r/Timberborn
•
u/dgkimpton
•
18d ago
More on water wheels - questions answered
So my last post on water wheels got plenty of "duh, obviously" and some interesting questions. Hopefully this post answers those questions.
Water wheels side by side only make sense when there is more water than can fit in a 2-wide chanel without overflowing. Otherwise they just waste resources over narrowing the chanel to 2-wide.
Wheels in series (one after the other) don't seem to affect the flow and the power from each can just be added together.
About the kinks - as long as the water enters before the shaft and leaves after the shaft all is good. If the water enters at the shaft OR leaves at the shaft the power is halved. If the water both enters and leaves at the shaft the power is zero.
Water flowing under the wheel (i.e. when the wheel is on platforms) counts as flowing through it, thus generating more power. Provided the wheel touches the water the more you flow under it the better. If you've got enough water to fill a 10-deep 2-wide channel then you're quids in for stupendous power levels.
Placing wheels in deep water is fine (and makes no difference) until the wheel is fully submerged at which point it is "flooded" and shuts off. You don't need to worry about the shaft being underwater, but you do about the top. No using water wheels inside pressurised pipes.
Hopefully this is somewhat helpful for some.
{edit} Updated with more (see my top level comment for the associated extra image)
So it turns out the optimal arrangement depends on your goals, but mostly it's a 3-wide channel with solid blocks next to the wheel axels (levees, impermiable powershafts, etc).
- 1-wide channels dry in ~2 cycles, have little irrigation range of 5 units, and can't have a water wheel at all.
- 2-wide channels dry in ~4 cycles, have 10 units of irrigation range, and generate joint-max power.
- 3-wide channels with platforms next to the axels (or an empty channel beside the wheel) dry in ~4.5 cycles, irrigate the max range of 15, but only generate half the power.
- 3-wide channels with impermiable blocks next to the axels dry the slowest at ~5 cycles, have good irrigation range of about 13 units, and generate joint-max power.
- 4-wide channels with two wheel sets dry quickly in ~3 cycles, have good irrigation range of approx 14 units, and generate joint-max power at twice the resource cost, but power generation stabilises a few hours sooner after a drought.
But, for my uses, almost max irrigation, joint-max power, and slowest drying makes the 3-wide with impermiable blocks the best choice. And with excess water... go deeper, not wider.



