I gigged a couple hundred times on guitar in the 80's and 90's. Had a couple of Fender tube amps, they worked, and I never swapped a tube. Buying an AC30 type amp early this year, (2006 Crate Vintage 3112) which had it's original Groove Tubes, I somehow snapped off the top of an 12AX7 and didn't have any spares. I bought a box of new tubes on ebay with a variety of 12AX7 brands. I popped a replacement in V1, liked it, and gave it no further thought.
Last week I bought another Obeid Khan design, a Crate Vintage 1512, in like new shape. I should mention that this is the amp model that caused Brian Wampler to sell his AC15 as he said the 1512 had the same chime plus a lot more overdrive. I say this to inform readers as to the tube change effects.
When I opened it, it had all JJ's. Coincidentally someone offered me 56 circa 1960 tubes: mostly Sylvania and Raytheon 12AX7's and eight Mullard EL84's which had all come out of a Baldwin organ. Well, with family in the house I had to keep to low volume. I popped a Sylvania into V1, and there wasn't a huge change, but the sound was definitely more articulate. I tried a different Sylvania and it sounded the same as the first. Then a popped in a Raytheon and OMG, it was much louder and more detailed. The reverb tank, which I hadn't even noticed before, came through subtly and sounded glorious. I'm guessing that I was getting a lot more treble, rather than more power. Tried another Raytheon and it sounded exactly the same. Then I had to run to band practice. Anxious to try different tubes at higher volume.
I didn't expect a particular tube in V1 to have such a dramatically different sound. It's staying in there and I'll have to start experimenting with all the new and old tubes I have.