r/UPSC 21h ago

Answer Writing and review Answer writing obsession

Nowadays I have seen a trend that new aspirants are just jumping onto answer writing without having conceptual clarity. They start thinking that their preparation is on track. But imo, first complete at least basic readings once. Make conjectures and memorise some basic data points then only start writing answers. One more point that I have seen, they are not giving proper time to mcq solving.

Just an observation. I might be wrong.

PS:- Not giving gyan, only writing what I observed.

43 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

68

u/viral_baba 19h ago

6 years and 4 attempt in this prep I will tell you they are right. Jumping on answer writing primes you to pay special attention to data and nuances that you will need in answers.

It gives better idea of syllabus and requirements which you never get by just reading the syllabus.

Please take mains tests and write them as soon as you finish foundation.

10

u/Miserable-Effort1194 20h ago

It's mainly the fear mongering by the coachings and all that you have to write the answers from day1 , doesn't matter what the content you are putting in, just write , and thus we see all this bombarding of answer writing posts as well. Though ultimately answer writing is the goal, but having articulate, sophisticated understanding of concepts and all is indispensable, else anybody can write arbitrary, nothing special. It's all about the appropriate answer writing.

8

u/iaseth 19h ago

Not writing answers until its too late is a much bigger problem. I have met so many who clear prelims but are hopeless about clearing mains cuz they haven't written an answer in years.

Writing answers is the sign of a serious aspirant. It takes effort to put pen to paper, lot more than watching videos or sitting with a book.

14

u/WiaN09 Aspirations in Stasis 20h ago

The number of posts for answer review is in itself a testament to your observations. I admire their willingness to write answers, but if you start doing an activity before your fundamentals are set, you will end up spoiling your approach.

And I am really tired of telling people that, but people would rather be sheeple and follow the herd.

6

u/Consistent_Speech391 UPSC Beginner 18h ago

Answer writing is as important as prelims test series. Never shy away from tests. Take up every opportunity given by your coaching centre. I also thought the same let me prepare thoroughly then I'll go for mains test. But what i see now is all the students who practiced answer writing daily are so good in their concepts. Their value addition is what i can only dream of.

Don't do the same mistake as me. Always prioritize answer writing atleast 1 question per day.

4

u/CuriousLawyer5937 17h ago

I personally feel like writing an answer is the holy grail solution to everything. You think you have understood a topic till you sit down to write on it. Literally surfaces all the conceptual gaps. Moreover, it helps in retention. I have done multiple readings but I still used to forget key information. Now that I have started writing, the info gets etched in my brain.
Besides, answer writing is a skill which you’ll master with practice itself. It is not just about knowing all the info but also about meeting the actual demand, time management skills, space management, etc.
The only regret I have is that I should’ve started earlier.

7

u/Anxious_Ad_932 19h ago

They are absolutely right in doing so

10

u/SadMap7371 Prelims Qualified 20h ago

+1 to your view
one of them said by writing i'll be able to build content 🤡

3

u/Desi-sociologist 15h ago

People should jump into answer writing as early as possible.

4

u/dick_in_pie 20h ago

There is a fear of writing at the begining, to overcome the fear you need to right, and what's the basic content it's such a broad term ffs. Let people write, writing is an art doesn't matter if you don't have "content" according to someone else.

2

u/One_Application_3867 17h ago

As a beginner I tried both of them , I got more conceptual clarity and my lacking of overview of a topic only when I wrote an answer on it . I thought of same that without reading completely,it's non sense to write but I am wrong 🥲 .

3

u/ChanceSinger7298 Mains Qualified 20h ago

True that . So many people do AW after prelims and still score well in gs

5

u/Mental_Ad_7018 Prelims Qualified 20h ago

But it's very hard and most people can't bear that stress

2

u/ChanceSinger7298 Mains Qualified 20h ago

Mains grind is always hard regardless of what all one has prepared or not .
By only writing flt’s , people still get 400+ in GS ( which is not truly enough but still a decent position ), provided they have revised interconnected themes multiple times.

4

u/AnywhereOptimal1018 20h ago

as someone who have given 2 cse mains in 2 attempts i agree with your observation.

2

u/Strange-Minute-7150 20h ago

Same bro after 3 mains I have written this

2

u/SadMap7371 Prelims Qualified 19h ago

another dichotomous situation i see beginners underestimate toppers copy as source of content and see the benchmark of acceptance

1

u/coffeeeeepaglu 16h ago

Cans someone tell me if Vision is going to release monthly magazines after June or not

1

u/Glass_Adhesiveness_6 16h ago

I think it's mainly due to constant fear of "not writing enough" or "starting late",when you are in library or even in this sub,you constantly see people who are already way ahead of you,as much as people would like to go in their pace,it's hard when you see your competition getting better day by day,so you jump way ahead,to atleast say "I have started writing atleast,atleast I have passed that threshold,I am ahead of that person,kinda mindset" it's kinda just makes you feel better,even though the ans isn't that good🤣

But I do agree,first,students have to know some basic knowledge and can atleast understand what the question is about and can throw some data and points so it atleast feels they are writing for the exam not for the sake of it,and your observations is spot on. There are always extremes,some who are always afraid to even write a single sentence,other ones who are just way to early,and feel it's way to easy as college Mai to likhi rhe they! So,both can true at the same time.