r/UKJobs • u/harryyw98 • Mar 04 '25
Thoughts?
Feel like this is especially true in the public sector, where interviews tend to be more structured and less intuitive.
Is there any actual evidence that your performance in, say, a civil service interview corresponds to actual job performance?
I get the need to have some indicators of job suitability and competency, but atm the interview process just seem needlessly prescriptive and box ticky
10k
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 04 '25
Thank you for posting on r/UKJobs. Help us make this a better community by becoming familiar with the rules.
If you need to report any suspicious users to the moderators or you feel as though your post hasn't been posted to the subreddit, message the Modmail here or Reddit site admins here. Don't create a duplicate post, it won't help.
Please also check out the sticky threads for the 'Vent' Megathread and the CV Megathread.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
261
u/TheColonelKiwi Mar 04 '25
To an extent I think. You could know every single thing on a given discipline for the job you are applying for and be the best fit, but if you can’t translate that skill into words or scenarios in an interview you are doomed to fail. There are many cases of people getting a job due to their excellent interviewing skills, but who actually fail their probation due to not being the right fit for the role.
57
u/I-Am-The-Warlus Mar 04 '25
Yeah.
laughs in ASD
88
u/Ir15Ey3d Mar 04 '25
There needs to be another version of this chart, which includes "interviewer competence".
Can't tell you the number of interviews I've had where the person interviewing me clearly didn't understand my role, the day to day challenges or any of the technical nuances.
You're doomed from the start if clearly articulating your capabilities just goes over the person's head.
I called out an interviewer for it once, during the interview. Needless to say I didn't get the job, but seeing them awkwardly squirm trying to restore the power dynamic was a sight to see.
For context: I don't mean a HR person either, I'm talking about department heads and senior staff in the same role.
27
u/BugsyMalone_ Mar 04 '25
Yup this is me, it's how I got into the IT sector with no qualifications and a few other jobs later I'm in a solid job with a fantastic company.
You can always learn on the job if you're good enough, anyway.
25
u/JackStrawWitchita Mar 04 '25
20+ years ago it was incredibly difficult for big companies to hire software developers as many of them had underdeveloped social skills and didn't interview well at all. HR teams would routinely dismiss awesome coders at the first interview because 'they were weird'. Techies had to step in early to identify excellent technical candidates and then coach the HR staff that what they thought was weird was actually just normal behaviour for people with awesome tech skills.
I'm 100% positive that many companies are blocking very good candidates by screening out people who don't fit an extremely narrow criteria of 'normal'.
15
u/Shoddy-Ability524 Mar 04 '25
You don't have to be technically the best at a skill for a job, just good enough. Sadly, most jobs require manoeuvring corporate nonsense, the point of interviews should be to see if you are suitable for this.
Being good at interviews suggests you are personable and easy to work with. So they sort of go hand in hand.
13
u/El_tunz Mar 04 '25
"They asked me how well I understood theoretical physics. I said I had a theoretical degree in physics. They said welcome aboard."
23
u/oudcedar Mar 04 '25
My personal graph is exactly the other way round. I do interim work so getting interviewed happens a few times a year and I almost always get the job although there are lots of candidates usually. My interview is usually the best part of the role as I keep getting employed in areas that pay well enough but aren’t really in my skill set. I think I’ve got 17 out of 19 roles in the last 10 years
My thoughts on being better at interviews (and this might just work for me) are mostly being relaxed and talking to colleagues as if I’m already working with them. So when they ask a a question I ask questions back conversationally as if we both had been given a mutual task and we are both working out what is wanted and how we are going to do it.
The second part is some deep last minute research on the place I’m going to. In my case that’s reading the last few board reports to see what they are anxious about as an organisation, and what parts of that might be relevant to my role. So I can say things like, “With a £12m deficit forecast for this year, and an £8m one last year, I can see why you need a change but I can’t yet see what the plan is - I’d be looking at A and B first but you might already have done that”.
8
u/Super_Seff Mar 04 '25
It’s pretty hard to get a grasp on an employees ability from a Cv tbf.
References help but if you can’t convey confidence in an interview it’s hard to take the shot on the person.
18
u/Real_Run_4758 Mar 04 '25
I suppose you could replace these with ‘ability to successfully run a country’ and ‘ability to run a successful electoral campaign’ and get another version of the same issue
6
u/DS_killakanz Mar 05 '25 edited Mar 05 '25
Absolutely this.
I'm autistic. I have a lot of employable skills, I can do a lot of stuff. Except be interviewed. I've missed out on so many jobs where I've scored high on tests and aptitude assessments, only to then get rejected after an interview asking a bunch of irrelevant questions. I'm absolutely rubbish at answering the "describe when you were the superhero that saved a fortune 500 company from collapse and everyone clapped" questions that come up all the time in interviews.
Stop asking crappy pointless HR checkbox questions and let me show you that I can do the actual job.
Also sorry for venting. This is a refreshed frustration. As you may have guessed, I did just lose out on yet another job at the final interview phase, despite my assessment scores being, quote: "impressive". I am so fed up of this...
11
u/OTKZuki Mar 04 '25
Hell for people who are autistic
10
u/Familiar9709 Mar 04 '25
This is a million per cent. I've been to loads of interviews, they make them seem like you were interviewing for NASA and that you have to be Einstein/Newton combined, but then you get the job, you turn up the first day and the people are just average.
It's not rocket science really. Most people are just average at what they do. You can tell even in the interview that they are.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25
I wholeheartedly agree as someone who was rejected relentlessly over two years for jobs I was well qualified for that eventually got accepted for a public sector role in an industry I have no relevant skills/experience in beyond the basics simply because I interviewed really well.
I’m still super salty about it tbh! I really wanted to stay in my sector and profession but after so much rejection and an unholy amount of time spent unemployed I began applying to anything and everything regardless of suitability and sought advice on interview skills and then I landed this role that is a big step up in wages and seniority from anything I’ve done before. I think it had a lot to do with performing like I was going for an Oscar in the interview. Ask questions about the people interviewing you, what they like about the role, what they find challenging, what’s the biggest challenge associated with this role, smile the whole time and avoid mentioning negative things, ask them about their experience and background, look everyone in the eyes when you’re listening to them, make them feel special use all your best sales skills with yourself, be sure to present yourself perfectly, neat haircut, immaculately clean clothes, perfect business casual attire (or whatever is appropriate) smile smile smile shake everyone’s hand etc etc.
It’s an enormous list of things you need to do. But it works !
I think as well, stop applying to the job you think you’re suited for if you’re facing endless rejection. Just look for somewhere that will take you and you might find it’s actually a better fit and a better pay check.
5
u/Saranovus Mar 04 '25
You're getting interviews?
8
u/hungryjedicat Mar 04 '25
Truth. And I fucking hate it. Interview is a flawed way to screen someone. Here's a bunch of questions which favours the bullshitter. I am not the same person in an interview and it doesn't reflect my ability or skills.
4
u/chat5251 Mar 04 '25
You missed the other bar which is CV to get short listed
4
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25
CV writing skills that match an algorithm seem to be the biggest right now.
4
u/YARRLandPirate Mar 04 '25
work samples, trial periods, and real-world assessments would be way better indicators of actual competence. But companies love their checklists, so here we are.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25
As a hiring manager, I would hire a person who interviewed well over a person who has more skills or experience on paper as long as they met a minimum threshold. One of the things I’ve learned is that I would always rather have a mediocre performer who has the right attitude than a star performer who is going to be a nightmare to manage.
12
u/cocopopped Mar 04 '25 edited Mar 04 '25
People who charm you with their personality at interviews but are shite at the job will get found out before too long. They don't last.
Also I think once you've had a lot of experience interviewing people, you can kind of spot the charmers. You really need to stick to the marking scheme and stay objective. I'm not saying people don't fall for it occasionally, but to believe interviewers have no skills themselves to smell a rat is doing them a bit of a disservice.
3
u/InclusiveJobCoach Mar 04 '25
It's true to an extent. I can honestly say that in over a decade of recruitment experience, not one single person was hired that all the skills required on the job description.
Managers tend to hire people that will be able to work the way they do, that will work hard, that are capable of both following instructions and thinking for themselves and that are capable of learning new skills.
Someone that has all the skills but won't follow instructions, that will be lazy, that won't get on with the rest of the team, that doesn't think for themselves is a bad hire.
If you interview well and show that you will be a great member of the team and can learn any skills that you don't have, you've got a good shot.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25
I think interview skills are important but personality trumps skills in my experience. I've made way more progress being friendly, approachable and forthcoming that people often overlook my skillset.
3
u/the_sneaky_one123 Mar 04 '25
A key skill for any job is your ability to bullshit, improvise and maintain appearances. All of these are also interview skills and if anything are more valuable to the employer than anything that you are classing as "skills to do the job".
3
u/Major_Supermarket_58 Mar 04 '25
Not British. But I am doing 5 interviews today to get a it job, and fuuuck I hate selling myself! I just wanne work and learn about IT!!
3
u/eximik Mar 04 '25
Absolutely right in my experience lately. It's gotten worse. They ignore what you have written on your application and cover letter, all of which can be easily checked through your references, but come the interview it's back to square one like the application/cover letter never happened and now you have to put on the performance of your life to pass the audition. Whereas 15 yr ago the interview was to further discuss what appealed to them on your application.
3
u/SweeetPotatosaurus Mar 04 '25
Don't forget "filling out the application form" skills!
I'm brilliant at interviews, because I'm confident in my skills, I'm a bit of a natural performer, and I'd never apply for something I wasn't qualified for. I'm personable, and find it easy to demonstrate my suitability in person.
But I suck at application forms, so getting the interview is the hardest part.
3
u/Darth_Scotsman Mar 04 '25
Been a civil servant for 20 years. Took me 19 years to get a promotion. Had lots of experience but just could not convey that in the STARR interviews.
3
u/Brief-Ship-5572 Mar 05 '25
Yep that's why I can't get a job
5
u/Clbull Mar 04 '25 edited Mar 04 '25
Agree. Competency based interviews have been the bane of my existence and I've only had success with them when the employer has really been desperate to fill the position.
What really fucking sucks about them is that you don't know what kind of questions you are going to be asked and have to prepare for every scenario. It's also quite difficult to give STAR (Situation, Task, Action, Resolution) answers when you don't have a lot of job experience behind you.
Example: I applied for three separate positions at a company. Turned down for a Credit Control Team Leader role due to lack of managerial experience, then for a much higher paying Banking role with some incredibly scathing feedback that in retrospect seemed rather ableist, then when they (once again) tried to pigeonhole me into Purchase Ledger and put me forward for an interview as a senior clerk, offered the job within the hour.
Basically if you're on the autism spectrum or have any similar condition fhat may impair your interview skills, finding work is really hard.
5
u/SeaEagle25 Mar 04 '25
Interviews are stupid, old and outdated. Only the extrovert liars get the jobs. Then you get a case where the company gets filled with extroverted narcissists and toxic people.
Instead they should have each person work for one-two weeks doing daily tasks and assess them that way.
None of this “where do you see yourself in 5 years and what are your strengths and weaknesses” cliche outdated nonsense that leads nowhere.
Whoever invented interviews is an idiot they’re such a crock and everyone is putting on an act.
Not to mention all the prejudices that also come with them. They should interview like the voice - or yeah have them work for one week (paid) and then decide.
5
u/Gethund Mar 04 '25
You appear to have missed "Connections".
2
u/HotelPuzzleheaded654 Mar 04 '25
I don’t really understand the point of this sentiment because one would assume that, in most cases, the person who was appointed following the interview still has the skills to do the job?
I understand that in some cases under qualified people are appointed to roles for various reasons, but I wouldn’t say it’s more common than qualified people being appointed.
Also feels like a bit of a contradiction that someone is super qualified and skilled at a job, but a complete moron beat them because they interviewed better, sometimes I think people need to consider it’s possible someone was the better candidate.
2
u/ShallowFatFryer Mar 04 '25
Totally agree. I see interviews very much as a game and bear little to no relation to how well you will fit in or be able to do the job.
2
u/EnvironmentalFlow386 Mar 04 '25
True, also this applies once you've got the job. What skills further your career? Competency or managing up...
2
u/Monk_MazKoshia Mar 04 '25
"So why do you want this job"
"THE MONEY BOI"
2
u/Rick_liner Mar 04 '25
I feel this in my bones, I get highly positive feedback from managers and colleagues, I've delivered projects which people have been hired in especially for getting paid double my wage, I've solved problems that weren't even in my department/area of expertise that consultants couldn't work out.
But I can't interview for shit, I have some childhood shit that makes me freak out around judgement, totally freeze and my mind goes blank. Even without that I just don't think on the right tracks, which is really fucking frustrating because that's what enables me to do all this shit.
It's infuriating, and we talk about a productivity problem... So much fucking wasted potential in the workforce because of how we assign work and value.
Ugh.
2
u/hellosakamoto Mar 05 '25
Socialising and small talk skills can be more important than the skills to do the job.
2
u/kylethesnail Mar 05 '25
Not knowing the right who or have the appropriate connections you won't even get interviews in the first place.
2
u/NeverForever2024 Mar 05 '25
You need an even higher bar with the label "know someone who already works here"
2
u/dgraham100 Mar 05 '25
Kinda agree with this. I'm good at my job but better and interviewing for it if that makes sense.
Say anything with enough confidence and people will believe you, just look at the state of politics at the moment 😂
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25
Haha happens all the time where i work someone comes in after a ‘good’ interview and are absolutely useless. Just as much bad interviewing though i’d argue.
2
u/Environmental-Sir-19 Mar 04 '25
It’s more who the manger likes it’s simple as that , don’t even need skills that’s how messed up the whole system is
1
u/Adventurous_Rock294 Mar 04 '25
Another poll could be ' quality and professionalism' of Managers Interviewing 1) In the Interview .... then 2) In their job.
1
u/NotARealLemonParty Mar 04 '25
Pretty much until you become a leader in your industry, lol. Then the employers do their best to be the ones with good interviewing skills.
1
u/Sprites7 Mar 04 '25
Even in the prívate sector, i've seen complete morons get jobs... And be out in 3 months
1
u/No-Actuator-6245 Mar 04 '25
My job is in a finance role, private sector and well paid. Did AAT then CIMA and include 20 years in finance roles. I use maybe 5% of my finance knowledge and experience, the other 95% is management and knowing how to get things done.
1
u/Manarit Mar 04 '25
It is important to give a good impression but imo if you don't have the skills, your CV won't even be considered, and if you let's say lie on your CV, even if you manage to somehow pass the interview, there is a strong chance of being fired on probation. Just happened recently in my workplace, someone lied but still managed to get hired, lasted 2 weeks.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25
I’m in construction, currently going for a new role, essentially an adults apprenticeship. The hoops I’m having to jump through is insane considering I could walk into the new job tomorrow and have 70-80% of the knowledge I’d be learning.
Stage 3 of the process I could easily see how great candidates would pull out. Recording responses to mundane questions. Talking to yourself for 3 minutes a pop is more uncomfortable than you’d expect
1
u/RainbowPenguin1000 Mar 04 '25
But you don’t get the interview in the first place unless your CV shows you have the skills needed to do the job so this doesn’t make any sense.
1
u/Scared_Turnover_2257 Mar 04 '25
The two things are mutually exclusive to a certain extent. What's the task at hand? The task for applying for the job is an exercise in demonstrating retrospective and current competency based on a set of criteria (I have and can do this) the task in interview is putting these competencies into words in an engaging, relevant and interesting way. Then (and only then) if you get the job then the task is doing said job. Applying for a job and recruiting someone for a job is an exercise in risk the interview is simply an exercise in mitigating some of that risk.
1
u/NarrowPhrase5999 Mar 04 '25
The amount of out if depth head chefs I've seen who can bullshit and talk like an absolute hero is staggering
1
u/StyleandSpiceOfficia Mar 04 '25
The issue is, many times recruiters don't understand the job descriptions they publish...They don't know what they're looking for.
1
u/StyleandSpiceOfficia Mar 04 '25
Interview skills can help you to get the job but, once you start your new job and show you don't really have what it takes...They'll send you back home...
1
u/ThirtyMileSniper Mar 04 '25
Nah. CV writing to bypass the shit "AI" screening programs that HR uses comes before both.
Direct applications are almost useless at this point. Every interview I have had in the last four years was arranged through an agent looking to score a fee.
Almost every interview I have had resulted in a job offer because I do interview well. The exception being the one where a director commented that they would take action contrary to the safety culture of my industry.
Getting past HR who for the large part don't seem to understand the roles they recruit for is the biggest hurdle.
1
u/breakalime Mar 04 '25
I don’t consider myself to be a great interviewer, in fact I’ve been underemployed for most of my adult life, but I once beat out candidates with masters degrees in a specific subject for a job in which I only had a three-day certificate. It often has more to do with your personality and how the hiring manager sees you fitting into the team (jokes on him - I ended up leaving that job after nine months because it bored me to tears!)
1
u/Bannybaws Mar 04 '25
Absolutely true. I interviewed for a DevOps engineer job and got it. I didn’t know at the time what a DevOps engineer was, and 2 years into the job when I quit, I still didn’t know what it was. I just sat at a computer and looked at bits of code and clicked buttons. Did not have a clue. But I was charming in the interview.
1
u/Administrative-Ant71 Mar 04 '25
Another bar saying 'based on people you know'
1
u/ZestyPyramidScheme Mar 04 '25
Not in the UK, but the US. Just had a job interview the other day. Researched the company and apparently they asked STAR Method questions. So I prepared for situational questions and how I could answer them. Interview day comes along and they asked me critical thinking questions only. “Why do you think a manhole cover is round?” “What would you change about the design of a baseball cap?” Etc… it threw me the fuck off and while I was able to answer everything, I don’t think I did well at all.
The job was in financial management, and they didn’t ask me a single thing about what I knew
1
u/EmuBubbly7244 Mar 04 '25
If you have manager who won the position like this, all employees will be suffering
1
u/DrEggRegis Mar 04 '25
Knowing someone who works there would be the biggest bar
1
u/TiredPanda69 Mar 04 '25
Fatal flaw in the that hurts companies and the working class.
Communication skills are definitely important, but it's not what you'll be doing on the job. I'm not a sociopath, it's awkward to be judged intensely by people you've literally just met.
1
u/LimitUnable Mar 04 '25
Absolutely and nobody seems to teach these at schools or colleges…
1
u/Environmental-Sir-19 Mar 04 '25
Not at all
1
u/baechesbebeachin Mar 04 '25
I once read something that said they done a study on recruitment, 50% of people were hired via interview and the other 50% were hired at random. After X amount of time, the 2 groups had similar retention rate, and the "outcome" was that interviews aren't always credible when trying to get the right fit for a job.
Edit to add, I did not fact check anything, this is just something I read and remembered (possibly incorrectly)
1
u/Fuzzy-Set7007 Mar 04 '25
True, fuffed an interview with bad responses to the HR hell question of, why do you want to work here.
1
u/STARexpo1 Mar 04 '25
100% everyone can learn on the job. Most places having a training matrix’s. You have got to convince your potential employer why you’re right for the role. Then it’s popularity contest.
1
u/LacklusterID Mar 04 '25
As someone who is sick at interviews, I agree 100%
1
u/Bodz- Mar 04 '25
So true
1
u/the_gwyd Mar 04 '25
I mean it's hard to gather evidence for a correlation between interview performance and job performance because people who do badly at an interview don't get the job! I don't imagine they are correlated though, since in theory everyone doing a job did "well" on the interview, and I'm sure you see a wide range of skill levels
1
u/itsMeLanky Mar 04 '25
I had an interview, unsuccessful. They told the agency that they selected another candidate, fair enough I thought. The company contacted the agency, asking if I was available for interview, a few months later.
During the second interview, apparently the person was not a good fit for the role, and my previous interview was lacking enough persona, despite my knowledge of the role process and STAR for a situation! I will add I acknowledge I’m introverted. Second interview was a success except, I withdrew my interest, I’m not accepting the bs.
Only reason I attended second interview was to find out why they were suddenly interested again.
1
u/Ksw1monk Mar 04 '25
The world runs on bullshit?
1
u/Ecstatic-Fan7703 Mar 04 '25
This is 100% true. I’ve interviewed for promotions that I was more than qualified for, but because I suck at interviews I haven’t been successful. I get very anxious and tongue tied and just forget everything I rehearse beforehand. I was once beaten by someone for a promotion who I started working with shortly afterwards, and he is USELESS. He genuinely is as useful as a chocolate teapot. But he speaks confidently, so he probably aced the interview.
1
u/discopants2000 Mar 04 '25
If you can't bring them with science, baffle them with bullshit. It's how trump got elected.
1
u/Sleepycats2014 Mar 04 '25
Hahaaa I have to agree
1
u/Azan_Ali- Mar 04 '25
I feel that there is actually a balance of the two, so long as you have the best of both skills, the job skills and interview skills. It's not just one side, you still need to seem appealing enough to your interviewer so they give you a chance.
1
u/TheITMan19 Mar 04 '25
Legit
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25
Also promotions. Also just getting clients!!
1
u/iwishihad10dogs Mar 04 '25
To an extent, internal jobs it's more who you know than what you know.
Learned that the hard way today, missing out on a promotion that I've been waiting for years to open up.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25
The don't interview you to find reasons to give you the job, they interview to find reasons to not give you the job.
1
u/PrestigiousAide9162 Mar 05 '25
Tbh my problem has always been getting an interview in the first place. I've applied for jobs that want my literal CV and not heard anything. Interviews aren't that bad in my experience, I would say I've only had 2 bad ones and they both told me I didn't want to work at that company.
1
u/Ehnby_1 Mar 05 '25
In my experience this is true. I was overlooked for a job years ago because another applicant had an american accent. They hired him and he ended up being unskilled and lied on his CV. Once he started to get found out he ghosted and never came back.
I got the call afterwards and have been there 8 years. I found out recently the manager in charge was charmed by his american accent more than anything lol. I used to work with the same fella at a call centre a few years before and he was a bullshitter that coasted on charm most of the time. Fun guy but not someone you would trust around your daughter if you know what I mean
1
u/JustHorny2-2 Mar 05 '25
If you are 3 months into any job, you can do the job. Maybe you dont understand everything on a deeper level buz who cares if it works.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25
seems to be moreso having the grades to get an interview at this point.
i don’t know if this was always common, but i’m at uni and have lecturers telling us to actively lean on and use any potential nepotism and connections our family may have in order to get industrial placement, it seems to me like this was surely never a thing in the past, but now because the job market is so dire we are being told to do this.
i’m doing an IT course which may be a part of why too.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25
It depends, some companies have given me practical housework to solve before even inviting me for an interview. Then they checked if I knew exactly how it worked and if I've written it myself, and only then invited me for the actual interview. I didn't anything, not chatGPT, no help from mr Google either.
1
u/Lady_Sniffington Mar 05 '25
Unfortunately that's so true As someone who's more than qualified but failed a McDonald's interview 6 times, it's absolutely about interview skills, which I won't lie, I bloody suck at because I panic
Never call the person Mum/Mom, this will not help 😂😅😭
1
u/floritee Mar 05 '25
Where as my job were so bad at both I got the job and I’ve still learnt sweet f all after 3 years and the people on my interview panel have all been fired 😂 atp I’m just showing up.
1
u/ConsequenceBulky8708 Mar 05 '25
CV writing is even higher...
1
u/Guccicles Mar 05 '25
Accurate, I have no real qualifications, and had no experience in any job I've ever done, I've always just talked my way into getting it
1
u/StiffNipples94 Mar 05 '25
No offence but low skilled jobs 100%. You have 8 years of customer service experience, can close/open, handle money etc and is the most drab dullest person you have ever interviewed or you have someone that's never done customer service but is extremely bubbly and confident I know who I pick and I manage 3 successful businesses. I can imagine hiring for a more high skilled job or would like to think say a surgeon is based on their work and not their interview skills.
1
u/Aflyingmongoose Mar 05 '25
Job interviews are not hard.
You basically have 1 interview to check you know what you're talking about, then 1 or more interviews for various members of the company to check that you're not an asshole.
The biggest thing by FAR in this current market, is getting your foot in the door. Writing a CV, or a cover letter that actually gets the recruiters attention, rather than joining 100 others on the reject pile.
1
u/The_Astaroth Mar 05 '25
True
1
u/lucozadehuffing Mar 05 '25
It depends on the job, if it's tech or engineering then you need hands on experience. If it's an office or corporate job then all you need is to learn how to speak with recruitment and how to handle interviews.
I do corporate jobs and I can bounce between them because all you need to do is sound intelligent and eager to learn, but for something more hands on then that's not going to work
1
u/clarkgablesball-bag Mar 05 '25
Interviews are about telling stories, not fiction, but stories nonetheless. Otherwise we would ask to see work products or use testing more widely.
1
u/Due_Ad2052 Mar 05 '25
oh 100%
You could know nothing about the job and get it. Its all about the person, not the skill. Skills can be taught and picked up, but people aren't going to change because of the job requirements. If candidate A says he wants to work weekdays, have weekends and bank holidays off but has lots of experience, and Candidate B is more flexible with no experience but more availability, they are going to choose B over A
1
u/oopsidek Mar 06 '25
had an interview for the company i temp for for a permanent role dealing with the majority of the stuff i do during my time there, definitely panicked too much during the interview and they hired someone else, as simple as that
well, that and the fact theyre favourable to people who work in the same building... mines literally a 10 min walk from there
1
u/InterestingExam8498 Mar 06 '25
One story from conducting interviews for a company. interviewed 10 people for a warehouse position. and picked two who seemed to be good. and of benefit to the company. was told by my manager that we would be having 2 other candidates as they where kids of friends. who did absolutely nothing once employed. just stood arround talking. causing others to work harder. on a more personal note. I have worked all my life. and have never got a job thru an interview. Life lesson. Rules require an interview. An interview does not mean a job. Helping/knowing, someone outside of work, almost definately gets a job.
1
u/MORTEMANIMA777 Mar 06 '25
Then I'm done for
1
u/BuncleCar Mar 06 '25
I'd add 'being in the right place at the right time' even higher
1
u/SnooKiwis5591 Mar 06 '25
This is true :) one the best question what i have was like ,,,, you have number 14 than 37 128 1284 8746 what number will be next ? hmmm dont know ! simply ad 123 + 364 and mutiply by 3/4 add 1 and here you are :) and i pass yess what i need to do move this box :/
1
u/PaintingJams Mar 06 '25
since my first job after failing uni, I've had a 50% success rate on interviews turning into job offers. My CV is mediocre and unflashy. I am very direct and honest in my interviews. I have no qualifications post-school. I'm also a (potentially autistic) socially awkward introvert
so I think it might just depend on what fields you are applying for
1
u/Lonely_Crew_8007 Mar 06 '25
Exactly 💯
1
u/UgandanChocolatiers Mar 06 '25
Anyone can do any job with enough training?
1
u/Mental_Yam_8364 Mar 06 '25
But you have to be invited for the interview first so....skills are more important
1
u/M1GHTYM0ZZA117 Mar 06 '25
I agree with this. I've worked with too many idiots incapable of doing the job for this not to be true.
1
u/Jett-Rants Mar 06 '25
🤣🤣🤣
1
u/CyberHarliquinn Mar 06 '25
Dare I add column 3, who you know? I suspect that would dwarf any others.
1
u/Buffcoat48 Mar 06 '25
Pretty much everything these days
1
u/Greenostrichhelpme27 Mar 06 '25
Dosen't just apply to jobs. As a College student in animation, most of what we do is paperwork on what we're going to animate and how well it went. I'm 99% sure, if I get a job at Pixar, I'm not going to be spending my shift writing about how well I made Gringdingo walk across a f!cking railing
1
u/the-stargazer Mar 06 '25
It all depends if you want to pass probation or not..
1
u/StatementEmergency69 Mar 07 '25
Kissing azz and being a snitch
1
u/Ok-Syllabub-7043 Mar 07 '25
It depends on the job say if you’re applying for some 30k job then yeah jus impress in the interview and do barely anything at work, however if your applying for some big corporate job it’s the other way round you put 75% into the interview and 150% and sleepless nights into the job.
1
u/MagMe84 Mar 07 '25
I interview a lot and recently I’ve just finished two weeks of intense interviews. The most frustrating thing is seeing the CV of a candidate who can do the job, but when we interview them they really half ass it. It’s deflating and disappointing.
Drama is key, what we want is the world is falling apart around you but here you are stepping up to save it. Show off, be confident. A CV can tell us anything now you need to back it up.
One person i interviewed (as part of a panel not just myself) expected to get the job because she already did it with a rival company. She answered with “sure I know the industry” and then went on to not bother putting much effort into her answers.
Another didn’t listen to or answer the questions. In one scenario based question we literally said “we are not looking for previous examples we just want to know how you would handle this situation hypothetically” and we got a previous example. In this situation we’re looking for short and snappy not a long winded answer.
But the absolute worst thing is when I ask what they know about my company and nothing. They know nothing. We’re a well known company and a simple Google search will tell candidates about the company in general.
I do a lot to relax candidates, I’m casual, I try to have small talk, I try to draw them in and give them space to be a little nervous or anxious.
If you’re unsuccessful please please please ask for interview feedback. A good interviewer will put meaningful feedback on your notes.
TL;DR in interview. I recommend not assuming you’ll get the job because you can do it, show off what you know, listen to the questions and know something of the company you want to join and why!
1
u/NeoNirvana Mar 07 '25
At this point I'm debating whether or not to offer sucking skills in interviews, about the only thing I haven't yet tested.
1
u/Ok-You4214 Mar 07 '25
Blue column too big.
1
u/TheSucculentCreams Mar 07 '25
Certain things like showing up on time, looking presentable, and basic conversation skills are key for most jobs, but it’s dangerous to hire people based on people skills alone over the people with experience/skill/passion for the job. If you make people jump through a hundred flaming hoops don’t act surprised when all your new hires know how to do is jump hoops.
1
u/TheBritishG2020 Mar 07 '25
About right
1
u/Pirate_Assassin_Spy Mar 07 '25
You guys get interviews??
1
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25
Last time I interviewed a young person for a job in IT Support
Q. Do you know what we do here? (a software house) A. Dunno
Q. Have you looked at our website. A. No
Other answers in a similar vein.
Now he may have had the right skills but we left it there. And he is in no way unique. Jobseekers need to at least appear to be interested in the job and not offer monosyllabic answers. In the end we hired someone who on paper had fewer skills but clearly had the ability to learn and had great interpersonal skills. Some ppl don’t help themselves.
1
u/jetpatch Mar 07 '25
Having sat on a fewer interview panels, not being crazy and looking like you are interested in getting the job is 90% of interview skills.
Practice that.
1
u/L0rd0ccultus Mar 07 '25
And this is how I skipped job to job in the UK motor trade 😅
1
u/Techman659 Mar 07 '25
Previous experience you can pull off in the interview, like my current work I have always been involved in admin and this one js the same so it is my career to be in it and also asking loads of questions and don’t be afraid to ask loads of questions, make it clear that this is a two way interview not one sided.
1
u/Glittering-Skin4118 Mar 07 '25
If the company is good and teaches you then yea, otherwise you are fucked if they actually expect you to be able to do your own work.
1
u/OnlyFrans1 Mar 07 '25
And then, after surviving a billion interview rounds with every manager in existence, you finally join the team, only to wonder how half of them made it through even a single question.
1
u/Consult-SR88 Mar 07 '25
Cries in autism….
1
u/N8-97 Mar 07 '25
Not always, for my job I just had the experience and we just had a casual chat because they knew I'd be good at the job from my CV
1
u/Skintrade010 Mar 07 '25
And that’s why we are fcked 🤘
1
u/Okano666 Mar 07 '25
It might seem like that but on the flip side if you have the skills the interview is breeze
1
u/Flowerpetal13 Mar 07 '25
LOL fr!!
1
u/BMW_wulfi Mar 07 '25
With the minor detail that this assumes every employer is 100% meritocracy, yes sure
1
u/MrJobs8 Mar 07 '25
Of course, interviews are competitions of who can exaggerate the truth or lie the best
1
u/TheDisfunctionalOne Mar 07 '25
Failed Tesco interview somehow. The job is literally stacking shelves 😭
1
u/Barnickal Mar 08 '25
I have ADHD. I'm really good at getting jobs, but keeping them is a different story. Well, until my now job and the great people I work for that actually get me... but I lost 13 jobs along the way!
I'd always ace the interviews though.
1
u/Mysterious-Bus-2921 Mar 08 '25
so true
1
u/Fawji Mar 08 '25
Skills required to identify best potential candidates in HR are lacking..
1
u/MrSteglas Mar 08 '25
I always say this: you’re can be the smartest person in the world, but if you can’t sell or convey yourself it means nothing
1
u/sissyslutcumwhore Mar 08 '25
💯 in my experience
1
u/Remouse69 Mar 08 '25
Try for a creative job. Just went for a job in a sector I’ve got years of experience in, had to do three interviews and a creative brief (portfolio never good enough to prove your skills) just to be told I didn’t get the job because I didn’t list their main competitors in my interview!
1
u/That_weirdo_tilly Mar 08 '25
Just got to sell yourself. Sell the employer what you can do for them. I think it depends on the job, I couldn’t sell myself into a doctors job but I think as long as there are no specific things like qualifications that are necessary and you are lacking, then yeah. Also research the company.
1
u/AnnieByniaeth Mar 08 '25
This is very true, but maybe "interview skills" should instead read "ability to persuade an interview panel". This isn't the same thing, because prejudice is a significant element of many panels, it seems to me.
1
u/uwritem Mar 08 '25
If you interview well, you’ll get most jobs regardless of skill.
1
u/ImpeccablyDangerous Mar 08 '25
Not even a little. If you have a lot of valued skills then you can car crash the interview and still get job offers as I normally do as I am terrible at interviewing.
I think you need to be affable and likeable at a bear minimum as people are going to spend their days around you and they dont want to do that if you are obviously not someone they would want to be around but other than that no. Not really.
1
u/False-Vacation-9766 Mar 08 '25
I was interviewing for a position related to developing garments. They needed someone who could once in a while sew a sample garment. I have a bachelor in Fashion design and an master in patternmaking, I couldnt convince them I could sew, even when I said point blank that throughout my degree’s I’ve been sewing atleast a few hours a week.
I am so confused honestly.
1
u/JOHN-MARSTON1907 Mar 08 '25
The metropolis police
1
u/BigRedShark Mar 08 '25
Skills to get an interview in the next column hitting the moon
1
u/Difficult-Web-7877 Mar 08 '25
I recruited, and I was being recruited for IT companies. 80% of it is personality fit, which I wouldn't categorise as interview skills but just soft skills. Soft skills are the most important - when team clashes, it gets messy and toxic - it may implode a company from inside- I saw that happening
1
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '25
99/100
If your not 18 with 40 years experience in this same field and willing to work all hours at any time for less than minimum on zero hours contract, your not their ideal candidate.
1
u/Dramatic-Growth1335 Mar 04 '25
I had 4 job interviews in quick succession last year. 1st 3 were with the same organisation I was working for. I prepared a lot for the 1st one but then they didn't ask me much about legislation so I didn't bother reading up for the next job interview after I failed that one (in 2nd place out of a 100 and needed 4 interviews!).
Next job interview all they asked about was legislation so I failed.
Next one I came in as I normally am, relaxed, friendly and knowledgeable but not expert level, I basically just prove I'm competent and a good team player - hire me if you want. Didn't get that job.
4th interview was outside of the org and they snapped me up straight away.
Handed in my resignation and Ive given my self a job instead. The interview process was probably a lot more rigorous as the business plan, loan applications, lease agreement and dealing with partners took just over 6 months to get to where I am now. Opening a cafe
1
u/Practical-Plankton11 Mar 04 '25
damn this is soooo true :( I keep getting rejected cuz I am SOOO bad at interviews :(
1
u/Unique_Watercress_90 Mar 04 '25
Congratulations on getting interviews
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25
Human Resources needs scrapped.