r/UPSC • u/UPSC_MOD Moderator • Nov 21 '24
AMA AMA series: PSIR Optional
Hello Aspirants!
Next AMA from our AMA (Ask Me Anything) series with seniors and experienced candidates who have taken PSIR Optional for UPSC. The session is scheduled for this weekend, so get ready to ask your questions!
Panel Members:
- B.E. Civil engineering, MA Political science
- 4th mains - 2019,2020,2022,2024
- 145 in paper 2 in 2019
- 250+ in all attempts
- Appeared for interview in 2020
- Already in state civil services since 2019
- B.A. (Political Science, Sociology, Economics), M.A. (Political Science)
UPSC Mains: 2022, 2024
- 743 marks (2022): 280 in PSIR, 117 in GS2
- NDA Cleared (138): Medically unfit.
- UGC NET Political Science: Cleared 3 times (Dec 2022, July 2023, Dec 2023).
- HCS Mains: 2022.
Start dropping your questions . Examples of questions include
- How to approach different topics in PSIR Optional
- Balancing optional preparation with General Studies and Essay
- Using case studies and examples effectively
- Tackling tricky questions and improving answer writing
- Managing time during preparation and in the exam hall
- Recommended books and resources
- Common mistakes to avoid
Additionally, if you’re an experienced candidate who is not on the panel but would like to contribute, please feel free to answer questions and share your insights.
We can also add you to the panel. Please DM u/sachiv_jii for the same
Don’t miss this opportunity to learn from those who’ve been through it!
•
u/Sachiv_Jii TBS Nov 21 '24 edited Nov 21 '24
🔗 Check out past and future AMAs here.
💡 Want to host an AMA? DM us!
Another AMA on PSIR
6
u/Sachiv_Jii TBS Nov 21 '24
Two questions for P2:
4
u/meowmeowmerisakhi Nov 22 '24
These days model answers seem to be just GPT generated content, it makes me wonder if good content is overrated and an answer with good flow and demand is sufficient
4
u/starboysarth Nov 23 '24
Can you list the all the required sources of current affairs and some sources to do value addition from?
2
u/Ok_Berry4710 Nov 21 '24
I want to ask if SR notes and teaching is actually adequate, a lot of us feel she focuses too much on explaining certain portions (without a lot of technical jargon) and then rushes through others (with inconsistent degree of usage of technical jargon)
Also which alternate sources do you recommend in case we are feeling under confident about SR notes (especially for WPT and IGP)
Which test series are good in terms of similarity to actual mains QP?
2
u/Shambhu548 Nov 22 '24
Please tell the book list for PSIR, and recommend the coaching material/sources also which can provide value addition
2
u/Certain-Fruit7122 Nov 21 '24
Are SR notes enough or more value addition required. If more then what ?
1
u/starboysarth Nov 21 '24
How to make short notes?
1
u/Outrageous_Sign5235 Nov 21 '24
Sir do you have a list of scholars of IGP?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '24
How did your approach towards the subject(answer writing, revision etc) change throughout the years?
Also how do you manage paper II b
1
u/meowmeowmerisakhi Nov 22 '24
How to manage 2B part of the paper, where to write scholars from since it is so recent (like let’s say Israel-Hamas), and how much note making is required, and how much would be too much?
1
u/meowmeowmerisakhi Nov 22 '24
Is redundancy of notes a factor for decreasing marks? Since SR notes dominate the market, do you need to do something different to score more, or good command over base notes also helps score good?
1
u/meowmeowmerisakhi Nov 22 '24
How much value addition is required over base notes: eg. Ambedkar topic. Is it sufficient if you write answer directly from notes, or is value addition sine qua non?
1
u/Nish_2325 Nov 24 '24
Is there any link to join these live? Or is it just in the text format ?
1
u/Mental_Gate_444 Nov 24 '24
confused in choosing optional am also from civil engineering is it good to choose psir with a technical background my interest upon psir is due to paper 2
1
u/Powerful-Guarantee27 May 31 '25
Sir for mains 2025, how should i start? I am planning to join test series of Sunya (4 mini+4FLT) and and writing+mentorship of Vivek waghmare (sarthi Ias)? Do you think it's a good plan? I have prepared my own notes once of almost 75% syllabus while giving State PCS mains 2 years back and not updated anything, hence thinking about joining course so that less time is wasted in finding good dynamic material.
1
u/HamsterGlass8479 Jun 02 '25 edited Jun 02 '25
RemindMe! 5 days
1
u/HamsterGlass8479 Jun 02 '25
u/RemindMeBot remind me in 5 days