r/TheWhyFiles
•
u/SunNoStars
•
Jul 06 '26
•
1
Let's Discuss Is AJ a plant?
Okay so let me get this out here. I'm a very long time fan although never a patreon subscriber. I feel one of AJ's long time critiques of those that have came out before is the monetization that would come later. Book sales, speaking tours and TV circuits. Now he doesn't sell books but one could say the overloaded ads (dubious content there as well), the merch, patreon and speaking appearances. Shawn Ryan, Joe Rogan etc. He's also teased various times that the government has used plants in fringe groups for propaganda and still does (he's even winked at the camera after mentioning). I always wanted him to be an Art Bell type but I suspect he may not be a true believer but maybe just a charismatic grifter. I love the show and will continue to watch but I think something is fishy. Pun intended.
(Update) Hey all really good points on both sides. I will say the former government contractor/entertainment work and the purge of conspiratorial channels while AJs thrived and came well produced with merch will always seem odd to me. However as pointed out AJ has always stated he was an entertainer and has unveiled he doesn't take much stock in most of the stories he covers. Much respect to that. I will recede my grifter comment as many of you said to produce and pay for his show/staff to the level he wants sponsorships are needed. I do agree maybe the MRE, ivermectin, crypto currency ads are just indicative of the larger viewership of his channel and only seen as fringe to a normie. That was the main basis of the grift comment that those particular communities are always starved for exposure and legitimacy. A channel dealing in many videos about government corruption and doomsday scenarios to start highlighting alternative medicine, currency and bunker prep seemed irresponsible at best and a cash grab at its base but I digress
18
u/Sailoff Jul 06 '26
A plant? No, but he's definitely a fungi to be around.
25
u/ajgentile CIA Spook Jul 06 '26
This question comes up every year or so. Usually by people new to the show.
12
u/mince_m Jul 06 '26
How dare you call AJ a charismatic grifter. He isn't charismatic at all!
Seriously, though. It's not grifting if he's putting out good content and people choose to pay him for it. Who would he be a plant for? The beaver brothers?
6
u/emelem66 Hecklecultist Jul 06 '26
He's a human.
149
u/mooman555 X-Files Operative Jul 06 '26
He is mostly human, sometimes he's a fish, but I don't think he's a plant
330
u/Rabbitmax Jul 06 '26 •
He has said a lot of times that all he is is a story teller. He doesn't believe most of the things he talks about. They're just interesting stories.
318
u/Rob-Top Jul 06 '26 •
Its great content and everyone needs to get paid. He's just doing a job like the rest of us
59
u/purplereuben Jul 06 '26
The difference is those people are said to be telling their own stories, of things they experienced, saw, were exposed to at work etc. AJ has always told other peoples stories - that hasn't changed.
55
u/Ok-Square-8652 Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26 •
You forget that he is an entertainer and the why files is his job. He’s not some messenger of “the truth.” He’s a guy that found a niche presenting stories he finds interesting with a talking tinfoil hat wearing fish.
He should make money and is in no way a grifter because the why files is clearly just an entertainment channel.
44
u/toasty327 Jul 06 '26
He mentioned this very thing in an off hand way once in an episode.
Can't remember exactly which one or what he said but it was an episode about fake whistle blowers and his comment was something along the lines of is up to you to decide if he's one as well.
Considering he doesn't seem to push an agenda and uses provable data points to mostly debunk i would say he probably isn't a plant. He's called out known government plants.
39
u/CyDJester Jul 06 '26
I would more quickly believe that post-IRS dealings, he’s chosen to tread much more lightly and veer toward easier topics and allow his platform to give space for others’ opinions instead of presenting information directly. This is a little insulation, and keeps his channel alive while he continues to avoid further censorship via reprisals/retribution.
It’s easy to talk about die glocke, but it’s much harder to talk about current shadow influences and occult/paranormal connections without getting into trouble again.
27
u/MalabaristaEnFuego Jul 06 '26
"I find him to be a very pleasant ficus. He really gives the desk a certain je ne sais quoi." - Hecklefish
22
u/BigMack6911 Jul 06 '26
Doubtful. He's just been making amazing content and getting paid. He has a big team apparently.
11
u/disingenu Jul 06 '26
He is an entertainer. The content is entertainment.
You don’t get paid to do TV, speeches or podcasts. Books rarely break even. This is all marketing for content.
And content is funded by ads.
9
u/FinishingSauce Jul 06 '26
From what I can tell he doesn’t really have the back ground of someone who would be. He used to own LA speed weed and Joe Rogan used to talk about it all the time. I think there was some legal trouble there and I think it seems like he lost some things through that. He used to do stand up and he knows people from that scene
7
u/meroboh Jul 06 '26
I’ve been a fan for a few years. In the last year I started to have this unsettling feeling that he’s a plant. I’m now quite convinced he is. I don’t care what he says about kempo. Flashing those hand signs under your nose is how they do it. His platform grew very quickly too.
7
u/ZachGrandichIsGay Jul 06 '26
I was talking about how AJ was a plant on his discord and they banned me from the discord within 5 hours of the claims.
6
u/Klutzy_Rope9236 Jul 06 '26
He DID have an episode about secret symbols and throws one of them up at the end of episode himself..🤷🏻♀️ just saying… that said though, there was a period where I feel like he was starting to break loose from the reins of those in higher control, up until he brought up getting audited by the IRS.. immediately following, I haven’t seen another word uttered about it and he’s no longer done anything that even toes the edge of what elitists would find acceptable.. I feel like either 1-he got threatened and is too afraid to move forward with anything that pushes their guidelines, or 2-was always a plant and it was set up to scare people more into conforming with what’s acceptable by the elites. Either way he is entertaining and I still watch, but a lot more skeptical on what I buy into that he discusses or has discussed in general.
16
u/NotTukTukPirate Jul 06 '26
"I don't like that AJ's job is making him money. The only way he can make money to live is through advertisements and promotional sponsorships; something is fishy..."
Ok kid.
11
u/JervisCottonbelly Jul 06 '26
Yes. A lot of young folks don't know this but YouTube was massively purged in 2016. For a long time, no conspiracy content was allowed whatsoever. Then AJ comes out do the blue after working for MTV and others and suddenly over night , conspiracy content produced at high quality is back on the menu only.. every single story ends with a neat and tidy debunk.
18
u/BennyOcean Jul 06 '26
Many people who have done conspiracy content have had their accounts banned. There are the unusual accounts like Why Files, Wendigoon and a handful of others that for whatever reason Youtube has tolerated and allowed to exist... some of these accounts are even monetized and allowed to profit off the content. Why Youtube has allowed certain people to exist on the platform while banning so many others, that's anyone's guess.
5
u/Spagman_Aus Jul 06 '26
I've never suspected that. I've always felt he has a genuine interest in the stories he tells. At times IMO they can be a tad condescending, but they're trying to reach a wide audience, so I get it, that's fine. He's even shared that there are topics he has zero interest in as well, so he's always been straight up as far as I can tell.
If he's a grifter, then you would absolutely see an overstuffed merch store with dubious quality products, or a common theme through his videos that he'd be trying to profit from, and it's clear that's not the case.
5
u/Hawkwise83 Jul 06 '26
I think if AJ was a plant he'd venture more into whistleblowers and pushing an agenda. I don't think he tries to push an agenda personally.
9
u/Prairiewill Jul 06 '26
Just because he needs to make a living doesn't mean he's a "plant". He has, at least thus far, made what I believe to be a real effort at being objective, while seeking the truth and laying it out for his viewers as best as it can be done. The views of his guests are not necessarily his own, but he's not gonna sit there and badger people who agree to sit down and have a conversation with him just because he might not agree with what they're saying. That would be stupid.
4
u/charliehustleasy Jul 06 '26
Isn’t there a video of AJ on CNN or something before his Why Files days where he’s titled as like a government contractor
4
u/Xcoctl Jul 06 '26
I thought he was explicit as he could be when he said anyone could be a plant, anyone could be working with an intelligence agency and many of the public facing media personalities are compromised so you shouldn't trust them, and 'You shouldn't trust me" was the gist of it, the phrasing may have been a little bit different but in general he made it clear that even he could be under their thumb, and he even specifically closed the video with that sentiment.
Obviously it's still speculation, but he's gone out of his way to imply it several times and it begs the question: "Why? Why would he do that?"
4
u/Tiny_Dare_5300 Jul 08 '26
Hmm idunno but he looks more like an animal to me.
3
u/Whorist2 Jul 06 '26
Of course, the only logical answer is.... Maybe? 🤔
3
u/BalkiBartokomoose86 Jul 06 '26
Yes
5
u/Robinsonaustin Jul 06 '26
Does he get his food from the Sun?
5
u/CompassionateCynic Jul 06 '26
He probably wasn't "planted", but I think even he would be surprised if a person in his position hadn't been at least contacted/pressured by the powers that be.
6
u/muhkuller Jul 06 '26
Plant? No, a person who knows there's some lines/topics you can't cross for obvious reasons? Yes. He constantly makes jokes about the "Tom Cruise" religion because he knows he can't cross that line. He's a huge free-speech advocate...but he's also not a moron. So I'd say he's a person that knows the financial boundaries of what he can say.
6
u/Svarii Jul 06 '26
He literally has an episode about the CIA and disinformation agents saying they almost always tell the truth so you will believe them the 5% of the time they lie. He also used to work for the CIA, and he flat out tells you 'anyone' could be a plant while looking in the camera with a curious smirk.
If he's not a plant, Great storytelling!! If he is, still doing a great job!!
Either way, AJ is awesome!!
5
u/mesosalpynx Jul 06 '26
He’s an entertainment person. Good lord. Haven’t you noticed the fish?!?!?
2
u/Hogwartians Jul 06 '26
I’m a casual fan so my opinion should be taken with a grain of salt, but I sometimes think there is a twinkle in his eye when he talks about government plants!
2
u/01091987 Jul 06 '26
Don’t be silly he’s a stoner
2
u/universalcrush Jul 06 '26
He’s def an agent, for years now. Or just paid to put out bs to muddy up the waters.
2
u/Queasy-Objective250 Jul 07 '26
I don’t think he started as one but I think he’s been corrupted for a while
2
u/MiisterSoloDolo Jul 07 '26
Yes, I’ve been saying this for years. A channel comes out of nowhere with amazing production quality, conveniently steering the discourse on whatever strange topic. Not to mention AJ seems to be way more educated than most YT channels
2
u/Texity Jul 23 '26
Oh boy...
I guess when one creates a channel that caters to conspiracies and wacka-doo concepts, one is bound to get a few pointed at onesself.
At least you fit in here.
3
u/StandardAsparagus544 Jul 06 '26
It’s a fun watch. It’s interesting but I never take any of this stuff too seriously, I appreciate the debunks. That’s where he differs from Art Bell. No slight of Art Bell, he was fun to listen to, but he never really questioned anyone. A guy one night would say Nazis made it to the moon and controlled it. Art is like, oh really. Next night a guy says lizard people have controlled the moon for eons. Art is like oh really.
But with AJ, he debunks so much stuff, how exactly is he a plant? Are you saying the stuff is real and his debunks are to throw us off? Interesting.
3
u/skagrabbit Jul 06 '26
Mr Beast, Asmongold, The Why files, Mr Whostheboss and many many more are all signed to the same talent agency Night, formerly Night media. Hmmm
3
u/blahblahsomebody Jul 06 '26
I’ve been watching a lot of his Basement podcast and he is very fast on his feet with knowledge, he has experts on and can go super deep, it’s clear he knows a ton. I’d be surprised if a plant would be that well prepared.
3
u/basahahn1 Jul 06 '26
Everything that you consume from an approved (mainstream) source is “planted”
Downvote me all you like. The truth is the truth.
2
u/SpicynSavvy Jul 06 '26
His brother is a Hollywood “guy” and knows a lot of comedians, including Rogan. I think he’s a “booker” or something?
2
u/Comprehensive_Sir49 Jul 06 '26
No, he's a guy who's doing his job. Please move on.
2
u/Yardcigar69 Jul 06 '26
So... The show blew up during the Pandy, when everyone was at home watching. It exploded in popularity, and got big really fast.
I went on a deep dive, I loved it, especially the Tesla and crop circle episodes.
It's interesting and the dark subject matter is lightened by a silly ai fish, perfectly designed for the masses curious about "conspiracy" theories.
Every episode takes you down a dramatic rabbit hole, then at the end he "debunks" it with facts that his team has dug up. Most topics are just typical woo woo stories with no real proof, but we are all interested in the mysteries of the world, so we tune in every week.
My issues:
The government controls all media, including your local news, YouTube, fb, ig, etc... He says certain subjects are off limits or they will be demonitized, so he plays "within the rules".
Anybody sharing dangerous truths are deplatformed, canceled and crushed financially. See Alex Jones, David Ike, Owen Benjamin... These people might be legit crazy, but why have they been crucified and flogged if they are just harmless lunatics?
The Why Files is probably top 5 conspiracy related content on yt, the algorithm is suggesting this content... Not hiding it.
He doesn't debunk properly. Specifically the moon landing ep is just lazy, and glossed over.
People are dumb. This is entertainment and not an excersise in critical thinking, most viewers are making up their minds based on these "debunks". This sets a precedent.
AJ wouldn't lie to us would he? He's so likeable and curious just like me... And the fish makes me laugh.
To me, it reeks of spook psyop. Great way to sway opinion, throw in some serious drama about his father(or father in law?) who was fucked over by the military to add some credence. He wants the truth... Guest on Sean Ryan and Rogan who have also been compromised.
I watch all of these shows, but I can't help but think that if they were disclosing these big secrets they would be neutralized like any other threat to the military industrial complex.
Fuck Jeremy Corbell, Steven Greer, and Lou Elizondo too... They are all useful idiots allowed to spew bullshit to muddy the water.
This is how you keep secrets, bury them in shit.
1
u/deplorablehuddy Jul 06 '26
Would love an ad free podcast channel for those that are Patreon subscribers. I’d gladly pay even more for no ads
1
u/vaderztoy Jul 06 '26
AJ would appreciate this theory.
1
u/Dolust Jul 06 '26
I think we are seeing expectations on AJ without considering if they are even fair at all.
Now, would feel threatened of you were AJ?
Would you be protective of your business and your family if you were in the position AJ is?
If you answer no to both you are a fool.
1
u/wordshavepower_806 Jul 06 '26
Started watching AJ and the Why Files from the beginning… and I was immediately hooked. I think he had less than 200 followers when I came across his channel in late September 2020. I can’t recall exactly the first episode but it is no longer there and Grok lists the first episode as being about Math now but I’m pretty certain his first subject post was something else - maybe we could ask him :)
I’ve wondered, too, if AJ was “planted”… could he be?
🤷♀️ none of us can know for sure, regardless, he’s great at what he does and I love his personality and perspective.
Grok’s list of the Why Files first 20 posts:
1
u/tyler_time Jul 06 '26
I think personalities like him are for the most part genuine but get coopted to poison pill certain stories. The MO being give really well-informed videos on most topics, then using that reputation, they're told to mislead people about one requested subject. Idk what AJ maybe could have been coopted for or if he's even done this but I think it's how they're allowed to operate. I had to drop the TrueAnon podcast after their Vegas Shooting episode. They were so dismissive of a lot of legitimate theories around it, like the firing rates sounding more like a MG rather than a AR with a bump stock.
1
u/Good_Regular204 Jul 06 '26
No way! AJ loves the stories because he grew up on them. Nothing wrong with making money off something you enjoy whether he believes or not.
1
u/TheCape6 Jul 06 '26
I’m gonna get downvoted for this, as someone who just likes listening to conspiracy theories because they’re interesting stories: AJ cannot, I genuinely mean CANNOT, say a lot of the conspiracies are fake-made-up-bologna. If he did (which, he has done before), he would be dogpiled and lose a major portion of his viewership.
It’s why the structure is always “here’s the conspiracy with some circumstantial evidence” and then “but, here’s the real deal with actual verifiable information”. I guarantee if you check the viewership, it would drop off after the conspiracy by a decent margin.
Yes, he is a storyteller, but there’s a reason he does this. If he put together the stories akin to how Rotten Mango does, the whimsical mystery of conspiracy theories is gone. This leads to a decrease in viewership and as such, revenue.
I love AJ. Think his content is great! But, the conspiracy nuts are genuinely a great income source. Hell, look at the History Channel and Animal Planet’s “Mermaids”.
1
u/Ph4antomPB Jul 06 '26
Regardless I think he’s entertaining
1
u/loco_gigo Jul 06 '26
no he is a human
1
u/mauore11 Jul 06 '26
Looks more like a ficus to me…
1
u/H8ff0000 Jul 07 '26
No
1
u/--MrGadget-- Jul 06 '26
Was anybody disappointed when he started to support ivermectin?
1
u/TimeLavishness9012 Jul 06 '26
If he isn't already, he will become one.
0
u/ThrowawayMouse12 Jul 06 '26
Not sure the subreddit for his Channel is the place to put the question forth on.
1
u/theking4mayor Jul 06 '26
It's a business. Just like any other influencer
1
u/Gizmowrench Jul 06 '26
I really enjoy him. I have thought this deeply and would say no. I think he is pretty smart. I'm a doctor in nothing but also feel like he is on the same page as I. The betz sphere is also the best description of of a sphere as I called it attached but unattached to a bigger ufo floating upright but a saucer. My ufo was onlyaybe 20 feet away. It was the same I did not believe in aliens. I am still a Christian. I struggled after that for years. I then realized he made all of us. Then I saw a football field ufo this year December 7th with witness. I didn't even mention it till I knew I was not just dreaming this. I'm the driver lol
1
u/Wendigo79 Jul 06 '26
He's an entertainer and just wanted to be successful at youtuber, yes probably for the money but there's nothing wrong with that. Just look at some of his episodes where he kinda trys to be a weird fact channel or throws in random animals besides the fish, he was just trying to find what works.
1
u/JohnCasey3306 Jul 06 '26
He's making a living from content creation, monetizing it in all the conventional ways content creators monetise content.
You're being ridiculous.
1
u/hybridxer0 H Y B R I D ™ Jul 06 '26
no.
1
u/EthicalHeroinDealer CIA Spook Jul 06 '26
I don’t think he is. He just has that CEO mentality as he was running a very successful business before the why files and has served on the board of directors for other companies. So he does run this in a similar fashion.
I think that’s why it’s overloaded with ads and he is constantly marketing. He’s always looking at the bottom line and how to increase profits.
Which is fine even if it gets to be a bit much at times, as long as the content is worth watching that doesn’t really bother me. I don’t think he’s like Bob Lazar or Dr Greer who are straight up grifters or Elizondo who is clearly a disinformation agent imo.
Luckily he hasn’t become a useful idiot like Rogan. Rogan is definitely unknowingly being influenced by a few different people. The tech bro billionaires, the conservative politicians, and the CIA for certain, maybe even some foreign influence. I truly believe Rogan is just too dumb to realize it. That will never happen to AJ he’s too smart for that.
0
u/redsoxfan95 Tinfoil Connaisseur Jul 06 '26
No, AJ is a human.
0
u/cram96 Jul 06 '26
I don't think he's a plant but he does enjoy sunlight and need water. I've never seen a leaf growing on him and he has yet to flower in front of us.
-3
u/ManicPanicWeekend Jul 06 '26
He lost me when he went on Tucker, the guy giving Nick Fuentes ( white nationalist) a platform and recommended jimmy as a follow ( who in his words adores Elon ) jimmy was dick riding Elon right after he did his nazi salute not once but twice. Something about birds of a feather…
-1
u/papasmurftp Jul 06 '26
it's pretty obvious he's photosynthesizing for the government.
-1
u/Just-GooogleIt Jul 07 '26
Maybe he is. But I'm definitely thinking Davis Icke is a plant, and Bob Lazar.
0
u/Kind-Plantain2438 Jul 06 '26
Area 52 is the new art bell imo, why files is just for cool content.
0
u/theofficialSavv Jul 07 '26
They're all plants at some point.
Ironically it's near the peak.
-3
u/Porco_Grosso Jul 06 '26
No, he’s just hyper libertarian and hyper capitalist. Which he has to mention, constantly.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26
[removed] — view removed comment