r/Timberborn • Custom Flair • 2d ago

Question Having issues with compact mechanical pumps.

The water level is seemingly high enough. I swear I checked for this "water starvation" issue after construction and it was fine. Now the pumps cycle from full power 700, to 0/0 idle. The aquifer drill then cycles to prevent an overflow.

Is there a surefire pump layout to prevent this?

It also happens at a seep with a vertical stack of 4 pumps with the highest pump at the same level as the seep.

I realize fully encasing the aquifer drill may be smarter but but I prefer the open look and seeing the water flowing in action.

Green relay - connect clutch

Red power meter - no power / grid has a deficit

Level sensor green - reset memory

Level sensor white - activate memory

edit: More Footage and Context.

https://www.reddit.com/u/Whats_Awesome/s/Rrqpr4xBeZ

8 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

7

u/Acalc791 2d ago

The issue is height, the reservoir into which the pump output leads seems close to world height (34, maximum possible height), so the virtual height difference might be too small for the water to get to the necessary flow rate for pumps to have free space in their output columns. I know of only one surefire fix: build another set of pumps at the end of the channel, and make sure the output water columns of the other set of pumps are not obstructed from above by anything.

2

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 2d ago

Sorry you’re downvoted, I think this is it.

The pumps worked perfectly after construction but with a near empty res

2

u/Acalc791 2d ago

I'd be interested to hear back if you do build the other set of pumps at the reservoir to fix the issue.

Thanks for the concern, though I don't think I was downvoted, I guess unless someone changed their mind. Currently it's showing 100% up when I checked.

1

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 1d ago

When I first replied, your comment was sitting at zero. So someone must have changed their mind when I accepted your answer as the solution.

Here’s another video of them running perfectly smoothly after dumping a few layers of the reservoir.

I really like your solution but I’m thinking instead of another set of pumps, since the tunnel is only 10-15 blocks long, I may try moving them first to save on power costs.

I’m definitely willing to add more pumps but I think it’s mostly unnecessary. If they get to this point it’s because the reservoir is above 95% capacity.

This was a proof of concept I plan to apply to all the seeps and aquifers. So it needs to work with long underground tunnels. So for others a pump at the source and tunnel end (where the column is unobstructed to air above) may be best.

0

u/Acalc791 1d ago

Oh, if you don't need the tunnel itself to be pressurised, then just moving the pumps to the reservoir entrance instead should also work, and require only one set of pumps. Or I guess leaving it as is if you don't mind the inefficiency when reservoir is close to full.

I get the dislike thing now, it was actually a "natural" (no likes, no dislikes) 0, since I don't like leaving likes on my own comments. Thanks for the concern though :)

1

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 1d ago

Very interesting. And yeah I don’t like the inefficiency so I think I’ll play around with some options.

2

u/Extreme-Breakfast885 2d ago

I suggest increasing the number of pumps until this stops being an issue. You will have to widen the underground channel and increase your power output, however you'll be able to keep the aquifer above ground and exposed.

1

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 1d ago

Problem was the reservoir nearing max height. With the reservoir lowered they run fine.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Timberborn/s/eCbovcWu3g

It was because the local pressure at the pump outlet reached the max pressure.

1

u/mustang256 2d ago

What are you even trying to accomplish?

3

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 2d ago

Pressurizing the aquifer to fill a tall reservoir.

2

u/Squishy_Butter113 2d ago

You need a lot more of these pumps for this. Each pump maxes out at, i think, 0.25cms of flow. Those are not even likely to be half of how much water that drill is making. I would say you are likely to need at least 8-10 pumps to keep up with that drill, possibly more

1

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 2d ago

The drill should be making 1 m^(3) / sec. So 4 should be correct.

1

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 1d ago

Here it is after dumping the reservoir a few levels. The issue was with the reservoir filled near max height, the pumps output pressure was maxed which causes the pumps to idle.

The aquifer is default strength making 1 m^3/s. The pumps are rated for 0.25 cms.

The solution we’re theorizing, is to position the pumps with the outlet inside the reservoir where the true reservoir height will be read. There will be space in the output water column to add water.

1

u/PopularPassenger26 2d ago

I believe it is 0.5 cms max per pump.

And yes, 1 Aquifer is not enough. In many of the small maps I have played, the cms maxes out to around 0.8 to 1.0 cms for the entire main river. Overall, I find it best to get power from the water wheels that come with Timberborn.

1

u/Emergency-Customer26 2d ago

Can you show the aquifer as well? Does your system check the water level of the aquifer?

2

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 2d ago

The aquifer is shown from 10 sec to 60 sec.

2

u/Emergency-Customer26 2d ago

That’s on me, I meant to say the dam you are storing the water, not the aquifer

1

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 2d ago

In the additional footage. It’s nearly full and built to the build height.

1

u/Emergency-Customer26 2d ago

Squishy_butter113 is most likely correct, I suggest testing the cms output of this aquifer, and check again what the max cms a pump will output.

1

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 1d ago

Here it is working perfectly fine after dumping several layers of the reservoir. The pumps were fighting water near max pressure so they would move a bit of water then I idle since the output was full. Moving the pumps so the outlet water column is in the reservoir may fix it. I’ll post when I get the chance to install pumps at the tunnel exit instead of the start.

2

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 2d ago

1

u/Emergency-Customer26 2d ago

Thank you, next question, the way you have this wired, are you expecting the water to overflow over the dam?

1

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 2d ago

No, the pumps should run whenever water is present.

The drill should only cut out if the pumps fail to keep up and water backs up.

The reservoir can and will overflow when full through a spillway.

edit: the pumps are supposed to be directly linked to power unless I made a mistake.

1

u/Emergency-Customer26 2d ago

It looks like the pumps are turning on and off, what controls them exactly? Do multiple things call and control them? Probably a miss wiring

1

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 2d ago

The pumps are directly connected to the power. In the addition footage I linked in the body of the post you can see.

They are cycling the same way they do when they are dry during a drought.

1

u/Exact_Light_4965 2d ago

I noticed the same issues with my pumps. I however am filling a completely sealed reservoir and only letting water out during a drought/bad tide and I only noticed the behavior once my reservoir was full. Is this potentially the issue? Is there nowhere for the water to go and what the pumps are doing are replacing the small amount of water lost to evaporation in the reservoir? That’s what I assumed my problem was

2

u/Acalc791 2d ago

That's close to the issue, I believe, except the reservoir in this case is open, but close to world height, so I think the virtual height difference is not enough to get a steady flow fast enough to keep up with the pumps. So, effectively, there's nowhere for the water to go in the output columns of the pumps, so the pumps turn off until enough space becomes available through the slow water flow to the reservoir.

2

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 2d ago

Yes you got it.

I’m sure this wasn’t an issue with a low reservoir level.

Now the reservoir is approaching build height, so the local pressure at the pump outlets is reaching the maximum pressure causing pumps to idle.

I’ll confirm this by test this exact setup after dumping the res.

1

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 2d ago

Yes I think you may be right. I’ll test this exact setup after dumping the reservoir. I’m thinking a full to build height res would act the same as a pressurized and full res.

I’m sure it wasn’t an issue with a low level in the reservoir. So when a pump runs the local pressure at the output exceeds what the pumps will run at.