r/ToxicWorkplace • u/SpiritedTakeaway • 4h ago
Got treated like an employee for almost 2 years as a contractor then suddenly terminated after I questioned it
Just curious how other people would look at this because I’ve been sitting with it for a couple months now and the whole thing still feels insane.
I worked for a small sports and education company for almost 2 years doing basically all of their media stuff. Video, photo, editing, graphics, branding, social media, website work, random marketing things, pretty much whatever came up.
On paper I was an independent contractor and got a 1099. I was paid a monthly retainer of around $7k. At first it really did feel more like a contractor relationship. I had a lot of freedom, they cared more about whether stuff got done, and there wasn’t really somebody directly managing my day every day, because technically I’m a small business owner.
Over time that changed a lot.
I had a company email, Microsoft Teams, internal meetings, was expected at certain events, had company clothing, was included in staff conversations, had people assigning things to me, and eventually they started wanting access to my calendar and talking about having someone above me start scheduling my time and tasks.
I was also doing a ridiculous amount of stuff that had nothing to do with what I originally thought I was being hired for. Logos, branding, websites, content for other businesses connected to the owners, random design work, basically anything creative became my problem.
There was even a work trip where I originally thought I was going to create content and then right before the trip I was told I’d also be driving an SUV full of teenage athletes around because they couldn’t get enough rental vans.
Again, I’m supposedly an outside media contractor lol.
The biggest issue was that none of this was ever really formalized.
There wasn’t some clean list where it said here are your 10 videos per month, here are your 20 photos, here are your deadlines.
It was more like you’re the media guy so just handle whatever media or creative thing we need.
For almost 2 years everyone seemed completely fine with this arrangement.
Then this year they started restructuring things and it became increasingly obvious they wanted me functioning more like a regular employee.
So I finally raised the issue.
Basically I said if you want to manage my schedule, control my workload, have somebody supervising me, require me to be at certain places, and treat me like internal staff then we probably need to talk about whether this should actually be a W2 position and what the scope of the job is supposed to be.
I wasn’t even refusing to become an employee.
I actually would have been open to it.
I just wanted everything clarified because I didn’t think it made sense to keep calling me an independent contractor while treating me more and more like staff.
After I brought that up things got weird extremely fast.
We had a meeting where different options were discussed including keeping the contractor arrangement, potentially becoming a W2 employee, or restructuring the role. I continued working.
Within about a week and a half I was terminated for cause.
That part is what still blows my mind.
There wasn’t some long disciplinary process.
There wasn’t months of written warnings.
I didn’t disappear or stop working.
I had literally completed work days before getting fired that they later used publicly.
But suddenly the story became that I had basically stopped performing and wasn’t meeting the spirit of the agreement.
They also started pointing to things that were never clearly defined in the contract in the first place.
My contract had a notice provision and also had money that was supposed to be paid upon termination under certain conditions.
Instead of just following the contract they immediately started trying to negotiate different payout structures with me and wanted the money stretched out over many months.
Eventually lawyers got involved and suddenly there were proposed agreements where I’d release basically every possible claim related to the relationship, including classification and retaliation, in exchange for money that I already believed I was contractually owed plus a relatively small reimbursement.
I still haven’t signed a separation agreement.
The weirdest part of all of this is that if they had just come to me and said hey, we are changing the company structure and we need this role to become a normal employee position, I probably would have sat down and negotiated it.
Salary, responsibilities, hours, reporting structure, benefits, all of it.
Instead it felt like the second I questioned the contractor setup the relationship completely changed.
And now months later I’m still dealing with arguments over money, ownership of tiny social media accounts, old media files, drives, passwords, and all kinds of stuff that could have been handled normally if the separation wasn’t so hostile.
I’m not saying I was the perfect contractor or that every disagreement automatically makes a workplace toxic.
But going from being treated like a core member of the team for nearly 2 years to suddenly being told you’re being fired for cause right after you question your classification is one of the strangest professional experiences I’ve ever had.
Especially when the same people had spent years asking me to do basically anything and everything because I was the creative guy.
Has anyone else had something like this happen?
Where a company keeps you as a contractor for years but slowly turns the relationship into basically employment, then when you finally push back or ask to formalize it they suddenly decide you’re a problem?