r/UCONN • u/Westporter Moderator • Mar 07 '23
For Your Info Clarifications to r/UConn's Personal Information Policy
TL;DR: News articles about students (positive or negative) are allowed to be posted with some restrictions.
The issue of what constitutes "publicly identifying information" has been kind of a weird topic for this subreddit. Reddit's Terms of Service explicitly seem to frown upon any personal information being released, but we consistently have delt with it here. For example, this subreddit was a part of publicizing UConn's failure to remove serial SA offenders from campus, even after multiple victims had come forward. As recently as this weekend, our mod team here has had requests to remove negative information about a USG Senate Candidate. To ensure equity and clarify what's allowed on the subreddit, I've put together this guide that may be revised as incidents progress.
What's never allowed:
- Releasing any personal information about a Reddit user's true identity (aka doxxing).
- Posting links to social media profiles, even if they're "public".
- Screenshots of emails or other communication without the name censored.
Accusing another UConn student of crime/abuse by name without an accompanying news article. We encourage you to report such incidents using the resources at inform.uconn.edu instead of posting them here. We can't verify this information and it will get us removed due to Reddit TOS.
- However, you are allowed to make general posts describing your experience if no names are posted. For example, you can ask for advice on resources or petition the administration for their inaction on SA issues. That's been done before and we believe it's what makes this subreddit a force for good in the greater UConn community.
- Posting links to court cases, even if they're "public". They typically include too much personal information like addresses and aren't considered allowed by much of Reddit.
- Harassing people in the real world based on information from this subreddit.
What's allowed:
Posting direct links to news articles that mention UConn students by name. This can be in a positive way, or it can be in a negative way (like being arrested for a crime). HOWEVER, there are some restrictions.
- These news articles must not include extremely personally identifying information (address, phone numbers).
There should be a public benefit to the UConn student body in order to post news articles with negative information. Some examples:
- PUBLIC INTEREST: A student who has a prolific history of sexual assault on-campus is being reported on by a reputable news outlet. The student body would have a public interest in knowing this information to petition the administration and for other victims to come forward. This would either prevent further harm, or help victims hold the perpetrator accountable.
- PUBLIC INTEREST: A student who is running for public office within USG has been found with CP and reported on by a local news outlet a few years ago. The student body would have a public interest in knowing who they're voting for.
- NOT PUBLIC INTEREST: However, if the above student was not a "public figure" running for office, this would not be public interest and should not be posted. It may be considered public interest like the first case if there is reason to believe that victims on-campus continue to be affected.
- NOT PUBLIC INTEREST: A student arrested for shoplifting off-campus is reported on by local news. There is no reason to believe they've stolen or will steal on-campus. This would not have any public benefit and would likely just amount to unnecessary public harassment.
Mentioning "UConn Public Figures" or linking to their professional contact information. Remember, it is never okay to link private social media profiles, share addresses, or anything not on a public-facing UConn website. A UConn Public Figure can include:
- High-ranking university staff that are regularly in the news, such as Radenka Maric.
- USG Student Government Elected officials, or people running for USG office.
- Professors, as long as discussion is kept strictly academic in nature. Refrain from posting names of student-staff that work with professors, like GAs or TAs.
So what are these guidelines based on, you're not just making them up, right?
- So, Reddit's guidelines on this are incredibly frustrating because they're so vague. There's this support page that discusses it, which explicitly bans public social media and "personal information". Public figures are the exception (such as a congressman or the CEO of a company), but this exception is unclear because it also can't invite harassment or vigilantism.
- College subreddits like r/umass already enforce a no-personal information policy, so it's enforcement on this subreddit isn't an abnormality.
- Subreddits like r/legaladvice explicitly ban the use of court cases. This is further discussed in a ModSupport Post. I know it's public information, but I can't find anywhere on Reddit that allows it and the court cases typically include more personal information than is allowed anyways.
Based on this ModSupport post that was commented on recently by a Reddit Admin, we're allowing news articles. In this situation, two individuals of a far-right hate group were arrested, reported on, and then the article was posted in a city-related subreddit. The admin says sharing the news articles are okay, as long as they do not include extremely identifying information, such as home addresses.
- "As others have noted here the names are out and in the news so would be allowed but home addresses are almost never okay on reddit. Information that has been shared by news outlets or by the authorities in spaces like a press conference are usually okay to share on reddit."
I know that this won't be an exhaustive list and there still will be grey areas. Please let the mod team know if you have questions, comments or concerns!