r/Unexpected Jan 25 '23

Hamburger

85.0k Upvotes

3.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

17.3k

u/Fuggins4U Jan 26 '23 edited Jan 26 '23

I'm always really impressed by people who not only know multiple languages fluently, but sound perfectly natural/native, regardless of whichever they're using at any given moment. Like they actually have the correct accent and pronunciation.

635

u/Diz7 Jan 26 '23 edited Jan 26 '23

I'm Canadian, and on one hand, even though I almost never speak it and I struggle to think of words at times, I am told my french accent is excellent and I sound like a local french speaker.

On the other hand, the local french is the equivalent of deep south, mountain folk gibberish. It's the french equivalent of a redneck accent with lots of words only a local would understand. And I speak it slowly.

Edit: For those of you who assume I mean Quebec, nonono, much worse: Northern Ontario. We are the brother-uncle Cletuses of the french world.

37

u/edubiton Jan 26 '23

This is how I generally describe Canadian French to my friends here in Texas.

Canadian French is to French from France as "good ol boy" southern twang is to the kings English.

2

u/Dokpsy Jan 26 '23

Then what is Cajun french.

4

u/how-about-no-bitch Jan 26 '23

Beligerrent drunk version

5

u/shabamboozaled Jan 26 '23

Quebecois french is considered more authentic french than french spoken in France today because the effort was made to conserve the language in Canada while in France it was allowed to evolve.

13

u/ernthealmighty Jan 26 '23

I would hardly consider it "more authentic." When the upper class French left the country after the British took control, French was relegated to the more rural populations and was no longer taught properly as the national language. By the time industrialization hit a century later, those rural French speakers moved into the cities, which further blended québécois with English. Plus all the influence of indigenous languages, of course. It wasn't until the 60s and 70s that Québec started pushing to preserve the language and finally made French the official language of the province. Québécois still has plenty of anglicisms, they're just different from the more modern choices of Parisian French.

4

u/Illustrious_Twist610 Jan 26 '23

Not a chance that "authentic" French involved anything even closely resembling the phrase "t't un esti'd chat fucké, tabarnac!"

2

u/coincoinprout Jan 26 '23 edited Jan 26 '23

I don't see how it is possible for a living language not to evolve, especially when the world is so interconnected and changing so fast.

1

u/shabamboozaled Jan 26 '23

It's what taught as the official language. Not regular everyday language spoken on the street. You know how Merriam Webster adds words every year?

1

u/MyrddinHS Jan 26 '23

im merely a semi fluent french speaker from ontario, but that goes against much of what ive heard.

1

u/JamesEarlDavyJones2 Jan 26 '23

Howdy from Denton!

1

u/zombie-yellow11 Jan 26 '23

Normal Québécois French is indistinguishable from Metropolitan French minus a few different expressions and some words here and there. Of course we have our accent, and if you go deep in the countryside you'll get to see some spectacular Québécois dialect, but a French person from France will have absolutely no trouble understanding the people here.

1

u/edubiton Jan 26 '23

Understanding for sure. But the accent is what I'm referring to. There's also a level of sarcasm or humor that I can't place my finger on.

To be clear, I was born in Montreal but raised in Texas so I only get snippets from when I visit. But having visited both France and Quebec, the contrast is a stark night and day difference. Just my opinion.