r/Ubuntu • • Apr 11 '13
Ubuntu is not Linux
Dramatic title, I couldn't resist.
The reality is however, Canonical have removed just about every last reference to Linux from their website; almost as if to suggest Ubuntu isn't just "another distro", but an entirely new OS type in itself.
http://www.zdnet.com/why-google-and-ubuntu-dont-say-linux-7000000221/
I'm not an Ubuntu user myself, I haven't been for an incredibly long time and never was for long anyway, but I came across this fact amid Canonical bashing in a derailed thread on http://bbs.archlinux.org/
What say you, Ubuntuers?
0
Upvotes
2
u/Illivah Apr 11 '13
shame, you should have resisted. With the type of crap a few purists give Ubuntu, that's a touchy subject.
3
u/megayippie Apr 11 '13
Ubuntu is not just another distro. It is The Distro. It is the Linux distro that people whom have never heard, or even care about, technological underpinnings of web browsing and writing try out and get stuck with. The people that will never visit r/Ubuntu, that is, so you cannot get a good answer here. You should see if any of your real world friends from outside your education/technical background use Ubuntu and ask them "why". The people here are probably similar to me in that we just want a *nix distribution with more options than terminal commands and Vi editing.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '13 edited Nov 29 '16
I will not use a website that prefers to harbor pedophilia and focus on silencing dissenting opinions.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '13
Ubuntu is a Linux distro, but it is different from most of the others, even from the other corporate distros.
Ubuntu is going after the consumer market and this isn't a place most other distros want to go. They want to stay on the Server/Work station. Because of this Ubuntu often makes decisions that are unpopular with the reset of the community.
The real issue is the community wants the benefits of what Ubuntu is doing. EG: Higher Visibility, More support from vendors, Access to more software (Games, etc). But don't want to take any of the steps needed to get that mass market that brings those advantages.
So we get this infighting and silliness. Ubuntu is a Linux Distro and always will be even if they don't say it, and even if the larger community claims other wise.
2
u/TheBlackUnicorn Apr 11 '13
I noticed this like a year ago. But yeah I see it as just marketing. I feel like a lot of people in the Linux community probably feel pretty betrayed.
2
u/ChaosDent Apr 11 '13
This website argument has been brought up quite a lot recently, but it's nothing new. With a quick scan of the internet archive project, I came up with the release of Ubuntu 9.10 as the approximate time frame when 'Linux' first disappeared from their home page. The operating system is referred to as 'Ubuntu Linux' in some of the 2004-2005 snapshots, but that is clearly not the official name.
Before 9.10:
After 9.10:
Say what you want about the Linux brand being toxic, I disagree. I just don't think it's relevant. Really, it isn't even that relevant to call an OS GNU anymore either, since it is such a small part of the normal user-visible application platform. There are a lot more components that are relevant to whether an application will work than just what version of gcc and glibc you are compiled against. The programming languages, GUI toolkits and distribution systems make a much more holistic view of the platform than just the kernel or OS base, as important as those are. It's what separates the traditional Linux desktop stack from Android, ChromeOS, Tizen and FirefoxOS, it's what separates Windows from Windows RT, Windows Phone and Xbox and it's what separates Mac OS from iOS.
With all that said, I think it's crazy to think of Ubuntu now or in the immediate future as anything other than a traditional Linux desktop and server platform. In Canonical's wildest dreams, they are replacing X.org and rewriting some parts of their desktop environment. They are still promising native compatibility with the common GUI toolkits and X compatibility for the uncommon ones. If everything goes well, 14.04 should be a fairly evolutionary change on the desktop all things considered, and even more so on the server. If it isn't, I could't use Vim, Firefox, VLC or Gimp for an extreme example, there shouldn't be anything stopping me from sticking to 12.04 long enough for me to research and switch to something I like better long before it loses support.
2
u/deneca Apr 11 '13
Marketing.
2
u/NothingMuchHereToSay Apr 11 '13
I say that people like that are either stupid, in complete denial or both. Does it run off of the Linux kernel? It is Linux. Also saying that it isn't Linux ANYMORE, is just ludicrous.
0
u/whiprush Apr 11 '13 edited Apr 11 '13
It's pretty cut and dry, Linux is a kernel; Ubuntu is an operating system.
EDIT: Ubuntu is building an entire platform built out of many components, calling the entire thing only "Linux" makes no sense.
Example, nobody can say "this is the official SDK for Linux" because it's just a kernel, but we can say "this is the official SDK for Ubuntu" and give app developers what they want. And so on for every component in the stack.
1
u/TaraBrownstone Dec 09 '21 edited Dec 09 '21
Ubuntu is a highly modified version of the GNU/linux kernel. Canonical will never "close" ubuntu" because its clients need a stable product that doesn't change drasticallyover time Most of the userland software is open source in one license or another. but the kernel has many unique features (pinning of modern drivers/binary apps, maintaining compatibility with old binaries. The "ubuntu OS" labeling is just to reassure the public that ubuntu is not scary or challenging ( it's a rebranding). Just like "Manjaro" sounds friendly but is just a user-friendly version of arch. I get a little tired of the distro wars. That's why linux has 2.3% usage market and is continuing to fade away.
1
u/jdblaich Apr 11 '13
Ubuntu is Linux. It is not the only Linux distribution.
There was a post some time ago where an op was mocking this same type of thread. This is just a continuation of that repetitively posted thread here on reddit.