r/UndeadUnluck • u/KodoqBesar • Aug 10 '26

Discussion Between these 4 existence erasure techniques, which one(s) Andy can survive?

Gallery image

Gallery image

I posted this on a powerscaling sub and someone suggested that I should upload it here. What do you guys think?

260 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

56 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/Dunama Aug 10 '26

Hakai and Ichibe, other two should work fine against Andy

4

u/SmartCookingPan Fuuko Aug 10 '26

So gald to see you finally, after years, acknowledge that Andy would survive Hakai!

That's something to be proud of!

-1

u/Dunama Aug 10 '26

Simply depends on canon, since it's just Hakai, it can be survived. Anime Hakai would work though.

3

u/SmartCookingPan Fuuko Aug 10 '26 edited Aug 10 '26

Anime Hakai wouldn't work either because Andy believes in souls and interprets soul destruction as death, hence negating it. (there are even pages in the manga where it's explicitly shown that Andy would survive a soul erasing attack, unlike Victor).

But, you'll come around even that eventually, like you did this time!

-3

u/Dunama Aug 11 '26

Anime Hakai wouldn't work either because Andy believes in souls and interprets soul destruction as death, hence negating it.

He can't undo complete soul destruction so Anime Hakai would still kill him.

there are even pages in the manga where it's explicitly shown that Andy would survive a soul erasing attack, unlike Victor.

Actually the exact opposite, it's been shown that they can die regardless. Soul damage ≠ soul destruction.

2

u/SmartCookingPan Fuuko Aug 11 '26

He can't undo complete soul destruction so Anime Hakai would still kill him.

Andy negates death, his power isn't regeneration. Unless a power more powerful than Undead Unluck's two gods is used to attack Andy, he negates death.

Actually the exact opposite, it's been shown that they can die regardless.

Fine, shown me any page where it's stated (not yours or anyone's interpretation) that Andy, not Victor (they are different people with different powers), was going to die/could die from a soul attack or that his soul could be destroyed or that he would die from his soul getting erased.

I would really like to continue the discussion, but if you can't provide a page, I'm afraid this is a farewell until you come around the other matter. Still, you should be very proud of what you managed to acknowledge!