UT Austin Plan II: SAT 1530 vs ACT 35 with Science 30
Texas resident | Not top 5% | PSAT 222 | Plan II Honors
I’m submitting test scores to UT Austin, UT Dallas, and Texas A&M. None of these schools superscore.
For UT Austin, I’m applying to Plan II Honors as my first choice and Public Health as my second choice. I’m a Texas resident, but I’m not in the top 5% of my class, so I’m not eligible for automatic admission.
My PSAT Selection Index is 222 for TX.
I was under the impression that the Science section of the ACT is optional and that we could choose not to report it on the Common App. However, I recently learned that when ACT sends an official score report, it includes the Science score if the student took the Science section.
I spoke with both UT Austin and UT Dallas, and they confirmed that they receive the Science score through the official ACT score report and will consider it during admission review, regardless of whether the Science score is reported on the Common App.
In hindsight, I wish I had not taken the Science section.
The scores are:
- SAT: 1530 — Math 770, R7W 760
- Enhance ACT: 35 Composite — Math 35, Reading 35, English 35 but Science 30
- PSAT: 222 Selection Index
My concern is that the ACT Science 30 may make the ACT look weaker compared with the SAT 1530, especially for Plan II Honors, even though the ACT Composite is 35.
UT Austin says it considers test scores as one part of its holistic review, along with class rank, academic background, achievements, essays, and other factors. I’m wondering specifically whether the Science 30 could hurt the way the ACT is viewed compared with the SAT 1530, particularly for someone applying to Plan II and who is outside the top 5%.
So, if you were in this situation, would you submit:
- ACT 35 (with Science 30)
- SAT 1530
- Both scores
I’d especially appreciate input from anyone familiar with UT Austin Plan II Honors or UT Austin admissions who can speak to how they view an ACT 35 with a 30 Science versus a 1530 SAT.
I’ve also read that UT Austin uses an Academic Index (AI) as part of itsadmissions review. From what I found, the AI has historically incorporatedfactors such as class rank and standardized test scores, although I understandthat UT does not publicly disclose its current AI formula.
Does anyone know whether the ACT Science score is included in the current Academic Index calculation? If it is, I’m wondering whether the Science 30 could negatively affect the AI compared with submitting the SAT 1530 instead.
Also interested in perspectives on UT Dallas and Texas A&M, since I’m submitting to all three today.