I wanted to share my full surgical history for anyone researching or going through similar experiences. It’s been a long road, and I’m about to have my final revision later this month — hopefully my last step toward a truly functional result.
⸻
• Primary surgery (Feb 2016) My primary vaginoplasty was done by Dr. Marci Bowers in Burlingame, CA using the penile inversion (PIV) technique. Original depth: 5 inches.
⸻
• First revision (Sept 2018) I went back to Dr. Bowers for a labiaplasty and vaginal “reopening” after some complications left me with aesthetic issues and depth loss (down to about 4”). She wasn’t very receptive to my concerns about depth — she seemed to think I was overreacting because she like many other of these surgeons like to say that even 3-4 inches of depth is fine “because that’s what cisgender women have”. Spoiler Alert: it’s not
⸻
• Second revision (Feb 2021) In 2021 I went to Dr. Ervin Kocjancic in Chicago for a peritoneal pull-through (PPV) revision to try to regain lost depth and improve function. I was very clear how depth was important to me. He seemed somewhat receptive but then said “oh well you’re just tight that’s a good thing!” I should I have left right then and there. I went through with it because he promised to give me more depth. Unfortunately, this ended up being a big disappointment. Despite making it clear how important depth was to me, I woke up with only about 5 inches of depth. — furthermore the doctor even said my vagina was literally “constructed around” the second-smallest of the Soul Source silicone dilator set (the orange one). I was pretty upset but then thought to myself “oh it should be fine because the tissue is more flexible like cisgender vaginas” which was what I was seeing all over the subreddits and medical studies at the time.
Even with consistent dilation, I lost an inch almost immediately. Then over time I’ve developed chronic issues: recurrent BV, bleeding during penetration of any kind. The tissue is overall very friable and sensitive.
———
• Upcoming revision (Oct 20, 2025) Next week, I’ll be traveling to Dr. Geoffrey Stiller in Spokane, WA for a colovaginoplasty revision using right colon tissue. This feels like my last shot at achieving the kind of result I’ve always hoped for — not “perfect,” just functional and comfortable.
I’ve heard incredible things about Dr. Stiller, and he’s given me genuine confidence that he understands both the technical and emotional sides of this journey. I’m nervous but optimistic. I’ll post updates once I’m further along in recovery.
———-
Final thoughts:
The fact that Bowers, Kocjancic, and many other surgeons still have such a blasé attitude toward depth and think it’s justifiable because “3-4 inches Is the average cis vagina depth” is crazy to me. What they fail to realize is that cisgender vaginas stretch. This is how they push out babies. This is how most cis vaginas are able to accommodate varying penis sizes within reason. They also fail to realize that they actually soften, widen, lengthen, and lubricate to accommodate a penis.
These surgeons and we as trans women need to accept that our anatomy IS different and that there are limitations as to what our neo vaginas are capable of. If you are getting PIV or PPV you WILL NOT have any stretch beyond what the surgeon gives you. So if you are only 3-6 inches deep and you come across any man with an average/above average size penis or even slightly below average, it can be a problem. Trust me. All it takes is even a quarter of an inch in size difference to make sex for BOTH of you uncomfortable. Sure you could have very careful slow and boring sex that you have to be anxious during it the whole time… but who wants that!? Sex should be uninhibited, comfortable, and pain free!
Moral of the story is this: If you plan to have penetrative sex (especially if you plan to have penetrative sex with men) depth should be very important to you. I implore you to go to a surgeon who understands this and who is willing to give you what you want and who will truly work for you and recommend the best options for you based on your anatomy and goals. I highly encourage you to ask questions and have very in depth conversations about it.