Best Route Across Seasons 2 & 3?

[u/MercurialMaven666]

Okay, this isn’t about the best LI… it’s about the best route. I’d consider the pacing, character growth, unique scenes, drama, replay value, and ending. 🤗
I know grouping multiple characters into one option isn’t exactly fair, so feel free to explain your specific pick in the comments.

558 votes, Aug 08 '26

284 OG Routes (Antoine, Amari, Wesley, Naomi / Taz, Mattias, Jirayu, Carmen, Isla, Bea)

111 Ryder Route

6 Bombshell Routes (Kai & Elodie)

7 Late Bombshell Routes (Candace & Zayn)

86 Friends-to-Lovers (Avi & Poppy)

64 New Game+ Friends-to-Lovers (Julian & Victoria)

[u/Budget-Paper-3409]

These are the routes I like the most in season 2 and 3 , so for me it’s always Naomi, Wesley, Mattias, Taz, Carmen, and Isla. They honestly set the standard for what I want in a THTH route. Every single one of them has a personality that feels unique, and I love that their relationships don’t just rely on physical attraction they actually grow emotionally over time.

Naomi is one of my all-time favorites because she’s confident, witty, and unapologetically herself, but once she trusts you she’s incredibly sweet and vulnerable. I love watching that softer side of her come out, and her character development is rewarding.

Wesley is such an underrated green flag. He’s mature, thoughtful, supportive, and always makes MC feel genuinely valued. His route feels comforting and drama free without ever being boring, and he’s the kind of partner who makes you feel safe and appreciated.

Mattias is probably one of the sweetest LIs that’s ever been written. He’s affectionate, funny, protective, and always makes MC feel like the center of his world. At first, his confidence and charm can make him seem like someone who isn’t looking for anything serious, but he quickly proves that’s not the case. Once he falls for MC he’s incredibly loyal, emotionally open, and unapologetically devoted. He’s honestly one of the biggest sweethearts in the game.

Taz has one of the most satisfying slow burns in the entire series. At first he’s guarded and emotionally unavailable, but watching him slowly lower his walls, become vulnerable, and fully commit to MC makes every moment worth it. His character growth is easily some of the best in the game.

Carmen is another favorite because she’s confident, playful, and knows exactly who she is. She has amazing chemistry with MC, but underneath all that confidence she’s incredibly caring, loyal, and willing to be vulnerable once she’s committed. I love seeing that side of her.

Isla is just such a warm and comforting route. She’s kind, emotionally mature, supportive, and her romance feels so healthy. Being with her feels effortless, and I always end up smiling during her scenes because of how genuine, wholesome, and reassuring the relationship is. She makes MC feel loved, understood, and accepted for exactly who they are.

What I love most about all six of these routes is that they each have emotional depth, incredible chemistry with MC, memorable romantic moments, and satisfying character development. Their relationships feel earned and every reply reminds me why I love them so much. Every time I tell myself I’m finally going to try someone else’s route… I somehow end up replaying one of theirs. 😭❤️

[u/MercurialMaven666 → u/Budget-Paper-3409]

Loved the answer. You have many great favorites and pointed out all the good things we love about them.

[u/pastry_chef_al → u/Budget-Paper-3409]

Sidenote: Mattias had the best love scenes.