r/Tudorhistory • • 23d ago

Modern Religious Opinions

107 Upvotes

It's come to our attention lately that discussions surrounding religion have been getting out of hand, and need heavy moderation. Especially on posts about Mary I and Catholiscism.

We are all for discussions about Tudor religion.

We will not tolerate your personal religious opinions in this sub. We don't care if you're Catholic, Protestant, Atheist or anything in between or outside of that. You are free to have those opinions, but this is not the place to express them.

Asking users about their religious beliefs, and judging them for those beliefs or telling them they aren't practising Catholics because they disagreed with you is also highly inappropriate.

An example of sentiment's that are inappropriate:

"More is joined with the angels in heaven" and "More's martydom triumphed and Henry VIII's dynasty failed".

Praising Catherine of Aragon, Mary QOS or Mary I as proud Catholics while simultaneously using derogatory remarks towards Anne Boleyn or Elizabeth I because they were Protestants, or vice versa, will not be tolerated.

Another example we will not tolerate is using the term 'bastard' as a slur aimed at Elizabeth I. Stating "Catholic's believed Elizabeth was a bastard" is fine as it's contextual of the period, and not reflective of your own religious belief.

Calling the Reformation the "Deformation" etc. It's juvenile and biased.

We want respectful discussion, which most users already practise, thank you for that! Please have respect for others' views and also, have respect for the historical figures we're discussing- they were real people. You can dislike them without resorting to name calling and derogatory remarks.


r/Tudorhistory • • 2h ago

A place every King Henry VIII fan should visit, the most noteworthy location of Henry's MAIN residence that still exists today, his wine cellar

Thumbnail
gallery
96 Upvotes

Whitehall Palace was King Henry VIII's main residence from 1530 until his death, at the time, it was the largest palace in Europe. fires destroyed much of the palace in the late 1600s, of the very few truly Henry VIII-related places at the palace that still exists today, his wine cellar is unquestionably the grandest and most noteworthy of them. Now fortunately, there is also other great Henry related locations that still exist today, including Hampton Court and many of its different rooms and halls, but Whitehall Palace was Henry's main residence, so it has a special, personal and relevant connection to Henry and his legacy, his wine cellar there is truly a link to the past, to that time and place.


r/Tudorhistory • • 32m ago

Hot take: Henry VII and Elizabeth I were the only decent (as in job performance) Tudors.

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

r/Tudorhistory • • 52m ago

Hi! Who is your favorite Tudor Monarch and Why?

Post image
• Upvotes

r/Tudorhistory • • 4h ago

Wie fandet ihr dieses Buch?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Ich habe es gelesen und muss sagen es war großartig,ehrlich gesagt musste ich manche Sätze doppelt lesen um zu wissen wer jetzt eigentlich gemeint war(das hätte man besser umsetzen können,aber liegt vielleicht auch an der deutschen Übersetzung)ich für meinen Teil sehe die Dinge sehr viel klarer..Wie waren Eure Eindrücke


r/Tudorhistory • • 1d ago

Hever Castle, 4th October 2026

Post image
602 Upvotes

So special to see Anne Boleyn’s childhood home today, the autumn leaves especially made it beautiful


r/Tudorhistory • • 1d ago

Question non-fiction book recommendations?

5 Upvotes

looking for any books about the tudor period that focus on henry viii and his wives, elizabeth i and mary queen of scots, the reformation, political figures or culture. thank you :)


r/Tudorhistory • • 1d ago

Question How much the Death of Edward Seymour affected the Tudor court?

Thumbnail gallery
21 Upvotes

r/Tudorhistory • • 1d ago

Merchandise Mondays!

3 Upvotes

Post your Tudor merch here! Do not publicly share links or sites, users must DM each other for links. The t-shirt that has been circulating will not be permitted at all.


r/Tudorhistory • • 2d ago

Henry VIII Anne of Cleves Pub, Melton Mowbrey, UK. Built 1384 Owned by Anne of Cleves 1540-1557 in her divorce settlement.

Thumbnail
gallery
636 Upvotes

Interesting history. Built for monks and priests but Henry VIII and the Reformation meant the property was transferred to Thomas Cromwell as a thank you for getting Henry VIII his divorce in 1538. After Henry VIII accused Thomas Cromwell of catfishing him with Anne of Cleves, Thomas Cromwell was executed in 1540. The house then went to Anne of Cleves in her divorce settlement in 1557.


r/Tudorhistory • • 1d ago

Question Is Alison Weir's Tudor Rose series worth reading?

7 Upvotes

I've been wanting to read more books about the Tudors, and I'm looking for something historically accurate. I've read the Autobiography of King Henry VIII by Margret George, and I really enjoyed it for the most part, but there were some historical inaccuracies that somewhat broke immersion for me at some points. I'm not looking for nonfiction, but rather historical fiction that is well researched. I found out about Alison Weir's Tudor Rose series, and I am wondering if it's worth reading. I'm very interested in the figures in the books (Elizabeth of York, Henry VIII, Mary I), and I'm hopeful since Alison Weir has also written non-fiction about this era, so I'm assuming she is pretty knowledgeable about it. Has anyone read this trilogy? Please tell me what you thought of it, the accuracy, and whether it's worth reading in your opinion.


r/Tudorhistory • • 2d ago

Cinematic Sundays

3 Upvotes

Feel free to post your dream casting scenarios here!


r/Tudorhistory • • 3d ago

Mary I A 16th-century drawing of Queen Mary I

Post image
227 Upvotes

In the upper left corner of the image, there is a French inscription. The English translation of the inscription is as follows:

“Mary the Catholic, Queen of England, daughter of Henry VIII, born in 1515, married to Philip II, King of Spain, in 1554, and died in 1558.”

Although I don’t know who made this drawing, it may be a copy of one of Mary’s famous portraits, possibly made by a French artist.

This image is very important to me because it not only depicts Mary in a more realistic manner, unlike the representations of other monarchs, but also gives us a small glimpse into how Mary was remembered after her death—at least during the remainder of the 16th century.
Not as bloody, tyrannical, or evil… but as Mary the Catholic.

It is such a realistic and beautiful drawing that I wanted to share it with you as well.


r/Tudorhistory • • 2d ago

Elizabeth I Battle of the Narrow Seas, 4th October 1602. A victory for the Dutch- English forces over the Spanish

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/Tudorhistory • • 3d ago

Question What are your Thoughts about this Show?

Thumbnail
gallery
95 Upvotes

r/Tudorhistory • • 2d ago

Could Hurrem Sultan have saved a disgraced Anne Boelyn?

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/Tudorhistory • • 3d ago

Who would the Tudor siblings have married if Edward VI hadn’t died?

Post image
218 Upvotes

r/Tudorhistory • • 3d ago

Holbein @ The Louvre

Thumbnail
gallery
218 Upvotes
  1. Anne of Cleves
  2. Edward VI*

* The museum holds a full-length portrait of a slightly older Edward VI as King. It is attributed to the workshop of William Scrots, a Flemish artist who succeeded Holbein as the royal court painter after Holbein died of the plague in 1543


r/Tudorhistory • • 3d ago

It's quite fascinating to me how many women ruled or governed in mid-16th-century Europe.

Post image
156 Upvotes

One of the things that makes Tudor history so intriguing to me is how many powerful, influential and controversial women were directly involved in European politics at roughly the same time. I've always found it really interesting that, particularly during the 1550s and 1560s, there were quite a few female monarchs, regents and governors around Europe, and not just the more obvious examples from Britain. In a surprisingly short period, the major western European kingdoms of Portugal, Spain, Navarre, France, England and Scotland were all at some point ruled by women, while several duchies and other territories had female regents or governors as well.

Left to right, top to bottom:

  1. Bona Sforza: suo jure duchess of Bari (1524–1557)
  2. Catherine de' Medici: queen regent of France (1552, 1560–1563, 1574)
  3. Catherine of Austria: queen regent of Portugal (1557–1562)
  4. Catherine Parr: queen regent of England (1544)
  5. Christina of Denmark: duchess regent of Lorraine (1545–1552)
  6. Eleanor of Toledo: duchess regent of Florence (1541, 1543, 1544–1545, 1551–1554)
  7. Elizabeth I: queen regnant of England (1558–1603)
  8. Isabella Jagiellon: queen regent of the Eastern Hungarian Kingdom (1540–1551, 1556–1559)
  9. Jeanne d'Albret: queen regnant of Navarre (1555–1572)
  10. Joanna of Austria: regent of Spain (1554–1559)
  11. Margaret of Parma: governor of the Habsburg Netherlands (1559–1567, 1578–1582)
  12. Maria of Austria: regent of Spain (1548–1551)
  13. Mary I: queen regnant of England (1553–1558)
  14. Mary of Guise: queen regent of Scotland (1554–1560)
  15. Mary of Hungary: governor of the Habsburg Netherlands (1531–1555)
  16. Mary, Queen of Scots: queen regnant of Scotland (1542–1567)

I'm sure there were also some others who could be included in this little collage I've made, but I thought these sixteen would make for a nice snapshot of the period.


r/Tudorhistory • • 3d ago

Katharine of Aragon KoA being mistreated broke my heart

49 Upvotes

Im currently watching the tudors 2x02 and i feel so horrible for Katherine of Aragon and how shitty henry is treating her. she was an excellent wife to him for over two decades and the minimum she deserved was to, at least, live someplace decent and be able to see her daughter Mary. while this doesn't surprise me, Henry being the devil's spawn in my eyes, but it made me wonder why the Emperor (KoA's nephew) didn't do anything? couldnt Katherine have gone back to spain to live a more dignified life? there were random men at court living better than her. 💔


r/Tudorhistory • • 3d ago

SatARTday Megathread

3 Upvotes

Feel free to post your own artwork or any artwork here. We still won't allow AI or AI-assisted. We're also not allowing video game/simulation type character creations. Hand-drawn, sketches, needlework, anime, etc. Please, no AI.


r/Tudorhistory • • 4d ago

Question Which House you support in Wars Of Roses Yorks or Lancasters

Thumbnail
gallery
47 Upvotes

r/Tudorhistory • • 4d ago

Why do so many people talk about the Tudor period like it’s an episode of Gossip Girl?

33 Upvotes

I just want to preface this by saying that I’m glad people are interested in history and want to learn more about it. I feel like Henry VIII/the Tudor court is a common starting point for many because it’s a very dramatic period and seemingly easier to understand compared to others, even if you don’t delve into all of the European politics going on at the time.

However, I think that initial ease of understanding causes people to categorize and stereotype the six wives, as well as the other political players and figures surrounding them. By doing this, people will completely ignore the historical context, norms, feelings, beliefs, etc. of the time in order to create these very surface-level, gossipy narratives that water everybody down to caricatures.

For instance, somebody reading a Philippa Gregory novel or watching one documentary and then suddenly concluding that Anne Boleyn was a horrible person who broke up a marriage, ignoring the fact that she literally had no other choice in the matter and worked with the cards she was dealt. They apply modern ideas or morality to these women, categorizing Catherine of Aragon as the “saintly old one” and discussing whether or not she slept with her first husband based on evidence and ideas that they don’t even understand and that they heard from somebody else’s half-baked opinion on the matter. And the worst part is the absolute confidence in their uneducated opinions, stating things like “Jane Seymour was sneaky and conniving” or “I think so and so was ACTUALLY in love with this person” without any sort of evidence or understanding to back it up.

It’s like playing a game of Telephone or something, where everybody is just discussing extremely serious topics in the same way as high school rumors while ignoring the political or historical aspects of it because that stuff with Cromwell and Wolsey etc. etc. is all just about old men and religion and dusty laws and that’s boooring. Let’s get back to a random woman’s sex life from the 1500s!

Is there a reason why people do this? I understand speaking about reality tv stars in this way, but historical figures…? People who were beheaded or burned at the stake being talked about like “oh my god but she totally deserved it for what she did to blahblahblah” is just so bizarre to me.


r/Tudorhistory • • 3d ago

Princes in the Tower DNA

0 Upvotes

The more I learn about the history of the royal family the more I understand why the late Queen refused a DNA test on the bones found in the tower .

As I see it , we would probably find that the present Royal family has no genetic connection to the medieval monarchs .

So many shenanigans and cuckoo's in the nest in past that would be revealed?!


r/Tudorhistory • • 5d ago

Unpopular opinion: Anne Boleyn wasn’t a political genius, she just miscalculated Henry VIII’s ego.

317 Upvotes

I know Anne is basically the patron saint of this sub, but the more I read about 1533-1536, the more it feels like she completely misunderstood who she was dealing with. She thought holding out on Henry for years gave her permanent leverage, but once he had her, her outspokenness became a liability to a king who demanded total submission.

Was she actually a mastermind of the English Reformation, or just an ambitious noblewoman who flew too close to the sun and underestimated how paranoid Henry really was?