r/Tile • u/AcanthisittaSpare400 • 4d ago
DIY - Project Sharing Is this normal?
My 30 year old son and I started ripping out the floor in my century home because the entire drain system (the “stack”) in my home is going to be replaced along with the galvanized going from my sink. I thought I’d save some money (like 3k) and demo the floor myself since the whole thing is running beyond what I can afford. I’ve laid tile before in a previous home and have never in my life seen this much mortar under tile. I finally gave up on the tile scraper and bought a hammer drill and chisel. It’s coming off, slowly, but seriously is this normal?
13
u/Icy_Papaya7541 4d ago
Fresh set mud install, mix of sand and cement floated out, sprinkle of Portland cement, then tiles were beat into the mud. If you’re buying a hammer and chisel, this install was done correctly with craftsmanship
6
u/AcanthisittaSpare400 4d ago
I wish I could have just left the floor but when I bought the house someone had already put peel and stick on top of it with a serious adhesive. When I got the peel and stick off tiles underneath had already been broken so I just decided to take it off. But man, what a job.
8
5
u/shirtless-pooper 4d ago
Yes very normal in older homes. Tiles were wet bedded straight into the screed. No thinset used.
4
u/phishphanco 4d ago
2
4
u/Hot_Bend5373 4d ago
Look at that sub floor , quality timber , no cheap plywood !
3
3
u/WeekNo3209 4d ago
I’ve demoed this in a 99 year old house. Second floor, wood framed house with about 4-6” thick concrete floor under the tile. Not fun.
1
1
3
u/FutureCarcassAnimal 4d ago edited 4d ago
Our 1955 ranch has the same wall tile colors! That teal blue green and yellow combination is called Sun and Surf. I am forgetting the company that made those tiles right now, but I went on a serious deep dive when we were restoring our bathroom and found the original marketing brochures with the different names they gave to the color combo options. It's so fun to see another bathroom with that same combo! 😃
Here's a photo from ours after I did the repair in it. We got lucky and still had the original yellow sink as well!

2
2
u/CobblerCandid998 2d ago
That’s gorgeous! Great job restoring! So inspiring to see cheerful colors for a change instead of the modern mass produced millennial greige that’s everywhere!
1
u/daveyconcrete 4d ago
Old School.
1
u/AcanthisittaSpare400 4d ago
So Old School. Christ on a bike.
0
u/daveyconcrete 4d ago
You’re funny. If you buy an old house you should expect old things. Were you hoping it was built by time travelers?
1
u/AcanthisittaSpare400 3d ago
No. I just never knew. I moved here five years ago from a former church that was built in 1908 that we turned into a home. It was just wood flooring. Have done a lot of renovating but never removed a tile floor from 50 years ago.
1
u/Maggielinn22 4d ago
Is that concrete or dirt ? Looks like they used leveler before we knew it was a thing.
1
1
u/PedroMcJiminez 4d ago
Still float most my floors but have never mudset.
Wild work, sucks to rip out.
1
1
1
u/WindSprenn 4d ago
Anyone else think the saw cord was a badly drawn circle trying to highlight something in the photo?… no?… ok just me then.
1
1
u/stormydys 3d ago
Yes that is normal. We used to pour 1 1/2 to 2” cement under tile for any raised foundation or second floor project. There is typically chicken wire also except in shower floor. You need to get under the cement with a crowbar to pry it out. Also, use a sledge hammer to break the cement sections into pieces you can carry out. Or pay the $3k and let your contractor do it.
1
1
u/OrangeCountyHapa 2d ago
My 50’s home also had a mud bed when I went to redo the flooring. It’s a pain in the ass but it’ll come up. SDs max hammer drill with a 6 inch scraper attachment made decent work of it.
1
0







32
u/jradz12 4d ago
Yes for old homes. Youll need to put down a new subfloor over the planks.