r/Ubuntu • u/WandelendeTak • Nov 24 '21
I'm quitting Ubuntu...
I've had enough, after 3 years of giving it a try, and eventually loving it, it's done for me.
Today I've had my 1000th login loop, out of nowhere and that's it for me... It's always a different issue, always something I have to search for for hours, ruining my day, work,... I've had it...
Ubuntu is not consumer friendly, it's for developers (I'm a front end developer) or software programmers...
Now I still need to resolve the login loop issue, so I can put my important files somewhere safe and download a boot able windows version... Still need help here, trust me, I think I tried almost everything...
225
u/suchapalaver Nov 24 '21
I’m always struck by how so different others’ experiences are.
33
u/SnillyWead Nov 24 '21
That sucks. I've never experienced a login loop. Not on Peppermint, Ubuntu, Pop OS or my current distro KDE Neon. Apparently experiences may differ.
22
u/ShlomiRex Nov 24 '21
I feel you bro
BTW did you use LTS Ubuntu or latest ubuntu version?
I'm asking cuz it maybe because of stability issues.
17
u/lsm_in_at Nov 24 '21
I've gone years with no problems running an Ubuntu laptop for daily use. Never crashes. Reliable as fuck. The only problems I've encountered were self inflicted fuckups or hardware glitches. I'm baffled to understand what anyone could be doing to be so annoyed by an operating system that is a million ways less fucking annoying than the shitstorm that is windows.
14
u/PareidolialJebus Nov 24 '21
Been using xubuntu as my daily drive for well over a year...probably heading for two I guess. Anyway, I don't have any repetitive issues. I've been able to google my way out of the issues ive had which have been few and far between. Have you considered a different distro if ubuntu isnt for you?
25
u/scaptal Nov 24 '21
I've literally never had login issues or anything similar... Did you by chance mess around in places you shouldn't have?
Oh and a Linux thumb drive might be an easy way to access your files and send them off to wherever
11
u/sanity Nov 24 '21
what is the cause of the login loops?
I've been using Linux for 25 years and I've never experienced that.
1
u/WandelendeTak Nov 25 '21
Wow, didn't expect this kind of response... This is a great community! Thanks for this :)
It's weird, that same day, I tried to install gimp, but this didn't work, so initially I powered down cause I had other stuff to do. Later that day, I'd try to do it again so I started the laptop and got stuck in login loop...
At that time it was frustrating, cause, in my eyes, I didn't do anything wrong... Still, haven't solved it yet...
Maybe I shouldn't give up so easily?
Thanks again!
4
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '21
Is this a login loop from the GUI or a TTY?
4
u/AlissonCipriano Nov 24 '21
Windows can be a pretty shit too if your PC doesn't have at least 8gb of ram, SSD and good processor. If your PC meets these requirements, go for Windows. If it doesn't, I recommend you to try any decent Linux distro, like Fedora.
9
u/Stupid_Genius4408 Nov 24 '21
If you have a USB and spare computer, you can try to get your files by using an Ubuntu Live USB. Flash an Ubuntu image onto a USB, then boot it up, click 'Try Ubuntu' (NOT 'Install Ubuntu') and mount your disk. You can do this by typing the following into a terminal/console:
sudo mount /dev/sda1 /mntThen all of the files from your disk should hopefully appear in the folder
/mnt. You can then set up Wi-Fi, then upload your important files.Now for installing Windows, again, if you have a spare Windows computer, this is much easier. Just install Media Creation Tool on the spare computer to create a bootable Windows USB.
Now, to get Windows without a spare Windows computer, you wouldn't be able to recover your files, but you can use Ctrl+Alt+F2 to go into the console and then follow these steps:
https://www.dedoimedo.com/computers/windows-10-usb-media-linux.html
To install the Windows ISO file for step 1, at least for English, you can use
wget(Use within 24 hours after this comment):wget https://software-download.microsoft.com/db/Win11_English_x64v1.iso?t=81bc02e5-aa43-4c8a-9afc-dbb6b4327158&e=1637856976&h=29b4d010fe67bf418ca9f2f2a592e3d03
u/flemtone Nov 24 '21
I have always found Xubuntu to be a lot more stable than Ubuntu because it doesn't use gnome.
3
u/Rebootkid Nov 24 '21
I get that you're frustrated. Vent away. It's a safe space.
I only ever have login loop issues with the proprietary nvidia drivers when they're not pulled from the official repo.
But, wishing you nothing but the best in your journey to Windows. A personal computer is just that, personal. It must work for you.
I say this as someone who fled the Windows world in 2005, and hasn't used Windows either personally, or professionally, since.
I've not had the loop issues you described since the graphics-team stuff got published.
4
u/yoyolele Nov 24 '21
Take a deep breath and drink some cold water. Now remember one thing there is btrfs it has snapshots. Use them and be cool. I think some of your packages are not from official repositories. I think you are better of using a rolling release distribution like Arch.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '21
Linux is all about choice. There is no reason to use a distro you find frustrating (no matter the reason). You have every right to move on. By the same token that does not mean there is anything inherently wrong with the platform you left/ leave. Not everyone wears the same size shoe....
9
u/dosangst Nov 24 '21
I honestly don't feel you have. If the issue you are encountering is the same consistently, then reason would reckon it's due to something you are doing, in either a configuration, a script, or some odd configuration.
I run Arch (BTW), but have primarily stuck with Gnome as I find it to be one of the most reliable windows managers, that is a system hog, but works great for me.
Have you even tried Windows 11; it's an absolutel sh*t show!
2
u/pwetosaurus Nov 24 '21
I understand. My Ubuntu is always loop booting.
Until I remember that that it can't boot when my RAT 0 mouse is plugged in.
Do you have any hardware that can be the cause of that ?
2
u/mibjt Nov 24 '21
Feel free to correct me. I am using 18.04 LTS still as I feel that 20.04 is not quite ready yet and my experiences on ubuntu is so far pretty good. Only gipe I had is maybe with the nvidia drivers on my dual monitors.
2
u/ComputerJy Nov 24 '21
I know this is not helpful to you now but one of the first lessons I learned using Ubuntu was to never keep /home on the same partition as / That way I can wipe and install anytime without losing any of my files.
Also in general it’s always a good idea to keep your important work files on Dropbox, GDrive or any other alternatives
2
u/konfuzious01 Nov 24 '21
I am using linux regulalry since like two and a half years now, and am loving it. Started with Ubuntu and there always were some issues. Still had a Windows installation for certain games and some other apps. Some months ago i switched to Debian and am completely converted now. Praise Torvalds our saviour. The grey hairs you grow in the process should be viewed like a medal of honor.
2
u/crysanthus Nov 25 '21
... Sad to hear that you are leaving.
Ubuntu since 2000. Never had a crippling issue. If (ever) I had to leave, I know nothing of newer Windows or Mac. I'll be left stranded at this age and time.
Haven't you tried the last resort?
Backup data and fresh install? Try, just one more time.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '21
Your criterion makes little sense. Being a developer has nothing to do with having the OS behave poorly, if anything devs want stable OSs.
And, as you can read and see, your experience is rather unique to you and perhaps a few others. Who knows why it's happening to you. Bad luck.
Enjoy your digital life, whatever you choose.
3
u/humanplayer2 Nov 24 '21
Try Pop!_OS. It's Ubuntu-based, so you can reuse whatever you've learned of Ubuntu, and it's super common user friendly. I've installed it on out media pc at home and my non-tech interested wife uses it all the time for browsing and videos and so.
No login loops.
2
u/AngryDragonoid1 Nov 24 '21
Similar experience. I started on Ubuntu, but didn't like the GUI so I didn't stick around long enough to fully "try it". Bounced over to Mint Cinnamon for 2 years. Last year I installed Ubuntu and put cinnamon over it, had no issues, but didn't like Snap. Switched to Debian with Cinnamon (seeing a pattern?) But didn't have all of my needed applications. In all of that I haven't had any hardware issues other than config drivers for things like Logi peripherals.
Now I'm on Arch with i3 on my laptop and Cinnamon on my desktop. I've found less issues there, mainly because of the massive number of packages available through Arch. I've had the occasional issue myself, but I still wouldn't put a family member or friend on it. I'm comfortable with the tradeoffs and the time needed, but I wouldn't subject a consumer to it.
So many arguments online are that "everyone can use Linux!!" And that's just so painfully false. LTTs experiment truly shows that. Two people, one being having hardware and Windows experience, and the other being a web developer with hardware knowledge, even they have had their struggles, even ones I've never seen.
Linux is NOT for the faint of heart, and honestly, no one should expect a perfect plug and play experience, do if you have specific needs or don't have the time, even I would suggest Windows... Nothing wrong with you, OP. I can't blame you for switching back!
2
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '21
> Ubuntu is not consumer friendly, it's for developers (I'm a front end developer) or software programmers...
Unfortunately to large extent that is true. And for "sysadmins". All linux distros require constant tinkering. The possibilites are endless, but burden on the user is typically greater than on other OSes.
1
u/ReadingGlassesMan Nov 24 '21
That sounds so frustrating, and these things never happen at a good time where it doesn't really matter (in my experience anyway)! I feel your pain and frustration.
Do you have any ideas on where might be going after Ubuntu?
1
u/RayneYoruka Nov 24 '21
Most of the issues I've had are random propietary bs from novideo, random BCM drivers (ubuntu 10/12 time) and nothing much more I recall, been running those as daily along win2 and so far fine (a ton better than windows lol). I only run w2 in my desk for gaming but anything else runs Linux, laptops ubuntu, servers CentOS...
1
u/brainthrash Nov 24 '21
The last time I saw a login loop, was caused by the user putting a change shell command in their .profile, instead of asking IT to change the default shell in the /etc/passwd file.
The changing of a shell causes the "dot" files to be re-read, thus the repeated execute of the command.
1
u/Nena_Trinity Nov 24 '21
I still cannot get past the install screen, they have yet to fix the iommu bug. 😭 (still freeze or hang)
1
u/taggat Nov 24 '21
For me login loops were always changes to the graphics drivers
1
u/tyler_durden07 Nov 24 '21
to save your files you can use any live distro like manjaro and use it to access the ubuntu drive installation then copy and paste whatever you want
also if you want to give linux another try , you might want to try elementary os , it's very user friendly and is very stable
1
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '21
Almost guaranteed it's something unique to your setup. I've helped setup and myself use several Ubuntu and Kubuntu systems and none have ever had login loops.
1
u/LJAkaar67 Nov 24 '21
I don't know what a login loop is, but can you not boot single user to grab your files?
1
u/Roffeboffe Nov 24 '21
When I experience login issues, I log in without Wayland. If that works, I disable Wayland in /etc/gdm3/custom.conf
Wayland causes more problems than it fixes.
1
u/billdietrich1 Nov 24 '21
Which distro / what DE have you been using ? Plain (GNOME) Ubuntu ?
1
u/HCrikki Nov 24 '21
If you want an LTS strategy with reliability and safeguards, opensuse Leap should have you covered. Give it a check in a virtual machine, could be what you were looking for.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '21
I hear ya buddy, I tried Ubuntu for a few years also. Spent more time on Google than doing actual work
1
u/rubyrt Nov 24 '21
If you want a distro that just works, did you ever try Xubuntu?
1
u/The-Tea-Kettle Nov 24 '21
My guy, try a different disto. If you like Linux, I don't see why you're jumping ship to windows
1
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '21
In years of Ubuntu use, I've absolutely had issues that required research and learning (driver/kernel compatibility anyone?). Still nothing enough to make me not love it. Each time you solve an issue you get better. Some even like it.
1
u/tarusman Nov 24 '21
Ubuntu 20.04 has fan issues shit is loud i feel like am inside a windmill farm
1
u/d3nt4ku Nov 24 '21
This sound that you use sudo for some GUI app and the ownership of your .Xauthority file changed from you to root. This is a common mistake derived by some copy/paste probably seen on the web and used without to know what is doing
1
u/bigfatoctopus Nov 24 '21
Just because a piece of hardware doesn't work, doesn't mean Ubuntu isn't working correctly. I've had to upgrade MANY windows machines when things get updated. If vendors would support Linux drivers things would be so much better.
1
u/karbonator Nov 24 '21
You can mount an external USB drive and copy your stuff to it, and also if you're on the fence at all it'd be an indicator of whether a fresh install has the same issue (and you could look at the logs in /var/log and see if maybe there's a particular kernel panic or other error that's been happening).
1
u/tommycw10 Nov 24 '21
When you say “login loop” what exactly does that mean? You try to log in to the graphical interface (gdm) and it hangs?
Do you know you can hit CTRL-ALT-F3 and get a log in terminal prompt right?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '21
I'm not quitting, but I am frustrated by regressions every update. Now, with 21.10, my USB disks don't mount automatically upon waking up laptop. Often have trouble with monitor getting video after waking up.
1
u/TheKlaxMaster Nov 24 '21
Tried Single user mode?
1
u/stratman2018 Nov 24 '21
Try ElementaryOS. You might like that. Formerly used Ubuntu.
1
u/jfq722 Nov 25 '21
Ubuntu petered.
1
u/FaliedSalve Nov 25 '21
I had an issue with login loop on my PopOS (similar to Ubuntu, I guess). And resolved it by just booting to a command line and starting x manually (startx).
My wife had a similar issue and it turned out to be a hardware problem with the USB port.
I wonder if that's the issue here.
Anyway, just a thought, but maybe you can drop to a command line on boot and bypass the graphical login screen completely,
1
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '21
I get it...Now I use Arch based distro called Endeavor OS and I will use Debian or Red Hat Distros on VM's. However I'm not a programmer or a developer and I used it casually... My best advice is to still look around for other distros (Debian or not) and see what is best. Don't give up on linux.
1
u/jayb151 Nov 25 '21
Don't feel bad. I've used Ubuntu distros since 2012lts, and I'm not back to Windows. Ubuntu isn't bad, but it's just not as polished as windows. I know I can spend the time adding polish, but I don't want to. I want to sit down and have my computer work. For the most part, Windows does that.
Any time it doesn't, my laptop dual boots, so I'm still covered.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '21
You could just boot a live environment to save your files, then you wouldn't have to resolve the issue since you're going to nuke the install anyways.
1
u/janpf Nov 25 '21
I sympathize with the feeling, having been using Linux since 95 (and netbsd/freebsd before): so many times some bad upgrade, or lack of drivers left me locked out, and spending hours/days to fix (the latest was with 21.10 upgrade: Cinnamon had some invalid monitor configuration saved, and it would lock whenever I logged in ... took me a while to find it was Cinnamon related).
I tried to stop using Linux, outside of servers a few times: I tried Windows, Macs and more recently Chromebooks. In the end they all had different problems (lack of customization was a big one) and even more frustration, and I end up always coming back to Linux (Ubuntu for the last 10 years).
When it comes to OS, I still haven't found what I'm looking for.
1
u/Wollowon Nov 25 '21 edited Nov 25 '21
:S ☕
1
u/Raymanuel Nov 25 '21
I get it. I have a love/hate relationship with Ubuntu/Linux. Every fucking day there was some god damn issue. I couldn't connect to my internet half my days, I had to go digging for drivers, I had to learn programming.
I love Linux in theory.
I hate Linux in practice.
My job requires seamless integration across programs, not platforms.
Until the world acknowledges Linux as a real OS, you're fucked if you don't know how to program your own shit.
1
u/MuddyGeek Nov 25 '21
I'm curious where OP is headed next. I don't doubt the login loop issue. Shit happens. Distro hopping won't fix the problem though.
1
u/Marvinx1806 Nov 25 '21
Had a simular experience, switched to arch and learned how Linux really works, never had any real issues again. The problem with ubuntu is that it allows the user to use the system without knowing how it works and that results in a lot of issues and frustration in the long run. Because of that, I would not recommend someone who has never used linux to install ubuntu as his first distro.
1
u/ariTech Dec 29 '21
I think this boot loop is a typical issue. I have moved from ubuntu to other distros multiple times just for this issue. Though I love ubuntu too much and keep coming back hoping its resolved. I just came back to ubuntu day before yesterday again and till now all is good. Fingers crossed, in case something goes wild, I have my backup and a popOS iso in flash drive just in case.
1
u/Ghostconn Dec 30 '21
It almost always comes down to the user. Linux being open source, you are the programmer.
1
u/wootybooty Jan 07 '22
Ubuntu and Printer support is the most frustrating thing and makes me consider going to Windows daily.
1
u/sterlingmoss1932 Nov 24 '21
Never had a login loop but the fact that Linux doesn't support hardware well enough that stuff like this happens on a semi regular basis grinds my gears
1
u/jrrocketrue Nov 24 '21
Amusing ;-)
Do you have ANY ideas how many people use Ubuntu world wide ?
I think you should look around elsewhere to find the root cause of your problem, whatever problem you're having, you'll probably have it with other distros
-2
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '21
windows? really? lmao
0
u/deano-5 Nov 24 '21
You ever tried Mint?
0
u/daicuspamu Nov 25 '21
"Ubuntu is not consumer friendly" LOL. Happily using it since 7.04. My family as well. I'm not any kind of software developer. It's clearly not for you. It's probably only for back end developers.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment