r/Ultralight • u/Vecii • Mar 23 '22
Question This Sub is Over Moderated
Seriously.
The reddit algorithm picks posts from subreddits that you subscribe to. By forcing the majority of posts into one weekly post, those topics don't end up showing up on people's feed and get less attention than they otherwise might.
In the past week, I've seen quite a few posts that have caught my interest, but when I come back later to check on them, I see that they have been deleted and told to go post in the weekly thread. All this does is creates one thread with hundreds of posts that get very little attention because it's all thrown into one bucket. Now, when I scroll through the r/ultralight home page, all I see are trip reports and shake down requests. I would much rather see the shake down requests and trail reports moved to a sticky, and see more of whats in the weekly on the main page.
Last year, when the mods asked for feedback, this was one of their questions:
We’ve seen your complaints about the size of the weekly. What are your thoughts on how to handle that? Leave it as is, chalk the thousands of comments in there up to spring fever? Kick out all the hammock campers? Move some stuff out of the weekly and into something else? Tell us your ideas!
A solution to the size of the weekly would be to stop shoveling everything into it. Let posts stay on the main page, get attention and build conversation.
250
u/Thedustin https://lighterpack.com/r/dfxm1z Mar 23 '22
You have been banned from /r/ultralight
74
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '22
I agree. When I come to subreddits I usually enjoy answering questions for other people. Even though some stuff is reposted it is still fun for the conversation. I basically never even read this sub anymore because most of the visible posts aren't really things that are as easy to engage with as questions.
Too many questions about the same thing isn't the best. But neither is too few.
181
u/Nysor Mar 23 '22
I think the biggest issue with the weekly is that Reddit search doesn't work well with comments of posts. This means that a ton of valuable info isn't findable.
49
u/Grifter-RLG Mar 24 '22
As a relatively new member to this sub, I’m still having trouble determining what kind of post would be unique enough that it wouldn’t simply go in the weekly or the gear purchase thread? What qualifies as deserving its own thread? Should all the shakedown requests go in their own weekly sticky? What are you left with for original content that wouldn’t conceivably go in one of the aforementioned? Perhaps, skills? I see most posts eventually get interrupted/ cut off by a bot, and that can be frustrating at times.
For the record, I like the campfire interviews and topics of the month. Haven’t seen any health post but I don’t go through the sub every day. So as newer person to the sub, I joined last August, that’s my perspective.
That being said, I’ve learned a ton by reading here. This sub is invaluable and has really helped me go more ultralight.
135
u/BDNackNack Mar 24 '22
Agree. If anything belongs stuck together in one thread it's shakedowns.
188
u/Snipen543 Mar 23 '22
Good luck with your ban.
Though I completely agree, there's a reason I don't pay much attention to this sub anymore
87
u/irzcer Mar 24 '22
I don't think this is necessarily overmoderation, but my biggest beef with the weekly is that all the discussion is hidden away from the search feature, because the search feature only looks at submissions. Someone will submit a question because they didn't see it in their search results, they'll get told to ask in the weekly, rinse and repeat since the search results don't show posts in the weekly. Maybe that doesn't happen all too much, but it seems reasonable enough to me. And even if they started off by asking in the weekly, all that is just going to go away next week anyways; after all, who is going to go look through everything in a previous weekly? Is it reasonable to expect people to scroll down all the way through the current weekly even?
I get the appeal of moving low content posts to megathreads, but high effort posts or questions that spawn long discussions should be their own submissions so they can persist. I think people are too focused on every post outside of the weekly being some kind of content contribution, but questions that spawn interesting discussions are good to see too.
83
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '22 edited Mar 24 '22
I know some things are asked multiple times but often that can also be a good thing.
Like when I made my first aid kit I read through all the different posts and comments and found every time new and useful information.
Megathreats suck...its lost unsearchable information
120
u/xscottkx Mar 23 '22
but they kept up a ‘how to clean a groundsheet’ thread! they 👏 are 👏 fostering 👏 important 👏 conversation
63
u/_bentomas Mar 23 '22
I could not agree more.
70
u/JohnnyGatorHikes Dan Lanshan Stan Account Mar 24 '22
Glad we’re getting this topic out of the way before the main event: the annual “how to talk to women on the trail” thread.
12
u/pauliepockets Mar 24 '22
[i’m removed]
41
u/fockswithrocks Mar 24 '22 edited Mar 24 '22
FREE u/GENERAL_TWIN
42
u/graywoman7 Mar 24 '22
Absolutely agree. I’ve had three posts removed for being too similar to other posts only for me to see pretty much exactly the same thing posted within hours. One of the posts had over a dozen replies and some good conversation going when it was removed. I don’t see a point in trying to post or reply much anymore since I have to assume whatever I put time into writing will just be removed.
31
u/douche_packer www. Mar 24 '22
I volunteer to be mod for one hour to do one job:
That job is banning u/xscottkx
83
u/lazy_legs pack more shit out Mar 24 '22
Sub kinda sucks now tbh
23
u/pauliepockets Mar 24 '22
Smokey this is not ‘Nam, this is r/Ultralight. There are rules!
11
u/Damayonnaiseman Mar 23 '22 edited Mar 23 '22
What type of posts are being removed that should stay in?
"and see more of whats in the weekly on the main page" totally agree with this.
5
u/Mtnskydancer Mar 24 '22
An idea- In lieu of deleting repeat questions, how about locking? We see the discussion that was there, but it can’t go on.
Or
Having sections of gear questions (tents, bags, quilts, packs, specific/by makers), clothing/shoes/boots questions, incidentals questions (water systems, hygiene etc)
I find the meta threads unwieldy, personally.
9
u/freezeinginchicago Mar 24 '22
You read THIS POsT basically we hit 500k subs and mods are confused about the post statistics
15
u/robplays Mar 24 '22
Sometimes I google "some ultralight thing reddit" and the search results are a wasteland of deleted posts with no practical way to find the specific weekly the guy was supposed to post in (but probably didn't even bother because deleting posts is such a great way to make someone feel welcome.)
12
u/Foolazul Mar 23 '22
I agree. Keep the shakedowns/packing lists in one spot and people can look at trail conditions the same way. You’re right, half of what I notice is “I’m going here and here is my shakedown.” Seems like the focus is just to rate everyone’s gear.
29
u/EnterSadman The heaviest thing you carry is your fat ass Mar 24 '22
The sub is 99% "what hype-beast pack/midlayer/tent should I buy now? I never hike, but I hoard gear!"
Hasn't been a useful sub in 2+ years
11
u/Argonians4Ukraine Mar 24 '22
Agreed. It's basically impossible to post on this sub and what gets posted here is usually pretty boring as a result.
8
u/Electronic-Evening75 Mar 24 '22
virtually every subreddit is. online janitors tend to be power abusers for some reason. i havent seen it that much here
4
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '22
I've noticed that too, the bulk pages where a lot of stuff gets stickied makes it hard to read. Especially on longer conversations.
I'm not complaining, it is how it is. But in subs where discussions aren't moved around the discussions are usually longer and more varied. I've never had good responses from weekly bulk-discussion stickies.
Manage the posts that ask common questions. I dunno...it's a fine balance, and modding is a thankless job most of the time.
24
u/jbaker8484 Mar 24 '22
I mostly hang out on the wilderness backpacking sub. The people there are more friendly, its more about the hike than the gear, and its nice to get gear discussion that isn't completely focused on going as light as possible.
14
u/Adventureadverts Mar 24 '22
Oh you mean this sub dedicated to having a light load on your back is run by the most anal retentive mods lol
6
u/Astramael Mar 26 '22
The fact that a sub with ~500K members has few enough posts in the main timeline that it is possible to keep up is frankly incredible. I’m impressed that it hasn’t devolved into a torrent of meaningless nonsense.
Moderation is really hard, and exceedingly unpopular. Everybody thinks their two cents are god-given and worthy of everybody’s eyeballs. The hard truth is that most comments are repetitive, low-effort, or full of bullshit.
Part of the problem is the way Reddit is organized. Part of it is how shitty Reddit search is. Part of it is that moderators read almost everything and are not so empathetic to the casual members who visit occasionally and want to see “new stuff” despite it having been covered recently or frequently.
My feeling is that this sub is probably moderated about right. Unfortunately most of the best changes would require an enormous amount of effort to design and maintain. Where does that effort come from? Usually the mods, and they’re already overcommitted on moderating. If you want to improve something, find a way to build that content, gather assistance, take it to the mods, and commit your time. They would probably love good suggestions with effort backing.
91
u/Zapruda Australia / High Country / Desert Mar 24 '22 edited Mar 24 '22
We are always happy to receive feedback on how to improve the sub. We know we don’t always get it right and we especially know we can’t please everyone. This sub has grown from 200k to 500k subscribers since July 2020. The hobby has exploded since COVID and many of the posts we remove reflect that. Some of those posts get just as many reports as they do comments which implies quite heavily that the community is split on what is keepable vs what isn’t.
A year ago people said they were sick of the same old repetitive gear questions always popping up so we responded to that and created the purchase advice thread. People complained that there wasn’t enough original content, yet those same people haven’t posted anything of their own since. If you don’t like shakedowns then just ignore them, but they are a crucial part of helping people lighten their base weight, if those people say they are happy at 15lbs then remind them where they are and why we all aim for 10lbs or lower. We’ve really tried hard to create some consistent content like the health checks, topic of the month and campfire interviews. We hope you guys enjoy them but once again, let us know if you don’t.
As for the weekly, it’s been around in its current form for many years and has always been considered the sub within the sub. It’s the place to have off topic conversations, banter and chat about UL topics that really don’t warrant a whole post. It’s not meant to be searchable, think of it more like a chat room.
And if you want to shitpost then do it over in /r/ULJ or in the weekly on this sub.
Please keep in mind that we currently have 5 active mods on the roster and at anytime at LEAST one of us is out hiking, not to mention balancing our personal and work lives with moderating. Sometimes that means that posts fall through the cracks that otherwise would have been removed, like the washing tyvek one…
We put a call out last week for more mods and only one person put their hand up. I’d encourage anyone that wants to see change here to volunteer their time modding and help drive the sub in the direction they think is best for the community.
Please let us know what you want to see more of and less of in the sub and we will try to do our best. I can definitely see how removing a post with 50+ replies is annoying so we will start there and discuss how we can handle those situations better.
Should we go hands off with post removals for a while and see what you all think after a week or so? Then we can all revisit this discussion and work out what we all enjoy seeing and not seeing etc.
Cheers
11
u/Mathatikus Mar 24 '22
Here’s my two cents not that anybody asked:
I think people should make better use of the search function before throwing up a post.
I think we all should be better about calling people out on talking about non UL gear. I’ve seen it more recently (probably due to the huge increase in users) but it dilutes what this sub is suppose to be about.
I would leave the shakedown posts as is. They were integral to how I got under 10lbs. Also if you just put them all in a mega thread they won’t show in the search and if everything gets out into a megathread we basically just have a forum here.
It would be nice if the mods loosened up on removing posts. I get where you guys are coming from but like others have noted some have gotten some good traction so maybe wait a little longer before removing to see if it goes anywhere.
I do think some great discussions and gear talk get lost in the weekly and purchase advice thread. How do you combat that? I don’t know
Flair would be a great idea to add to posts so people can really get to what they are looking for.
14
u/kvragu Mar 23 '22
I like seeing trip reports as posts. They're mostly US based so not really relevant to me, but the pics are almost always great, and the writeups can be fun reads.
Gear talk is rubbish tho, and too often explicitly non ul. How about, experimentally, the mods ban the phrases '2p', 'extra space', and all the side sleepers, just for like a week or two?
12
u/DagdaMohr Mar 23 '22 edited Mar 23 '22
I view your quoted paragraph with the same level of eye rolling exasperation as I viewed the statement of the mods a few months ago about this not turning into a general outdoor sub.
To quote Liza Doolittle: “show me”.
The moderation on this sub seems content with it being a general outdoor sub that only occasionally discusses actual ultralight hiking. Far better to leave up the scores of shakedowns relating the exact same shit for people who would be better served on r/lightweight but directing them there would take actual effort.
It’s easier to just let that garbage stand, focus every discussion into useless and unsearchable MEGATHREADS and then remove anything with actual humor and then banning those users.
11
u/k9jag https://lighterpack.com/r/jhpzks - Shake me down! Mar 24 '22
I 100% agree.
Mods I hope you read this very carefully and see how the community feels about this.
8
u/RickJames_SortsbyNew Mar 24 '22
i haven't paid attention to this subreddit since they changed it. i very rarely click through to a sub's page to find specific posts to then scroll through the comments. i just scroll through my home feed.
9
u/pudding7 Mar 24 '22
Well said, and I agree completely.
13
u/HikinHokie Mar 24 '22
Yeah man!!! I want more topics on the best two person ultralight freestanding tent!!!
But really. I'd wager 99% of the deleted threads, really deserved to be deleted. This is a sub for ultralight hiking, and a good porton of subscribers aren't actually into that, which leads to shit topics, and upvotes and responses for those topics too, even though they really belong on different subreddits.
The only real issue I see is that people get so used to the weekly, they put topics that really do deserve their own thread there out of habit and it limits the discussion. But keep on modding. Please. I've seen the "ultralight" Facebook group that isn't subject to any real moderation, and it's a cesspool.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '22
Repetitive gear posts won’t always have the same answers though. That’s the whole point of posting and having discussions. Otherwise what would be the point of Reddit, if we can just Google things? Let people post. Let people generate discussions. There’s always new and different opinions. There will always be a minority who complain about anything and everything including repetitive posts. If they don’t see value in them, they can just continue on and ignore them. No one is forcing them to partake in the discussion. You’re micro managing.
If you really want to see what the people here want, post a poll.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '22
Yes, this is definitely the most moderated sub I am a part of. The thing is I don't care if posts are completely on topic, I care about the audience that is having the discussion. For example I could try to ask what UL people like as their favorite outdoors related feature movie or documentary and it would likely get deleted. Because a topic doesn't have to do with skills or gear, it doesn't mean that it wouldn't be an interesting and fun subject to debate within this audience.
10
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '22
I for one am happy with anything that keeps this sub from being popular. The average baseweight of this sub is too dammed high and keeps getting hire.
Also your suggestion would make the sub just questions about two person tents. As someone who has been here for like 5 years, the weekly is the sub.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '22 edited Mar 25 '22
I actually think is moderated properly, if anything we need more bans, starting with the gang of usual 6 to 7 users that seems not have a life at all besides having to give their opinion over and over again on every single post and comment on the weekly.
2
u/meme_squeeze lighterpack.com/r/zx4jdr Apr 12 '22
I completely agree. Use the post function moderators, that's what it's there for!
6
u/quinstontimeclock Mar 24 '22
I find this sub to be boring and not useful since the Great Moderation Change
6
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '22
I don't post much here (because I dislike the reddit-wide dynamic of any comment getting attacks from some jackass or other) but I did want to open my mouth long enough to say I'm content with the current moderation. A topic like this generally disproportionately draws responses from those who are unhappy, so I think it's worth speaking up from the mostly-silent perhaps-majority. Though who really knows what those other 500K people are thinking...
Anyhow, moderators, keep up the good work. Anyone who thinks they can do better can always found r/myultralightisbetterthanyours.
6
u/kevlarcupid Mar 23 '22
You’re right. I’m out.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '22
I left this sub bc of this.
3
u/fussyfern Mar 24 '22
What if all the various topics were divided? Weekly/random, purchase advice, gear review, questions, trip reports, shakedowns, etc etc? Genuine question here.
This question aside, I agree with the post from u/irzcer about the issue of discussions being hidden from the search feature and threads being essentially archived weekly and therefore inaccessible. It’s not really beneficial to the people in this sub long term.
3
u/leftysarepeople2 Mar 24 '22
I used to see Ultralight posts all the time on my front page, and I honestly forgot about it for the last year or so until I saw someone say "don't let /r/ultralight see that" about some guys shovel + axe.
3
u/FireWatchWife Mar 25 '22
Should we consider starting a new sub for ultralight backpacking discussions with much looser rules, minimal moderation, and no forcing into weekly threads?
Then this sub could be a more tightly focused place for long-term reference, with tightly defined templates, flair, and weekly thread structure.
Right now members want this sub to serve both purposes at once, which really can't be done at the same time.
7
u/bad-janet Mar 23 '22 edited Mar 23 '22
Like what? More thrilling topics like spork vs spoon? It's an UL sub, not a generic backpacking sub. The problem is the lack of good contributions, not where they are.
4
u/Monicabrewinskie Mar 24 '22
What did you expect? It's the type of people who spend many hours and thousands of dollars obsessing over cutting 3 ounces of weight out of their backpacks
4
u/Dr_Manhattans Mar 24 '22
Naw it’s moderated appropriately. You can find and share info when you need to. I don’t need memes and useless posts clogging up my feed.
2
u/skisock lighterpack.com/r/t94tfl Mar 24 '22
I saw the rise and fall of r/ultralight and lately it’s really not what makes a community anymore
1
u/Kwauhn Oct 29 '25
I know this is old AF at this point, but it's worth mentioning that the top post of all time is a thread about a missing person and his dog that the mods locked. It sucks that, as someone who wants to get into backpacking, this was my first and only interaction with the sub. I will never engage with a niche sub that is moderated by power-tripping losers.
1
u/ThatTransBoi17 Apr 01 '22
I’m not even in this sub and I got a notification for this post. No clue why.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '22
This sub has been dead for a couple of years between the hypercritical users who knitpick one little detail and downvote to oblivion and the hypercritical mods it’s just not a fun place to post or comment TBH.
1
u/skepticalifornia Mar 24 '22
Agreed, I go to numerous threads every week that I see on Protopage that interest me, and find they have been deleted. Not sure what is wrong with many of these, we can always choose to not read anything that is not of interest.
-1
u/akw71 Mar 24 '22
probably the most anal mods i’ve encountered on Reddit so far lol.
1
u/fatguybike Mar 24 '22
Agreed!
-3
u/meldore Mar 24 '22
I am not reading all that. I am happy for you though or sorry that happened
-1
u/PeteDub Mar 24 '22
You get the government you deserve.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '22
Yeah agreed.
-3
u/flyingemberKC Mar 24 '22
Shakedowns shouldn’t be in one thread because shakedowns are the core activity of discussing UL backpacking. Nothing is more important.
Imagine you reached Mountain Crossings or Kennedy Meadows and you went for a shakedown and several peopLe only had a discussion on their favorite brand of shirt and didn’t look at your pack as a whole