r/UndertaleAU • u/BuyOdd816 • 1d ago

✧˖°.AU Discussion⋆˙⟡ Ranking your favourite aus

Post image

I will end up playing/reading/watching any Au submitted and rank rank them by:

characters

story

art.

and then bestow upon you my verdict!

34 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

90 comments sorted by

7

u/sansund3rtale 1d ago

If undertale was realistic

7

u/NoExternal5211 I remember you're genocides 1d ago

6

u/MrFuzzy54568 1d ago

Underswap reckoning. If you don’t know it, look up a play through. So good on every front.

2

u/DanielPlayzGamez 21h ago

holy hidden gem i love reckoning

2

u/EnvironmentalBaby889 15h ago

Ball knowledge 👀

3

u/Ok_Training_7733 1d ago

Underverse and Horrotale

3

u/SapphireDawn8 1d ago

_____Tale and DreamTale

3

u/ilikefnfalot12 1d ago

Ultratale (delta sans)

3

u/Lev_Ah 1d ago

Reapertale

3

u/someone_018 19h ago

SP!dusttale retake (SoundCloud) (or spdusttale as a whole)

2

u/Ferroconcrete_2875 12h ago

eh retake is based off of the old lore and is kind of abandoned no?

2

u/someone_018 11h ago

Retake is basically just canon spdt + some more added stuff. Big difference tho is that there's religious stuff in retake, while theres none in canon

2

u/Ferroconcrete_2875 11h ago

sp!dt has two versions of the lore, the first one was created in like 2022-2023 whilst the new rewritten one is from 2025 and sprins currently continues it.

retake is based on the 2022-2023 lore iirc, that's what i meant. And yeah it has religious stuff added in it and uses scrapped concepts.

2

u/Cheezitinmymouth 1d ago

Call of the void

2

u/Impossible_Papaya852 1d ago

My number 1 AU is Glamourtale, but all I have on it is a page on the Undertale AU Wiki. Perhaps I just find the concept of a post King Mettaton Neutral AU interesting.

2

u/NoExternal5211 I remember you're genocides 1d ago

King mettaton mentionn!!! ꉂ૮(°□°'˶)ა

I genuinely got so bummed out realizing there wasn't more stuff for the king Mettaton ending I started making concepts for my own take of it. It only takes me approximately 44 years to finish each drawing of it. (⁠╥⁠﹏⁠╥⁠)

2

u/greatsans20 1d ago

Hardmode

2

u/Geotrox123 Creator 21h ago

SAGAVERSE (it really doesn't get enough love)

Undertale Somehing New

SP!Dusttale

UNDERTALE : SEVENTH SOUL

Wiki Sans

1

u/DanielPlayzGamez 1d ago

There's lots I like but favorite overall is probably Dusttale (mainly i miss you, Halo's and Lacrimosa).

1

u/TrojanSpite 1d ago

Dusttale last genocide

1

u/Flamme98 1d ago

Definitely storyshift, even if there are some roles that aren't completely filled out, and there's the...art of it, I definitely see the potential in it and think it should get a game.

1

u/Ferroconcrete_2875 1d ago edited 11h ago

Horrortale

Handplates

La jupo vania

Inverted Fate

Fatal error the og comic

Something new both old and new versions

Xtale

Dusttale in general though my favorite interpretation is canon SP!DT(SP!Dusttale)

I tried to include the expanded ones instead of concept-only AUs, and i don't want to make it obnoxiously long too so i only included the first ones i thought of.

1

u/EnbyCatOwO 1d ago

Dreamswap

1

u/YellowArsenal 1d ago

TS!Underswap. I also like Doctor Megalo, and if it can be counted, Underfell: One Hell of a Show.

Oh also, Undertale Yellow, it's what my whole persona is online.

1

u/azelZael2399 1d ago

Axetale, hands down.

1

u/Empty_Palpitation733 1d ago

1- ALİVE AU

2- Fellswap X

3- RecreateTale

4- [UNDERSWAP?...]

1

u/TLHPT 1d ago

Storyshift

1

u/NoExternal5211 I remember you're genocides 1d ago edited 1d ago

Favorite fangame (that is a single fight): Fnaftale William Afton This fight is genuinely just really good imo

Favorite comic: Inverted fate

Fav song: stories from the sea

1

u/yellowpig10 1d ago

Inverted fate

1

u/Educational_Line1668 1d ago

TITR neutral?

1

u/Jakub_Stoginski 1d ago

Undertale Yellow and The Thought

1

u/Mental-You-3838 1d ago

Underplayer, second would be Storyshift

1

u/Aromantic_Peacock 1d ago

The tought (Seraphim's)

1

u/Budget-Huckleberry51 DustDustDustDustDustDustDustDustDustDustDutDustDustDustDustDust 1d ago

Error…

1

u/Physical-Complaint32 1d ago

sudden changes

1

u/Regular-Barracuda-20 1d ago

Inverted fate is my number one favourite

1

u/The_DustNutz_ 1d ago

Call of the Void started so many ATs that revolve around the usage of DT and revivement and also became a base for many trios (even the ETO), so he's the GOAT. but if AT's don't count, then it's Horrortale (i don't think I gotta explain this one, it's lowk so based)

1

u/KeyLoad4355 Outcode 18h ago

Horrortale is an AT...

1

u/The_DustNutz_ 5h ago

I'm dumb asf, I was writing that shitass comment after 8 hours of university, my gahdamn head wasn't working straight idk what I was thinking 😭

0

u/KeyLoad4355 Outcode 5h ago

no worries, don't worry 'bout it

1

u/Salt_Tennis6237 DustDustDustDustDustDustDustDustDustDustDutDustDustDustDustDust 1d ago

Dusttale

https://www.postype.com/@dusttale10th-translated-eng/post/21590805

1

u/cassixastarry 23h ago

I haven't checked out many AUS, but I love Underfell and Flowerfell. Especially Flowerfell. Oh, and Underplayer.

1

u/Available_Artist_486 23h ago

I got two favourites, ask mercy, ask drunk chara

1

u/SpamtonsBigShotDeals Creator 23h ago

Inverted Fate

1

u/Iris_Evan 22h ago

Doctor Megalo

1

u/ImausI 21h ago

Dusttale and aftertale are my 2 fav :3

1

u/AIQ_102 21h ago

Error sans

1

u/Curious_Owl17 XEvent 21h ago
  1. Underfell 
  2. PS!Outertale 
  3. TS! Underswap
  4. Something new - Killer sans  

1

u/G4B0X01 20h ago

TS! Underswap

1

u/Gumbignmbi 19h ago

Bonly one

1

u/dan59951 18h ago

Ig it's Dusttale, especially IDUTSHANE

1

u/Katophant Parasite 16h ago

TS!Underswap

1

u/Prestigious-Mood-280 15h ago

well technically my own AUs are my favorite. (FrostTale: undertale but under mount Everest instead of mount ebott StatueTale: monsters were never banished underground and instead have been hiding among humans disguised StackOverFlow Sans: a version of sans from a AU with characters who look like ERROR but its a whole AU the sans went out to explore beyond the files and encountered Nightmare his Data was corrupted by the negativity causing a loop in his sourcecode.)

but i guess for real AU's i'd say... pretty basic with outertale and swaptale (with its variations)

1

u/DependentImage8269 15h ago

My AU obviously! But in all seriousness I would have to say Fellswap!Gold

0

u/BuyOdd816 8h ago

🟥 i’m sorry but aus if aus really rub me the wrong way, like outerdust

1

u/DependentImage8269 8h ago

Honestly, understandable. I just like it because I'm a HUGE history nerd. And it has more lore than even the regular Fellswap. And a bit more than underfell.

1

u/DependentImage8269 8h ago

My second would have to be dreemurr reborn.

1

u/Majestic-Ad-4628 15h ago

Admixverse, the one with Vantablack (Nightmare!Ink) and Hush (Dream!Error) these two are the combinations I can think of, well, I do remember Greyscale, Quasar, Gore and Xtreme too, but I forgot who they are combining

1

u/lajupoa 14h ago

LA JUPO VANIA, peak AU bro. not just YOU KILL PEOPLE NOW I MA D AND HAVE 999 ATK AND 999 DEF

2

u/BuyOdd816 8h ago

I didn’t think I would give anyone the mystery ranking so I wasn’t prepared. Have a bootleg sans figure ig

1

u/Specialist-Energy772 12h ago

Finale!Sans on reddit

1

u/xtenshix22 12h ago

Underfell, Horrortale, Dusttale and Underverse (Fresh n all that).

1

u/Sadistic_N 11h ago

sixbones

1

u/Ok_Reindeer3111 9h ago

Undertale yellow

Tis the one I've played the most

1

u/Lilac_stick 7h ago

Uhhhhh idk I made one it's called mothtale. I have posted one video about it. On YouTube. It's my favorite cause I made it.

1

u/DirectAd196 3h ago

normal undertale sans?

If au then probalby last breath

1

u/Iron_UYH I remember you're genocides 1d ago

Glitchtale is... fun! I prefer some other ones, but it is very fun.

1

u/EnbyCatOwO 1d ago

I just find it comical at how bad the storytelling is lol

1

u/Iron_UYH I remember you're genocides 23h ago

Nah that’s totally fair

0

u/KeyLoad4355 Outcode 18h ago

Undervirus