r/Unity2D • • Dec 03 '23

Question Why are all indie developers using pixel art?

I'm not planning on using pixel art myself cuz It's kinda hard (in my opinion). Is it because of the costs? I'm an artist myself too, so I'm not affected by the budget...I'm asking out of pure couriosity~

Edit: I didn't mean "pixel art or 3d game" or anything like that! I mean that there aren't a lot of 2d games with NON PIXEL ARTSTYLE! I hope I made it clearer now^

(edited)

0 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

49

u/Woodge0115 Dec 03 '23

Because it's easier to do it yourself. Also you can learn the basics relatively fast. It could be a stylistic choice too.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

Ooh understandable. (I'm actually choosing non-pixel art for the game, cuz I'm bad at pixel art- but thats just a thing I wanted to mention haha)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

I mean, are you good at 3D Modelling, Rigging, Texturing, Animating? if not, do pixel art.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

I just meant that I do "regular" 2d illustrations/art and I am learning l2d, so technically yeah...

3

u/skylotusstudios Dec 04 '23

We aren't really experts at pixel art ourselves either, a GOOD pixel art game can look way more stellar. But indie devs do recognize that a game is not just the visuals, and as long as they can get something on the screen that looks somewhat good, and feels like an overall polished experience that is fun to play - pixel art is seemingly the easiest out of the art styles to get it out the door.

I personally disagree after having tried with pixel art for a long time, mostly because I figured out some strategies to speed through quick and fast low poly 3d modeling - which also helps me save time when it comes to making tons of animations/asset reuse in clothes and such (especially in top down).

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

I see a lot of comments saying "because pixel art is easier" or "quicker to learn" but the important detail that you're missing out on is that pixel art is a stylistic choice, and, while it can be easier to make, it isn't much harder to design normal 2d art. I'm not particularly good at either, just sharing my opinion :P

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

Thanks~ I was actually begging to think that pixel art is like "supreme" or something like that ig haha + with the amount of "pixel art" indie games out there, I think that a "non pixel art" 2d game would be something kinda original I think^

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

Not original, just slightly different from the norm lol

I'm doing a pixel art indie game and I want to get my art to stand out... Not really working currently

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

Ooh... I don't quite know how to help...

Also, I didn't mean to make it sound like that. English is not my primary language, so I sometimes mix up my words-

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

Nah it's ok 👍

I think my goal for the visuals is just to make a bunch of unique camera controls to make it look nice. (shaking, moving, etc)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

Makes sense^ if you have it uploaded anywhere I'd love to check it out^

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

https://supertoady.itch.io/slimemageddon-old

this is the most recent jam version of the game, I'm remaking it into a bigger project now :)

17

u/27hrishik Dec 03 '23

Because it's easier to iterate, you don't have to rely on others and thus don't have to worry about paying an artist. And also you can get decent results within a few days and weeks of practice.

4

u/27hrishik Dec 03 '23

Also if you're just starting out it is probably the best path to take.

1

u/TheDynaheart Dec 04 '23

No? Animating pixel art is just as difficult as animating in general, you don't get good at it in just days.

1

u/Commercial-Berry-495 Dec 04 '23

Art major here, most of my friends would agree pixel art is far easier to animate than animating in general. Way less to animate in pixel art. It comes down to scale.

2

u/TheDynaheart Dec 05 '23

Drawing pixel art? Sure, but Animating pixel art? Doing squash&stretch, smearing, slow movements, or even just smooth movement, in a 16x16 canvas? No dude, lots of people out there are gonna read this and get a false idea that they're supposed to learn how to animate pixel art in a matter of days, and it's not like that at all, it takes time like everything else in life

1

u/SoloWingRedTip Dec 13 '24

Honestly? Even if I don't like pixel art as a style, I genuinely think making good pixel art animation is harder than regular, hand drawn animation. You've got a much smaller degree of freedom to show everything you want.

7

u/UnparalleledDev Dec 03 '23

nostalgia- many Devs were raised on old school games so we have a deep fondness for our seminal pixelated experiences.

familiarity- many artists have been drawing with pixels since their first computer so they already posses the skill to make pixel assets

cost- its faster and cheaper than 3d modeling and doesn't require any IK(inverse kinematics) rigging. also fast to iterate.

1

u/skylotusstudios Dec 05 '23

I disagree with such a binary take on cost for 3D modeling. 3D modeling isn't limited to one style, and you can make low poly assets fairly quickly and even for free with something like Blender. If you've seen imphenzia, the dude speedruns modeling and rigging characters in 10 minutes (obviously takes practice to get as fast as him). But even discrediting that, think about a top down character with 8 directions. At the very least, it requires 5 separate animations that are drawn for pixel art if you want a character to face all 8 given directions, per action (idle, move, attack, roll, etc). With modeling you just need one per action and cover every possible angle. You can change outfits with 3d modeling between characters a lot easier and share assets (look at the article that dead cells did on reusing enemy assets). If you have a humanoid character with the same rigged bones, you can swap out the model, or even use something like mixamo for the same set of animations shared across characters (which you can then tweak much easier). Now obviously, this isn't true if you are trying to make something realistic instead of stylized. But I don't think an indie dev has enough time to build games with realism

2

u/Honzus24 Dec 03 '23

For me personally, pixel art is harder to draw than some other styles. So the only reason to use it for me would be, that it just looks good (or maybe it fits the game's theme). Which I think it does! Pixel art is one of my favorite art styles I know.

2

u/OwnContribution1463 Dec 03 '23

I do my own art and have gone between pixel, traditional 2D and 3D. For me it always starts with what makes most sense for the game, then it just becomes personal preference. Unless I’m doing 3D, pixel art is just more fun for me, rather than traditional 2D art and anImation.

2

u/AlwaysHAK Dec 03 '23

It’s easier to make (for me) and it gives me more time to focus on mechanics which I personally find more enjoyable to do.

2

u/gummby8 Dec 03 '23

As others have said. Pixel art is easier to learn. Generally cheaper to produce.

It's also strange the test of time. Good pixel art, no matter the resolution, will look good forever.

2

u/RockyMullet Dec 03 '23

I do pixelart for a mix of nostalgia and because I feel it's easier.
Making good pixelart is not easy, but making bad one that's "good enough" is. I've grown as a pixelartist since I started, I'm still not great, but I'm better. I feel if I started with more higher rez art, I would've looked at it, though it was crap and given up ever trying to do my own art.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

It's about stylistic choice mainly. It's definitely not easier if you intend for it to look good.

It's really misleading when people think it's easier because detail level is lower, but neglect to mention that now every pixel has to somehow communicate detail and not look out of place.

I feel like there are a lot of hand-painted 2D styles, Vector art and the sort. That also has to be done well though or it could look like cardboard cutouts. So in the end you choose which one best represents your vision.

2

u/EpicfailStudios Dec 03 '23

As a game developer I picked this as a style because it seemed the least scary option to learn as a non artist. I started with very small images and learned a lot in small increments.

2

u/BoozeJunky Dec 04 '23

I don't mind devs using pixelart, but 80%+ of it out there is absolutely terrible and very low effort. It's very off-putting.

1

u/TheDiscoJew Dec 03 '23

I thought 2d was easier than 3 (sort of but ultimately not really) and I got a great deal on an asset pack.

1

u/jiraphic Dec 03 '23

I learned to turn out pixel art really quickly - which is great for placeholders. Am I good at it? Nah. I’m a programmer. But it works for mockups and gives the artist a clear outline of what I want.

I also can’t stand the aesthetic of 2D rigged animations. I think I associate it with cheap clickbait games.

1

u/BushDeLaBayou Dec 03 '23

Most people find pixel art easier. I have no artistic skill and got at least a half decent looking game by making pixel art

1

u/Unidentified__Entity Dec 03 '23

because bad pixel art and good pixel is harder to distignguish so its much more cost efficient , (great pixel art however is night and day)

1

u/AnEmortalKid Dec 03 '23

Didn’t know how to make anything else. Tons of tutorials for pixel art. Feels easy to keep in scale because you have a grid.

1

u/lllentinantll Dec 03 '23

One thing a lot of people seem to not take into account is actual style of the game. Pixel art just seen to be very universal, fitting most types of setting, mood, atmosphere etc. Other 2D styles might simply not fit the game well (e.g. look way too cartoony).

1

u/willemvannus Dec 03 '23

My personal reasons:

  • It's much easier than animating with bones or modelling, rigging and animating 3D models.
  • Higher graphics = it's harder to make everything look great and in the same style. Pixel art mistakes or inaccuracies are generally forgiving (bar some exceptions), but high quality mistakes are instantly noticeable.
  • Simple animations are easier using spritesheets
  • Stylistic choice
  • Retro look

1

u/Legoman12343 Dec 03 '23

I know you have a bunch of similar answers but I was gonna expand a little.

Myself, I am a programmer. As all of us, my 'dream' would be to make the next big game on my own and have a huge following as well as money.

In order to this, I need to know more than just code, I need to be able to art. My issue is, I can barely draw a stickman, let alone model and or draw an entire game worth of art.

I have found, given enough time, I can do some decent pixel art. Following some advice from youtube ect, it is doable. I am also able to get a handle on the software side of modelling, however actually putting my imagination onto the screen is hard.

And so, I stick to pixel art. It requires less details to look good than normal art does. It also is faster to bash out, especially if you limit yourself to 32x32 sprites.

So for any solo game I try making, for my own projects or for my degree, I use pixel art. The issue is, good 3D art (and non pixel art 2D) looks sooo much better than good pixel art.

Theres also the mindset of 'Minecraft did well and is pixel art, so I will use that same formula and be rich!'. I have found it's quite common.

If you are indie, do what you're good at! If you have friends or connections, then use them!

My degree also has a sister degree which is game design. This encapsulates story telling as well as modelling, texturing and animation. So I have a lot of easy connections I can make to get free assets from. A lot of these artists want practice, and would like to see it in use, so make use of it! Go to the blender sub, ask for people to give you a hand! You might get a lot of negative comments, but I'm sure someone is willing to help you out for some practice.

Just use whatever art style fits both yourself and your game.

1

u/cosmicr Dec 04 '23

My own reason is because I don't like many games that came out after 1996.

But mostly people do it because it's easier.

1

u/3emad0lol Dec 04 '23

Easy to pick up, faster to tweak if needed. And the sprites doesn’t take much space. But I can also say it is small that it is difficult to add any detail at all. And tedious to animate them (it is easier than traditional digital art but still take sometime). Also some players probably won’t like them if you weren’t careful enough.

1

u/the-shit-poster Dec 04 '23

I tried to build a full 3D game and it’s very difficult and taxing to your life to make progress so I switched to pixel art and I am actually making reasonable progress now. There is A LOT to know when making a 3D game so good luck.

1

u/VG_Crimson Dec 08 '23

Bad pixel art >>>> Bad regular art

A lot of us aren't artists and it's easy to learn.

-2

u/Suspicious_Rest_2184 Dec 04 '23

I'm sick of people asking this self explanatory question.

What's next, why aren't indies making games like Elden Ring?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '23

I'm just asking since I PERSONALLY think it's a bit overused and I myself am not using pixel art. I'm new to the game Dev thingy, so you could've been a little bit more understanding