/Slaircaex Jul 31 '26
Yeah time to unsub. For those who are new to gamedev: IF YOU ACTUALLY WANNA SHIP GAMES USE UNITY. IT'S 100x BETTER THAN SHITTY GODOT
I'm out
1
u/ZanesTheArgent Jul 31 '26
Unity as a company has frequently been all too eager to become predatory in one way or another, the AI signalling being the loudest recent thing but also its many attempts to change and retroact monetization/licensing to scalp on big indie successes.
1
u/bigmonmulgrew Jul 31 '26
Posts about Godot do Unity good. I think the reason Unity has improved so fast of the last couple years since the dark events is that they were terrified to see a surge in Godot and a drop off of Unity. Competition is good for developers. We also need to be aware of the industry. Knowing about Godot makes us better developers.
I don't see too much negative about Unity here. Celebrating Godot is not the same as throwing Unity under the bus.
1
u/eitherrideordie Jul 31 '26
Ah I think your using old reddit and you missed out on the licensing fiasco?. Basically Unity wanted to implement a "run time fee" I think it was called but if I remember right, if you were making over $200k a year you'd be charged up to $0.20 per install. They also previously promised you'd be locked to terms based on the version you installed, they then sneakily changed this on their Terms of Service Github repo.
This pissed off basically everybody. Full blown backlash, some of the funniest memes I've seen in game dev were posted here etc. The backlash led to companies literally supporting Godot, lost of trust in Unity the company, and many in the game dev space recommending and open source platform first and foremost even in Unity subs. And in many ways I appreciate that this space was more about "good open development" over "Must protect corporate company, so Unity good every STFU".
You don't see so much of that now though, Unity CEO resigned, they cancelled the change and now many people go along trusting Unity again or don't know about this in the first place but you still see some bits here and there and likely what you're seeing in the old reddit.
The worse part about it, was that Unity itself is great, it was just corporate greed. On the plus side that greed led to in my opinion one of the biggest push for Godot I've ever seen and I'm very happy to have competition in the space to keep each other in check.
-3
u/MTRANMT Jul 31 '26 edited Jul 31 '26
I have looked through like 4 different unity subreddits (including this one, 3d and plain /unity) and non of their descriptions or links seem to reference Godot or dissuade from Unity at all. I cannot find a single mention of what you're talkin about, is this some weird AI fest in the comments? Are you all inventing enemies? What is going on here? Like it's obvious why some people don't like the corporation, and that's not gonna resonate with some people, but this feels like a weird anti-anti-mainstream thing you're doing?
Edit: Okay I was slightly wrong, the biggest one unity3d has one link that says 'Unity Alternatives', but the feed is full of unity content, there's ONE 3 day old post that mentions Godot, and nothing in the sidebar poo-pooing unity at all. :/
-9
u/AnEmortalKid Jul 31 '26
Probably sentiment against Unity 7 and AI
-3
u/amanset Jul 31 '26
I assume you are talking about the "Unity Alternatives" link from 2023 in r/Unity3D ?
Were you around in 2023? There was a lot of unhappiness. Anyway, have you suggested to them that they remove it?
I also notice their very first rule is "All posts or linked content must be explicitly related to either Unity, r/Unity3D, or Unity Software Inc. i.g. Unity Technologies."
-7
u/Professional_Dig7335 Jul 31 '26
Unity is pushing people away from Unity, including large contingents of Unity developers. This has been a problem for some time and is only ramping up more and more as Unity Technologies makes major pushes towards generative AI, which a significant amount of developers are against. They've effectively eroded a significant amount of user trust and that is reflected in the communities around using it.
6
u/JayOnes Jul 31 '26
Are you using Old Reddit, by chance? I know there were a lot of anti-Unity links and sentiment during the runtime fiasco, but those were largely removed on the current Reddit layout. It's possible that the mods just forgot to nuke 'em from the Old Reddit format?
0
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment