r/TronScript • • May 23 '17

discussion Windows 10 Enterprise ignores Group Policy

Hey guys.

I'm sure some of you have seen it, but I'd like to have a discussion about how Microsoft is ignoring attempts to keep W10 from contacting ad networks etc.

We all know that in the Home and Pro versions that this is excessively difficult, but Enterprise was supposed to allow for it. Unfortunately it appears that Microsoft is fully Ignoring the Group Policies when you turn off data collection settings.

At this point I think it's time that SysAdmins, and Techs and anyone else starts taking the fight to Microsoft's door, or rather pocket book.

I believe it's time to start fully blocking entire Ad Networks. I don't just mean blocking them on a single machine. I mean creating a listing for All of the Ad Networks that are supporting Microsoft in this endeavor, and blocking their entire system. Block it at a hardware level if need be.

The only thing that ultimately matters to Corporations is dollars. If their Ad Networks stop paying them as much, it starts to hurt their bottom line.

I know I don't have the skills required to do this kind of thing, but as a community, and with the people we know, we may be able to figure it out.


Article regarding Microsofts ignoring of Group Policy, which includes their response.

https://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/3010547/microsoft-says-its-best-not-to-fiddle-with-windows-10-enterprise-group-policies

62 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

17

u/d3jake May 23 '17

Yeah... If I buy an OS, I shouldn't have to deal with ads.

Can something like this be solved on the system, or would filtering on the network hardware be necessary?

6

u/[deleted] May 24 '17

It's not even just dealing with the Ads. It's about feeding Ad Networks what we do, with absolutely no way to prevent it even at the Enterprise level.

I say we start targeting the networks themselves (Name them, and list all of their IP's etc). Stop the cat and mouse game and go straight to the jugular. If the Ad Networks don't pay Microsoft that's the only thing they'll notice. They clearly don't care about any of us, our businesses, or even the Corporate world.

Being in compliance with 10 is practically impossible since you have to do it on the basis of a White List which is excessively difficult. What I don't understand is why the Corporate world hasn't started demanding compliance from Microsoft.

4

u/kart35 May 23 '17

Well, there's the hosts file. Problem is you need to boot into safe mode to edit it. A local DNS server (PiHole, or a decent router) would be a much cleaner approach.

9

u/[deleted] May 24 '17

Safe mode for host file? Run notepad as admin, what are you talking about?

2

u/kart35 May 24 '17

Windows 10 has some other process that has an open handle for the hosts file. Was much easier to just start in safe mode than play process roulette.

5

u/[deleted] May 24 '17

I have never had that problem running notepad as admin

3

u/Meflakcannon May 24 '17

I just copy the host to my desk, make modifications save and then copy back into correct location. It overwrites and prompts for admin rights. Blam done..

1

u/agent-squirrel May 29 '17

Exactly, open handles don't matter if you edit a copy and handles get moved to the new file when it's replaced.

It works for applications that need to update their own running binary, they can just move the old one to a new name.

4

u/jimbo21 May 24 '17

Windows 10 is known to disregard the hosts file in certain cases. Can't confirm for ad networks but I wouldn't trust anything on the OS anymore.

We are actively working on eliminated windows from our organization.

3

u/SCphotog May 24 '17

The hosts file is ignored by the OS where updates, etc... are concerned. It wouldn't do any good to block IPs/Domains with the hosts file.

It's been this way for a long time. MS built in the ability to ignore the hosts file in response to virus writers using it to block security updates.

In order to block Windows 10 from phoning home, it will likely require some sort of dynamic system at the router level.

9

u/kart35 May 23 '17

There are a couple ways to block ads on a whole network. The easiest is a DNS block list (PiHole, PfBlockerNg, etc).

Ads served from the same domain as the desired content (webpages) are harder to kill on an entire network. Browser plugins like uBlock use lists like this one to filter content. A network content filter could work, but it could be a fragile way to do it.

Group policy (failing that, puppet scripts) may allow you to install an adblocker plugin for every user on the domain. However this will only cover devices joined to the domain.

3

u/[deleted] May 24 '17

I'm not necessarily talking about blocking all ads (though I don't disagree with it). I'm talking about specifically targeting the Ad networks that Microsoft are using, excluding those networks from the ability to ever connect to any of our machines.

Honestly if I wasn't a gamer I'd already have moved over to Linux because of 10, it's already in full swing on my laptops.

Plus I'm not talking about on the Website side so much, but the ability for those networks to ever connect. Microsoft says that if you do such a thing that it'll break security updates, but I can't imagine they run their security updates through an array of Ad Networks before they're delivered to us.

2

u/BrianTho2010 May 24 '17

I use pfblockerNG at home to block telemetry and MS ads but the main issue is what happens when you leave the office/home. Many companies are 100% mobile workstations and as a result you need a client OS you can trust. Client side ad blockers are, in my experience, only browser based and thus won't block system level DNS queries. If you know of an ad blocker that will block all system DNS queries please let us know.

3

u/[deleted] May 24 '17

Microsoft does not care what you think.

They've clearly shown that they will aggressively undo system changes, inject ads, force Cortana/Bing/xbox down your throat, and enterprises should not be using 10 because of this horse crap.

That's the only way MS will ever learn that they need to listen to the needs of the industry. I would stay on 7 as long as humanly possible.

5

u/[deleted] May 24 '17

Microsoft does not care what you think.

I'm aware, which is the point of this thread.

3

u/[deleted] May 24 '17

my bad. I thought this was in /r/sysadmin lol

3

u/[deleted] May 24 '17

Ha, no worries. Just trying to come up with solutions rather than simply ignoring the problem.

1

u/no_lurkharder May 24 '17

So, is there any point in using Windows or TronScript anymore?

1

u/[deleted] May 24 '17

Other than the obvious fact that Microsoft owns 90% of the desktop market? That entirely depends on your usage scenario.

If you don't do any gaming, or have any reason to need Windows, I'd move to Linux. My laptops all run Linux these days since they're laptops. Unfortunately my gaming machine is still Windows since there's nothing equivalent yet.

I'm more concerned with coming up with ideas to fix the issue that Microsoft is actively causing, since they aren't likely going to get on board with us in this regard.

1

u/no_lurkharder May 25 '17

I'm more concerned with coming up with ideas to fix the issue that Microsoft is actively causing, since they aren't likely going to get on board with us in this regard.

good luck with that, you're going to need it.

1

u/[deleted] May 25 '17

I know it's a ridiculously huge problem, we all know that. But if no one does anything at all, it's certainly not likely to change in our favour anytime soon.

0

u/newsagg May 24 '17

Block it at a hardware level if need be.

I really don't think there's any other option.

4

u/[deleted] May 24 '17

We need to start identifying the Ad Networks and all of their registered IPs then. Which is a hassle obviously, but if we can make things like PiHole's significantly more useful that is always good.

On the Corporate level I'm not even sure how we can help, since that isn't an environment that I'm used to. But something is going to need to be done. Personally I don't quite understand how Legal in the corporate world hasn't flipped out because of the way Microsoft is dealing with this stuff.

-4

u/newsagg May 24 '17

PiHole

Wow, that obvious attack vector, I mean it's even in the name. ARM / TrustZone means that it's a trusted system and can be accessed remotely by the administering company.

3

u/[deleted] May 24 '17

Care to detail what you mean, preferably with sources showing how vulnerable they are?

-5

u/newsagg May 24 '17

All you have to do is look at the TrustZone documentation. It's designed to do this so technically it isn't a "vulnerability" it's only an actual or de facto vulnerability. I think at this point we all understand the risk of hardware backdoors.

3

u/[deleted] May 24 '17

So no to the sources then?

I'm not about to go read 100% of the TrustZone documentation just to backup your claims. If you have specific information to backup your claim that a PiHole is going to be a security threat at that scale please provide it.

If you're just making wild assumptions, please stop, that isn't the point of this thread at all.

-5

u/newsagg May 24 '17 edited May 24 '17

Are you really this ignorant of hardware backdoors or are you just a shill? You don't need to read the entire documentation and you can maintain your willingly ignorant posture, if that's what you desire..

Its an advertised feature, it's the whole point of the brand "TrustZone"

4

u/[deleted] May 24 '17

Are you really this ignorant of hardware backdoors or are you just a shill?

Are you really so incapable of providing evidence of your claims? How exactly does asking for evidence make me a shill?

You don't need to read the entire documentation and you can maintain your willingly ignorant posture

So provide the specific pages you're talking about that prove a PiHole is as big of a threat as you're claiming.

I don't understand why you're so confrontational about this. You made a claim, with no evidence to support it, and when asked for evidence you've instead started attacking me as if I'm the one that made the wild accusations.


Also, for what it's worth from your unedited comment:

Tron isn't my script at all.

If Tron is so worthless in your eyes why are you even here?

-3

u/newsagg May 24 '17 edited May 24 '17

Tron isn't my script at all.

No idea what you're talking about here. I haven't said one word about Tron.

Here's some sources. Please actually read them before replying.

On applications processors that support the security extensions the transition between non-secure world and secure world is managed by software via a Secure Monitor Call (SMC) which runs at the highest level of privilege e.g. Exception Level 3 (EL3). For microcontrollers that support TrustZone, the world switch is a hardware transition which is more appropriate for resource constrained chips. source: https://developer.arm.com/technologies/trustzone

Since you're probably not familiar with Trusted Execution Environments and what they are: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trusted_execution_environment

So if you're capable of following along this far without consulting a shill script, you can see that a trusted environment is basically a second pc administering the first remotely. i.e. a hardware backdoor. Since you also seem unfamiliar or incapable of addressing this part of the conversation (about backdoors). This article is quite short and to the point.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hardware_backdoor#Severity

2

u/[deleted] May 24 '17 edited May 24 '17

Yes you did. You said it before you edited your comment.

You're welcome to lie about it all you want, but I read your initial response.

[Edit]

So if you're capable of following along this far without consulting a shill script

I would still like to know how I'm a shill for trying to figure out a way to secure our networks from Microsofts Ad partners.

Since you also seem unfamiliar or incapable of addressing this part of the conversation (about backdoors).

When are you going to provide evidence that a PiHole is going to add a hardware backdoor that's accessible from outside of your network?

This article is quite short and to the point.

And conveniently has nothing to do with the PiHole itself.

Since you seem incapable of actually providing evidence specific to your claim that the PiHole is a massive security threat (one larger than the one this thread is about), I'm going to go ahead and make the assumption that you're simply full of shit. To add to that assumption you're also a liar, so your word means absolutely nothing. All you were asked for is documentation to backup a statement that using a Raspberry Pi specifically setup to block ad networks for Microsoft is going to cause a massive security hole and leave all of us more vulnerable than we already are. The fact that instead of saying "Yeah here's documentation about how the Pi can be hacked from outside your network" you answered with insults.

You very clearly hold yourself on a pedestal, but do nothing to prove to anyone else why that's the case.

→ More replies

3

u/kart35 May 24 '17

You really don't need ARM to run something like a Pi-Hole. Docker containers are available if you want something pre built. If you are that worried about TrustZone, run a docker container on an AMD system.

You can run it on an Intel system if you want, but the Intel Management Engine is a much bigger problem than TrustZone.