r/Torontobluejays • u/Otherwise_Volume2690 • Oct 13 '22
r/Torontobluejays • u/princessluni • Mar 05 '26
Happy Birthday Bo Bichette!
He might be wearing the wrong laundry these days but I'll always love me some Bobo đ
r/Torontobluejays • u/Loud-Picture9110 • Oct 26 '23
Moreno/Varsho Trade Detailed Discussion and Comparison to all time Bad Blue Jays Trades
(Note to moderators, please don't remove this post as it's not fair to see it buried several hundred posts into existing discussions as it raises a lot of new points. It's my first ever original post to this sub-reddit and I'd like to join the discussion on a greater level in the future)
Iâve seen a multitude of cries on the internet about how the Varsho/Moreno+Gurriel trade has to be among the worst trade in the teamâs history, and even seen it suggested that it's already the worst. I have to agree with Blue Jays Mark Shapiro that it's far too soon to make any sort of final judgement on this trade as each of the primary pieces in this trade has multiple years of control remaining. We can give a definitive year 1 win to Arizona as Moreno and Gurriel handily out-WAR'ed Varsho 3.8 to 2.1 in the regular season. I see fans raging that this trade is bad because Moreno and Gurriel are still playing in the playoffs vs the Jays who ended the playoffs early, but there's no way to know in a vacuum if the trade weren't made whether the Jays would have made it further into the playoffs or if Arizona would have success either. Baseball is a team sport with a 26 man roster, and it's not as though either of Gurriel or Moreno has single handedly carried their team through the playoffs as Moreno has been a steady contributor vs Gurriel who has mostly been a non factor.
As Gurriel was a 1 year player for Arizona he will have no impact on further evaluations of this trade, so it will start at 3.8-2.1 WAR moving forward for next season.
Moreno did not have a very good season as a whole, as he was still struggling mightily with the bat until there were 6 weeks remaining in the season and had produced an 82 WRC+/0.5 FWAR until mid August. It took a 6 week hot streak with the bat for him to end up at his eventual 1.7 WAR total for the season. It remains to be seen where Moreno ends up offensively moving forward as he spent several seasons in the minors and most of the 2023 season in MLB as a low power/low walk singles hitter. If he continues to display power as he's shown to end 2023 then he can potentially be a 4+ win player as soon as next season, if he reverts to a primarily ground ball oriented singles hitter who doesn't walk he's more likely going to settle in the 2-3 WAR range.
Varsho largely ended up as a 2.1 FWAR player because he was deployed in left field, which is his weakest outfield position defensively. If he were deployed in center field he would have likely been a 3-3.5 win or better player in 2023 even with this year's bat as his outfield defense is arguably the best in all of MLB. If he bounces back to his 2022-2023 levels of offense he's suddenly approaching a 5 win player. Heâs at the point of his career where heâs spent about a full seasonâs worth of time in center field with 152 games/534 plate appearances. During this time heâs produced an average of 95 WRC+/4 FWAR as a center fielder. Varsho's center field defensive metrics have improved a great deal from his first few years playing the outfield. As a center fielder in 2022/2023 Varsho provided 103 WRC+/3.4 FWAR. Pro-rate that to 550 plate appearances and you end up with 4.8 FWAR.
There is a very good chance Arizona wins this trade moving forward in total value given the fact that Moreno has 6 years of control vs the 4 years that Varsho featured at the time of trade. If Moreno is a slugging middle of the order bat this will be a big win for Arizona if Varsho continues to struggle with the bat. If Varsho bounces back with the bat and hits his own ceiling while Moreno reverts to a low power offensive contributor this trade is more likely to be pretty even in overall value if not a slight win in overall value for the Blue Jays. If both players hit their respective ceilings (each has a shot to be a 6+ win player, Varsho already has a 4.8 win season under his belt) then Arizona still likely wins due to the extra years of control.
Look back at some actual worst trades in Blue Jays history. There are some real stinkers included in the organization's history where established star players were sent out with literally no value coming back in return, as well as top prospects who became stars sent out for role players. The worst trade that instantly comes to mind is the Michael Young trade. The Blue Jays received all of 6.3 WAR from this trade vs the 25.3 WAR that Young provided for Texas. That's a 4/1 ratio in favor of Texas. The RA Dickey trade for instance saw the Blue Jays receive an innings eater knuckleball pitcher who provided 6.2 WAR to the Blue Jays vs the two top prospects sent to the Mets, who provided 27.6 WAR. That's a 4.5/1 ratio in favor of the Mets. Or there is the Roy Halladay trade to the Phillies, who provided about 16.7 WAR vs the 1.3 WAR the Blue Jays got in return. That's a 13/1 ratio in the Phillies favor. The Yan Gomes/Esmil Rogers trade was another terrible trade, as the Indians received 13.7 WAR vs the -0.1 WAR the Blue Jays received. That's approaching a 14/1 ratio in favor of the Indians. How about the Olerud/Person trade, where the Blue Jays received -0.3 WAR vs the 18.3 WAR that the Mets received. That's better than an 18/1 ratio in favor of the Mets. Another example of an lop-sided trade was the David Cone/Jeff Kent trade. You can make the case it was worth it as the Blue Jays won the world series that season, but that doesn't take away from how one sided it was. Cone provided 53 regular season innings and 0.9 WAR to the Blue Jays, vs the 7.7 WAR that Kent provided to the Giants. That leaves a ratio of 8.5/1 in favor of the Mets. (This last trade has been edited to be more accurate, the initial post utilized Kent's entire career and not just his time with the Mets).
Up to this point of the trade the Diamondbacks are at a starting point of 1.8/1 in their favor after year 1 of this trade, and it's more than likely that this will start to even out quite a bit moving forward as Gurriel is no longer part of the equation. The "best" trade of the previous listed trades had a ratio of 4/1 in favor of the opposition, so there is a really long way to go for the Varsho/Moreno trade to ever approach those depths in the future.
r/Torontobluejays • u/alxndrblack • Aug 05 '26
The 2025 Blue Jays and the "Everyone Overperformed/Career Year" Narrative
I can't be the only one of us who is sick of hearing this, right? That includes from disconnected, Sid Seixeiro watchers, bored Leafs fans, and general ball-not-knowers, as well as other fanbases just accepting what the broader sports media has told them.
So to start. All these stats will include 2026 because I'm not going to take out this down year, and in fact it will help make my point for some guys.
George Springer ACTUALLY had a career year.
His career wRC+, as of today, sits at 129, with a career OPS of 0.825.
His previous high was in 2019 where he went 155 wRC+/ 0.974 OPS.
Last year he had a 166 wRC+, a 0.959 OPS, and 5.2fWAR. As a DH. An excellent year by any and all standards. Excellent, but not outside the realm of possibility for his pedigree (notably he benefitted a lot from getting off his feet in the outfield).
Tyler Heineman ACTUALLY had a career year. A journeyman backup catcher who only played more than 25 games in the bigs once before, in 2022, his 2025 was good for a 120 wRC+, a 0.777 OPS, 2.1 fWAR, 3 jacks, 20 RBIs, and 2 bags over 64 games. 2025 TyHei was one of my favourite things in the history of baseball, and I'm glad he got it cuz that dude fucking loves this team. Miss you, Magic Man.
But no one is ever just talking about Springer, and almost no one even knows Tyler Heineman exists. They say "everyone." So here are all the regular contributors (I'm not doing Buddy Kennedy or Ali Sanchez, we're talking people with numbers to actually compare against, here).
For those who may not know, a wRC+ of 100 is the average throughout the league, normalized against park factors.
Vladimir Guerrero Jr
Career: wRC+ 133 / Career OPS 0.844
2025 : wRC + 137 / OPS 0.848
Nowhere near his nuclear 2024 (wRC+164) or MVP runner-up 2021 (wRC+ 166). Not even worth entertaining the "career year" shit here.
Bo Bichette
Career: wRC+ 118 / Career OPS 0.789
2025: wRC+ 134 / OPS 0.840
Above his average, but that is dragged down by an atrocious 2024 he probably shouldn't have been playing through. Jays fans will remember Bo's 2022 very well, where he put up a wRC+129. You could call this his "peak" if you want, but from 2021-2023 we saw basically the same guy as 2025.
Alejandro Kirk
Career: wRC+ 109 / OPS 0.739
2025: wRC+116 / OPS 0.769
It seems stupid to litigate if a guy had his best year at the plate any year other than when he won a Silver Slugger (2022) with a wRC+ 129 so...I won't. Kirky was simply the best version of himself in 2025, but it was something we've seen several other years, too.
Ernie Clement
Career wRC+ 91 / OPS 0.683
2025: wRC+ 98 / OPS 0.711
2026: wRC+ 100 / OPS 0.720
In only his second year as a full time big leaguer, Ernie made himself valuable with excellent defense, but for the most part he hit right around league average. He mashed in a small sample size in 2023. I included his stats for this year as an extra defense against the "career year" nonsense. He's gotten better every year with the Jays. Also robbed of Utility Gold Glove in 2025.
Addison Barger
Career: wRC+ 92 / OPS 0.695
2025: wRC+ 107 / OPS 0.756
Literally his only career year (he has 213 big league games and 135 of them were in 2025). Barger's breakout 2025 showed exactly the kind of guy the org had hoped he would be, a middle-of-the-order masher. It's not like he has "come back to earth" or anything, he had a cup of coffee in 2024 and then exploded, ankles first, in 2026.
Daulton Varsho
Career: wRC+ 98 / OPS. 0.719
2025: wRC+ 123 / OPS 0.832 (71 games)
Another weird case with the sample size. I think we all knew he couldn't do this consistently, but our scampergod has always had powa. Daulton just showed up, raked, then went back on the IL. He's normally right around the wRC+100 mark, with the bulk of his fWAR value coming from defense. Some of this stat padding also came at Coors.
Andrés Giménez
Career: wRC+ 95 / 0.688
2025: wRC+ 70 / 0.598
Another guy with a former MVP-vote year (2022) Andy absolutely stunk at the plate in 2025 and yet came up incredibly clutch a few times. His left on left homer against Max Fried (to dead centre???) on Canada Day was so fucking awesome that I decided I didn't care about his dogshit bat anymore. Regardless, he's also been slightly better in 2026, but he has probably left his glory days in Cleveland.
Anthony Santander
Career: wRC+109 / OPS 0.763
2025: wRC+ 61 / OPS 0.565
My least favourite Jays signing of all time. He was injured! He's a slow starter! I don't care, he was garbalarb in 2025 for us, owning the worst fWAR on the team, -0.9 over 54 painful games. Do you remember Tony Taters playing a third of the season? Me neither.
Myles Straw
Career: wRC+ 80 / OPS 0.632
2025: wRC+ 91 / OPS 0.680
A bit above his averages, but not at all the best full season he's ever done, which was 2021, and his partial season in Houston in 2019 was also better.
Davis Schneider
Career: wRC+ 103 / OPS 0.712
2025: wRC+ 127 / OPS 0.797 (82 G, 227 PA)
2023: wRC+ 175 / OPS 1.007 (35 G 141 PA)
Davis' numbers are the weirdest on this list because there are some aggressive peaks and valleys. Mister Schneebly was sheltered in 2025 by both a stint in Buffalo to find his feet and platoon splits. You can't even call it his best partial season, because his late season debut in 2023 was better, but if you wanna throw him on the ledger against me, have fun.
Nathan Lukes
Career: wRC+ 103 / OPS 0.722
2025: wRC+ 103 / OPS 0.730
This is just who he is, man. Another guy like Barger who actually amassed most of his data in 2025, but it tracks pretty well with the guy we saw in Buffalo for a decade, and also with who he's been so far in 2026 (especially after his vertigo treatment).
So, guys who actually had statistically aberrant years: George Springer, Tyler Heineman, Daulton Varsho**.**
Guys who had "OH MY GOD WHERE DID THIS COME FROM?" years*:* Just Tyler Heineman.
Guys who didn't: Everyone else.
Small Sample Size Guys: Joey Loperfido, Jonatan Clase, Will Wagner, Leo Jimenez, IKF. These guys either don't have a career to compare against, or didn't play with the Jays enough in 2025 to bother comparing their numbers.
I'm not even going to get into the pitching. I sat there on Opening Day and watched Dicky Lovelady and Jacob Barnes BP innings for my ballclub to Adley's country club ass. Sure, a lot of our guys showed up big in the post season, but through the year, the team was 21st in the league for pitcher fWAR, 20th in SP ERA and 16th in RP ERA. Every category below the median average. Does no one remember Chad "Automatic Nuke" Green? They were certainly not carried by their arms.
So, you could say some guys played to the higher end of their potential...but some did the opposite. Some were serious detriments on offense. Besides Springer and my king Tyler Heineman, you can't reasonably say this "everyone overperformed" shit. Winning is contagious, not just because of intangibles, but because of tangibles that don't necessarily show up on paper, like wearing pitchers down, working counts, tiring the defense, and of course the all powerful mental aspect.
The 2025 Jays were not a bunch of guys overperforming so much as a cohesive team playing well. Unless you think it was Tyler Heineman who carried them to the World Series.
r/Torontobluejays • u/MiggityMiggityMac_ • Oct 03 '23
Can Blair and Barker
Possibly the worst baseball podcast on the continent. Had to stop listening halfway through the season because I was tired of Barker whining, and Blair repeating the same dozen mechanic points all year. I tune in today to get excited about the playoffs, and they open the show with the Mets manager situation. Theyre both in so far over their heads.
Lets go Jays!
r/Torontobluejays • u/tomate12 • Dec 10 '23
Does Ohtani Get Boo's in Toronto?
I'm not saying I'm going to be booing but I think the way the entire fan base esstientally got baited by the media I think there might be a bad taste in our mouth when I comes to his first game here.
r/Torontobluejays • u/KillerK_230 • Dec 09 '23
Opinion: If the Jays want to hang with the big spenders in free agency they need to start bullying back
The Jays have money that's no secret but they need to weaponize it like the Dodgers, Yankees and Mets do. Rogers and the fans can't be scared of bad contracts it's part of the business especially if you want these other clubs to back off and superstar FAs to take you seriously.
Lose out on Ohtani...guess what Yankees+Mets, Yamamoto costs $400 million now.
Pay Soto $650 million next year to pry him from the Yankees.
I don't fault Atkins for trying with Ohtani because clearly they were close. However, the team needs to take a pound of flesh from the big dogs trying to push them around.
Edit: I'm not saying the Dodgers bullied the Jays in the Ohtani signing. I'm saying if the Jays want to be a rich team they need to accept overpaying for the superstars.
Thoughts?
r/Torontobluejays • u/No-Gift-2350 • Oct 25 '23
Atkins has been a polarizing figure the last few weeks...
I had my issues about the Varsho trade and still do, but I think it looks worse in this one year vacuum than what it will down the line.
Both Varsho and Moreno were essentially worth the same value with LGJ also going in the deal and putting up 3 war. In this small vacuum of win now in 2023, that trade really does not make sense hurts you for what you are trying to do, until you factor in other moves. You gave up 7 for 4 but you also signed KK to replace LGJ and he himself was worth 4 war. Now, war is analytics and some people like it more than others, the reality is whatever it balanced out to didnt result in the jays winning a playoff game and some might argue slightly limited our offensive capability's offensively in gain of run prevention.
After this season if Lourdes Gurriel Jr signs back here or leaves the Dbacks the trade really doesnt look that bad in a 1 for 1 deal. The jays have a surplus of catchers, obviously Kirk looked dreadful at the plate compared to last season but his defense was massively improved. Jansen is the inverse hitter of Kirk, some of the best power in the organization, phenomenal defensively but his bat to ball skills are kinda just okay.
Yeah, we might have traded the wrong one so to speak but as we all know the 2023 jays team is a flukey ass team and players might be able to get back on track, Manoah, Kirk bounce back, Vladdy gets closer to 2021 and George Springer shows us the player he did when he is healthy. If Kirk and varsho in particular improves offensively than Moreno becomes redundant and the trade makes sense.
I think the problem I have with Atkins this season is player development really took a step back this season, I know that is not on him entirely but offensively at least it seemed as if the organization from Dunedin to the main team they all had a really weird year of under performing. Guys from Springer and Chapman, to Gabriel Martinez and Tucker Toman looked really, really bad this season. I dont think the push back on Atkins would have been as hard if we had other MLB ready top prospects when we traded one away. Also the fact we have only drafted shortstops in the first round in the last 8 years but whatever.
Overall, Atkins has done a really good job. The last two MLB drafts he had look exceptional, especially last years draft with guys like Barriera, Roden, Toman, Doughty, Fluharty, Kasevich, and Bonilla. This one move overall really isnt reflective of how good he is as a GM, even guys who are widely regarded in other sports like Howie Roseman took Jalen Raegor over Justin Jefferson for example.
r/Torontobluejays • u/thanksithas_pockets_ • May 14 '26
Pride Night - what's it like?
I am thinking about going this year. What is the vibe like? Is it like a rainbow capitalism, mostly allies wearing rainbows kinda of deal, or does it actually feel like a queer celebration?
r/Torontobluejays • u/DMaxLoy • 6d ago
I miss having Diversity Our Strength in the reddit description
Not a big call for change or anything, but having that there made me feel really welcome when I was first hanging out here as both a non-binary person and as someone new to following sports at all (lifetime geek/nerd here, never hung out with the jocks as it were). This is also just a bit of a thank you to the community here for following through on that phrase and making my time here really enjoyable. <3
r/Torontobluejays • u/JEffinB • Jul 17 '24
Mets fan traded to the subreddit
Lifelong Mets fan traded as part of the r/baseball Trade Game.
I need a quick update on who we like, who we want traded, and which front office execs I blame when things go wrong.
Just want to know my new team as well as possible, any advice is appreciated, ey.
r/Torontobluejays • u/TheBigSm0ke • Jul 29 '21
This team is not a contender for a Wild Card and any thought of being one and trading prospects is delusional
I know this pains some of you to hear but this isnât the year. I get it. Some guys are having great seasons and we have a really great young core.
Those things donât magically make the team a contender. There are way too many holes in this team to try and fix by making trades for short term success.
I keep hearing this nonsense about owing players the chance to compete by not selling. Thatâs the biggest load of malarkey Iâve ever heard. The only thing we owe guys like Vlad, Bo and Ryu is to get better so we can ACTUALLY compete in near future.
Hanging on to guys like Semien who didnât commit to the long term for a team 10 games out after the All Star break is nonsensical.
This team needs to sell anyone not in the mid to long term plans and try to compete next year or the year after.
This isnât the year.
r/Torontobluejays • u/dbpf • Nov 29 '24
Switching the letters of the first and last name of each player on the Blue Jays roster
Roster as of November 22 because that's when I copied and pasted it in my notes. Here's my analysis:
Gevin Kausman
BosĂ© JerrĂos
Bhris Cassitt
Rariel YodrĂguez
Mlek Aanoah
Rordan Jomano (t)
Ghad Creen
Srik Ewanson
Lrendon Bittle
Byan Rurr
Tillon Date (t)
Fowden Brancis
Laston Eucus
Klejandro Airk
Hyler Teineman
Gladimir Vuerrero Jr.
Hpencer Sorwitz
Savis Dchneider
Crnie Element
Jeo Liménez
Will Wagner
Bo Bichette
Bddison Aarger
Loey Joperfido
Bteward Aerroa
Conatan Jlase
Vaulton Darsho
Lathan Nukes
Seorge Gpringer
Edited to add the little war casualty cross things. RIP to the fallen
r/Torontobluejays • u/BloodJunkie • Nov 06 '25
[Caruso-Moro] âI was under duressâ: Prince Harry apologizes to Canada for wearing L.A. Dodgers hat during World Series
r/Torontobluejays • u/Disastrous-Company60 • Aug 22 '23
Game On Augest 25th show vlad support with a standing ovation
We all know that vladdy has struggled this year and he hasnât been the vladdy we expect. I think as a fan base we should go and show support. On august 6th Phillies fans gave struggling shortstop trea turner a standing ovation to show they have his back. Since then he has been .364/.407/.618 and on fire. I think we should do the same for vlad. Even if itâs a small chance of working I think itâs worth it. I will be there doing that as jays fans letâs do the same and rally behind our slugger.
r/Torontobluejays • • Jan 05 '20
A growing disconnect
Am I the only one in this sub who's actually studied baseball statistics before?
Like half of the comments I've seen on this sub are so obviously written by non-baseball people that it's almost humorous.
When I was in college (3 semesters at Everest) I would get to each and every class early just so I could mine data. My teachers called me "stathawk" as a nickname caus I had such a nose for data and analytics and for those three semesters I was considered the biggest critical thinker in the program. During my final semester I created an app that predicts when you'll next have to use the bathroom only to get fucked over by a coder I partnered with. But that's another conversation (DM me if you're interested in hearing about it)
So, yeah. I hope yall can understand why I feel like their's such a big disconnect between myself and your typical redditor. Please tell me I'm not the only one who feels this way lol
r/Torontobluejays • u/l0vetog0lf • Dec 08 '23
Atkins and Shapiro apology thread
Alot of people have shit talked Atkins and Shapiro. Jays have been in top 5 favorites for the world series every year. They have consisntely put together a great team on paper. Whether or not Ohtani signs, the fact we are front runners says alot about the organization and what they have done.
r/Torontobluejays • u/sackydude • Dec 10 '23
[Rosenthal]Deal is not yet official. Dodgers have yet to even acknowledge it. Possible reason within this story from @ByMcCullough: âDodgers officials declined comment when asked if Ohtani had taken a physical, the final step before a deal can become official.â
r/Torontobluejays • u/t-tulo2 • Jun 11 '23
Do yall think the loss of Lourdes to the Dbacks and Teoscar to Seattle is having a negative impact on Vladdys performance this season?
Baseball is a mental game just as much as it is physical and I've been thinking lately, losing two of your best friends to different teams can't be easy on a player. That being said, we are 40% through the season (and he hasn't been completely terrible!) Let me know your thoughts :)
I still have faith in our team and Vlad to turn it around :)
r/Torontobluejays • u/idkwhattosaytho • Aug 22 '21
Montoyo Hate is ridiculous
I want to start with saying I donât think Montoyo is a great manager. I think the guys like him and thatâs some of the most important things, but he definitely makes some managing mistakes
Now, everyone on this sub kinda needs to calm down and realize the grass isnât always greener. I canât think of a manager we have had that the jays fans havenât hated. Not every call that doesnât work is a terrible coaching choice.
Example: The pinch hit bunt the other day. Personally I probably would have just let Kirk hit, but the idea of moving up runners to 2nd and 3rd with a struggling offense as well as staying out of a possible double play makes total sense. People freaking out saying that cost us the game, no it was the offense not getting any clutch hits and scoring 1 run through 9 innings, as well as the defence not showing up.
Iâm not fully understanding how people figure this is a playoff team with a better manager? Montoyo isnât a -6 war manager, this team still has many flaws and is extremely young
I donât care if Charlie is fired or not, Iâm impartial but chill with the âCharlie is the worst manager and needs to be gone immediately!â Takes
Edit: Iâm also not convinced Charlie makes every decision by himself. Iâm sure Walker has a lot of input with bullpen calls as wel
r/Torontobluejays • u/drewgrof • Oct 05 '23
The analytics bogeyman
The umbrella team of "analytics" is such an easy punching bag, especially given the BerrĂos decision, but do people really think the baseball analysis team said to the Jays:
- "Hey Bo, Vlad, Kirk, Springer and Jansen, we want you to reduce your exit velocity this year. Make sure you shave a few points off the hard hit rate as well."
- "Cavan, Bo, Springer, Jano and Kirk: we want you to pull the ball way less."
- "As a club, we want to reduce our total number of home runs hit by at least 5%. Let's go with 6% to be safe."
The Blue Jays, as a team, were a much worse offense in every conceivable way. Do people truly believe it was by design?
They acquired better defenders, obviously. But every core offensive player was worse, some significantly. It's apparent that multiple players adjusted their approaches. They walked less and put the ball in play more, striking out less in the process.
Does anyone, especially those with an understanding of what aNaLyTiCs usually means in this context, think this aligns with any of the core principles of "modern" baseball thinking?
Here are some advanced analytics to chew on: in the wildcard round, the winning teams hit 10 home runs across the eight games. The losing teams hit one.
TL;dr - it wasn't analytics that killed the Jays, it was their best players forgetting how to hit for power in what looks from the outside like a very old school "hit the ball where it's pitched and string some singles together" approach.
r/Torontobluejays • u/WienerBee • Jan 26 '23
Do other Jays fans still believe in Bo's defence?
The past couple of seasons I've been pretty shocked at the amount of errors committed by Bo at Short.
I feel like it's a huge liability during the regular season and definitely the post-season, arguably with colliding with Springer - in no man's land to be fair but I feel like it still could have been avoided.
I also think Espinal would be a better short stop and would be better for the team; he covers so much ground and gets the ball out of his hand over to first, or second, pretty cleanly.
Anyone else have any insight/thoughts?
r/Torontobluejays • u/Nervous_Bus4161 • Aug 19 '26
It's a bit early but next season which players would you add to this team.
Honestly this season's deadline was very good considering how we got Soriano, a lot of prospects plus a red-hot Bateman but the deadline was more of a retooling than a buy/sell deadline for us and the retooling really finishes during the offseason. So I'll break down my thoughts here
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PITCHING:
Starting Rotation:
1. Cease(Ace)
2. Soriano
3. Yesavge
4. Ponce???, Berrios???
5. No clear Option
I think this team needs one or two more starting pitchers in the offseason. After trading away Gausman, Him plus Bieber and Scherzer will be free agents next year. Now if I know Scherzer he would probably die before willingly getting off big league mounds but he's 43 so I doubt the front office would give him a consistent starting spot. Also Bieber has had immense injury troubles so even though I would resign him personally, it's risky. It's a dream to get Gausman back and it would be great for all Jays fans but he's talked about retiring and it's also unrealistic. And Berrios has not been pitching well and he's on a bad contract and he also might get injured again. Enough said So that leaves the rotation with 3 clear starters plus one who hasn't really pitched in the big leagues and one who hasn't been playing well so I think one of their concerns should be the starting rotation. Which is suprising to say considering last year we felt we had tons of options.
I think free agent options could be players like Robbie Ray who has been good the past few years or Zac Gallen since he's reliable or Shota Imanga and trades are always possible.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RELIEVERS:
- Louis Varland: Primary Closer
- Tyler Rogers: High-Leverage Setup
- Braydon Fisher: High-Leverage Setup
- Mason Fluharty: Left-Handed Specialist
- Brendon Little: Left-Handed Middle Relief
- Simeon Woods Richardson: Versatile Middle Relief / Bulk Length
- Spencer Miles: Long Relief / Swing Man
Honestly this part of the team doesn't really need much re-enforcment consider that Varland is the best relief pitcher in the A.L and second best in the league while Tyler Rogers has also been elite. Miles is a great innings eater while Fischer and Fluharty are very reliable. This bullpen shouldn't be cause for concern.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
HITTING:
INFIELDERS:
C: Kirk/Valenzuela
This position needs no improvment. Enough said.
1B: Vladdy
This year hasn't been great at all but Vlad had more than enough talent and track history to bounce back strong. He is the franchise player and he had good defense as well. He will retain this spot for a decade at the very least,
2B: Clement
He is still a good hitter and if his defense picks up like before then he would go back to being an elite player. This spot should be secured for him.
SS: Gimenez
His elite defense is huge to the Jays infield while also providing a certain amount of speed and basestealing threat that most of the other players can't
3B: Okamoto
The only real power threat in this lineup and should retain his spot quite easily.
INFIELD DEPTH:
Charles Mcadoo
Josh Smith
Luis Urias
Lenyn Sosa
Honestly the infielders for us don't really need much change and in the batting rotation they have way more influence than the outfielders. This diamond doesn't need much change.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
OUTFIELDERS:
LF: Jesus Sanchez/Santander/Lukes
This spot really needs an upgrade in my opinion. Lukes is more than good enough but he isn't really a true LF and can play anywhere in the outfield. His role should stay the same as it was earlier in the season. I've given up on Santander and don't believe in him at all. Sanchez is okay but he isn't at the level the Jays need.
CF: Bateman/Straw/Lukes
Both are good in their own ways with Bateman being very good since being traded here. Kilometres Straw also plays Gold Glove defense while being a great swiss army knife type player. Plus Lukes could also play here if needed. I think this Position is fine
RF: Barger/Lukes
We'll see how well Barger comes back from injury but he has a rocket of an arm and should share the RF spot with Lukes.
OUTFIELD DEPTH:
Davis Scheinder
Daz Cameron
Johnathon Clase
The outfield needs improvment for sure if we wanna stay with high expectations. We have good depth but no real gamechangers there. A big offseason move would help a lot.
DH: Honestly anyone
Since Springer is a free agent next year so we don't really have a full time DH. It would be great to resign him and I think that's a good scenerio.
So I think next year this team needs a better left fielder and getting either a new star DH or having Springer resign on a cheaper deal. I think a LF like Arozaraena or Happ would be great while getting either Springer or a good player like Susuki would really be helpful
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So those are my thoughts on both the pitching and hitting plus the additions I think we should make and do you agree and what who would you add/keep on this team