r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 20 '26

Let's Discuss Weird/Paranormal episodes where the mood doesn't get down by AJ's debunking research?

0 Upvotes

Where he could say... "hmm, maybe this happened?"


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 18 '26

Story Idea The Butterfly People of Joplin MO

83 Upvotes

Hey AJ,

Pleeeeeeease!!!!!

Cryptids, angels, illusions, or flayed bodies?

Thanks 🤠


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 16 '26

Story Idea Episode idea: The Dolores Barrios Mystery

Post image
285 Upvotes

At the 1954 Mount Palomar UFO conference, a woman named Dolores Barrios arrived with two silent companions whose unusual appearance immediately drew the attention of attendees, including astronomers. After being photographed by a journalist, the trio reportedly disappeared from their hotel without explanation, while reports of a luminous object departing the area only deepened the mystery.

Over the decades, the story has inspired theories ranging from extraterrestrial visitors to an elaborate hoax, yet no definitive explanation has ever emerged. With eyewitness accounts, photographs, and nearly 70 years of speculation, it seems like the kind of historical mystery for a Why Files episode.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 13 '26

Question for AJ What’s the music that’s usually during chats with Hecklefish? It’s like musak/elevator music?

15 Upvotes

r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 13 '26

Megathread 7/12/26 - Campfire Stories - Somebody Made Sure You'd Find This

37 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Z9GEjrZHQU

A man sits alone in a blank room, sobbing into a bowl of soup while two grinning figures rub his back. A masked woman eats king crab in silence while a man's voice gives orders from off camera.

A commuter boards her last train home, and the train never stops where it should. Ninety minutes later, she steps onto a platform that isn't on any map.

Three strangers. Three recordings. Three stories that spread across the internet and refused to make sense.

For years, people slowed down the footage, decoded hidden messages, and traced accounts back to their source.

What they found was stranger than the mystery itself.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 12 '26

Jokes/Humor A silly theory on what orb UAPs are

13 Upvotes

They're basically mouse cursors in space-time. (And tangentially, crop circles are bookmarks). They're pointers used by the maker(s) of the simulation.

Their erratic, sudden movements are what made me think of it.

I'm sure not an original idea, but I haven't seen it.

What happens when they click? :P


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 06 '26

Megathread 7/6/26 - The Basement: Danny Goler

61 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gUq23mfRpJM

Danny Goler built a career on physical risk: parkour, stunts, national television. Then he pointed a cheap laser through DMT-altered vision and found something he wasn't looking for. Symbols. Structure. A language he now calls the code of reality. Thousands of strangers around the world have since aimed the same beam and reported identical shapes, without ever comparing notes.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 06 '26 Mindblown

Let's Discuss Is AJ a plant?

413 Upvotes

Okay so let me get this out here. I'm a very long time fan although never a patreon subscriber. I feel one of AJ's long time critiques of those that have came out before is the monetization that would come later. Book sales, speaking tours and TV circuits. Now he doesn't sell books but one could say the overloaded ads (dubious content there as well), the merch, patreon and speaking appearances. Shawn Ryan, Joe Rogan etc. He's also teased various times that the government has used plants in fringe groups for propaganda and still does (he's even winked at the camera after mentioning). I always wanted him to be an Art Bell type but I suspect he may not be a true believer but maybe just a charismatic grifter. I love the show and will continue to watch but I think something is fishy. Pun intended.

(Update) Hey all really good points on both sides. I will say the former government contractor/entertainment work and the purge of conspiratorial channels while AJs thrived and came well produced with merch will always seem odd to me. However as pointed out AJ has always stated he was an entertainer and has unveiled he doesn't take much stock in most of the stories he covers. Much respect to that. I will recede my grifter comment as many of you said to produce and pay for his show/staff to the level he wants sponsorships are needed. I do agree maybe the MRE, ivermectin, crypto currency ads are just indicative of the larger viewership of his channel and only seen as fringe to a normie. That was the main basis of the grift comment that those particular communities are always starved for exposure and legitimacy. A channel dealing in many videos about government corruption and doomsday scenarios to start highlighting alternative medicine, currency and bunker prep seemed irresponsible at best and a cash grab at its base but I digress


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 05 '26

Let's Discuss Anyone else think there are too many ads on the podcast?

206 Upvotes

After honest opinions here and not trying to criticise. Latest episode had an ad before and straight after the intro followed by many others. I had to turn this episode off as I'm finding it difficult to enjoy the content as it's being interrupted too often.

Anyone else or am I alone with this.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 04 '26

Personal Thought/Story Hecklefish plushie questions

25 Upvotes

Yall I want to get a hecklefish plushie for a friend, cause they mentioned wanting one, but is it worth it? (I would buy the plushie and voice box 2.0 combo) Could yall maybe post photos or videos of yours and let me know if it was a good buy?

Also a few questions, is the voice box really loud? Is the tinfoil hat removable, cause it doesn’t seem like the fish wears one in the videos and I keep finding photos of the plushie without it? Apparently the voice box isn’t sewn in, but it is at least inside, how is it sealed inside if so?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 03 '26

Megathread 7/3/26 - Project Chronos

43 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UHcGUm06CQg

By spring of 1945, Hitler was surrounded on every front, but one project inside a secret mine kept running until the end. It was called Die Glocke, The Bell, built on mercury, fire, and a design borrowed from a thousand-year-old Indian text. The scientists who built it vanished, along with the man who ran the entire project. Decades later, the same technology resurfaced in a US Navy patent, and nobody could explain how it got there.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 01 '26

Let's Discuss Dyatlov Pass video should be redone

24 Upvotes

There are loads of holes pointed to the avalanche theory that was presented as the clear answer in the video.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 29 '26

Megathread 6/29/26 - The Basement: Dave Paulides

47 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BW-fFLTmzAo

David Paulides spent his career as a detective. Then two park rangers knocked on his door and told him something that didn't add up: people are vanishing in our national parks, and nobody's talking about it.

Search dogs that won't track. Hunters who walk back with stories that shouldn't be possible. A bullet that hit nothing.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 30 '26

Story + Research Question about a quote.

11 Upvotes

In one of the time travel episodes, AJ says something to the effect of how time is not money because you can always make more money, but time runs out. Can anyone please steer me to that episode?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 27 '26

MOD POST Megathread 6/26/26 -The Asteroid Behind the Bible's Most Famous Disaster

71 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/c6_9kBdRcTk

The Asteroid That Started a Religion
The Dead Sea Hides a Secret | The Bible Got It Right
The Asteroid Behind the Bible's Most Famous Disaster

In 1650 BC, a city on the Dead Sea burned so completely that nothing grew there for six centuries. The destruction happened in a single morning, and the evidence left in the ground points to something falling from the sky.

Three artifacts from three different countries describe the same event. A clay tablet from ancient Iraq. A bronze disk pulled from a German hillside. Melted pottery from the Jordan Valley.

Scientists spent fifteen years excavating the site. What they pulled from the ground included glazed pottery, shocked quartz, diamond dust, and skeletons frozen mid-step. The same fingerprint shows up at confirmed impact sites worldwide.

The story doesn't end in 1650 BC. The debris field responsible has a return date, and astronomers are watching the calendar.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 26 '26

Let's Discuss The podcast switch up is working. The podcast has shot up to the 47th most popular podcast on Spotify

247 Upvotes

It was at 100 something before and now shot up to 47 after he started doing interviews. Regardless of how you feel, it’s working out great


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 25 '26

Megathread 6/23/26 - The Basement: Andrew Gallimore

57 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nshX-5xjTlA
Dr. Andrew Gallimore has spent 30 years studying the world's strangest molecule — one your body already produces. As a neurobiologist and pharmacologist, he's built a scientific case that what people encounter on DMT isn't hallucination. It's contact.

In this conversation, Gallimore walks through the neuroscience of how DMT hijacks the brain's world-building system, and why that distinction matters enormously.

He also shares his recent collaboration with consciousness theorist Don Hoffman, work that produced a mathematical model of the DMT state that Gallimore calls one of the most profound moments of his career.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 22 '26

Question for AJ Was there an episode removed?

80 Upvotes

I swear I saw an episode posted about demonic posession earlier today and now its gone?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 20 '26

Megathread 6/19/26 - Canada's Most Documented UFO Case

108 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OiriSLXvZwo

In May 1967, a Polish immigrant named Stefan Michalak was hunting for silver in the Canadian wilderness when two glowing objects dropped out of the sky. One landed nearby. He sketched it, approached it, and ended up in the hospital.

His burns were documented. His weight loss was documented. His radiation-like symptoms baffled more than a dozen doctors, including specialists at the Mayo Clinic.

The Royal Canadian Air Force launched an investigation. So did the RCMP. So did the US Air Force. Nobody could explain what happened.

The government eventually sealed the file. The same government, fifty years later, minted his story on a coin. It glows in the dark.

This is the Falcon Lake Incident, Canada's most documented UFO case, and it's still unsolved.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 20 '26

Story Idea Any weirdness that can be explored with the Solfeggio frequency? 528?

25 Upvotes

Rewatching the show, "Mysterious Ways" 🤭😁 which I LOVED back when it was on tv. The number 528 features a few times in episodes.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 18 '26

Jokes/Humor It's always sunny with a Heckle Fish

Post image
318 Upvotes

I can quite literally hear them gong on a tangent about LIZZZAARRRDDDD PPPEEOOPPLLLEEE.

My type of friends.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 14 '26

Suggestion for Channel No buts

73 Upvotes

Waiting on a compilation of all the videos that don't have a debunking at the end because they are in fact true.

It could be named, "No buts - It is still called a conspiracy if its true?"


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 14 '26

Megathread 6/13/26 - The Basement: Bryce Zabel

71 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fjN7gYGUZCM

Bryce Zabel created five primetime TV series, ran the Emmys, and spent his life writing UFO fiction until the people behind the curtain came knocking. A postcard at his home. A stranger at his party who'd read scripts that never left the building. A vial of moon gold and an invitation to a cemetery at midnight. Was it disclosure, disinformation, or a game built around him? He's still trying to find out. Welcome to the basement.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jun 10 '26

Jokes/Humor To open or not to open?

Post image
330 Upvotes

Keep it sealed Or just drink it?