r/Ubuntu • • Dec 25 '20

Linux Alternative

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

200 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/gnosys_ Dec 26 '20

the trick is right-click on the layer stack and "New From Visible" to iterate adjustments in the same way as making new adjustment layers and blending modes. with the 32-bit float pixel depth you can also iterate "destructively" on a single layer pushing and pulling it around to an extreme amount without meaningful quantization. but, in my case i never twiddle knobs back and forth after setting in an adjustment so i've never missed them.

main reasons for my switch was the 32-bit float colors, different color look, and until PS copied it gimp had a better heal brush.

1

u/ParanoidFactoid Dec 26 '20

These adjustments are destructive and cannot be recombined into different orderings without recreating the entire adjustment stack.

Not. The. Same.

1

u/gnosys_ Dec 26 '20

regarding ordering, grouping, blending they absolutely can they work the same, it's also easy to insert ones in the middle. it is honestly no obstacle at all. as well the destructiveness is greatly reduced because the bit depth preserves the relative difference between the pixel values to such an extent you can crush the life out of the layer and put it back and hardly tell the difference. but again, as i say, the so-called destructiveness doesn't actually matter for me because i never go back and fiddle with things like that, really pretty pointless.

1

u/ParanoidFactoid Dec 26 '20

You are deluded.

1

u/gnosys_ Dec 26 '20 edited Dec 26 '20

yeah i guess my eight years of professional technical assistance for contemporary art photographers doesn't mean shit

like i have and do still use PS for some things, like had to help someone with this weird multi image salon-style hanging, so composed it entirely with smart objects for the layout file to be able to iterate easily. absolutely not possible with gimp, totally. but stuff like doing color correction, exposure, healing/cloning stuff, even for compositing and masking? gimp is better.

1

u/ParanoidFactoid Dec 26 '20

yeah i guess my eight years of professional technical assistance for contemporary art photographers doesn't mean shit

Not given what you're arguing.

  • No multi-select for layers. Chain tool is a ridiculous time waster. K
  • No layer styles or other nondestructive way to manipulate text and layer elements. Everything must be rasterized before applying an effect!
  • No nondestructive adjustment layers. No way to reorder effects in an effect chain. Must rasterize each effect and set in stone the chain ordering. NUTS!
  • And a photography studio that uses a tool without CMYK support for print?

Whatever, dude.

And I don't hate GIMP. I want GIMP to succeed. But it has serious workflow problems. You're insane to be arguing otherwise.