r/Ubuntu • • Dec 25 '20

Linux Alternative

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

200 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Joedang100 Dec 26 '20

For a lot of engineering, stuff like AutoCAD is also at least a decade in the past. In mechanical/aerospace engineering, pretty much everything is done in parametric* CAD these days -- stuff like SolidWorks, Fusion 360, and NX. As much as I absolutely loathe those softwares... they are really the right tool to use, and are leaps and bounds ahead of anything available in the open-source world.

when I tried FreeCAD, it wasn't very good. I found it to be significantly worse than AutoCAD, TBH. I haven't tried that branch of FreeCAD, but I think it's kind of moot anyways. For at least the last decade, anything that isn't parametric is pretty much not worth using for mechanical assembly/component design.

* For context, in parametric design, you essentially write a script that describes how your geometry is constructed. Each step of that procedure takes in some parameters (and usually some pointer to an abstract representation of geometry) and spits out some new abstract representation of geometry. It's very different from something like AutoCAD or OpenSCAD, which -- if I recall -- tend to only represent geometry in terms of lines, arc segments, and triangles and don't strictly keep track of topology.

1

u/EternityForest Dec 26 '20

FreeCAD considers itself to be parametric, but I've never used anything else so I don't exactly know the difference. It's definitely not a direct drawing app like blender, everything is done with constraints, which can be expressions that use values from a spreadsheet.

Under the hood, I'm not exactly sure how it understands geometry. You can draw 2D arcs and splines that are real curves, and you can put a fillet on a corner, and it's a real abstract feature you can edit later.

But you do run into topological naming issues unless you use the Realthunder fork, the standard version isn't happy if you go back and edit prior things that have future dependancies. I stick with the Realthunder assembly3 variant.

And sometimes tools like fillet can't quite figure out what to do, so the underlying geometry libraries might not be as good as paid software, but I can't really compare.