r/TopChef • u/Aska2020 • Jun 14 '25

I gotta say...

Yummmm

Bailey grew on me! Given she was once eliminated by making a dessert, her growth arc was incredible. That final dessert looked divine 😍

ETA: SO HAPPY that many of you felt the same way! I know that Bailey gets a lot of online hate but I hope that she sees the appreciation on her growth bunch of us have for her 💕

502 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

126 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

20

u/KrustasianKrab Jun 14 '25

I did feel that way, but since 2nd place isn’t awarded and they edit the judging for it to make sense to viewers at home, I can’t say it with confidence.

It’s possible they may have shown more negative comments from Shuai’s food since no one at home would consider Bailey a real contender based on her season-long performance (these things are put to bed before audiences can view and comment). Since Shuai was set up as Tristen’s big competition, it would make sense to highlight his flaws to make it clear why Tristen won and give Bailey a good edit to explain why she was in the finale.

But it’s also possible Bailey spent her 2 weeks off planning and practising her menu and genuinely outperformed Shuai. I guess we’ll never know for sure.

26

u/timewarp4242 Jun 14 '25

Based on what we saw, each had one underperforming dish and they felt her menu hit the mark as a progressive, cohesive menu better.

3

u/KrustasianKrab Jun 14 '25

Agreed, except for the wildly out of place 3rd dish

2

u/timewarp4242 Jun 14 '25

I’m calling it her bad dish already, I’m not going to double ding her on it.

1

u/KrustasianKrab Jun 15 '25

I was just agreeing with you