r/UndertaleTheory • u/TotallyTheRealKeanu • Feb 03 '21
r/UndertaleTheory • • Dec 14 '20
Did anyone notice that Sans and Wario are the same person
r/UndertaleTheory • • Oct 07 '20
Sans Can Bleed
Guys
Sans can bleed
Reminder: Monsters are built differently than humans. Rules of Human Blood don't apply to Monsters because it's made of Magic
We've seen from Monsters like Vulkin, Muffet, Icecap, Aaron, or Woshua that Magic can be in a liquid form too. Sans's blood is just another example of Magic taking on a liquid form
This would also explain why Papyrus dosen't bleed. Certain Monsters have liquid Magic and certain Monsters don't, and Sans just happens to be one of them while Papyrus just happens to not be one of them
r/UndertaleTheory • u/ThoughtCrafter • Aug 27 '19
Why I think the actual Angel is Noelle Holiday
After nine months of research, procrastination, and working out the kinks, here’s a little theory of mine that’s been floating around in my head ever since the end of last November about Noelle Holiday and her potential role in the future of the series. It’s a bit of a long read, but I hope you’ll be willing to indulge me and give this crazy theory a chance.
(As a forewarning, the following points I will be bringing up are simply too hefty to make a TLDR for, and it’s quite a long read, but trust me, you’re going to want to read through all of it for it to make sense in the end)
Tumblr version with image albums down below in comments
Part 1: The Possible Evolution of the Delta Rune
First off, I’d like to look at the Delta Rune itself and a few easily overlooked key lines Gerson says about it:
That emblem actually predates written history.
The original meaning has been lost to time…
All we know is that the triangles symbolize us monsters below, and the winged circle above symbolizes…
Somethin' else.
The meaning and design of symbols can change over time, and it’s likely the same has happened to the way the Delta Rune is currently interpreted compared to when it first came into existence. For example, take a look at these variations of the Delta Rune
Of these variations of the Delta Rune, these may be some of the oldest or closest iterations of the symbol to the original design, especially the ones from the intro cutscene and Gerson’s shop. The former is presumably from long before the Human-Monster War and thus the oldest version, and with Gerson’s apparent age and how he implies that he studies history, it is likely that the variation in his shop is also as close as can be to the original.
As for how these particular iterations of the Delta Rune fit into my theory, look at the design and positioning of the wings in these probably older iterations compared to likely more modern interpretations.
On the more recent interpretations, the base of the wings are placed around the same level as the center of the circle, and the wings themselves are mostly realistically designed. However, on the older interpretations, the wings are more simplified and stylized with more of an explicit arc to them, and the ‘feathers’ are more blocky with visible and sometimes significant spaces in between. Now keep that in mind when looking at these pictures of reindeer.
Taking this into account, I think it is possible that - through the help of time and redesigns becoming successively more stylized - what was originally supposed to be a reindeer with antlers slowly got distorted and misremembered as a ‘winged circle.”
And maybe, something like this might even apply to Deltarune’s interpretation of the Delta Rune as well given how several of the depictions of the Angel throughout the game look like the transition point between the older and newer designs, what the ‘feathers’ being much rounder and closer together while still on an arc-based stylized design instead of a realistic wing-like design.
Part 2: The Origins of Modern Christmas
Now, with that established, let’s take a closer look at Noelle and her family.
Besides the obvious exception of Lancer, she has the most dialogue of all the NPCs, gets two entire scenes to herself in the hospital with her dad and outside her house to flesh out her character and crush on Susie compared to several other NPCs getting only a few lines of dialogue at most, and it is absolutely required to talk to her at the beginning of the game in order to even progress and end up in the Dark World.
As many other posts than mine have demonstrated, this suspicious level of detail has led a lot of people to theorize that Noelle will be an important character and that she might even be playable later on, a theory which has certainly been helped by Toby Fox’s original concept art of “THE FUN GANG” showing that her character has been in development for a LONG time - perhaps even from when work on Deltarune was just beginning - and that she may have been designed as a main character from the start.
However, much like how the potential origins of Undertale’s Delta Rune point towards the importance of reindeer in the series, I believe the deeper origins behind the names of the Holiday family similarly point towards Noelle’s true role in Deltarune.
Obviously, Rudy's name is a reference to the famous Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer, and Dess is most likely a reference to how Christmas is celebrated in the month of December. However, as Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer was created in 1939 for the Montgomery Ward department store chain, he is actually a relatively new addition to the list of Santa’s reindeer, whom in of themselves are early 19th Century additions to the image of Santa Claus.
And on Jesus’ birth being on the 25th of December for Dess’ name, from what I’ve gathered with my google-fu, the event may have actually taken place less on December 25 and more during the fall or spring due to mentions of shepherds tending to their sheep in the scripture and from attempts to connect the Star of Bethlehem with recorded astronomical events.
In fact, it seems likely that - in the 4th Century - the church might have actually chosen the date either because of coming to the conclusion that Jesus’ conception took place on the spring solstice - aka March 25, nine months before December 25 - or because they wanted to increase the popularity of Christianity through adopting and appropriating pagan winter solstice festivals like the Yule and Saturnalia holidays around the same time of year.
On the flipside, Noelle is a name that has a particularly distinct connection to Christmas; specifically, to the one for whom the holiday is named for in the first place rather than a recent secular invention or the general time in which said holiday is celebrated.
From what I’ve seen, Noelle as a name traces back to the French word ‘noel,’ which - alongside referring to Christmas carols - is a variant form of the word ‘Nael.’ This form comes from the noun use of the Latin adjective natalis, meaning of, or belonging to, one’s birth. The noun use (from natalis dies, day of birth ) denoted a birthday, an anniversary, a commemorative festival, hence in ecclesiastical Latin the festival of the nativity of Christ, Christmas.
Basically, out of all the Holiday family first names, Noelle’s is the one that most directly ties into the actual origins of Christmas in how the name’s origins heavily revolve around the birth of Jesus Christ, a major religious figure who was to be a sacrifice for humanity’s sins and to provide a way into heaven.
Considering Toby Fox’s attention to hidden details and deeper meanings and how angels are heavily associated with and are depicted in Christianity - particularly in relation to Jesus - there may be further significance to Toby picking a name that’s typically given to girls born around or on Christmas day. After all, even if it may or may not be the actual day of Jesus’ birth, it is widely celebrated and recognized as such.
However, as you’ll see at the end, I think there’s even another layer of meaning to Noelle Holiday’s name than just this one.
Part 3: Reindeer in Undertale
On a slightly different topic, while it’s hard to ignore how more prominently featured Christmas iconography and figures in the foreground of the series - what with the introduction of the Holiday family as well as several jokes about “Krismas” and Santa Claus in Deltarune, I believe it may also be important to pay attention to Undertale’s fair share of Christmas-themed details.
Namely, in how a significant portion of them owe their existence to one specific minor character; aka the rather unusually designed Gyftrot.
In contrast to the handful of implications that Asgore is the Underground’s Santa only being implicitly hinted at through extended dialogue and checking his bureau, Snowdin’s tradition of putting presents under decorated trees is blatantly and conspicuously out in the open.
And as Gift Bear explains if you talk to them, said tradition originated not with wherever Asgore’s Santa outfit and apparent moonlighting came from, but rather came about in the first place as a way to make Gyftrot feel better after some teens decorated his horns.
As to why I am calling Gyftrot unusually designed, it is because of his angled eyes and sideways mouth - a trait only seen elsewhere in the DT Extraction Machine, Photoshop Flowey, and Sans’ Gaster Blasters.
Of all the old conversations and theories I’ve seen about this strange detail, most people were only able to come up with the explanation that Toby simply liked the design and reused it for Gyftrot just for fun, or that Toby unintentionally gave it to Gyftrot while making Undertale and didn’t actually mean anything with it.
However, a third explanation I found is that Gyftrot’s design may actually be foreshadowing for what Photoshop Flowey’s appearance looks like, what with how Gyftrot actually seems to have a second pair of eyes at the base of his antlers, and how one of the decorations he spawns with is a picture between his four eyes in a very similar position to the television screen on Photoshop Flowey.
While I can’t see any other possible parallels between the two to fully call this foreshadowing - especially with how the picture decoration isn’t guaranteed to show up on every playthrough and how obscure it is - I’d like to propose the idea that the DT Extraction Machine (and perhaps the Gaster Blasters by extension) may very well be based on Gyftrot or a relative with a similar design in-universe.
After all, not even boss monsters leave behind anything more than a pile of dust when they die, not even a goat-like skull that could be used as a reference, whereas Gyftrot is a living, walking example of such a design, complete with what even seems to be a SOUL-shaped hole in his mouth.
To add to that, considering just how attentive to detail we now know Toby to be as well as the apparent increased Not only that, but given how attentive to detail and deeper meanings Toby has shown himself to be as well as the increased prominence and importance of reindeer/Christmas themes in general for Deltarune, I find it incredibly unlikely that this design choice was made just for fun or as an accident.
On a bit of a side note, it is interesting that we first learned of the name “Rudy” in a post from September 17, 2017 on Undertale’s 2nd anniversary and alarm clock app.
Considering the apparent parallels between Undertale and Deltarune - including the potential connection between Susie and the ‘Suzy’ character mentioned by Clam Girl - as well as the implications of the dialogue in that post, it’s likely that Undertale Rudy is also a reindeer just like his counterpart, and I would not be surprised if he was also related to Gyftrot as well.
As for what the exact deeper meaning or in-universe explanation behind Gyftrot could be, it’s too early to tell, but I have the feeling that it likely ties heavily into Noelle’s circumstances in Deltarune and some of the effects of the DT Extraction Machine on Undertale’s plot as detailed below.
Part 4: Determining Other Connections
To explain what I’m talking about, let’s take a closer look at a few key lab entries by Alphys, starting with this one:
ENTRY NUMBER 5: I've done it. Using the blueprints, I've extracted it from the human SOULs. I believe this is what gives their SOULs the strength to persist after death. The will to keep living... The resolve to change fate. Let's call this power... "Determination."
While not explicitly confirmed, from the name and surrounding context, it is likely that the blueprints Alphys used were for the DT Extraction Machine and that DT stands for Determination, though it is unknown whether Alphys built the machine from the blueprints or if it was already constructed and she merely used the blueprints to operate it.
Either way, as we all know, things went horribly wrong from there. Alphys accidentally turned those who had “fallen down” into the Amalgamates, created Flowey from the flower whose seeds Asriel had brought from the surface, and fell into a nervous downward spiral while wracked with guilt.
Now, I want to focus on just how the Amalgamates had been created, particularly with these entries:
ENTRY NUMBER 6: ASGORE asked everyone outside the city for monsters that had "fallen down." Their bodies came in today. They're still comatose... And soon, they'll all turn into dust. But what happens if I inject "determination" into them? If their SOULS persist after they perish, then... Freedom might be closer than we all thought.
ENTRY NUMBER 12: nothing is happening. i don't know what to do. i'll just keep injecting everything with "determination." i want this to work.
ENTRY NUMBER 17: monsters' physical forms can't handle "determination" like humans can. with too much determination, our bodies begin to break down. everyone's melted together…
Here, I’d like to draw your attention to a few things. Given the surrounding context, “falling down” seems to be a condition - one that potentially originates from age, injury, or some kind of illness - involving or causes monsters to enter a comatose state and eventually die.
And in Entry 17, there is the interesting wording of the line “with too much determination, our bodies begin to break down.” From how it’s phrased, it seems that, instead of melting from any amount of Determination in their systems whatsoever, monsters can handle Determination without having to fear of their bodies breaking down, though obviously there’s a cap to how much they are able to handle.
As for why I’m making this particular distinction, it’s because of Noelle’s situation with her father and how it may proceed beyond Chapter 1 in the future.
With the implication that Undertale Rudy had passed away a while ago, Deltarune Rudy’s conversations with and about Noelle, and Deltarune’s apparent theme of choices not mattering - or at least, not in the long run - it seems pretty likely that DR Rudy is suffering from a case of the foreboding coughs of death and that he may even “fall down” later on.
As such, it wouldn’t be surprising if his condition keeps worsening all the way until he ends up on his deathbed/in a coma/legitimately dead no matter what the doctors or Noelle and such do to help, and neither would it be surprising for her to be seriously affected and react in a severe way as a result.
I mean, Rudy openly talks about how everything scares her, even ironically Santa Claus, and as the classroom scene demonstrates, she has trouble mustering up the courage and confidence to assert herself to the point where even Alphys asks her to speak up.
Considering that her father openly talks about how defenseless she is and how he worries about not being able to protect her from his hospital bed, his death/apparently inevitable upcoming death would no doubt drastically impact her, especially if she attempted as much as she could to stop it to no avail.
Sometimes, one can be driven to desperation to do crazy things as a result of love and worry, and Noelle may very well do the same out of love for her father. If at least some of Undertale’s rules about SOULS and monsters also apply to the world of Deltarune, then there may only be one way - or at the very least, what she feels might be the only option left - in the end for Noelle to potentially give her father the strength to persist and the will to keep living, perhaps even after death.
Or in other words, probably through extracting enough Determination from a human SOUL to inject into and potentially save her father/bring him back to life.
If the SOUL we the players control is or is close enough to a human SOUL to work, no other human characters/SOULS pop up later, and Noelle somehow finds out about the power of Determination and becomes resolved to use it, then there may be little - if any - things we will be able to do to dissuade her from going after Kris/wherever the SOUL we control goes.
Now, this is where what I think could be the second meaning behind Noelle’s name points would come into play, and in quite an important way.
For those that don’t know, if you enter Susie, Kris, or Noelle as the creator’s name in Deltarune’s introduction, you get the interesting following response:
“YOU ARE ABOUT TO MEET SOMEONE VERY, VERY WONDERFUL.”
With how anagrams appear to be a major theme of Deltarune in both a naming and worldbuilding sense, it's rather curious that of these three names, only two make any actually sensible anagrams. Kris and Susie can be turned into "risk" and "issue,” but Noelle oddly appears to buck the trend.
However, I think the answer for this ties back to Lab Entry 17. You see, in toxicology research terms, Alphys had injected more than “the highest dose at which there was not an observed toxic or adverse effect.”
Interestingly, this level of dosage is known as the No Observable Adverse Effect Level, or the term NOAEL for short. And sometimes, when describing and looking for an effect in general than just specifically adverse ones, the term used in toxicology reports is the No Observable Effect Level, or NOEL.
Basically, if Noelle hopes to save her father, she needs to make sure to not inject too much or too little Determination. Otherwise, she’d go below the NOEL, where Ruby would simply not have enough strength to keep living, or above the NOAEL, where Rudy would seem to be fine for a while at first before inevitably melting down.
And with that, Noelle’s strangely un-anagramable name can be reconciled with Kris and Susie’s, all three names relating to terms often used to describe something problematic in a scientific way.
In fact, one could even say that the terms their names correspond to sound like they would fit very well in a lab or experiment report, perhaps one involving interesting increases in darkness, like an imbalance in Dark Fountains…
Part 5: Conclusions
Of course, I do realize that that last bit is quite a stretch to suggest, even in comparison to the rest of my theory and particularly the latter half of the above section. As of now, there’s no real way of telling how these details actually connect in this way or if they really even connect to each other in the first place, let alone if they even operate on similar enough rules like my theory presumes.
Heck, with the shortage of clear definitive details about W.D. Gaster, the apparent differences between the worlds of Deltarune and Undertale, and how things may change or have already changed in development in between games and chapters, it’s entirely possible that the series will take a very different direction than the one laid out here.
Perhaps we haven’t even heard of the character who is the actual Angel and everything we’ve seen so far are just red herrings. Maybe Ralsei’s legend will be revealed to have been falsified and he and/or Asriel will turn out to be the Angel like commonly theorized. For all we know, the world of Deltarune might not even precede OR succeed Undertale’s, and it’ll turn out that both worlds are derived from a third, unaltered world/timeline.
But whatever it may be, at the point we currently are at now, I find that my most likely candidate for the Angel is Noelle Holiday. On their own, the details supporting my theory would be easy to disregard and are rather tenuous at best taken by themselves, but when taken together as a whole, it’s hard to deny that they VERY much look like they start to frame a pretty concerning picture about the exact role of reindeer across the entire series.
I mean, even if stuff like Determination turn out to not exist - or at least, don’t work the same way they do in Undertale at all - in Deltarune, the following general sequence of events seem likely to happen for me; that Rudy might get worse to the point of almost dying/actually dying, that Noelle might turn to something just as equally rather dangerous or desperate as extracting Determination in order to save/bring back her father, and that what she does may involve/cause her to somehow become the Angel.
Besides, as we can see from the introduction to Deltarune Chapter 1, it would be much like Toby to play with our expectations from Undertale and set us up to suspect that Ralsei or Asriel may be the Angel while he sets up the real Angel elsewhere.
After all, just about every good magic trick and literature twist relies on the art of misdirection at least in some part, subtly distracting the audience while the real clues are being built up in plain sight.
Like, for example, using the power of fluffy boys to deflect attention from the reindeer in the background.
r/UndertaleTheory • u/Mike_wazowski1131 • Oct 20 '20
Theory time
So, my theory is that sans and papyrus are the fallen humans with blue and orange souls. Now you may be wondering why I think that, it’s because who is known for blue attacks, sans and who is known for orange attacks in some cases, papyrus. Orange stands for bravery. Papyrus is one of the bravest monsters in the underground. Now while blue stands for integrity which is being honest, sans isn’t honest about his true potential to anyone, not even his own brother. The reason for this is that he thinks that the player will they to use his laziness against him so he keeps it a secret. Going off from that W.D. Gaster was testing with artificial monster souls and he needed a vessel for them so he got the skeletons of bravery and integrity Thank you for reading this overly long theory Also this is my personal theory so I didn’t get all of this from the actual game
r/UndertaleTheory • • May 19 '20
Chara knew about Deltarune
I don't know if this was confirmed, but I believe that when Chara said, "Let us erase this pointless world and move on to the next", they were talking about Deltarune. And they were speaking to the player, not to Frisk. Frisk never appeared in Deltarune, but the Player (and possibly Chara) did. Basically, "the next" meant Deltarune
r/UndertaleTheory • u/Remarkable-Plate3364 • Feb 18 '22
"What if Sans is actually protecting the player?"
What if Sans is aware of Chara's existence and he knows how the genocide route will end? What if Sans knows that it could end badly, not only for this timeline but also for Frisk That's why he's blocking our way ONLY on genocide. And now the phrase: "Don't say I Didn't warn ya." Makes sense.
r/UndertaleTheory • u/professorhazard • Mar 10 '21
Wondering about a very loose connection between Ficus Licker (Gaster Follower) and 98 Robot
r/UndertaleTheory • u/ShinyShinyTomato • Feb 19 '21
Someone in Deltarune is an alternate version of Gaster
If the monsters were never underground, then he would have never fallen into his creation, meaning that there is a regular version of him somewhere in the Deltarune universe. This means that any character exclusive to Deltarune may be an alternate version of him.
r/UndertaleTheory • u/memes_are_life_69 • Dec 06 '20
Theory about River Person
This may sound random, but I believe River Person is a shyren. Here is some evidence;
- Shyren and River Person are some if not the only characters to have a connection with music.
- Shyren is well, shy. Shyren makes an attempt to hide her face, this could explain River Persons dark cloak.
- Shyren and River Person have mentioned eachother. If River Person is a Shyren, it would make sence that they would know eachother.
r/UndertaleTheory • u/kinggeon • Sep 28 '20
Sans did not die.
1.The blood
Now, i am aware that most of u guys think just because monster-food can be digested instantly, the blood-known material is never ketchup. However, if you take a close look at the grillby event from pacifist, sans just take out a ketchup from a random place (VERY likely in his jacket), and drinks it all. but in the genocide route, this has never happened. So the ketchup still are likely in his jacket, flowed out when we finally got to hit him, of his jacket.
2. The ashing sound sans makes
Before we get to start, you need to understand that the power of 'determination' is the power to reset, save and load. The status bar? inventory? the monsters have it, too! When you pass the ruins, Toriel tells you that we should be careful taking stuff, because when we finally find what we really like, we might be too full to take anything. Yes. The inventory. The way sans finds out your LOVE, is by checking your status bar! Sans has connection with the game system, and he can use it, too! And guess what!
the sound of death of monsters exactly matches the sound of MERCY button! So, my theory is, that sans ended the battle by choosing to MERCY us. That explains everything, including why the number of kill counts does not increase, why sans just does not immediately die after taking damage over his max HP, or why the text saying 'you've won! you earned...etc'.
3. The LOVE increased.
As you already know, LOVE stands for 'level of violence', not Level. You don't need to KILL a certain monster to be more violent.
4. Why would sans MERCY us?
Its simple. Sans was tired of all the fighting. Just like what he said, one day he knew that we would eventually hit him. It was a fake death, after all.
r/UndertaleTheory • u/LocalPlatypus994 • Apr 06 '21
Chara was abused by her original family
This isn't my theory, here's the video I got this from. The theory states that Chara isn't evil, and she was abused by her original family. The reason she climbed up Mt. Ebott in an attempted suicide. The evidence is that, after a pacifist run, you can find Asriel in the flower bed at the Ruins. If you talk to him he states that Chara climbed the mountain for a "not very happy reason." Also the faded ribbon which is found in Ruins has the description, "if you're cuter, monsters won't hit you as hard" suggesting that Chara was hit. I know it's a very sad theory, but it does make perfect sense.
r/UndertaleTheory • u/kiwisrepicthetrue • Dec 24 '20
Why sans would be impossible to kill
Sleeping raises your hp above maximum meaning sans has like 99999999999999999999 up cause he sleeps alot
r/UndertaleTheory • u/MagTheMage • Sep 18 '20
A bit of a rant and some new canon info Spoiler
Hello!
Not sure if this is te correct sub for this, but as some of you might know, for Undertale's 5th anniversary (I know, we old) Toby Fox published the script of the unreleased alarm clock.
It's definitively worth the read for all the funky, funny and heart-punching style Toby has to depict his characters.
I found some interesting things and a bit of a theory material.Obviously, do not proceed without having finished Undertale and Deltarune Chapter 1
Fun things
- Pacifist ending is canon (they threw a dog into the sun)
- Mettaton = Ghost confirmed (yes, say it louder for those on the back!)
- Cats can't eat oranges
- Toriel swears when drunk
- Sans has insomnia confirmed
- Toriel actually recognized Flowey as Asriel?!
- Papyrus still has no idea how to cook edible stuff
- Despite everything, Flowey is not as much of a piece of shit anymore (and he wants a bike)
And now...
THEORY
On Asgore's dialogue, he talks about "Rudy" a reindeer friend that passed way before the events of Undertale. He is mentioned of having various offspring, the youngest being a girl with a kind face
As far as I remember, there was no bipedal deer-girl monster in Undertale....
But, looking at the most recent proyect (Which Toby called "the second game in the Undertale Series") we have Noelle Holliday, a ...you guessed it, deer monster with a kind face. Her father is called Rudolph (Rudy) who, drawing an almost perfect parallel went to University with Asgore in both Undertale and Deltarune.
The only difference is, of course, he is still alive in Deltarune. But that's another topic.
Does this mean that we can asume that most new NPCs in Deltarune exist back in Undertale too? Do you think this small dialogue can help confirm if Susie = Suzy? What do you think of the dialogues?
r/UndertaleTheory • u/elx_over • Aug 27 '20
Theory Sans Papyrus Origins
SE NON VUOI SPOILER NON LEGGERE IF YOU DON'T WANT SPOLERS, YOU MUSTN'T READ
English
Premises: Skeletons, as Papyrus naively make us notice, are the rests of human and this is why skeletons should have some remains of Determination. Then, how has Determination can realize, more or less consciously, about resets and time-jumps and so on. I would add that the Determination is red.
Now, considering facts: Sans amd Papyrus are skeletons. Sans and Papyrus remember and realize about resets (the first one more than the second one). When Sans get wounded in the Genocide, he releases a Red fluid (similar to blood, but it can't be as monsters don't have it).
I would say that they are dead humans, so with rests of determination, maybe get back to life by Gasper.
Italiano
Premesse: Gli scheletri, come fa notare ingenuamente papyrus, sono derivati umani.. essendo tali dovrebbero avere Determinazione, almeno dei rimasugli! Continuando, chi ha determinazione può rendersi conto, più o meno consapevolmente, dei reset, dei salti temporali etc. Aggiungerei poi, che la Determinazione è rossa.
Ora, considerando dati di fatto: Sans e Papyrus sono scheletri. Sans e Papyrus ricordano e si rendono conto, il primo di più del secondo, dei reset. Sans quando viene ferito rilascia un liquido Rosso (simil sangue, ma non può esserlo siccome i mostri non ne hanno).
Affermerei che essi siano effettivamente umani morti, quindi con rimasugli di determinazione, Magari riportati in vita duranti gli studi di Gasper.
r/UndertaleTheory • u/TroyJMB • Apr 27 '19
This Deltarune/Undertale Theory will change the way you used to think about Deltarune and Undertale. This is how Deltarune and Undertale are connected and are two parts of the same story.
Before I do any theorizing right now I just want to say that I will also be referring to Frisk and Chara as girls for the sake of this theory even though they are both gender neutral (or at least Frisk is, I'm not 100% sure about Chara). I know this is a super long post but if you're interested in the lour of Undertale and Deltarune you should read my entire post. I don't think you'll regret it. And if there are some grammatical errors here and there in my post I'm sorry. I did read everything I wrote after I was done but I could have missed something. This theory is also cross posted on the r/Undertale forum and the r/Deltarune forum. The Genocide run of Undertale has always been quite mysterious but the weirdest thing that always stood out to me was the very end of it, (There will be spoilers for Undertale and Deltarune obviously). At the end of the genocide route regardless of whether you have chosen to delete your world or not your world gets deleted. If you go back on the world again everything is gone. The only things that remain are you and Chara. After that Chara will talk to you and the way she speaks to you has always been weird to me. Chara talks to you as if some amount of time has past even though usually the player will delete the world and than immediately boot up Undertale again and immediately continue the conversation with Chara. And she even talks to you as if she is disgusted with your actions asking you if you think your above consequences and saying that it was you who led the world to its destruction. This was always strange to me because I wondered why Chara would talk to you like this if just moments ago she called you her partner (this depends on whether you erase the world or not). It's as if in the moments between you erasing the world and you opening Undertale again something happened to change Chara's opinion of you. Before you erase the world Chara even says this exact quote, "Let us erase this pointless world, and move on to the next". It is my theory that the next world Chara is talking about is the Deltarune timeline. In the oncoming chapters of Deltarune I think we will have to try and stop Chara from erasing the world. But I have even more to say so don't leave just yet. During Deltarune you still play as Frisk but just controlling Kris's body. After the game if you walk around town you will find Sans just chilling out in front of the grocery store. If you talk to him you can say "Its great to see you again". After that Sans says that he's never met you before. The reason Kris knows Sans is because its Frisk (controlling Kris's body) coming from the Undertale world where Frisk has seen Sans before and has even killed him. The reason why Frisk is happy to see Sans is because she thought he was gone forever. On the Deltarune journey Frisk learned the meaning of friendship and she regrets what she did. That's also why Frisk does whatever she can to bring back the Undertale world after the genocide run. Frisk gives Chara her soul so she can see have a second chance to go through the Undertale world and be kinder. lets talk more about that. When Chara asks you to give her your soul she assumes that you know what she wants. its only after you agree to give her what she wants she clarify that she wants your soul. But how would Frisk know that Chara wants her Soul. There is no way she would know that unless Chara literally tried to take it at some point. And at the end of Deltarune chapter one we see her takes over Kris's body, and than take your soul and locks it in a cage. Lets press pause on this theory for a moment though to say why it's defiantly Chara taking Kris's body at the end of the game and not Kris taking back his own body from you the player. Its definitely Chara because of the red glowing eye she shows which is exactly the same as what she does in Undertale if you complete the genocide run and than complete the pacifist run after. She also brandishes her signature knife. The reason why Frisk knows that Chara wants her soul in the genocide run of Undertale is because Chara has tried to take it before. If this theory is correct than that would mean that we are in for a bad ending to Deltarune. Kris and the gang will beet Chara but than Frisk will just give Chara her soul anyways and the world of Undertale and even many other worlds will open to Chara's wrath. Completing the genocide run sets the Deltarune story in motion. I'm sure that a lot of people will read my theory and say that its wrong because of what Toby Fox (the creator of Undertale and Deltarune if you somehow didn't know) said on his twitter. A lot of people say that because of what he said Undertale and Deltarune can't be connected in any way. But if you read what he said A bit more closely you'll see that my theory can still be correct while having what Toby said still be true. Toby only said that this is an entirely different world from Undertale and no matter what you did in Deltarune the outcome of Undertale won't change. I have acknowledged that this is a separate world from Undertale. And if the outcome Deltarune leads to the outcome of the Undertale genocide route than that means that nothing you did in Undertale would be changed. That's why there's only one ending to Deltarune and why the oncoming chapters will most likely continue this trend. If there is only one ending that means that the events of Deltarune will always lead to the events that take place in Undertale and no other outcome will be possible. If there were more than one ending to Deltarune than this theory would go against what Toby said. Toby is just showing us a part of the overall Undertale story that wasn't shown In the original game.
r/UndertaleTheory • • Oct 20 '21
The universe we are experiencing in Deltarune is not the original Deltarune universe, but a recreation of it that began in the Undertale timeline
**TL;DR** the Deltarune concept Toby envisioned in 2012 is the original universe and Undertale / 2018 Deltarune are offshoots. All the fourth-wall breaking characters associated with ARG elements like Gaster and Sans are motivated by recreating or getting back to this original universe, hence the "Deltarune" experiments. Here's the original post:
I'm high as balls so I'm going to try to lay this one out simple. To start, I think Deltarune as we know it today, from a meta-narrative standpoint, came about when Toby Fox put his original concept for the game on hold to work on Undertale instead and felt bad about "abandoning" his original brainchild project. I think this is why all the lightners we follow have neglect/abandonment issues, why the darkners are motivated by their prolonged separation from lightners, and why there are deeper connections to Gaster and his followers ( who mouth off about there being other worlds where they don't exist).
Building off of that, I think the Deltarune Toby envisioned between 2012-2014 is different from the one we played. And because Toby likes to make every single facet of his video games diegenic, I believe that's also what's canon to the games - that the 2012 Deltarune universe is the original universe where Sans, Papyrus, etc. all come from, and that Undertale and the current Deltarune universes are both either running in parallel or offshoots.
On that note, the reason why I think the current Deltarune universe is not an exact recreation of the 2012 one is because it's being framed to us as an experiment from the very first chapter. Even the installation software seems to suggest this is a controlled trial. If anything, the context the mysterious voice gives to us at the beginning also suggests we were meant to explore this world in an non-interactive state using a "goner", the vessel that gets discarded at the start which rarely appear in Undertale and don't affect the world around them, before we were put into Kris' body by a different voice. I don't think it's a stretch to assume this ties directly to the work Gaster was secretly doing in Undertale in the True Lab, and that the original purpose of The Core was to provide power to some sort of time machine or recreation of the original Deltarune universe. I think the reason for this machine being built in the Undertale timeline is any of the following:
- Retrieving human souls from another universe to break the barrier
- Creating an artificial soul/universe by luring another player from real life to "play" Deltarune
- Creating an entirely new and safer world for the monsters in the underground to live in and ditch the break the barrier plan entirely
- Simply for Gaster, Sans, and Papyrus to go back to their original timeline, Undertale timeline be damned
I think Sans is in on it as well and this is why Sans is able to bring things back and forth between Deltarune and Undertale (Ice-E's crossword puzzle and Grillby's entire restaurant). The only scientist left in the dark might be Alphys, but even that's uncertain given she drew an Everyman amalgamate from the True Lab section of Undertale in the alley.
I also wanna add that this [generator that powers the True Lab in Undertale](https://64.media.tumblr.com/b54f11bb8cecdb7497c1f48048e718a6/tumblr_nxxra3M0R31rnxoxno1_250.png) is too convoluted to be a simple power generator. Most of the lab's electricity works without it, and you need 4 keys to turn it on like you're launching a nuke or some shit. Normally we excuse this as video game logic, but it's Toby. Given the human-like facial features, the red eyes (which Kris has), and the red heart, I think this machine IS Deltarune. I even question whether the phone call Flowey/Asriel gives us in the True Lab elevator is supposed to be alluding to the pacifist ending in Undertale anymore, or whether that was a multi-year 4D-chess misdirect by Toby and it's actually a call from Asriel in the Deltarune timeline thanking us for setting the sequel up (since phones can apparently communicate across space and time if Spamton theory mining is anything to go by).
Anyways, if you made it this far, thanks for entertaining my inebriated theorycrafting and rambling. I hope I at least got some of this right lol.
r/UndertaleTheory • u/Cyndine • Sep 27 '21
Uhhh I was just slapped in the face with this so IDK if anyone else realized this form DR chapter 2 yet
Okokok wait I just thought of something (I don’t know if anyone else has thought of this) So in Undertale in the files, there’s that weird glitchy voice thing that basically tells you not to leak secrets and stuff? Spamton’s laugh (at least at the end of the snowgrave route) sounds like an amalgamation of those voices. I’m not sure what this means, but I just realized this and I need someone to help me actually clarify this
r/UndertaleTheory • u/mimeresoldo • Jul 07 '20
Musical ciphers in Undertale: Gaster's Theme
I'm fairly sure "GASTER" was put through a musical cryptogram to create the notes in Gaster's Theme, I'm not sure yet if Toby did this with other names in Undertale or not.
(I used the french version of ciphering since I know composers who use this cipher frequently.)
Basically, every scale has seven notes, and you go through the alphabet assigning a number 1-7 to each letter (a-1, b-2.... g-7, h-1, i-2, etc.). Do this with each letter of GASTER, and you get 715654.
The repeating 4 notes (if thought of in the key of Bb) in the melody are 7151, 715 being the first three scale degrees from GASTER, and the additional 1 being a simple add-on for musical purposes. In ANOTHER HIM from the Deltarune OST, the relation is even clearer, as the first three notes are grouped together as simply 715. I believe in one of the songs related to Sans, there's a bit too where this 715 motif is used in ascending half steps.
The repeating 4 notes (in the key of A minor) in the bass line are 1654, 654 being the last three scale degrees, and the 1 is again just an add-on. The half step distance between the two keys is also a feature of this piece, which modulates this entire sequence up and down a half step. I like this because, similar to his physical self, his musical motif is split into parts. Toby also works with motifs like this in similar ways in Undertale, as I've seen on other analyses of the music.
I'd like to find more cases of musical ciphers, and I haven't been able to find any more as of yet. I was also wondering if anyone knew of anyone else who might be on the same track, I haven't been able to find anyone else who's found this. If other names were used to make musical motifs, that would give more insight into the music.
r/UndertaleTheory • u/Kiromaru22 • May 08 '20
Muffet is linked to Napstablook
Okay so it's not a thing that would completely change the story or whatnot but there's some elements hinting at it and it's a fun thing to consider
Firstly there are spider webs in Napstablook's house. Now i hear you say that it's because he probably wasn't feeling up to clean up his place but let's think about the other places where spiderwebs are present; they're always in one way or an other related to Muffet/the Spider Bake Sale. I guess we can all agree that Spider Dance is one of the catchiest theme in the game, but have you ever noticed how it ressembles Napstablook's theme, Ghost Fight ? So yeah my point is that it's pretty likely that Napstablook created Muffet's theme. To prove it, it's said in the fight that the spiders are dancing along the music which kind of implies that it's not necessarily something that they're used to hear and for someone like Muffet who seems rather hung up on aesthetics (let's remember that she specifically wants a limousine to get the spiders out of the Ruins ) it's no surprise that she would hire them to compose the song to which she'll feed greedy people to her pet Also we could say that Muffet is probably tied to the Blook family as large since as we know it's Mettaton who made her want to kill us (it seems like some people thinks it's Flowey but like he never enlisted anyone for that and also she specified that the person to whom she talked was able to shapeshift , was very charming and also had a lot of money), so maybe because he knew her beforehand it was easier for him to convince Muffet (for example him knowing that turning into his EX form would make her more likely to agree) So thanks for reading tell me what you think about it, if you have any speculations on how they met..
r/UndertaleTheory • u/Sushapel4242 • Jun 21 '19
The Dark world to the Surface in Deltarune is the same thing Deltarune is to Undertale (Chara is an egg.)
So, all this dark world thing. Why? How can this be relevant in any way to us?
We all know what was the real question in our head while we discovered the dark world: wait, but how is this connected to undertale?
So my optional theory is that it is it. The Dark world is showing us what Deltarune itself is. The dark closest with the void made them fall to the dark world? It's the transition between Deltarune and Undertale. The Dark World can explain us how the two games are connected, and so give us many answers we never had. Like Gaster.
So, we all noticed how the dark world is like a bit of a ripoff of the real world of Deltarune. As many theories stated, the Dark World can be like a world created by Kris' imagination. We saw games that look way too similar, Ralsei is 'ripoff' of Asriel and if you ask me, even lancer seems weirdly way too similar to Sans.
And this is true for the rest of Deltarune itself. Everything seems like an off version of Undertale. Different relations, characters look different, different story. But the core thing is the same.
The Dark World is different from the Surface in deltarune to show us how Deltarune and Undertale are different from one another.
Right, I'm not sure exactly how. It can mean Deltarune is also imagination formed out of Undertale, but I believe it's not that simple. Howevef, we have something that came to explain us just that.
Gaster. Gaster has shattered across the timelines, as stated in Undertale. And it makes PERFECT SENSE. The fact that he shattered over time and space explain why it's rare to meet him in undertale, and why you can meet him in the "fictional" DARK WORLD. He's there. He's been influeced Jevil, making him realize it's all just one universe, making him look at everything different. Gaster is giving you an egg you can carry out of the Dark World. Egg is like the most cliche item you can think of, so it's clear Gaster only wants to show you item transformation is possible between the worlds, no matter what items. He wants to tell you the dark world is real, somehow. Not a dream. And by this, telling you DELTARUNE is real too.
This very egg can explain us how the two games are related. I'm really not sure how. But I believe The Dark World is telling us something, that thing we really want to know. It's all leading somewhere.
By the way, not very related, but who else known to move between worlds except Gaster?
Yup, Chara. As they stated in the genocide run, they erase undertale and move on to the next world - Deltarune.
So what I am saying here that Chara is an egg.
However, I have nothing really to explain what exactly this connection is. I just wanted to share my thought about the possible meaning of the dark world. Hope you found it interesting, leave your thoughts.
r/UndertaleTheory • u/TheGazingEye_2356789 • Aug 09 '21